This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Ever Evolving Superweed Essay

1388 words - 6 pages

The next phase of my journey revolved around how weeds were developing resistance. In the article, “Reports of Superweed Greatly Exaggerated," published in New Scientist in 2005, gives me perspective into a counterargument of my claim. It claims that there is no proof of gene transfer within these weeds (New Scientist). Lab tests have proven that gene transfer from GM crops such as corn, soy, or wheat are unable to cross pollinate with the surrounding weeds because they are too distant of plant relatives to cross breed (New Scientist). The article insists that these weeds are thriving on the repeated use of roundup and are in fact evolving their own mechanism of resistance toward the roundup herbicide (New Scientist). That helped to clear up the questions I raised regarding how weeds were developing the resistance and will in turn help me strengthen and clarify my argument against farmers using GM crops. I felt after this step I was closer to having a full background on the issue and could at that point begin to relay to my audience why my argument was credible. I knew I could also increase my credibility by including a counterargument against my claim regarding gene transfer and how it isn't possible in these circumstances. Since GM traits aren't being crossbred, nature would be to blame for weed resistance, which shows I have considered that this could just be nature’s process. Before I could use that counter perspective to my advantage, I would have to deplete the constraint that many readers may not realize increased evolution rates of weeds is just as harmful, if not worse. After evaluating these first five sources, I had developed my thesis to state; US farmers should not invest in GM crops because they lead to an increase in weed resistance due to weeds ability to evolve against the repeated use of a single herbicide.
I found another perspective in the New Scientist from 2010 in an article titled, “Weed Resistance Could Mean Herbicide is Futile," written by Bob Holms. This article challenges my preconceived notion and applies constraint because I want to put a lot of the blame for the issue of super weeds on Monsanto for developing the GM crops and their process, which has given weeds the ability to evolve quickly against roundup but explains that the farmers who used these GM crops are just as much to blame. The article finds common ground by explaining how Monsanto probably knew or predicted that this could give rise to more powerful weeds but did not take enough precaution when providing farmers with the recipe for disaster, because they claim that more than one herbicide is suggested for use along with the round up so that weeds don't develop a resistance against it (Holms). It also explains how Monsanto shouldn't be the only one at fault because farmers need to have been more responsible when messing with the genetic variation in their crops (Holms). It claims that farmers cannot look past the fact that they are using altered...

Find Another Essay On The Ever Evolving Superweed

Biotechnology Research paper

1118 words - 5 pages food products longer than ever before as science develops foods with an increased shelf life. Pharmaceutical also have a lot to gain as gene therapy allows us to treat and cure genetic diseases that were once thought to be incurable [4]. Recently, a study had been released in the hopes of manipulating cowpeas (or black eyed peas) to make them more heat and drought resistant. This pea is grown in more than 80 counties and had been chosen due to its

An Evolutionary Shift Essay

975 words - 4 pages with our ever growing technology”. But many argue that human beings are not even evolving from a mental standpoint and that our intelligence is sharply decreasing. Then again we are evolving though our creation of proficient and effective technology. This statement can be supported by Michael Spivey’s lecture ,“The Science of The Mind: Cognition and Language”, in which Spivey argued that computing technology is showing similarity to the human

The Veldt by Ray Bradburry

1263 words - 5 pages advancement, compared to human intelligence, will one day reach the ‘singularity’ were it will surpass the human mind (pg. 52). We may never know if technology will ever have the power to surpass the human intellect or what the consequences will be if it does attain these capabilities. Will humans still maintain control over them, or will they control us? Theses eight articles illustrate the implicit and explicit control that technology holds over humans

Creation Vs Evolution

549 words - 2 pages ). The great flood was supposedly the first time it had ever rained on Earth. This rain consumed the entire planet, and caused a massive flood. One fact that supports this event is held in the location of fossils. In temperate regions fossilized coral has been discovered. Likewise in artic regions fossilized tropical forests and animals have been found. Oil and coal deposits have even been found in artic regions. Now this validates the story of the

Family Health Nursing as a Growing Specialty

1354 words - 5 pages the family a person's sense of self-esteem and personal competence is developed. The action taken by or for the person with a health problem depends on this sense of self-worth and the family's definition of illness.The definition and demographics of the family is ever evolving with the changes in society. It is important for nurse to keep themselves informed and up-to-date about demographic trends pertaining to children and families per Stanhope

