The Epa And Anti Tobacco Zealots Essay

1287 words - 5 pages

The EPA and Anti-tobacco Zealots

Tobacco smoking has been one of the hot controversies of our time. Many people find tobacco smoke annoying, smelly and just plain dirty and unpleasant. Some smokers themselves agree with that sentiment. Today's smoking restrictions, not to mention the attack on smokers and extortion of tobacco companies, could not have been engineered simply on the grounds that tobacco smoke is unpleasant. We needed another reason. So the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) literally manufactured, using bogus science, the finding that second-hand smoke is a class A carcinogen causing death and illness for tens of thousands of people who are simply around tobacco smoke. The major news media, along with anti-tobacco zealots, convinced us of the wisdom of the EPA report. They downplayed or ignored findings showing EPA science to be bogus and outright fraud. (1)

The EPA and anti-tobacco zealots "proved" that tobacco smokers harmed other people. Stopping and preventing harm to others, especially to the nation's children, is something most Americans can wholeheartedly support. Thus, all manner of smoking regulations descended upon the nation from bans on smoking on airplanes, in airports and restaurants to bars, workplaces and even outdoor open air stadiums. Let's pretend that the EPA's bogus science about the harmful effects of secondhand smoke is legitimate and examine this business about harming others.

The first thing we should acknowledge is that we live in a world of harms. The secondhand smoke from my cigarette might harm you. However, your being able to prevent me from smoking harms me; I have less enjoyment. We cannot say which person's harm is more important and should take precedence. The reason why is that it is impossible to make interpersonal utility comparisons. In other words, there is no scientific way of deciding whose well-being is more important: whether the harm you suffer from my smoking is more important than the harm I suffer from not being permitted to smoke.

This impossibility of making interpersonal utility comparisons is applicable to most well-being type comparisons. For example, suppose there is a beautiful lady that both Jim and Bob are pursuing. If Jim wins her hand, Bob is harmed and if Bob wins her hand, Jim is harmed. There is no scientific way anyone can determine whose harm is more important and should take precedence over the other.

In a socialistic society, conflicting harms are resolved through government intimidation and coercion. In a free society, conflicting harms are settled through the institution of private property rights. Private property rights has to do with rights, belonging to the person deemed owner of property and protected by the state, to keep, acquire, use and dispose of property as he deems fit so long as he does not violate the property rights of another.

Therefore, in a free society, whether smoking harms others or not is irrelevant. The relevant issue is who owns the...

Find Another Essay On The EPA and Anti-tobacco Zealots

The use and abuse of anti-biotics

1311 words - 5 pages This essay will be describing the good and bad sides to they can be safely used or dangerously abused of. An antibiotic (anti biotic) is often a medication made from a natural, or at most, semi-synthetic substance This means that the medication is derived from a bacterium, a fungus, the bark of a tree, and so on. An antibiotic is any chemical substance produced by or derived from a microorganism that has the capacity in dilute

My Term Paper is on " The shortcomings of the EPA under Anne (Burford) Gorsuch". It's about hazardous waste. My introduction is strong and includes my thesis.

1621 words - 6 pages The shortcomings of the EPA under Anne (Burford) Gorsuch. Research is continually reaffirming the need for a strong, aggressive Environmental Protection Agency ("poison" 7). The average American's exposure to toxic chemicals is expected to double in the 1980's. Experts estimate that there are as many as 50,000 dumps with toxic chemical wastes across the country and 180,000 open pits, ponds and lagoons with toxic waste and at least 14,000 of

Anti-rape Legislation and the Commerce Clause

1262 words - 5 pages ], In other words, the application of this law would violate the separation of powers between the central government and state governments. Congress passing anti-rape legislation would give Congress too much say in local rules which would render state authority negligible. Following the precedent made in the 1995 US vs Lopez case, the opinion is that all criminal laws passed through the commerce clause are unconstitutional. The civil

The Framers: Federalists and Anti-Federalists

650 words - 3 pages system of government, with two sides emerging both with contrary, but comparable motives on how to keep their country running efficiently. First there were the Federalists, who favored a stronger national government run by elected officials. They believed there was a need to protect both the right to private property and free enterprise that only a unified central government could ensure. Then there were Anti- Federalists who believed that the bulk of

McCarthy and The Anti-communist Crusade

1293 words - 5 pages country. They lost their friends, jobs, families, and all respect by everyone they knew. Ellen W. Schrecker states, “The anti-communist crusade affected thousands of individuals, institutions, and communities […].” meaning that this Red Scare affected every aspect of American life, not just the people accused (199). Businesses, families, organizations, and every part of American society were negatively impacted by this incident. Safety of mind is

Spanish Anti-terrorism and the Basque Society

2595 words - 10 pages Within Basque society, there is an ideological conflict due to the use of violence as a political tool. Many criticize Spanish anti-terrorism movements as violating the human rights of the ETA—many captured ETA members are imprisoned for decades, exiled from the country, tortured, or killed (Basque Conflict)—but they also find themselves exhausted and emotionally overtaxed by living in an environment that revolves around constant violence and

The difference between Anti-Zionism and Anti-Semitism and their histories. Includes footnotes.

