The Ethics Of Prison Privatization Essay

2357 words - 9 pages

How true is Christie’s warning that an increasingly privatized penal service threatens the ethics and effectiveness of the criminal justice system?

More aspects of the penal system are now privatized, and are set to increase. This includes the privatization of such services as prisons, electronic tags, catering companies, probation work or prison escort services. David Taylor-Smith, head of the world’s biggest security firm, G4S says he expects private companies will be running large parts of the UK’s police service within five years (Taylor and Travis, 2012). Nils Christie’s text (2000) “Crime Control as Industry” draws upon increasing prison populations in the US. However reflecting upon that the prison population in England and Wales has increased from 41,800 prisoners to over 86,000 in 14 years (Ministry of Justice, 2013, 1) Christie also looks upon other countries that face similar problems and how this and modern crime control represents a move 'towards gulags, western type’ (Christie, 2000, 15). He describes the criminal justice system today as a “Pain Delivery” service (Christie, 2000, 143) and argues that it is regulated by the amount of pain they choose to inflict on society and not by the actual number of crimes committed. Christie also identifies changes in capitalist societies and their social organisation, this he says is due to factors such as a larger readiness to report incidents to the police and social controls have declined producing a greater ‘supply’ of criminal acts (Jones & Newburn, 2002, 175)
However the main force behind this is crime control becoming a commodity, as represented by the expanding privatization market. Christie argues that crime control is now a product and privatization of the penal system has made it possible to make it a profitable business, and this can damage the ethics and effectiveness of the criminal justice system. On the other hand there is research showing how privatization can be beneficial, proving effective and working well with other third sector organisations and there is some contemporary research showing how private prisons for example are proving a success.

With a higher prison population this means they are overcrowded and more expensive to run and the easiest thing to do is to turn prisoners over to private companies. In England and Wales, September 2012 there were 12,872 prisoners held in private prisons, which is 15% of the prisoner population. This is a higher proportion than in the US, where the figure is around 9% (Prison Reform Trust, 2013). There has been a huge debate whether private prisons threaten the ethics of the criminal justice system and if the overall effectiveness is acceptable.
HMP Oakwood is the UKs largest privately own prison and a report by Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Prisons (2013) is an example why many consider private prisons unethical and inefficient. Oakwood is ran by G4s and opened in April 2012 as a super-size prison, capable of imprisoning...

Find Another Essay On The Ethics of Prison Privatization

The Privatization of Anatolia National Telekom Simulation

1241 words - 5 pages seeks the privatization of this giant. That would bolster confidence in the government’s ability to follow through on past promises and lead a wave of other privatizations that would fundamentally change the Turkish economy, polity and society. Cohen, O’Connell, Rivera & Associates, “CORA”’s relationship with TAD is probably a pure commission deal. Therefore, CORA certainly will be a tough party regarding the price since a lower price will

Unique Challenges of Privatization of the Juvinille Justice System

1286 words - 6 pages conflicting responsibilities for the public administrator. For example, privatization has typically pitted the values of increased efficiency and lower costs against methods of human treatment, rehabilitation and reintegration of juvenile inmates back into society as productive citizens. For instance, the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) examined a state-funded, for-profit juvenile prison in Florida after allegations of horrific conditions

"The Need for Privatization" A paper on the reasons and benefits of the Privatization of Social Security

1452 words - 6 pages The Need for Privatization Every paycheck 7.65 percent is taken out for a retirement program, after the employer kicks in, a total of 12.4 percent of what you earn goes to the government to fund your retirement. The government system offers minuscule returns by anyone's measure and the system is expected to go bankrupt as soon as 2014. If a private company had these problems, no one would invest. But, this is a mandatory program, Americans have

Proposed Alternative to the Privatization of Social Security

953 words - 4 pages the government. Democrats are deeply troubled by this proposal and claim that this course of action would be disastrous for seniors. According to Democratic Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid, "it's wrong to replace the guaranteed benefit that Americans have earned with a guaranteed benefit cut of 40% or more. Make no mistake, that's exactly what President Bush is proposing," in rebuttal to President Bush’s plans of privatization on Thursday Feb 3

