The Electoral College Versus A Direct Election System

1513 words - 6 pages

The Electoral College Versus a Direct Election System

“The Electors shall meet in their respective states, and vote by ballot for President and Vice-President…they shall name in their ballots the person voted for as President and in distinct ballots the person voted for as Vice-President” ( The Twelfth Amendment set forth the rules and regulations for which the Office of President shall be determined. The founding fathers, in the second constitutional convention, laid the grounds on which setup what would be the Electoral College.

Adoption of the Electoral College plan came late in the Convention, which had previously adopted on four occasions provisions for election of the executive by the Congress and had twice defeated proposals for election by the people directly. So why not conduct a direct election, by the people? After all, the President was to serve the people.

There were four main reasons why the delegates of the Second Constitutional Convention wanted an electoral system. For one, a census as a prelude to the first election could not be taken. The first election served more as an appointment. There was not time for delegates to go back home, while under this newly formed Constitution, and search for delegates. Who would serve to defend the Constitution while this happened? The delegates knew this before hand.

The states had a wide variety of suffrage requirements. If electors were to be chosen on the basis of population, should slaves count as a property, or under population? Even though they held large populations, the larger states rejected the idea of a popular vote. Virginia, one of the largest states of the time, had a population of 748,000. Of those, 306,000 were slaves, which at the time wouldn’t count as population. This dwindled the lead of the larger states almost in half. The larger states would no longer control the population lead as their fellow states.

Registration and supervision of a national election would be expensive and very time-consuming. In the 1800s, ballot machines were not available to determine the votes on a wide-scale usage. So, ballots had to be hand-counted. And where an election would rest in counting every ballot, it would very time-consuming. And who would be in place to count these votes? Enslaved blacks would almost certainly favor the candidate who promoted freedom. The issue of bribery of vote-counters was brought up in the convention, and any talk of a corrupt government was quickly hushed.

With an Electoral College in place and guaranteed by our Twelfth Amendment, why should we replace a system that up until now, caused no problems? Why do critics continue to bombard the Electoral College with complaints of it being obsolete? Why do the majority of the population see it as an “unnecessary barrier to true democracy” (Kuroda)?

On September 4th, 1787, an appointed committee proposed a new method for electing the president, which took account...

Find Another Essay On The Electoral College Versus a Direct Election System

The Electoral College: How It Has Shaped the Modern Presidential Election Since 1968

1174 words - 5 pages Every four years that a Presidential election comes to pass the Electoral College is responsible for the formal election of both the President and Vice President of the United States. As an example of an indirect election, where people in each state at large vote in order to decide which individuals will be delegated the responsibility of casting votes for President and Vice President in accordance with the popular vote of the state which

Electoral College - What Is It, Different Types, Process, Examples (2000 Election)

1672 words - 7 pages The United States of America, a country that is a federal constitutional republic. A country where the head of state and other officials are elected as representatives of the people. These officials are elected in by the delegates whom they are elected by the people and this is Electoral College. Although Electoral College may be controversial, In the end it is the best system for the election process.Electoral College is the election of the

The Electoral College System Teacher didn't even have anything to say about it except be consistent with how I hyphenate words

820 words - 3 pages decided that the candidate has no chance to win the election in that state. For example, if the system had been used in the 2000 election, " the 100,000 Ralph Nader voters in Florida would have had the option of ranking a second choice, their run-off choice. No question that thousands of them would have ranked Al Gore as their second choice. Al Gore would have ended up winning the state of Florida and the election," says Steven Hill, who

A speech disputing the electoral college

1112 words - 4 pages obvious answer to this in "No." Then how come in the good ol' US, a presidential candidate can receive the most votes by Americans yet loose the election? The answer, the antiquated institution we call the electoral college. I was not fully aware of how truly unjust the Electoral College is until I did my own research into the subject. Through a look at the Electoral College, some of the problems with the system with examples from the 2000