2088 words - 8 pages generations. The Zionists (and other Jewish) movements sought to restore these geographical territories to Israel as well.Anti-Semitic literally means prejudice against Semitic people, but in practice it has been directed only against Jews. Anti-Semitism became strong in Austria, France, and Germany, and from 1881, pogroms in Poland and Russia caused refugees to flee to the USA, to the UK, and to other European countries as well as Palestine. In the

Classical and Modern Anti-Semitism in the Mortara Case

1904 words - 8 pages According to the Merriam Webster Dictionary, anti-Semitism is hostility toward or discrimination against Jews as a religious, ethnic, or racial group. There are two main types of anti-Semitism: classical anti-Semitism and modern anti-Semitism. Classical anti-Semitism is the hatred and intolerance towards Jews because of their religious differences. According to, “Modern anti-Semitism, in contrast to earlier forms, was based

"The Merchant of Venice" and Anti-Semitic beliefs.

1393 words - 6 pages a fact that Jewish people killed Christ. I wouldn’t blame Shakespeare for being anti-Semitic towards people of the Jewish faith because the crime they committed is unforgiveable.What exactly is anti-Semitism? Derek Cohen explains it as “A work of art as one that portrays Jews in a way that makes them objects of antipathy to readers and spectators-objects of scorn, hatred, laughter, or contempt” (194). Was Shakespeare anti-Semitic

The history and roots of anti-Semitism is Europe

889 words - 4 pages When people hear of anti-Semitism, they think of the horrific events that happened in Germany when Hitler was in control. But anti-Semitism actually existed in Europe long before those events took place. This essay will discuss why the Jewish people have been discriminated against, what has happened as a result of that discrimination and what action has been taken to prevent it.Anti-Semitism started because of religion. According to the New

Shakespeare And Anti-Semitism In The Merchant Of Venice

1384 words - 6 pages      Anti-Semitism and the desecration of the Jewish population have been in existence for nearly five thousand years. In the Elizabethan era, a question of anti-Semitism invariably arises. In William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice, we find that one of the characters is the embodiment and expression of anti-Semitic attitude that is pervasive in Elizabethan society. "Anti-Semitism was an intricate part in

Similar Essays

The Tobacco Industry And Taxation Essay

810 words - 3 pages . Will taxing these products be what makes the tobacco industry fail? A majority of our nation has let it be known that they favor the higher prices that have been placed on tobacco products; however, these prices are not harming the sellers as much as the buyers.The sales of cigarettes have a state and federal taxes placed on them. The sellers of cigarettes try to place most of these costs on the consumers, so they can make as much money as possible

The Beatles And The Anti War Movement

2522 words - 10 pages The Beatles have been noted as one of the greatest, if not the greatest, and most persuasive bands of all time. They were both musical and lyrical masterminds whom interpreted their opinions through their music. Of those many opinions their main message they wanted to send was the idea of peace. The Beatles opposed the war in Vietnam and were avid participants in the anti-war movement; by trend setting, not being afraid to speak their mind

Tobacco Use And The Effects On Individuals In Society

936 words - 4 pages Tobacco use is a very common issue that continues to arise in todays fast pace ever-changing economy. Nevertheless, with the present increase in stress, people seek for different ways to help indulge cravings or reduce overbearing and endless stress related problems. Cigarette use these days seems to be a helpful and resourceful way out for many people as they can easily become addicted and crave tobacco. Ironically, despite the health conscious

Jane Eyre And The Anti Heroes Essay

851 words - 3 pages numerous characters. Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre, however, had a strong-willed anti-heroine main character that did not comply with social customs. Characteristics of anti-heroes and heroines are definite human flaws, not always thinking about what the moral action is, and rejection of traditional values. Jane Eyre is considered the anti-heroine because she defies the patriarchy and the social hierarchy in Victorian Society, as well as maintaining her