The Ethics And Limitations Of Animal Research

1871 words - 7 pages

The moral status of animals is an issue of much debate in Science. According to The Royal Society, the oldest scientific academy nowadays, it would have been impossible for science and medicine to develop so without animal research (“The Use of Non-Human Animals in Research”, 2004). Nevertheless, do the human medical benefits really justify the animal suffering in animal research? If so, what should are the possible considerations and limitations related to the matter? It appears to be a challenge to find common ground concerning the above questions. This paper will first present the current guidelines of animal research, and what is being done to help preserve the suffering and health animals as much as possible. In order to have a full insight on the matter, it is also needed to present the main methods of animal research. Scientists have used animals in many research projects or operations. Not every animal experiment carries the risk of physical or mental stress to the animal. The purpose is to eventually build on the existing instruments, and identify the concern of the moral status of animals as and additional tool to evaluate the appropriate limitations of animal research.

Types of Animal Research

The range of applied animal research varies from simple observational studies, up to drug testing or dissections. Therefore, it is important to differentiate between the circumstantial procedures that are carried on animal research. Considering the above, it will be easier to understand the pivotal objections about animal experimentation and how they can vary from situation to situation. This differentiation will help to set the limitations of animal research and identify the most problematic issues. Saying that animal research is harmful for the animals is poor judgment.
Observational and behavioral studies involve minimal first hand interaction between the experimenter and the animal subject. In these cases the animals are situated in certain environmental conditions (i.e. maze) where the observers record the interaction of the animal with the environment. The purpose of this type of research is to understand the interaction and mutual effect between environment and biology. In general, observational studies tend to minimize the human-animal interaction. As a result, these studies are generally safe for the physical wellbeing of the animal. Nevertheless, if an animal is stationed in a maze or similar puzzle, this may lead to psychological pressure. Despite this, observational studies tend to be less risky for the animals while operating on the respective principles of conduct (Snowdon, n.d.).
On the other side, a series of animal experimentations put the subject in both mental and physical stress. These cases can range from dissections to in-vivo experimentation. Much of the controversy on animal research is coming from experimentation with alive animals, which is in-vitro. Claims follow that using an animal for experimentation is...

Find Another Essay On The Ethics and Limitations of Animal Research

Research Findings of Both the Benefits and Limitations of DAP Testing

1401 words - 6 pages Research Findings of Both Benefits and Limitations of DAP Testing This paper focuses on research information of Draw A Person (DAP) testing in both its original form of Children’s Human Figure Drawing created by Florence Goodenough, it’s limitations, and it’s current form of function as DAP testing of today. DAP is typically used to identify cognitive strengths and limitations among primary aged youth through the evaluation of the drawn human

Comparing Jane Goodall's A Question of Ethics and Heloisa Sabin's Essay "Animal Research Saves Human Lives"

1189 words - 5 pages choices human beings make. This view can be unrealistic in many situations. Jane Goodall’s A Question of Ethics was a very emotional and Rogerian style essay, but I found it lacked the supporting facts and credibility that can be found in Heloisa Sabin’s aggressive “classic” styled essay Animal research Saves Human Lives. Heloisa Sabin helped establish the Sabin Vaccine Institute in 1993 whose mission is to promote the role of vaccines which will

The Ethics of Weapon and Military Research

2723 words - 11 pages The Ethics of Weapon and Military Research missing works cited Many people everyday get in their car, look at their navigation system and try to figure out how to get home. While they are driving, a voice will direct them in the correct direction, all they have to do is follow the directions. Once they are home they put some food in the microwave. While waiting for the food to cook, they might call someone on the their cell phone or check

The Definition and Limitations of Harm

1536 words - 6 pages are also necessary for his overall definition to be viable. Without such limitations, society could restrict any action the majority of the population finds disagreeable. The actions an individual is at liberty to do would become limited, and Mill’s liberty principle would transform into “a law on the minority” (Mill 88). For example, vegetarians or vegans could insist that an individual should not eat meat, citing that it insults their morals

