The Engineering Approch To Problem Solving

5819 words - 23 pages

Proceedings of the 2004 American Society for Engineering Education Annual Conference & Exposition Copyright © 2004, American Society for Engineering Education
The Engineering Problem-Solving Process: Good for Students?
Durward K. Sobek II, Vikas K. Jain Montana State University
As part of an ongoing effort to better understand student problem-solving processes to open- ended problems, we have coded 14 mechanical engineering projects (representing about 60 journals) according to abstraction level, design activity, planning, and reporting. We also developed quantitative outcome measures that are reported in a separate submission to this conference. We then developed a computer model of the journal data that correlates 12 key process variables to design outcomes, and conducted a computer design of experiments to extract the effects that the process variables have on the response variables (i.e., project outcomes). In this paper we report the results of this modeling effort and discuss their implications for the general model of engineering problem-solving presented in various forms in many engineering textbooks. Our results suggest modifications to the engineering problem-solving model to make it more suitable for engineering students.
1. Introduction
Solving open-ended problems is arguably the cornerstone of the engineering endeavor. Employers look for engineers who are effective at solving open-ended problems. Engineering accreditation demands evidence that students can tackle open-ended problems proficiently. Much faculty effort is devoted to improving student skills in this area. The basic process model used for these kinds of problems starts with identification of need, then goes through information gathering, idea generation, evaluation and selection steps-in other words, a basic design process model. Our three-year study of student design processes suggests that the general model for engineering problem-solving may require some tweaking to make it a more effective model for engineering students.
Over the decades, numerous models have been proposed to describe "the engineering design process." However, few of these have been empirically validated or experimentally verified. Most have been developed through personal experience and accumulation of anecdotes. Furthermore, few models explicitly consider student processes relative to project outcomes. Our work attempts to further our understanding of problem-solving processes by gathering data from actual projects (one in which the participants have real stakes) in large enough sample sizes to enable statistical modeling that directly links design process to outcome.
In this study, we analyzed data collected from 14 student mechanical engineering design projects, relating design process variables to project outcomes using statistical techniques. Our aim was to better understand what process characteristics tend to be associated with good design outcomes.
Session 1331


Find Another Essay On the engineering approch to problem solving

The Army Problem Solving Model Essay

917 words - 4 pages Military leaders make decisions and solve problems every day. Some need a decision quickly while others can take time. The US Army has several decision-making methods to assist leaders. The Army Problem Solving Model (Process) is a systematic approach to identifying the best possible solution to an issue or problem and a deliberate method of decision-making. (FM 6-0, 2009) Leaders use it to solve a problem when time is not critical and they

School Uniforms Solving the Problem Essay

542 words - 2 pages School Uniforms Solving the Problem Over the past couple of years, school uniform policies have been enforced as the most efficient method for “solving” problems such as crime and attendance ratings in our public schools. Many schools state that it is quite true that uniforms are lowering such mentioned rates of crime tremendously, but can this really be proven? Currently, there have only been informal studies that try to actually

Solving the Worlds Water Problem

759 words - 4 pages technique that we need to use in the future to ensure clean water for all the world’s population. It may have some negatives, but the positives outweigh it by far. Recycling may be the best solution but that can only go so far. Drilling more wells will temporarily solve our problem, but eventually ground water will run out. Currently, desalination is the best idea to solving the world’s water problem in the long run. Works Cited Desalination What

Solving the Adverse Selection Problem

698 words - 3 pages Charlene Wang Adverse selection Adverse selection is a problem that generally arises from the occurrence of symmetric information prior to the execution of a transaction. In the insurance sector, an adverse selection refers to a situation where an insurance firm is faced with a probability of loss as a result of not factoring in a risk during the sale of an insurance cover. In the case of an adverse selection, individuals are advised to look for

Solving the Problem of Procrastination

828 words - 4 pages with acute anxiety and hassle, even if I ultimately finish the assignment on time. I am on a journey to find out why people procrastinate and hopefully find attainable solutions to the problem of procrastination, but first I must go outside and play in the snow. People all procrastinate at one time or another. Procrastination is the practice of delaying work on important tasks in favor of less challenging ones. Chronic procrastinating hinders

