The Effect Of Gender And Criticism On A Viewer's Opinion

1532 words - 6 pages

Film critics are an insightful source for moviegoers. For those that are unsure whether to attend a movie, critiques allow consumers to evaluate the film's worthiness. Research has shown that individual evaluations of a movie commonly reflect those of well-recognized critics. Furthermore, consumers' evaluations of a film are more likely to follow a critic's when the critique is distinct from the critic's common attitude towards films (i.e., when the critic is a well-established harsh arbiter, but suddenly makes a gracious comment). (d'Astous, Touil, 1999).This experiment sought two hypothesizes, the first was to find a positive correlation between the critical comment about the clip and the viewer's opinion (did the criticism influence the viewer's opinion) and the second was whether the gender of the critic would steer the viewer's opinion.IntroductionResearch has shown that individual evaluations of new movies are more likely to follow a critic's judgment when the critique is consistent with other critiques and when there is favourable consensus. People are also more likely to follow a critic's opinion if the critic is well established; this is especially true if the review is negative (d'Astous, Touil 1999).Although there is research that suggests criticism will affect a viewer's opinion, there does not exist any experiments that test both the effect of gender and criticism. The purpose of this study is to determine whether the gender of the critic will influence a viewer's judgment about a film. It is expected that when subjects are exposed to both positive and negative reviews of the same film, the gender if the critic will manipulate their opinion.Materials*The DVD chosen is "the Red Violin" it has 4 unique scenes which all have one topic which is a violin, but the stories of each person in the movie are unique. They are represented in 4 different languages. Each clip does was chosen in hopes to not denote a feeling of happiness or sadness.oClip 1 - 6:35 - 8:35oClip 2 - 39:00 - 41:00oClip 3 - 51:00 - 53:00oClip 4 - 1:14:00 - 1:16:00*Survey questionnaire*DVD player*Meliza and Tristan as speakers*A script for good and bad opinionsSurvey1.How would you rate the movie on the scale of 1 to 7? (1-Bad, 7-Excellent)□1□2□3□4□5□6□72.To what extent were you paying attention during the film?(1-Not attentive at all, 7-Very attentive)□1□2□3□4□5□6□73.Have you seen the movie before?□Yes□No4.What is your gender?□Male□Female5.What age group are you in?□16-21□22-27□28-33□34-39□40+Your input is very important to us and we appreciate the value of your time and commitment to this survey. Thank you for your participation!CriticismBoth will say: "We are conducting an experiment which will require you to watch a movie clip and answer a survey after."Good Comment: "The movie clip you will be seeing is part of a great movie, I hope...

Find Another Essay On The Effect of Gender and Criticism on a Viewer's Opinion

On Pride and Prejudice, which in your opinion, comes in for the sharper criticism by Jane Austen

978 words - 4 pages Pride and Prejudice.'On pride and prejudice, which in your opinion comes in for sharper criticism from Austen. Support your answer by referring to specific incidents and episodes.'pride n., v., 1. high (or too high) opinion of one's own dignity, importance, worth, etc. 2. the condition or feeling of being proud. 3. a noble sense of what is due to oneself or one's position or character; self respect; self esteem.prejudice n., v., 1. an opinion

The Significance of Animal Symbolism and its Effect on Gender Role

2260 words - 9 pages The Significance of Animal Symbolism and its Effect on Gender Role Throughout many ancient Greek texts, there are aspects of nature playing important roles in the main plot. Sometimes they assist the thesis through a metaphor or simile which better visualizes the author's true meaning. Lions have many different personality traits which make them extremely diverse creatures. This also promotes various applications to characters in

Report on movie: World War II - Cause and Effect (the conclusion needs a little work in my opinion, but my tutor said it was a good report.)

729 words - 3 pages appointed Chancellor of Germany. In August of 1934, Hitler was made Fuhrer giving him the power of president and Chancellor. As a result of Hitler's dictatorship, Germany became a totalitarian police state. Communists, gypsies, homosexuals, and above all, Jews were chastised. The Nuremburg Laws were passed banning Jews and non-Jews from marrying. After Kristallnacht, Jews were put into ghettos. On August 23, 1939, Germany signed a non-aggression

Gender Criticism and The Turn of the Screw by Henry James

1556 words - 6 pages Gender Criticism and The Turn of the Screw The Turn of the Screw by Henry James continues to stir up an immense amount of controversy for such a short novel. Making a definite, educated decision on the actual truth considering the countless inquiries that develop while reading this story proves more difficult than winning a presidential election. That being understood, taking one particular side on any argument from a close reading of the story