The Electoral College

1192 words - 5 pages . Having a president and vice president from two different political parties could stymie the executive branch and cause almost nothing to be accomplished (Grolier). All the proposed changes to the Electoral College solve one problem with the system but at the same time create another. The direct election by the people causes the influence of the smaller states to decrease and the possibility of a president being elected with only a small

Elimintating the Electoral College

1661 words - 7 pages day, American elections are not truly democratic, for there are no direct Presidential elections. The Electoral College is the constitutional system for the election of the president and vice president of the United Sates. It is the collective name for a group of electors, nominated by political parties within the states, who meet to vote for those two offices. Each party within a state selects a slate of electors numerically equal to the

The Electoral College

1010 words - 4 pages system because this system has worked to elect our officials and candidates since 1787. If this system has worked for more than 300 years, our founding fathers certainly had our best interest in mind. After all, the Electoral College was established to balance the state and people's interests. (Department of State n.d.) Nevertheless, our Founding Fathers first feared the direct popular election option. Since there were no organized national

The Electoral College

733 words - 3 pages ensures presidential interest and support nationwide, as opposed to simply being in the 15 biggest states. The electoral college is the most practical system. The cons of other systems are much more of a reality and pose threats which cannot be exaggerated. The suggested alternatives include: direct popular election, proportional and district elections. These three all share the same problems. The first of which being the cost of the election

The Electoral College.

946 words - 4 pages system and prevents the rise of splinter partiessuch as those that plagued many European democracies. The winner-take-all system means that minor parties get few electoralvotes and that a president who is the choice of the nation as a whole emerges. In the present system, splinter groups could noteasily throw an election into the House.The Electoral College system does democratically reflect the population centres by giving urban areas electoral

The Electoral College - 2395 words

2395 words - 10 pages details of the Electoral College system, a system which denies the power to elect the president to the American people. (The Constitution) To ensure a more complete democracy and a true democratic election of the president, the Electoral College should be abolished in order to allow popular vote to be the method by which the president is elected. Although not common knowledge among the American electorate, presidential elections in the United

The Electoral College - 2474 words

2474 words - 10 pages the mystery is stirring in the minds of the people in the United States of America. With the 2000 Elections underway sides are beginning to be taken among the people. Many oppose the Electoral College because of the fact that unknowing electors choose their leader and many support it because it was created by the founding fathers. Both sides are arguable and not one side is right. The question is: Can a system be created to satisfy both sides of

Similar Essays

The Flawed Electoral College System Essay

1041 words - 4 pages There are quite a few criticisms that surround the Electoral College system. In the next few paragraphs we are going to explore some of these criticisms and some of the advantages and disadvantages of various reform proposals. One major criticism that we faced and still face today is why not vote by popular vote instead of rely on the Electoral votes. Well one of the reasons being is that states like Wyoming or Idaho benefit from it and

Why We Need A New Election System, Problems With The Electoral System.

517 words - 2 pages The Electoral College is an obsolete institution that undermines the citizens' involvement in government. The idea that a candidate can win the popular vote yet lose the election is ridiculous, and only through a system reliant on a popular vote based on a popular vote can the true will of the citizens of the United States directly effect the choice of their leader.The Electoral College was drafted with the birth of this country partially to

Electoral College System Essay

1054 words - 4 pages was in 1988. Even though this has happened many times, it has never changed the outcome of the election. Many people fear that the Electoral College may cause a decline in voter turnout. They say that there is no incentive for states to encourage people to vote. They say that people may decline to vote because many believe there vote does not count. An issue that has plagued the system since its development is the inequality of Electoral

Electoral College Vs Direct Popular Vote

2000 words - 8 pages The current process of electing the President of the United States through the Electoral College system should not be changed because the Electoral College system is superior in comparison to other comprehensive voting systems. Systems like direct popular vote or the national popular vote may work in democracies; however the United States is a federal republic. While allowing large metropolises and large states to be represented in a manner