This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

'the Excellent Foppery Of The World': Skepticism In King Lear

2424 words - 10 pages

`The Excellent Foppery of the World':

Skepticism in King Lear

"As flies to wanton boys are we to th' gods; / They kill us for their sport." (4.1.41-42) So bemoans the blinded and despondent Earl of Gloucester in King Lear. Whether his claim deserves merit, while intriguing, is far beyond the scope of this paper. What I do intend to explore, however, is whether Shakespeare's play supports or opposes these and other skeptical ideas. I will argue that King Lear strongly advocates a skeptical worldview, not just in regards to belief in theism, but in all areas. A skeptical, humanistic philosophy pervades the entire text of Lear; I do not believe this is incidental.

First, an important distinction must be made. Skepticism is not atheism, and it is not nihilism. By "skepticism" I simply mean the philosophical position whereby all claims and belief systems, particularly, although not excluded to, those involving the supernatural, are questioned and critically examined, with the scientific method applied when possible. Skepticism does not necessarily lead to atheism, just as credulity does not lead to theism. For the purposes of this paper, whether solar eclipses really "portend no good to us" (1.2.109-110) is not important; what is important, and what I intend to show Shakespeare advocates in King Lear, is that people should critically examine the available evidence for that and similar claims.

King Lear contains numerous examples of characters advocating a skeptical worldview. Edmund, the bastard child of Gloucester, provides many. In his opening lines, he declares, "Thou, Nature, art my goddess. To thy law / My services are bound" (1.2.1-2), choosing naturalism over spiritualism. Later, after Gloucester warns him that the recent eclipses don't bode well for them, Edmund says to himself,

This is the excellent foppery of the world, that when we are sick in fortune (often the surfeits of our own behavior) we make guilty of our disasters the sun, the moon, and stars, as if we were villains on necessity, fools by heavenly compulsion; knaves, thieves, and treachers by spherical predominance; drunkards, liars, and adulterers by an enforced obedience of planetary influence; and all that we are evil in, by a divine thrusting on. (1.2.125-33)

Further, Edmund manipulates other characters' beliefs, invoking the supernatural to support his cause. Directly after dismissing astrology as "excellent foppery," Edmund replies to Edgar that he is "thinking... of a prediction I read this other day, what should follow these eclipses" (1.2.147-8). Later, after accusing Edgar of trying to murder him, Edmund describes to Gloucester how Edgar "stood... in the dark, his sharp sword out, / Mumbling of wicked charms, conjuring the moon / To stand auspicious mistress" (2.1.43-45). Gloucester advocates skepticism on his own, when, after being blinded, he questions the logic of a just god, declaring, "As flies to wanton boys are we to th' gods; / They kill...

Find Another Essay On 'the Excellent Foppery of the World': Skepticism in King Lear

The Wisdom of King Lear's Fool in Shakespeare's King Lear

2833 words - 11 pages The Wisdom of King Lear's Fool in Shakespeare's King Lear King Lear's fool is undoubtedly one of the wisest characters in the play. He is not only able to accurately analyze a situation which many other characters are blind to, but he is also able to foreshadow the actions of many characters and many other incidents to come. The main instruction the fool gives to the king is to beware of doing things that are unnatural, such as giving

The Nature of King Lear Essay

1071 words - 4 pages The most prevailing images in King Lear are the images (metaphoric and actual) of nature. The concept of nature seems to consume the dialogue, monologues, and setting. It might be useful to view nature as `the natural order of the world' (and, perhaps, the universe). When one goes against the natural order, chaos will follow. Shakespeare has made this point clear in "Troilus and Cressida" where Ulysses predicts that once "the specialty of

The Tragedy of King Lear

1029 words - 5 pages Gonorill. Regan. Cordelia. Those names should ring a bell if you have ever read or seen “The Tragedy of King Lear.” The plot behind this play revolves around King Lear’s relationships with each of these three characters; his daughters. King Lear has a different relationship with each of them. Gonorill, Regan and Cordelia all have very distinct personalities. In this play, King Lear decided it was time to give up and divide his kingdom amongst

The Reinvention of King Lear

2118 words - 8 pages The Reinvention of King Lear         On any given night within the global theatre community, chances are good that somewhere upon a stage there is at least one production of a Shakespearean play being performed, and whether it is Hamlet set in Nazi Germany (Eine Klein Hamlet) or The Tempest reworked as children's theatre (The Island of Anyplace), this production is, more often than not, a new interpretation of the ancient text. While the

