The Ethics Of Torture Essay

1607 words - 6 pages

In the United States legal system, torture is currently defined as “an act committed by a person acting under the color of law specifically intended to inflict severe physical or mental pain or suffering (other than pain or suffering incidental to lawful sanctions) upon another person within his custody or physical control.” as defined by Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives (US Code, 1) Though this is a seemingly black and white definition, the conditional “…other than pain or suffering incidental to lawful sanctions…” have led many to question what precisely this entails. In other words, what are the lawful sanctions that permit such acts? Are they ethically right? Where is the line drawn as torture in this respect? Several arguments are offered.

To test what each ethical theory would say regarding the justification of such acts, I am utilizing the ‘ticking time bomb’ thought experiment. Simply put, this experiment provides a hypothetical scenario where an individual has knowledge of vital information regarding the disarmament of an active weapon that could potentially kill millions of individuals. (Wiki 1) Do we torture the individual? The norm is that Consequentialist theories (teleological) seem to have an almost universal stance supporting while Non-Consequentialist theories (deontological and natural rights) represent almost the entirety of the opposition. (Wiki 2) However, as you will learn, it is not as clearly defined as one may think.

Utilitarianism is roughly defined as being procedurally or morally right only if it benefits the majority of everyone. (Jason 5.8; 1) Following this model only regarding procedure, the action of torturing a suspect seems without a doubt, just. However, this is simply regarding the action not the moral. Morally speaking, if we define torture as acceptable when the loss of life can be averted, there seems to always be cases where torture may not lead to a majority benefit. (Stanford 1) Also, one might be able to analyze the cost-benefit analysis in a specific situation, but what about the next time? Known as ‘the calculation problem’, it states that because we cannot always weigh the ‘prerequisite to outcome’ ratio the same in all situations, it is impossible to make a morally permissible universal rule, in this case, regarding torture. (Jason 5.8; 2)

Next up is Ethical Egoism. Similar to Utilitarianism, it states that an act is procedurally or morally right. However, it is so only if it benefits the specific individual committing the act at that moment. (Jason 5.2; 1) Would it benefit an individual to torture someone? The individual could gain something from it such as prestige for diverting a threat or knowledge otherwise not obtained. But is it worth it? According to Joe Navarro of the F.B.I. “Only a psychopath can torture and be unaffected.” (NY 1) This is a question of good over bad for each specific individual to decide if they would or not torture....

Find Another Essay On The Ethics of Torture

The Benefits of Torture Essay

2220 words - 9 pages traumatic event is by the skilled technique of information extraction known as torture, would it not be the government’s obligation to the people to ensure this method of prevention was exercised? When considering the threat from extremists, the United States government must allow for the use of unorthodox interrogation methods, such as torture, when lives are on the line and time is of the essence. A widely popular argument against torture

The Art Of Torture Essay

1838 words - 7 pages Going by the title of this paper you are probably asking yourself "How in God's name can torture be seen as an art, were these people mentally ill?" well it was, but I talk about that later, let me tell you a little about the history of torture. Torture has been around since the times of Ancient Greece and is still around today, usually in the Mafia. Other than the mob, torture isn't very common in our society. Punishments aren't near as harsh

The Issue of Ethical Torture

2102 words - 8 pages job to train its people, and, by the nature of mankind, this training may only be accomplished through punishment. Should criminals be subjected to torture for the gathering of information? Thomas Hickey, author of Clashing Views in Criminal Justice, explains that this view would answer “yes”. Man can be persuaded to give information through means of pain (375-381). Rebecca Evans, author of The Ethics of Torture, gives light to the view that

Torture: The Abuse of Violence

985 words - 4 pages The legality of using torture as punishment has been historically controversial. Today, some people see torture as an efficient form of punishment; they believe it is especially necessary in the treatment of terrorist captives or prisoners for the purpose of extracting information. Some writers such as Michael Levin even intentionally make up fake scenarios to exaggerate the advantages of torture, claiming that it is danger free, low cost and

Limiting the Use of Torture in America

618 words - 2 pages Many social groups as well political groups have discussed the issue of torture. The elements and basic working of torture have many against it saying it is too cruel and violates America’s 8th amendment. But the question does arise what do we do if there is a suspect found hours before the crime is committed? Or what do we do to those that are known to have committed the severe crime (ie. a serial killer that has three victims hidden away

