The Ethical Treatment Of Prisoners Essay

2355 words - 9 pages


A Utilitarian View of Prison Labor & Behavioral Impact of Prisoners
INTRODUCTION
The ethical theory of utilitarianism and the perspective on relativism, of prison labor along with the relativism on criminal behavior of individuals incarcerated are two issues that need to be addressed. Does the utilitarianism of prisoner’s right laws actually protect them? Or are the unethical actions of the international and states right laws exploiting the prison labor? Unethical procedures that impact incarcerated individuals and correctional staff, the relativism of respect as people and not just prisoner’s; the safety of all inmates and correctional staff, are all issues worth continuous reflection.
LABOR & PRISONERS
When reviewing the international human right laws we see that it is put in place to protect the prisoner’s capabilities working in the private prison systems. With the advance degree of the rise in population of prisoners incarcerated every year, the more rapidly they are exploited in their labor capabilities. Where there are three different areas prisoners may work :) in the institution where the prisoner is incarcerated which is called a private prison, a private subdivision which is involved with the prison industries, and, private subdivisions that are engaged with the work release program. Over the years prison labor has been a matter of interest and concern with the (ILO) International Labor Organization, yet the international law is not advancing to the degree that it needs too on this specific subject. (Fenwick, C. 2005). In argument of this we need recognize how the prison labor is being used for profit beyond what it should and needs to be addressed if we have any regard to how we treat the incarcerated. Yes they have committed a crime or many crimes or they may have been convicted falsely, but if God has hope for humanity then the utilitarian relativism of treatment should conclude we treat fellow humans with the hope that they can change and not exploit their labor capabilities. Using their labor as means for profit is not ethically correct. I’m not saying there is an easy answer; it involves many facets of virtues well within the prison system and the individuals themselves. Yet the utilitarian view of prison labor should not be a market of how many can monopolize these prisoners for their own selfish profit and be a continuum of globalization.
Both private operation of prisons and the private use of prisoners’ labor, they are part of a broader increase in the private subdivision involvement in the direct operation of correction facilities. This is related in the process of globalization. In respect for a better understanding of the impact of globalization and the capabilities of nation states to support their international legal obligations to protect primary human rights. While private involvement running prisons and exploitation of prisoners’ labor does contribute to globalization it has been a rule rather than an...

Find Another Essay On The Ethical Treatment of Prisoners

The Differences in the Treatment of Prisoners of War by Britain, Germany and Japan

3929 words - 16 pages The Differences in the Treatment of Prisoners of War by Britain, Germany and Japan Works Cited Not Included According international law a POW is defined as "persons captured by a belligerent while fighting in the military." International law includes "rules on the treatment of prisoners of war but extends protection only to combatants. This excludes civilians who engage in hostilities (by international law they are war

Comparing the Treatment of Prisoners of War in the Andersonville and the Rock Island Prison Camp during the Civil War

2215 words - 9 pages A. Plan of investigation The ethics and rules of war have been a fiercely debated topic for centuries. One facet of war that is particularly divisive is the treatment of prisoners of war. This investigation compares the treatment of prisoners of war in the Andersonville and Rock Island prison camps during the American Civil War. Andersonville and Rock Island are widely regarded as the harshest prison camps of the Confederate and Union armies

Ethical Treatment of Clerical Phedophilia

1904 words - 8 pages either, and masturbation is considered to be a sin. If, after presenting this treatment offer to Father X and being granted his approval, it would be ethical to proceed with the approach as it would mean that harm-reduction would be done to the community – the religious importance of the guidelines of Catholicism would be up to Father X to deal with. The final treatment which may be presented to Father X would include medications to lower his

Animal Testing and People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals

1307 words - 5 pages animal. For example, penicillin kills guinea pigs but it is totally inactive in rabbits. When tested on animals the results are not always the same. Alternative methods would be beneficial to companies so that they don’t loose money when people start to not by their product. Researching on the PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) website a Journal of the American Medical Association and British Medical Journal stated that “Animal

Hypothetical Treatment of Ethical Dilemma

1969 words - 8 pages This paper is an analysis of a hypothetical vignette in which a counselor-in-training named Callie, a fairly experienced and nearly-licensed counselor supervisee, approaches her counselor supervisor for advice and direction regarding an ethical dilemma. The purpose of this paper is to identify the ethical and legal implications of the dilemma along with an optimal solution to ethically resolve the issue. Using the Forrester-Miller and Davis

