This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Ethics Of Cloning Essay

1906 words - 8 pages

The Ethics of Cloning

On February 27, 1997, it was reported that scientists produced the first clone of an adult sheep, attracting international attention and raising questions on the morality of cloning. Within days, the public had called for ethics inquires and new laws banning cloning. Issues are now raised over the potentially destructive side of this scientific frontier. Many people are morally opposed to the possible consequences of women being able to give birth to themselves, or scientists seeking to clone "genetically superior" humans. Others argue that the positive effects of cloning will outweigh the negative. The issue over whether cloning humans is ethical is receiving more and more attention as scientists successfully experiment with cloning and gene therapy, coming closer to making human clones a reality.
An ethical basis for the rejection or acceptance of cloning in science can be based around several different theories of morality. Interestingly, those supporting a Utilitarian approach, seeking the greatest good for the greatest number, can be found on both sides of the issue. Some advocates of cloning argue that allowing society to benefit from cloned organs, for example, will outweigh the detrimental consequences of that may result from the abuse of cloning technology by a few scientists. At the same time, those adamantly against cloning argue that denying some individuals their right to a cloned child or organ is necessary to protect society from the negative affects this technology will have on humanity in general. Another common ethical approach to cloning is based on Kant's principles of autonomy and self-determination. Those supporting this theory often believe that in many cases the individual has a right to benefit from cloning if they chose. However, some have argued that cloning objectifies humanity or treats life as a means to an end. Kant's ideas of autonomy can then also be used against cloning. In the specific arguments given on both sides of the issue that follow, both of these moral philosophies are apparent.
In understanding why some chose to reject or accept the practice of cloning, basic knowledge how cloning is achieved becomes helpful. Some reject cloning because they believe humans are "playing God", others claim that scientists do not "create life" by cloning any more than they would in the practice of in vitro fertilization. According to the American Heritage College Dictionary, cloning is "to reproduce or propagate asexually". This is obviously not the traditional form of human reproduction. There are three basic methods of cloning: separating the embryo and making twins with the same genetic make-up, taking a cell from a fertilized ovum when the cell begins to split and replace it in another female's ovum, or nuclear transplantation (Travis). The famous cloning of an adult ewe, who's offspring was named Dolly, was accomplished through the second method by Dr. Ian Wilmut and his...

Find Another Essay On The Ethics of Cloning

The Ethics of Human Cloning Essay

1191 words - 5 pages pain and suffering sometimes that we can hardly endure. Works Cited Birch, Charles, and Paul Abrecht, ed. Genetics and the quality of life. Australia: Pergamon Press, 2011. Print. Cullis, Christopher A. "Entering The Clone zone." World & I 12.10 (1997): 145. Academic Search Premium. Web. 2 Nov. 2013. Dudley, William, ed. The Ethics of human cloning. San Diego, CA: Greenhaven Press, Inc, 2001. Print. The Human Cloning Foundation. The Benefits

The Ethics of Human Cloning Essay

1813 words - 7 pages society would not be our greatest worry. Works Cited Mitchell, Dr. Elizabeth. "Human Clones: Created To Die." - Answers in Genesis. N.p., 30 May 2013. Web. 16 Apr. 2014. . Logston, Amy. "THE ETHICS OF HUMAN CLONING." THE ETHICS OF HUMAN CLONING. N.p.,13 Jan. 1999. Web. 21 Apr. 2014. . American Medical Association, Council of the. "The Ethics of Human Cloning." American Medical Association. N.p., 1 June 1999. Web. 21 Apr. 2014. https://download.ama -assn.org/resources/doc/ethics/x-pub/report98.pdf

The Ethics of Human Cloning

2006 words - 8 pages The Ethics of Human Cloning Imagine the world as only beautiful people. Everywhere you look is a Cindy Crawford look-a-like: 5’9”, brown hair, brown eyes, and the perfect smile. A “Master Race.” Do we really want to reenact Adolf Hitler’s plan of seeking world domination killing million upon millions as a “final solution?” Instead of killing, we’d be reproducing millions, going against nature. Say we went and got one of Princess Diana’s

The Benefits and Ethics of Human Cloning

1522 words - 6 pages The Benefits and Ethics of Human Cloning Introduction On February 24, 1997, the whole world was shocked by the news that Scottish scientists had successfully cloned a sheep. Dolly an artificially cloned mammal was born a star. After the shock, that cloning was not only a possibility but a reality, wore off the out cry against human cloning began. Physicians, scientists, politicians and church leaders and many more have been trying to ban