Are Modern Humans Still Evolving? A research paper on the relevancy of Darwin's age-old theory

1751 words - 7 pages suggest that humans owe their existence to evolution, however, many people are skeptical as to whether or not it is still occurring, and whether or not it is happening in the same way. Some scientists hold that the human race has reached "its biological pinnacle and is no longer capable of changing" (McKie, 2005, ¶1). Alternatively, some experts believe that humans are evolving faster than ever (Sample, 2007), and others believe it is still

The Global Workplace

633 words - 3 pages managers with these types of companies may want to consider is how their company will be set apart from another and how will they run this business. They do have to consider a few things which may set them apart which are technology and diversity. Technology plays a great role in the global workplace, with the Internet and the World Wide Web, it is so easy to communicate to someone that works for the company or affiliated without ever meeting

Essay vs Poem

559 words - 2 pages 'creative forgetfulness'.An example would be slavery, a major role in the growth of New York's industry, however in the public history when it comes to slavery a large emptiness still prevails. I stated in the article, "Who Owns History", "No such exhibition has ever been mounted in New York, which grew rich in the early nineteenth century the products of slave labor" (Forner XIII). It is kind of foolish to think that such a big part of New

Biological Weapoms

652 words - 3 pages that scientists may not be able to control once released. If weaponized, no one knows how powerful the biological agents will become, or how far the threat would spread. If this bacterium is released, no scientist may be able to stop it from reproducing, evolving, and growing. The only way for harmful biological agents to be controlled is to prevent them from ever being released. Eradication of these weapons from Earth is the only way to keep


978 words - 4 pages concept because humanity's expectation of it is always evolving. The anticipation of the things we desire tomorrow are the things that fill our emptiness today. Tessa had found happiness, she knows it may not last forever and that within itself is a beautiful thing to evolve from. Up until Even now Carina's laugh still resonates within Tessa, illuminating the deepest and darkest parts of her soul. Comment by LeRoux, Tyler: Happiness is an elusive concept due to humanity's ever evolving expectations? Idk hahahaha

Human Evolution: Ideas and Opinions Related to Evolution

1249 words - 5 pages tested and critically analyzed. Burnett questions how humans have virtually stalled their own evolving process. There are speculations that humans are evolving extremely slowly due to adjust to their ever improving technology and changing world. Modern humans often forget that people still bear the ability to be well suited 4 tree climbers (Harmon, 2013). This trait would have been adapted from the evolution of a chimplike species to Homo

Similar Essays

The Ever Evolving Superweed Essay

1083 words - 5 pages include any concept of cross pollination since I was still unsure if that was proven, or if it was still just a theory predicted in early GM crop use. It led to me question more about how the weeds were evolving, I needed to find out if this really was due to gene transfer from crop to weed, or if it was the weeds independently evolving against roundup. The article helped me to understand how farmers and scientists were trying to fix the problem

The Ever Evolving Age Of Social Networking

1035 words - 4 pages Changing and ever evolving, technology has impacted everybody’s lives in an irrevocable manner . Beginning in 2003 with MySpace, social networking is one aspect that has completely revolutionized people’s everyday lives. The empire created by MySpace was then further expanded by a new generation of social networks such as Facebook and Twitter. This era was marked with innovative new features including video chat and increased commercialization

Genetically Modified Food: A Potential Economic Disaster

1036 words - 4 pages environmental consequences of horizontal gene flow by GMO's. Cross pollenation between GMO's and other plants is almost inevitable. Such cross pollenation could easily lead to the evolution of maverick organisms. The possible transfer of genetic traits, such as some plants immunity to herbicide, has provoked great concern from environmental groups. One such organisms that many environmental groups fear could arise is the superweed. A superweed would be a

Cons Of Genetic Modification Of Plants

1154 words - 5 pages side effects of having altered plants in the wild. This avow from the adversary has no grounds what so ever. The pollen from the plants can travel hundreds of miles away and plant themselves elsewhere. Then, they will destroy the other, lesser, crops and make themselves the prominent one. The altered crops can also create a “superweed” which will engulf an area and make itself the dominant plant by killing the others off . Charnes says, “...The