Effect of Gender Inequality on Economic Status

2096 words - 9 pages , and highly dependent on foreign aid . This is simply a microcosm of the pattern that can be identified around the world. This pattern can be identified among many countries in every part of the world. The strong correlation between a country’s level of gender equality and economic wealth exists because educated women tend to have fewer children, own property and increase the country’s income. These women will have a more prominent role in the work

Criticism on the morality of "Romeo and Juliet"

1776 words - 7 pages A CRITICISM ON THE MORALITY OF WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE'SROMEO AND JULIETDoes Romeo and Juliet need an introduction? Of all Shakespeare's plays, it has been the most continuously popular since its first performance in the mid-1590's. It would seem, then, the most direct of Shakespeare's plays in its emotional impact. In this paper, the researcher examines the play Romeo and Juliet, its contents, characters, setting and theme being criticized.During

The Farce of Heroism An opinion paper on heroism using examples from "The Gemeral" and "Birth of A Nation".

875 words - 4 pages The Farce of HeroismThe concepts of heroism in war depicted in Birth of a Nation (1915) and The General (1927) are much the same throughout the two films, but the theory of heroism is much different toward the end of the films. The heroism concept portrayed in Birth of a Nation is one of pure and true heart with no stopping until death as was the perceived way of soldiers in the time period. However later in the film the "hero's welcome home

"The Two:" A Look at the Woman-to-Woman Bond and Its Effect on Traditional Gender Roles. Written about "The Two," a chapter from Gloria Naylor's "The Women of Brewster Place".

981 words - 4 pages her participation in the traditional gender role of the subordinate wife, it seems that Sophie may in fact be jealous of the relationship, both romantic and friendly, that Lorraine and Theresa have. She shares no loving relationship with her husband and isn't on particularly friendly terms with the women of Brewster. As Mattie, a supporter of the two, puts it: "'I've loved some women deeper than I ever loved any man... And there been some women

The Effects of Gender Roles and Gender Identity on Behaviour

2221 words - 9 pages The Effects of Gender Roles and Gender Identity on Behaviour Gender is a psychological term, which refers to our awareness and reaction to biological sex. It is also a fundamental part of our learning concept. Gender is influenced by many things, which include: Biological Influences ===================== Such as, Genetics, Estrogens and Androgens. Social Influences

Internalisation of power- an essay on cultural ideals of femininity, internalisation of gender power relations and the effect this has on woman's sense of self.

1949 words - 8 pages against the traditional feminity in the 1920's, the categories of feminine and masculine should have been abolished in order to build a productive society based on solidarity. Instead they were institutionalised. Though irrelevant to most feminist concerns, mass attention was placed on the female body and hasn't shifted since.In conclusion, the power relations in the gender order still remain in favour of man. Early feminists believed that femininity

A Christian's Take on a Worldly Tale is a criticism based on the knowledge of the author and the historical background to the book's era.

968 words - 4 pages A Christian's Take on a Worldly TaleBeowulf, a worldly folk tale, is surprisingly full of Christian values, traditions, and symbolic references. This book was written by a priest who loved history of all kinds, especially Anglo-Saxon. Of course, being a priest he naturally tied in his religious beliefs. The folk story emphasizes the virtues of loyalty, courage, and faith in the face of extreme dangers and even death. These teachings are

Similar Essays

The Effect One’s Gender And Personality Has On Their Ability To Identify The Emotion And Gender Of A Face.

1542 words - 6 pages the faces (Wild et al, 2000). This demonstrates that the biological cues present in the anatomy of a face are sufficient for gender identification to occur efficiently and this ability is acquired during early childhood. Male and female faces can be differentiated between by the shape and texture, which act as cues for identifying the gender of a face. From a front view, identification relies on the texture of the face, which is more noticeable

A Personal Opinion On Pro Choice Along With The Opinion Of Gore And Bush

751 words - 3 pages There are many different sides people can take on the issue of abortion. By viewing the sides and opinions of the candidates for president, it may help you understand what is important, and unimportant about the issue. I believe it is only right for the woman to chose, if she wants an abortion. No man or woman should have the right to say a woman can or can't have an abortion. In conclusion, Vice President Gore is the side I would choose. This

The Effect Of Gender On Response Time

2123 words - 9 pages give the most concentration on the effect of gender on response time. IV. Summary Even though there have been some different experiments showing different results, but the majority experiments were about the influence of gender on time response reaction. Zajdel (2007) concluded that men did respond faster than women which meant men took less time to respond. The purpose of this experiment is to prove that there is a significant

Methods Of Presentation Influence The Viewer's Response.

842 words - 3 pages The methods of presentation influence the viewer's response to the people involved, events reported and the cultural beliefs of a certain topic, showing how the commercial broadcasting stations present reports manipulating the information given to influence the viewer on a certain viewpoint or opinion presented.There are many methods that influence a viewer's response such as the usage of technical and audio codes and the role of the reporter