The Enduring Allure Of Tragedy Essay

1233 words - 5 pages

According to Aristotle, the appeal of tragedy, at its foundation, is katharsis: a purgation of the emotions pity and fear (Kennedy and Gioia 1203). Although scholars do not entirely agree on his meaning, it seems Aristotle had observed something that rings true today: that witnessing a person falling from the apex of achievement, to become humbled and utterly ruined, is inexplicably pleasurable. This is seldom more obvious today than in the keen attention paid to politicians embroiled in scandal, or celebrities having public meltdowns. Like the dramatic tragedies throughout the ages, those observing cannot help but become transfixed. When observed in literature or television it is harmless entertainment, often prompting deep reflection. When played out in the real world, it becomes a guilty pleasure. It often arouses disgust, yes, but also pity and fear.
In Aristotle’s view, the protagonist of a tragedy must be someone whose misfortune could impact many, such as “a king or queen or other member of the royal family” (Kennedy and Gioia 1203). In some ways, it is inarguably it is more dramatic to witness the downfall of a person of great importance, as the resultant mess is quite spectacular. However, Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman is evidence that the tragic descent of the common man can be equally riveting. Moreover, if a proper tragedy should cause the audience to experience fear and pity, the ruination of an unremarkable person should hit much closer to home. Despite being separated by 2400 years, and having vastly different contexts, the tragedies Death of a Salesman and Oedipus the King both tell the story of a man doomed by too much pride and too little information.
In experiencing the unravelling of the lives of both Sophocles’ incestuous hero, King Oedipus, and Arthur Miller’s piteously vitriolic Willy Loman, the reader will almost certainly be stirred to empathy. Both men are condemned by things that they do not understand. For Oedipus, his ignorance of his lineage is his primary fault, ultimately leaving him “damned in his birth, in his marriage damned, [d]amned in the blood he shed with his own hand” (Sophocles 1235). Even with the knowledge that he was destined to kill his father and wed his mother, his ignorance of his birth is his undoing. Willy’s ignorance is less tangible: he doesn’t understand what it takes to become successful, nor does seem to have a flexible definition of what success is. His narrow view precludes him from finding work he enjoys, robs him of time with his family, and leave him alienated from his adult children. This leaves him doubly bitter at the end, as he has emerged a failure, and he hasn’t even enjoyed life along the way. While neither man is truly blameless in his troubles, it is difficult to suppress empathy for those who are ruined by ignorance. Neither man could know that he did not know.
Likewise, both men are confronted with truths over the course of the story which they failed...

Find Another Essay On The Enduring Allure of Tragedy

Tragedy of the commons Essay

1470 words - 6 pages The tragedy of the commons is a dilemma arising from situation in which multiple individuals, acting independently and rationally consulting their own self-interest, will ultimately deplete a shared limited resource even when it is clear that it is not in anyone's long-term interest for this to happen. Hardin's Commons Theory is cited to support the notion of sustainable development, meshing economic growth and environmental protection and has

The tragedy of medea Essay

682 words - 3 pages The Tragedy of MedeaThe play Medea by Eurypides is looked upon as a tragedy even though in the end, the main character of the story succeeds in what she had set upon to accomplish. Even so, this play still fits the Aristotelian definition of a tragedy. Aristotle wrote that for a play to be a tragedy, it must have several characteristics. First, it must show life as being better than it is in reality. Tragedies are also imitations of events in

The Tragedy of Hamlet.

860 words - 3 pages Arguably the best piece of writing ever done byWilliam Shakespeare, "Hamlet" the is the classic example of atragedy. In all tragedies the hero suffers, and usuallydies at the end. Othello stabs himself, Romeo and Julietcommit suicide, Brutis falls on his sword, and like themHamlet dies by getting cut with a poison tipped sword. Butthat is not all that is needed to consider a play a tragedy,and sometimes a hero doesn't even need to die.Not every

The Master Of Tragedy

583 words - 2 pages effects that he is best known for. While people may believe that all of his plays are significant, and rightly so, Sophocles had a certain theme to his works. This was primarily his idea of tragedy, and this is why Sophocles is considered to be one of the most important play writes. "The greatest of the Greek tragedians and the perfect mean between the monumental symbolism of Aeschylus and the rhetorical realism of Euripides" ("Sophocles").Sophocles

The Tragedy of Oedipus

1541 words - 6 pages The Tragedy of Oedipus When there is the mention of a hero in literature, the image of a tall, strong man on a pure colored horse, with a sword drawn and the shield held up, crying out to his men the honor and good they will bring in defense of their homeland, may come to mind. This, though, is not the image Sophocles gives to Oedipus, yet Oedipus is considered a true hero. Even if he is not depicted as a great war hero, or one who does some