An essay about ethics of cloning

821 words - 3 pages CLONINGWe are living in the era of technology, due to this, science is improving very fast. Science has a lot of branches and most of them are affected by this technology. Genetic engineering is one of them. It is very popular nowadays. The main aim of it is to make better animal and plant species for the benefits of human being and to cure illness genetically. Cloning is the one of the ways that brings genetic engineering to its aim. Cloning

The Philosophy of Cloning

2845 words - 11 pages diversity. Diversity is what the world, America especially, runs on and if diversity were void, then the world would be mundane. The ethical standards play a large part in the forming of a solution, but the largest part is if it can actually happen (Ethics).The problem solution should be measured by what changes the world would have to endure because of cloning. Having mass-produced children isn't too far away from reality, but it will never be accepted

The History of Cloning

2443 words - 10 pages quality of their herd.Mid to late 1970's- Scientists cut down small forests publishing research papers arguing the ethics of cloning and if it can be done. While they do this other researches around the world are actually investigating if it can be done.1981- Karl Illmensee and Peter Hoppe report that they clone normal mice and embryo cells. It is later found to be a fraud.1982- James McGrath and Davor Solter report that they can not repeat the

The Cloning of Dogs

1323 words - 5 pages The Cloning of Dogs Introduction: The new "Star Wars" movie features an entire army made of clones. These clones are genetically perfected to be the ultimately obedient and powerful soldiers. How could this type of cloning technology be used in dogs? We could use it for the good to make the perfectly obedient dog, for use in seeing-eye work, rescue work, etc. This technology could also be used to affect the world of dog showing. An owner

The Benefits of Cloning

1015 words - 5 pages Technology has developed significantly all around the world in recent years. Cloning is the one part of the developing technology. Having identical twins without being born on the same day is feasible in these days thanks to cloning . Cloning is the procedure to produce copies of DNA piece, cells, or organisms. Almost all people know about Dolly the cloned sheep, but only some people know all the nuances about cloning

The Benefits of Cloning

1611 words - 6 pages The Advantages of Cloning The first successfully cloned mammal was created on February of 1997. It was a breakthrough in scientific research when the Scottish scientists cloned a sheep by the name of Dolly. The method of cloning requires the extraction of DNA from anywhere on a subject's body and inserting that DNA into a woman's egg. Worldwide attention was turned to the prospect of human cloning and with a push for sweeping prohibition

The Problems of Cloning

1087 words - 5 pages A cloned ewe, born after the famous cloned sheep named Dolly, died after a few weeks due to underdeveloped lungs. Both were cloned by the same group at the Roslin Institute in Edinburgh. The first mammalian cloning was produced by embryonic nuclear transfer and was conducted in 1983 (“Timeline”). In fact, the Basic Science Partnership at Harvard Medical School states that actual cloning of animals can dates back to the 1960’s. Cloning is

Similar Essays

The Ethics Of Cloning Essay

1717 words - 7 pages According to Richard Dawkins “Cloning may be good and it may be bad. Probably it's a bit of both. The question must not be greeted with reflex hysteria but decided quietly, soberly and on its own merits. We need less emotion and more thought” (Dawkins, 2011). Cloning is a general term used to describe the replication of biological material (Cloning Fact Sheet, 2009). Throughout this paper the reasoning behind why cloning is an acceptable and

The Ethics Of Cloning Essay

848 words - 4 pages The technology of today’s world is astounding. We have learned how to battle diseases that were once thought to lead to a certain death, we have invented incredible technologies that allow us to communicate with people across the world instantly, and maybe most impressively of all, we are able to create human life. We now hold in our hands the technologies that allow a person, their entire genetic makeup, to be recreated through cloning. In an

The Ethics Of Human Cloning Essay

1307 words - 5 pages , Parkinson’s, cancers, and diabetes can all be treated using therapeutic cloning treatments (“Human Cloning”). Among all the great world religions, Buddhism is the only religion to agree to the fact that therapeutic cloning could alleviate or even stop human suffering and bring benefit to our future (“Introduction to The Ethics of Human Cloning: At Issue”). Human reproductive cloning may also provide infertile parents a chance to have children with

The Ethics Of Human Cloning Essay 1340 Words

1340 words - 5 pages The Ethics of Human Cloning In order to make a fully justified decision on whether human cloning is ethical or not, one must be exposed to the background of the subject. To start, a clone is an exact replica of an organism, cell, or gene. The process itself is done asexually with the use of a cell from the original human. It is then placed inside a female capable of bearing a child and is then born as a clone. Along