The Flaws of Prison Labor

953 words - 4 pages The Flaws of Prison Labor The debate over prison labor has existed as long as the concept it’s self. Opponents claim that it exploits prisoners, takes away jobs from the general population, and puts people in danger by allowing convicts access to their personal information. While supporters of prison labor argue that it helps the economy as well as benefits prisoners. On this issue I stand on the side of the supporters. By having

The Importance of Prison Reform

1343 words - 5 pages that 60 percent of Americans are against social reform because they have made up their mind that once a crook, always a crook. This is flawed mainly because it seems to assume that showing people that what they've done is wrong will always accomplish something, that punishing those who commit crimes will deter others from following the same pattern. The problem with prison is that prisons are not a place of rehabilitation. There are people

Sheding the Light on the Privatization of Prisons from the Costs Point of View

1780 words - 8 pages In 2013 a paper from authors, Kish and Lipton discuss the title: Do private prisons really offer savings compared with their public counterparts? The purpose of this article is to shed light on the privatization as far as the cost savings. The authors point out the key points of cost saving are: The construction of a private prison is typically faster since voter approval is not required. The reduction of staff members is one way of

The Effects of the Prison Punishment

1040 words - 5 pages Just twenty four hours out of prison a man raids the same exact shoe store he had robbed fifteen years earlier. Authorities claim he took a bus from Atlantic City up to Toms River and approached the store in the same exact fashion he had fifteen years ago. (Goldman) He was easily caught. It was as if the man wanted to return to prison which may actually be his only home. Was this a man that wanted to go back to prison or did he just not learn

The Implications of the Stanford Prison Experiment

1115 words - 4 pages The Implications of the Stanford Prison Experiment In 1971 Dr Philip Zimbardo conducted an experiment in the basement of Stanford University. This involved imprisoning nine volunteers in a mock up of Stanford prison, which was policed by nine guards (more volunteers). These guards had complete control over the prisoners. They could do anything to the prisoners, but use physical violence. The subjects were all students

Privatization of the power utility in The Bahamas. "BEC Should by Privatized. (external sources are cited)

2522 words - 10 pages Abrupt power outages that lasts for hours and hours, damaged electronic goods and appliances due to constant power surges and irate local folk that perhaps would not prefer to bear the blazing heat during the hot summer nights; these are all adverse effects imposed on innocent electricity consumers due to apparent deficiencies and inefficiencies at the publicly owned power utility in The Bahamas. Energy privatization has been part and parcel of

the prevalence of prison sexual violence

971 words - 4 pages sometimes look the other way when it happens to men and women in prison. In this paper, I am going to summarize current research on what is and what is not currently known about the prevalence of prison sexual violence, also I am going review different strategy that researchers came up with to reduce the amount of sexual victimizations in prison. Finally I am going to review new legislation that addresses this problem, but first I am going give

Similar Essays

The Privatization Of Prison Healthcare Essay

1955 words - 8 pages There are over 2.3 million persons within the” Prison Industrial Complex”. The “Prison Industrial Complex" is used to describe the overlapping interests of government and industry (Herzing, 2005). The interest of industry within the state prisons of Illinois has led to the selling of inmate healthcare rights to many private companies. The privatization of healthcare within the prison industrial complex is unconstitutional and perpetuates

The Ethics Of The Stanford Prison Experiment

941 words - 4 pages priest that was called in and the prisoners parents that came for a visitation day didn’t protest the treatment of their sons after hearing stories of the mock prison. There is something about these symbols of authority that I think led to this happening, and I feel that Zimbardo’s ethics are questionable for even conducting the experiment. I think that the reason why this experiment turned out how it did because of the symbols of authority shown

The Privatization Of American Prisons Essay

4434 words - 18 pages The Privatization of American Prisons Introduction Since 1984, the California Penal System has been forced to undergo drastic changes resulting from increased legislation aimed at increasing the severity of retribution to offenders leading to an exponentially increasing prison population. In the 132 years between 1852 and 1984, the state of California built twelve prisons, but has since supplemented the prison system with 21 new

The Privatization Initiatives Of The 1980s

2078 words - 8 pages Privatization is not a new phenomenon and has been affecting governments both positively and negatively for many years. Privatization is the process in which a government will sell a state owned enterprise and assets to be privately owned and operated. “The United Kingdom, under the Thatcher government, ushered in the era of privatization in the early 1980s.” (pg3) “The focus on privatization is rooted in the ideological belief that competitive