The Tragedy of Hamlet

681 words - 3 pages 3Harold BittThe Tragedy of HamletThe protagonist of Hamlet is Prince Hamlet of Denmark, son of the recently deceased King Hamlet, and nephew of King Claudius, his father's brother and successor. Claudius hastily married King Hamlet's widow, Gertrude, Hamlet's mother. Denmark has a long-standing feud with neighbouring Norway, and an invasion led by the Norwegian prince, Fortinbras, is expected.The play opens on a cold winter midnight on "platform

The Tragedy of Steroids

4006 words - 16 pages and Drugs. ?  "Racing Demons: Use of performance-enhancing drugs may grab sporting headlines, but the real tragedy is what happens later." Time International. 157.10. p 50+. Mar 12 2001. Infotrac. Galegroup. Lebanese American University Library, Beirut. 18 Apr 2001. Sports and Drugs. ?  Reuters. "Drugs as old as Olypmpia, as new as the Internet" Sep. 19 2000. 19 Apr 2001. ?  Ringhofer, Kevin R., & Martha E. Harding

The Triumph of Bundle Theory: A Lack of Evidence for an Enduring Self

1270 words - 5 pages ). With death, a human is stripped of thoughts, stripped of pain and pleasure, of heat and cold. Perceptions and the self coexist with each other, as seen in death, so it stands to reason that the self is nothing more than a bundle of various perceptions. IV. Arguments for the Bundle Theory Overall, many philosophers have failed to find evidence that an enduring self, as described by the substance theory, actually exists (Behrendt 2). In trying to

The Obsessive Nature of Desire Presented in The Great Gatsby, Othello and Enduring Love

2886 words - 12 pages Obsession is defined as “an unhealthy and compulsive preoccupation with something or someone” (1), and is a prominent theme (in) The Great Gatsby, Enduring Love and Othello. For example, in all three, there is a great desire to obtain things which are unattainable, and in turn this fuels their obsession and causes it to intensify. Furthermore, the act of being obsessive is a common human characteristic, which enforces the fact that obsession is

The Tragedy Of The Commons

9628 words - 39 pages (Jan Melis) In de praktijk komt het beheer van natuurlijke hulpbronnen vaak neer op wanbeheer. Het bekendste voorbeeld hiervan is ongetwijfeld 'the tragedy of the commons'.1.1 The Tragedy of the Commons Reeds in 1833 vroeg Lloyd zich af waarom de dieren in een gemeenschappelijk weiland zo mager waren, en de gewassen zo schraal, net als het land zelf (Lloyd 1833, in Hardin, 1977). Hardin

The Tragedy of Sophocles' Antigone

969 words - 4 pages The Tragedy of Antigone  In the story of Antigone, Oedipus has already died, his two sons. Polyneices and Eteocles, left to contend for the throne of Thebes. In their contention for the throne, the two brothers slay one another, leaving Creon once again to be the acting regent of Thebes. With this power, Creon declares that Polyneices must be left to rot on the battlefield, the highest disgrace to any Greek. Antigone, daughter of

Similar Essays

To What Extent Has Your Personal Response To The Tragedy Of Othello Has Been Shaped By The Enduring Power Of Shakespeare's Characterisation Of Othello.

1168 words - 5 pages My personal response to Othello has been completely shaped by Shakespeare's characterization of Othello. The themes and ideas that Shakespeare tried to convey through the play are all done through the characterization of his characters.Othello is predominantly a traditional Shakespearean tragedy shadowed with post-colonial aspects. This view is supported and demonstrated through the characterization of Othello in Othello.Through Othello's

The Enduring Legend Of Romeo And Juliet

2297 words - 9 pages noticeable change is the time span in which the story takes place. Shakespeare had shortened the time span from nine months to a few days. With such a little time to solve the problems "the hasty march of events becomes a major cause of the tragedy" (Hankins 17). Another example of time, gave Romeo and Juliet three months of bliss in the Brooke poem compared to one passionate night in the Shakespeare play. Shakespeare changed the characters

The Enduring Benefits Of Graphic Notation

2648 words - 11 pages addition, these works demonstrate that notation can extend beyond instructional functionality to allow for prominent interpretive and aleatoric elements, and can harbour an intrinsic aesthetic value of its own, apparent before a single note is sounded. This paper will discuss some of the enduring benefits that early forays into graphic notation have imparted to later generations of performers and composers. I will contrast these advancements

The Allure Of Power In The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy

1992 words - 8 pages our hands against. He is fallen” (Tolkien 1019). Frodo acknowledges that before the Ring Saruman was great, powerful and noble. Unfortunately the temptation of the Ring destroys him. After his defeat at Isengard he is powerless apart from his words. Like Saruman, Gandalf is a Wizard and a member of the order. However, Gandalf is able to withstand the allure of the Ring. Gandalf the Grey is very powerful Wizard, although he is not as powerful as