Mairead Farrell: IRA Member, Female Prisoner/Hunger Striker and the Treatment of Women Prisoners in Armagh Jail

1803 words - 7 pages -searches were actually a violation of Article 3 of the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms Act, which states that "No one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment (http://irelandsown.net/armaghwomen.html).These incidents started the "dirty protest" at Armagh Jail on February 7, 1980. They also started a "no-wash" protest as well. The women prisoners didn't wash

Helping the Family of Prisoners

1067 words - 4 pages 1. Helping the Family of Prisoners According to available statistics, the number of people who are incarcerated in state and federal prisons in the United States of America increases each year. Estimation indicates a 2.5 percent increase in the number of prisoners in USA from last year; it suggests a number of 2245000 inmates in all prisons in USA (Reuter). Such a rapid growth in the number of prisoners has several consequences. More prisons

AIDS and Ethical Treatment of Infected Patients

4033 words - 16 pages IntroductionThis paper will examine the ethical issues related to HIV/AIDS testing, treatment, and research. Key issues analyzed include confidentiality, informed consent, and end of life, research design, conflict of interest, vulnerable populations, and vaccine research. Although many examples are drawn from the United States, these issues are also explored from a global perspective. Major U.S. and international legal statutes, regulations

The Ashley Treatment: Practical, but Ethical?

788 words - 4 pages The Ashley Treatment: Practical, But Ethical? Allison Veeder, RN - Hitler times – medical experiments - Kennedy sister – lobotomy - Potential grave consequences that can result from irresponsible, or criminal, medical experiments. While we must be vigilant to protect innocent victims from such experimentation we cannot let that stifle our duty to continue making advances in healthcare and improving the lives of patients. - Moral obligations

The Prisoners of “The Long Sheet”

872 words - 4 pages Imagine being a prisoner tasked with a strange sentence. The prisoner is to be let free when the sheet draped across room is completely dry. However, the prisoner is not burdened with this task alone. The task is shared with several other prisoners who must work together to ever hope to get out. This is the basis of “The Long Sheet.” However, this strange tale also offers a detailed look into the variety of work ethics and the mishaps each room

P.E.T.A -The Protection of the Ethical Treatment of Animals (Special Interest Groups)

540 words - 2 pages PETA (People of the Ethical Treatment of Animals), which operates under the simple principle that animals are not ours to eat, wear, experiment on, or use for entertainment.Testing at the University of Oregon, Barbara Gorden-Lickey, Ph.D, sewed kittens' eyes shut and forced them to jump from various heights onto a platform surrounded by water so she could study the effects of sight deprivation on the brain. Cruel and inhumane experiments like this

Similar Essays

Treatment Of Transgender Prisoners Essay

2782 words - 11 pages all available community health records.” (Federal Bureau of Prisons policy 6031.003, Patient Care) The federal policy on sex reassignment was left open as an alternate, as are all “appropriate treatment options”. (Federal Bureau of Prisons policy 6031.003, Patient Care) “Although transgender prisoners with medical needs related to their gender identity has experienced increasing success litigating their claims in courts.” (Silpa, 2011) In state

The Ethical Treatment Of Animals Essay

736 words - 3 pages I believe in the ethical treatment for all animals is an ethical obligation by all humans. We have come to an era that we believe that all humans should be treated equally and fairly. Well, what about our other living, breathing counterparts? They deserve to live their life as they choose in quality and in the pursuit of happiness. Just as Europeans came and took over Northern America's land and resources on the Indians. We have also taken

People For The Ethical Treatment Of Animals

1043 words - 4 pages People for the Ethical Treatment of AnimalsBy: Jonas TrefzgerPeople for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), is an American organization focusing on animal rights. It is a non-profit corporation with 300 employees, and it claims to have three million members including supporters. It also claims to be the largest animal rights group in the world, with its slogan being "Animals are not ours to eat, wear, experiment on, use for entertainment or

The Geneva Convention's Influence On The Treatment Of Prisoners Of War

822 words - 4 pages What is the Geneva Convention? The Geneva Convention was created to take care of prisoners of war. It contains rules about the treatment and rights of prisoners of war during captivity. A quote told by Michael Ignatieff, Human Rights as Politics and Idolatry about the Geneva convention: “...our species is one, and each of the individuals who compose it are entitled to equal moral consideration.” It