Critical Thinking-Applying Reasoning to Problem Solving

599 words - 2 pages amounts that I normally pay to each of them on a monthly basis. In conjunction with this spreadsheet I also had to log onto my online banking service, so that I could capture expenses that were not of a regular monthly payment nature.What I found in the analysis phase of my problem solving assignment was astounding. I came upon large amounts of money being spent on miscellaneous items at Wal-Mart, a large amount of e-bay activity, and some various

Solving the Foreclosure Crisis, like Solving an Algebra Problem

2474 words - 10 pages From the mere sight of this problem, if you have not been regularly practicing algebra, solving it may prove to be a daunting task. The fearful would turn a blind eye; they would allow this problem to go unsolved. Those with a bit more courage, and a general idea of how to solve the problem, may look at all of the X’s and cancel them out leaving just the numbers behind. The X’s are the terms. If one were to cancel out the terms, they would be

The Process of Creative Problem Solving

1917 words - 8 pages Creative Problem Solving PAGE 1 Running head: THE Process OF CREATIVE PROBLEM SOLVINGThe Process of Creative Problem Solving Dallas Baptist UniversityLiterature ReviewWhile problem solving is an almost universal aspect of life, very few individuals follow a structured approach to solving problems. There is no simple plan that represents the universal problem solving process. Any process one may apply in the workplace or in ones personal life

The impact of organizational culture on approaches to organizational problem-solving

2121 words - 8 pages The impact of organizational culture on approaches to organizational problem-solvingتأثير ثقافة المنظمة في حل المشاكلby: Paul Batev Anthropologists would recognize that humans are social animals and form communities to achieve common aims, through cooperation and mutual

Proposed Solution for Solving the Foreclosure Problem

1463 words - 6 pages My proposed solution for the foreclosure problem has several parts. They include eliminating and legally banning interest only loans, mandatory loan modifications, government tax incentives to stay in a potentially foreclosed home and consumer education. Many years ago the mortgage companies created the thirty year home loan. It seems like this extended payment plan would benefit the homeowner by allowing more time to pay for the

Insight Problem Solving and the Nine-Dot Problem

1664 words - 7 pages can be well-defined or ill-defined but are encountered more often when the overall issue is ill-defined as there are several alternate paths. What is an Insight Problem? Whether well-defined or ill-defined, most people follow a general problem-solving model which requires identifying the problem, developing steps and strategies, implementing a plan, and assessing its progress. Sort of like the idiom of “getting warmer” or closer and closer to the

Similar Essays

Adding Value To The Problem Solving Perspective

913 words - 4 pages Problem solving is part of every organization strategic management functions whether the organization is functional in structure or a large decentralized type of organization; problems exist and management ought to find appropriate problem solving mechanism in order to deal with them. “Adding value to the problem-solving perspective (PSP)” written by Herman A Van Den Berg argues on the elements of a firm emphases to opportunity or value which he

The Sara Problem Solving Model Applied Criminology Associates (Aca). (2002). Introduction To Partnership Problem Solving; Problem Solving Workbook

1959 words - 8 pages A problem is defined as recurring incidents that are similar in nature, cause harm or have the potential to cause harm, and that the public expects the police to fix. (The International Association of Crime Analysts [IACA]) Problem solving consists of a planning process which involves brainstorming and coming up with alternative ways to correct an undesirable situation. There are many processes, approaches, procedures, methods, tactics

Solving The Algebraic Problem Essay

718 words - 3 pages become better at a subject they enjoy and have motivation to study something they love? Today students study and do their homework so they can pass the class, not to sit there and actually absorb the information that teachers try to teach. Today multiple occupations don’t even utilize algebraic equations to figure out the problem at work. Multiple companies have to teach their own math because schools focus on calculus, algebra, trigonometry, etc

Steps To Solving The Foreclosure Problem In America

1259 words - 5 pages unemployment as well as the high increase in foreclosures around the country. I, along with many other American would just like to be reassured that our future will not be in fear of how to make the next payment on a home. Reassurance that a home can be purchased and not fear that if a decrease in yearly income occurs, foreclosure will shortly follow. This problem cannot be swept under the rug anymore but addressed promptly and eagerly.