This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Ethics Of Genetically Enhancing Children

1244 words - 5 pages

The term designer children is unnerving at first to many. The idea of parents designing the genetic makeup of their offspring makes children seem like a commodity in a genetic free market. Thoughts of a dystopian society like the one in the film “Gattaca” come to mind. However, taking an immediate repugnant stand against genetic enhancement is not well-founded. A more open-minded inspection of the issue reveals that the idea of parents improving their children’s life prospects through genetic engineering (provided it is safe) is, at its core, not unethical. In fact, some genetic enhancement in addition to correcting deleterious genes to prevent disease is a moral obligation. It is moral to make rational decisions using the science and technology known to us to improve the lives of humans and promote well-being. Genetic enhancement, if used wisely, does not violate the right of a child to an open future and rather can provide more opportunities.
Well-being, not just health is valuable. The main point of curing a disease is to improve the patient’s well-being so that the person may live and enjoy life on a more profound level. With this perspective, it is an ethical responsibility to improve well-being and not just correct health problems. Consider the following thought-experiment. Suppose humans, designing a society without knowledge of their personal roles in it, had two options: (1) any member upon entering society is assigned a potential for great well-being drawn from a normal distribution, or (2) every member is provided a high potential for great well-being. The later choice is clearly the better one, and refusing it would be unethical. Our own society will have to make this choice in the near future, with regard to deciding whether to allow genetic enhancement, as biotechnology will make its possibility inevitable. As Savulescu argues, agreeing with the presented viewpoint: humans should revolutionize natural selection, which is indifferent to well-being, to instead select children not only with the greatest chance of surviving but also with the greatest opportunities available for a good life [Savulescu, 3].
Genetic enhancement is just another form of enhancement which has the benefit of the child in mind. There are many others: education, medical care, extra-curricular activities, etc. As Goering puts it, a parent does not blink when they give the child vitamin supplements, vaccinations, and dental enhancements (e.g., braces) [Goering, 2]. Imposing parental treatment is a part of being human and is ethical when the intentions are beneficent. There is no real difference in changing attributes of a child for the better at the genome level, or once the child is born. If administering growth hormones to young children to prevent them from being too short [Simon] is justifiable, then so is germline genetic modification of height to produce the same result. Or, if parents are fine with the installation of braces to straighten their...

Find Another Essay On The Ethics of Genetically Enhancing Children

Biology Research Notes: Ethics of Genetically Modified Animals

997 words - 4 pages pig's genome and cannot be bred out.(2006, July 20). Biotechnology: Transgenic animals. Retrieved March 11, 2008, from BBC Web site: http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/ethics/animals/using/biotechnology_2.shtml•Combining species of animals is an unethical alteration of the natural order of the universe.•It is unethical to modify an animals genetic make-up without previous knowledge of whether or not the modification will have any detrimental

The Effects of Genetically Modified Foods

1453 words - 6 pages General Mills Cereal company had stopped using GMO’s in Cheerios mainly because of public pressure. Cheerios was thought from the buyers to be a family food. Respectively, Cheerios got rid of GMO’s and in that 20 seconds walking down the cereal aisle my topic was found. This move by Cheerios was golde n.Moms will start bringing Cheerios into the house over any other kind of cereal if they know its healthy for their children. Cheerios just boomed

Genetically Modified Foods: The Future of Food

2452 words - 10 pages Are genetically modified foods a step in the right direction? Many people automatically retort with a resounding “No!” when asked this question, believing that these newfangled foods are unnatural and therefore, unsafe. They cringe at the thought of the so-called “frankenfoods” that are packed with chemicals and mutated DNA. However, genetically engineered foods are quite the opposite. Bio-engineering is used to make foods more nutritious by

The Perils of Genetically Modified Food

1407 words - 6 pages for herbicide tolerance, which can result in the transfer of genes resistant to herbicides from crops into the weeds. Moreover, genetically modified foods can cause some human health risks. For instance, many children in US and Europe have developed life-threatening allergies to peanuts and other foods. There is a risk of introducing a gene into a plant that may cause an allergic reaction in some individuals. Furthermore, there is a growing

The Dangers of Genetically Modified Food

809 words - 4 pages Many Americans consume thousands of pounds of genetically modified foods every day. Throughout the 21st century, genetic engineering tremendously impacted new research in pharmaceutical and forensic science. During that time, it also revolutionized the food in America and many other countries around the world. Using Recombinant DNA biotechnology on crops and farm animals helps improve nutrition and quantity of foods. However, crops that are