The Misuse of Torture in Rendition

1371 words - 5 pages What if someone you love just disappeared? The United States used this same idea to install a program known as the extraordinary rendition. It was put in place during the Clinton administration, but became publically recognized after 9/11. In the context of the movie, Rendition, rendition refers to the transfer of suspected terrorists outside of the United States to a foreign country, where harsh interrogation and torture takes place

History of Torture and the Organizations that Attempt to End Torture Practices

663 words - 3 pages Torture is defined as the use of physical or mental pain, often to obtain information, to punish a person, or to control members of a group. Torture has been ongoing since the early ages of man. Many organizations attempt to stop the use of torture for any of the above mentioned reasons through conventions, protests and lobbying government officials to change laws. Such organizations as the Geneva Convention, the United Nations and Amnesty

The Ethics of Euthanasia

1417 words - 6 pages Bioethics is the study of moral issues in the fields of medical treatment and research. The idea of bioethics is based upon several different codes of ethics, some of these being the ancient Greek Hippocratic oath, which stated above all to "do no harm," and the professional code of ethics written in the 18th century by Thomas Percival, a British doctor. The code written by Percival was the basis for the first official code of ethics that was

The ethics of abortion

1316 words - 5 pages whether or not a fetus is the sort of being whose life is seriously wrong to end." (Readings in Health Care Ethics, 241) This assumption allows Marquis to set up his thesis which states "that abortion is, except possibly in rare cases, seriously immoral, that it is in the same moral category as killing innocent adult human beings." (ibid)Marquis's arguments are set up in a dialectical essay format. He first argues from his anti-abortion

The Ethics of Engineering

787 words - 4 pages Ethics refer to those habits or standards that are considered to show good character and conduct. In the professional practice of engineering, engineers are confronted with different ethical issues and interpersonal conflicts. These cases could range from a small scale involving few people to larger conflicts where the outcome influences the engineering community and the society at large. Classically, engineering education does not duly address

The Ethics of Ambiguity

1899 words - 8 pages people less fortunate, and still there are those that sit on a couch all day watching TV as their years monotonously pass by. In The Ethics of Ambiguity, Simone de Beauvoir develops an existentialist view that explains the details of an ambiguous existence and how those who exist should act in this world. De Beauvoir relies on an individual’s freedom to argue that existence is ambiguous and that each individual should act with the intention of

Similar Essays

The Ethics Of Torture Essay

1439 words - 6 pages conditional. In addition, by saying that torture is ethical when x y and z happen, means that the consequences of torture are being used to judge torture’s morality. However, this is problematic because it goes against Immanuel Kant’s Categorical Imperative; and therefore by definition, it is irrational. Ethics must be absolutes; if they are conditional then returning justice is impossible. In order to see this irrationality the notion of Good Will and the

The Morality Of Torture Essay

1348 words - 5 pages , any behavior is acceptable. It has been proven by organizations such as Human Rights Watch, United States Institute of Peace and The Crimes of War Project that legitimizing torture, even on a small scale, or any form of cruel treatment brings the principles and ethics that society is based on down. Especially if the U.S. uses it because to the rest of the world we are looked up to as the most law-biding nation, yet we bend the rules to fit each

The Morality Of Torture Essay

1710 words - 7 pages Torture is a controversial topic in today’s society. What is torture? Torture can be defined as, ‘the act of inflicting excruciating pain, as punishment or revenge, as a means of getting a confession or information, or for sheer cruelty.’(Dershowitz, A) According to international law, it is illegal to use torture in any situation of any kind. Though torture undoubtedly continues throughout the world, the moral argument prohibiting torture

The Art Of Torture Essay

1698 words - 7 pages The Art of Torture Going by the title of this paper you are probably asking yourself “How in God’s name can torture be seen as an art, were these people mentally ill?” well it was, but I talk about that later, let me tell you a little about the history of torture. Torture has been around since the times of Ancient Greece and is still around today, usually in the Mafia. Other than the mob, torture isn’t very common in our society