The Ethics Of Assessments In The Classroom

1886 words - 8 pages

Examining teacher ethical dilemmas in classroom assessment
Pope, N., Green, S., Johnson, R., & Mitchell, M. (2009). Examining teacher ethical dilemmas in classroom assessment. Teaching and Teacher Education , 25 (5), 778-782.

Précis
Pope, Green, Johnson, & Mitchell (2009) suggest that we need further research and discussion around ethics and assessment in the classroom. Many ethic dilemmas are faced by teachers however little has been researched around ethics and assessment. Teachers spend one third of the time in assessment related activities and do so with no clear guidelines of the ethical dilemmas involved. There is a need for pre-service teachers to undertake training and discussion around ethical conflicts and dilemma around assessment as it appears that ethical reasoning does not develop on the job. The group study of in service teachers highlighted the dilemmas around ethics and assessment. In discussing a scenario where there is no right or wrong answers teacher responses were grouped based on two principles of ‘do no harm’ and ‘score pollution’. Although responses varied greatly, score pollution rated highest with institutional requirements vs. students needs being the greatest concern around conflicting elements. Ethical conflict based around institutional expectations is described as unavoidable, as institutions deal with the abstract and teachers deal with the person. Within Institutional requirements teachers see ethical conflict where rules from the governing body do not match with what the teachers sees as meeting the need of the student. As demands of large-scale assessment increase so does the focus on the practice. Students need to be the priority and teacher’s lack formal training. Research, clear guidelines, and discussion around ethics need to be implemented. We need clear guidelines around score pollution and the ethical dilemmas involved.

Critique
The authors being affiliated with American Universities and having prior published research allows for confidence in credibility of the article in an academic sense. Dr. Nakia Shane Pope is assistant dean at Winthrop University, with interests in areas of philosophy and social foundations of education (Winthrop University, 2011). However, the evidence gathered for the report was from a small group of in-service teachers undertaking further study at two universities, and may be subjective, the authors themselves warn against generalisation of the findings.

The report’s aim is to document the specific ethical conflicts faced by teachers in assessment and expand prior research undertaken by Green, Johnson, Kim, & Pope, (2007) & Johnson, Green, Kim, & Pope (2008). However there may be bias, as the respondent’s ethical understanding may naturally be towards institutional conflict as an area that has been given media attention. Secondly, as noted by the authors, the teachers own ethical stance will influence the outcome. Another consideration...

Find Another Essay On The Ethics of Assessments in the Classroom

The Effectiveness of Weblogs in the Classroom

2362 words - 9 pages The Effectiveness of Weblogs in the Classroom The internet has proven that it can be a very reasonable and valuable tool for research and communication within the classroom setting. Over the past decade, it has redeveloped the way students retrieve and use information, claims Richardson (2004). Richardson continues that until now it was not very clear if the internet provided students with anything more than a vast tool for

The Exclusion of Homosexuality in the Classroom

3559 words - 14 pages similar level to that of teachers with 73% of high school parents believing sexual orientation is an appropriate topic for the classroom (Dailard, 2001). If both teachers and parents believe students should be learning about homosexuality one is lead to ask; why aren’t students being taught about it in an accurate and appropriate level? While metropolitan areas generally make up a larger proportion of the population, non-metropolitan areas are

Are Current Assessments Effective in the Identification of Specific Language Impairment in Bilingual Children?

2155 words - 9 pages accurately identified or ruled out by the use of English tests complemented by background information, observations, and case history from both parents and educators. Gillam et al. (2013) helped me confirm my hypothesis that commonly used assessment practices are not effective in properly diagnosing SLI in bilingual children. The results of this study indicate that current assessments have serious limitations in the identification of SLI in bilingual

Negative Impact of Technology in the Classroom

881 words - 4 pages what users have been doing, and that technology is an overall distraction in the classroom.             The situation revolving around these sites is not likely to clear up any time soon; in fact, as freshmen enter higher education institutions, more activity regarding social networking will take place. Christine Rosen, “a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center in Washington” (2), said that the amount of freedom and control that