The Negative Effects of Genetically Modified Foods

1579 words - 7 pages Dear Senator Stabenow, As Chairwoman of the Senate Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition and Forestry, I feel you are most authorized to govern my grievance. America has become the land of the free and the sick. Americans have a higher disease and death rate than all European and industrialized countries. Since the creation of genetically engineered organisms in the 90’s, the number of American’s with a chronic illness has doubled and our infant

The Advantages of Genetically Modified Foods

1148 words - 5 pages . Genetically modified foods should be perceived as an advantage to either the producer or consumer of these foods through a lower price, posssibility eliminating world starvation, and greater benefit in terms of durability and the increased improvement of crop production. As we all know, food has always been an important essential in our lives and is abundant as well as relatively easy to obtain here in the United States. With the help of

The Controversy of Genetically Modified Crops

1436 words - 6 pages The Controversy of Genetically Modified Crops     You may know about the emerging field of biotechnology - the medicine, the ethics, the DNA, the Human Genome, etc.  But few realize the emergence of its agricultural branch, and the international conflict that has arisen from it.  It may apply to you more than you thought, for half of the soybean products and a quarter of the corn you ate in 1999 may have been genetically modified (Kaufman

The Dangers of Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO)

3835 words - 15 pages Introduction Recently, there has been a huge uprise in reports from all over the world of new diseases that have affected much of the population today. Diseases such as obesity, Alzheimer’s, Celiac Disease, Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), and so much more have been on the rise. Researchers have suspected the culprit of these diseases to be our food. Along with the diseases, Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO) has also been on

The Dangers of Genetically Modified Foods

2694 words - 11 pages generations of hamsters raised on a diet of GM soy, the majority had lost the ability to have children. They also grew more slowly, and had 300-400% increased infant mortality, and some of the hamsters had hair growing inside of their bodies. Studies show that animals which consumed a GM diet displayed organ damage, gastrointestinal and immune system disorders, accelerated aging, and infertility. The organs of rats who ate genetically modified potatoes

The Impact of Performance Enhancing Drugs on the Olympics

3241 words - 13 pages    The use of performance enhancing drugs is undermining the integrity of the Olympic games.  It is impossible to accurately determine the number of athletes who use them, but it is believed that a substantial percentage do.  According to an anonymous Soviet coach, "Perhaps 90% of sportsmen, including our own, use drugs" (CASA 40).  One reason it is difficult to determine how many athletes "dope" is that in international events like the Olympics

Similar Essays

The Ethics Of Genetically Modified Food Production

4169 words - 17 pages The Ethics of Genetically Modified Food Production As human technological innovation proceeds into the twenty-first century, society is faced with many complex issues. Genetic engineering and cloning, encryption and information security, and advanced weapons technologies are all prominent examples of technological issues that have substantial moral and ethical implications. Genetic engineering in particular is currently a very

The Ethics Of Giving Children Adhd Medication

2180 words - 9 pages Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is a psychiatric disorder that causes children to have problems with paying attention, trouble with following instructions, have impulsive behaviors and become easily distracted. Medications, such as Adderall and Ritalin, are used to treat the symptoms of this disorder by helping the patient to focus and pay attention while also curbing their impulsive behavior and hyperactivity. Side effects of

An Examination Into The Potential Brain Enhancing And Educational Potential Of Electronic Media On Children On The Autisim Spectrum

3061 words - 13 pages ¬ Virtual Learning Environments: An Examination into the Potential Brain-Enhancing and Educational Potential of Electronic Media on Children Diagnosed along the Autism Spectrum Benjamin Thomas Middle Tennessee State University Psychology 4040 Virtual Learning Environments (VLEs): An Examination into the Potential Brain-Enhancing and Educational Potential of Electronic Media on Children Diagnosed along the Autism

Discuss The Value Of Understanding Sociological Approaches To The Family In Enhancing Effective Partnerships With Families And Children’

1852 words - 7 pages they carry out central tasks which contribute to the well-being of society (Cunningham and Cunningham 2010). Similarly, according to Comte (1798-1857), society is a system of interrelated parts, each of which depends on other parts to function. For example the education system relies on the family to produce effectively socialised children; the economy is dependent on the education system to produce educated individuals to become skilled workers