Nazi Appeal And The Limitations Of Democracy

2144 words - 9 pages Germany suffered severe financial and ideological crises in the aftermath of World War I. Even as it struggled to rebuild itself in the post-war period, the Allies saddled Germany with the Treaty of Versailles. This document assigned sole responsibility for the war to Germany and required staggering reparation payments. The treaty also stipulated that Germany must tremendously scale down its military forces. Disillusioned, economically

The Use of Animal Research

1894 words - 8 pages How will animal research tell us the outcomes of the human body? How can we live longer and healthier lives with the use of animals? Do animals have a link to the human body that we are able to prove that trying new drugs or new cosmetics will be a benefit for us? I disagree. I believe we test on animals to figure out what are the possible outcomes for humans; however, the use of animals is cruel and unnecessary because they do not have a

The Cruelty of Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation

1391 words - 6 pages The Cruelty of Animal Testing and the Need for Alternative Methods In his book Inhumane Society: The American Way of Exploiting Animals, Dr. Michael W. Fox estimates that twenty-five to thirty-five million animals are used in the United States each year for laboratory testing and research (58). Research involving tests done on animals is unnecessary and cruel. More humane methods of research need to be employed. Fox states that animal

The Ethics of Medical Animal Testing

1896 words - 8 pages organizations’ complaints centers around the differences between the physiology of humans and other animals. Just because a works on and doesn’t hurt a rat doesn’t mean it will work on a human, and vice versa. In they paint the whole picture of animal testing as meaningless cruelty supported by people too embarrassed and too worried about getting in trouble to admit they are wrong. Sites such as the Research Defense Society attempt to debunk many of

The Statute of Limitations

810 words - 3 pages liabilities, with injuries may take time to manifest, many courts adapted different rules such as postponing the running of the statute until the injury has been reasonably discovered. The length of time differs among states and branches of law (Danzon, 1985). The long and deferred statutes of limitations lead to long tail of claims and contributed majority of medical malpractice and product liability (Danzon, 1985). In this section, statutes of

Limitations of the Paparazzi

1424 words - 6 pages The paparazzi can receive up to thousands of dollars for candid pictures of celebrities. As celebrities become more popular, the public wants to know what their doing every second of every day, even when they aren’t on camera. The paparazzi make it their job to find those things out Paparazzi are photographers who repeatedly hunt celebrities, public figures and their families for a chance to photograph them in candid, unflattering and at times

Limitations of the Gods

833 words - 4 pages In many myth’s the gods seem to be able to everything, and nothing can stop them. As figures who are personifications of things humans cannot understand, they are powerful beings, but even they may have times of struggle. As some stories tell, the gods themselves had weaknesses, and things that they could not achieve. The gods do have human traits or tendencies that often lead to them being unable to do things. Sometimes it was the fact that

Similar Essays

Ethics Of Animal Research Essay

747 words - 3 pages Ethics of Animal Research One of the many issues of today's conversations is still confusing on my understanding it. Is it ethical for people to engage in animal research for human excellence? And if so, just how far can animal research be taken to meet these achievements for human kind? When thinking about this, I would conclude that animals over human beings do not have any rights what so ever, but I would be the biggest hypocrite in

The Ethics Of Animal Use In Biomedical Research

1986 words - 8 pages surgically manipulated and exploited for money. The use of animals as subjects in biomedical research brings forth two main underlying ethical issues: firstly, the imposition of avoidable suffering on creatures capable of both sensation and consciousness, and secondly the uncertainty pertaining to the notion of animal rights. Although human beings exploit animals for multiple different purposes, the use of animals in scientific research

The Fields Of Qualitative And Quantitative Research Have Both Advantages And Limitations Within Each Paradigm

612 words - 3 pages knowledge”. Qualitative and quantitative research both have their own advantages and limitations in the research process. The differences and similarities of each approach are apparent. Quantitative research uses mathematical methods to measure results conclusively. It can be defined as a type of empirical research which can be measured with numbers and analysed in order to determine whether it predicts or explains the research Generally

Animal Research And The Advancement Of Psychological Research

3149 words - 13 pages After having read Professor Joorden's article, I was slightly unsure about how to approach my reflection of his perspective. I didn't entirely agree with his opinion but at the same time I noted how he'd taken any likely defenses I could have possibly used to present the opposing views and demolished them. The article did make me think very deeply about the issue of the paradox between human and animal research ethics and though I am not