King Lear - Disruption Of Order In King Lear And The Causes

881 words - 4 pages Shakespeare's King Lear is a play which shows the consequences of one man's decisions. The audience follows the main character, Lear, as he makes decisions that disrupt order in his Kingdom. When Lear surrenders all his power and land to his daughters as a reward for their demonstration of love towards him, the breakdown on order in evident. Lear's first mistake is to divide his Kingdom into three parts. A Kingdom is run best under one ruler

plotlear King Lear Essays: Importance of the Parallel Plot in King Lear

728 words - 3 pages the main plot that otherwise would be unmentioned.  William Shakespeare shows excellent use of a parallel plot in his play "King Lear", but some question it's essentiality by asking: Is it really necessary? Does it help the story or does it degrade it? Is the Gloucester's plot really needed?  Many argue that it is very important and others say it is completely useless.  This essay will try to prove that the parallel plot used

The Role of the Fool in King Lear

1111 words - 4 pages Untitled The Role of the Fool in King Lear King Lear is arguably one of the greatest of Shakespeare's tragedies. It is a tale of love and deceit, folly and loss, madness and sanity. Amid the action of Kings and knights, regents and dukes, turmoil and war stands the enigmatic character of the Fool. Unlike most of Shakespeare's Fools, The Fool in Lear is not even given a name even though he is one of the most important

The Role of the Fool in King Lear

2149 words - 9 pages Alison Dew Explore the role of the fool in King Lear. In Elizabethan times, the role of a fool, or court jester, was to professionally entertain others, specifically the king. In essence, fools were hired to make mistakes. Fools may have been mentally retarded youths kept for the court’s amusement, or more often they were singing, dancing stand up comedians. In William Shakespeare’s King Lear the fool plays many important roles. When

King Lear - Discuss the role of the fool in King Lear and his function in the unfolding of the plot

687 words - 3 pages In 'King Lear', the Fool is a character of dramatic importance in the play. The Fool helps the reader, and in Shakespeare's time would help the audience, to understand what lies beneath the surface of certain actions or verses. He equally strives to make Lear 'see'. The Fool may be a very intriguing character and very often a complicated one but his role is necessary in 'King Lear'.The Fool plays three major roles; one of these roles is that of

The Foolishness of Fools in Shakespeare's King Lear

1705 words - 7 pages " of his son Edgar. Edmund states that, "This is the excellent foppery of the world, that / when we are sick in fortune../...we make guilty of our disasters / the sun, the moon, and stars, as if we were villains / on necessity; fools by heavenly compulsion" seemingly for the soul purpose of illustrating his wickedness (I, ii, 32). Edmund realizes that his evil was borne by himself. This soliloquy shows the audience Edgar's foolishness in his

Shakespeare - The portrayal of universal themes in "King Lear"

1304 words - 5 pages society making Lear just as relevant and applicable to society today. Whilst fundamental differences between the Elizabethan audience and contemporary society today exist, most notably that the Elizabethan era was a theocentric age while today is a more anthropocentric age this does not negate the universal themes of Lear. Such themes include love, family values and power which still exist in society today. This is why King Lear is still relevant to

Similar Essays

Skepticism In The Modern World Essay

860 words - 4 pages Philosophical skepticism, according to Scottish philosopher David Hume, is asking whether human beings can perceive the world around us with any degree of accuracy. Practicing this school of thought means that a person initially never believes anything to be true, but at the same time, does not say everything is necessarily false; instead, he maintains a position of doubt. The final source of truth for a skeptic is experience. In terms

The Theme Of Blindness In King Lear

943 words - 4 pages blindness, he lived to become the leader of which was once Lear's kingdom. In King Lear, blindness is a theme portrayed by the main characters of these plots. Throughout the play Shakespeare is saying that the world cannot be seen with eyes only. It is a combination of mind, emotion and heart. True sight comes from within.

The Theme Of Justice In King Lear

1713 words - 7 pages justice and divine justice. As King Lear is a brutal play, filled with human cruelty and many awful disasters, the play's terrible events raise an obvious question for the characters, namely whether there is any possibility of justice in the world. Various characters offer their opinions. Towards the end of the play Gloucester says: "As flies to wanton boys are we to the gods; / they kill us for their sport

The Theme Of Blindness In King Lear

1785 words - 7 pages In Shakespearean terms, blinds means a whole different thing. Blindness can normally be defined as the inability of the eye to see, but according to Shakespeare, blindness is not a physical quality, but a mental flaw some people possess. Shakespeare's most dominant theme in his play King Lear is that of blindness. King Lear, Gloucester, and Albany are three prime examples Shakespeare incorporates this theme into. Each of these character's