Benefits of Technology in the Classroom

2346 words - 9 pages Do you ever think about how much technology has changed the way we work, learn, play, and even think? Technology is a major beneficiary to society; especially in the classroom where we get the opportunity to learn and grow. In recent years, schools have begun implementing tablets and other devices in the classroom to better student’s education. The use of technology in the classroom provides more of a personalized learning experience and gives

Use of Technology in the Classroom

892 words - 4 pages a post test that is given to the students to see if they learned anything from the lessons along with assessments at the end of each lesson. The small group phase had a questionnaire that each student filled out after the unit.   Assessments There were different assessments that were given at the end of the lessons. There was a KWL chart that was filled out for the prior knowledge lesson. Students wrote predictions down in a reading journal

Uses Of Chinese In The English Classroom

6389 words - 26 pages Uses of Chinese in the English Classroom -------Introducing the "Functional-Translation" Method 中文在课堂中的使用 ----介绍"功能-翻译"教学法 Abstract The assumption that the "English-only", direct method can be applied equally well to any size and type of class and any level or content of language learning is simply false.The fundamental

Recognition of Individual Differences in the Classroom

2391 words - 10 pages Recognition of Individual Differences in the Classroom Recognition of individual differences is one of the hardest jobs that a teacher faces in the classroom. It requires a strong sense of instinct as well as the knowledge of characteristics of each of the specific differences. Without this, the teacher is unable to fulfill their job to the best of their ability because they are denying the students an environment in

Constructivism in the Classroom

2393 words - 10 pages students to make sense of what they are doing by relating it to the real world and where they could use the information in their future. Con: Constructivism classrooms do not have much room for structure (Rhinehart Neas). For new teachers, structure is important to maintain to have control of the classroom. Constructivism is meant for classrooms that can be more student centered than teacher controlled. For new teachers this method could not work

Electronics in the Classroom

1120 words - 4 pages It seems today everything is being done electronically, homework, job, and even college applications are submitted online. People learn so much through various types of technology. Years ago in the classrooms there were not as many chances to incorporate technology into the classroom. As the years progress there have been more technological advances yet there is much controversy over whether classrooms should be permitted to have their students

Inclusion in the Classroom

2514 words - 10 pages Inclusion in the Classroom Inclusion is one of the very controversial topics concerning the education of students in today's society. It is the effort to put children with disabilities into the general education classes. The main purpose is to ensure that every child receives the best education possible by placing them in the best learning environment possible. Inclusion is a very beneficial idea, supported by law that promotes a well

Similar Essays

Assessments In The Classroom Essay

1800 words - 8 pages objective that I had set according to the state standard, since that where I started from to create the lessons in the beginning. I gave the pre and post assessments via an online assessment system called Quiz Star. This allows the students to answer the questions that I created in a more secure setting and allows for easier data collecting. In addition to individual student reports and scores, the site gives an overview of the test; including a

Technology Ethics In The Classroom Essay

876 words - 4 pages Technology in the classroom is important to assist in the learning process; however this is creating new challenges for teachers. Teachers are now required to educate students on the importance of technology ethics. Computer ethics is the moral guidelines that govern the use of computers and networks (Shelly, G, Gunter, G, and Gunter, R 2012). Ethics in the classroom also requires teachers to explain what plagiarism is and the proper way for

The Consequences Of Inaccurate Nursing Assessments

1989 words - 8 pages Inaccurate nursing assessments and recording of client data can detrimentally affect a patient’s well-being. Nurses are ethically, legally and morally responsible for assessing their patients appropriately. Nurses are also expected to document this data accurately in order to ensure safe and effective care for patients. In this case study, a nurse fails to assess the patient’s weight and instead estimates it. In this situation, it is key to

The Reliability Of Education In The Classroom

1229 words - 5 pages educational growth. The difference between formative and summative assessments is: formative assessment is part of the teaching process, while summative assessment is the evaluation given at the end of the lesson or school year. When the educator combines both assessments into classroom, it will provide the information needed to make adjustments, consequently allowing the students to achieve the goals of the class. A formative assessment gives the