The Execution Of Private Slovik Essay

893 words - 4 pages

In the narrator’s quest for information about the bombing of Dresden, he wrote to the Air Force, hoping to gain more knowledge about what went into the decision. His only official response at the time was “that the information was top secret still” (11). How bombing of Dresden could ever be considered classified when it had such a devastating effect on so many people is just one of the many absurdities pointed out by the narrator in his quest to provide a balanced view of the war.
One novel, The Execution of Private Slovik by William Bradford Huie, details the only execution of an American soldier for desertion during World War II. The narrator quotes from the opinion of a staff judge advocate who supported Slovik’s sentence, stating: “If the death penalty is ever to be imposed for desertion, it should be imposed in this case, not as a punitive measure nor as retribution, but to maintain that discipline upon which alone an army can succeed” (45). The view that a soldier should have to die in order for the military to maintain unit cohesion and essentially teach a lesson to other draftees who may want to desert their post is a hard one for those not in the military to sympathize with. Furthermore, it illustrates the paradoxical nature of militaristic actions, where one is forced to fight against enemies who wish to do them harm, or face death at the hands of their fellow servicemen if the choose not to fight.
During a Lions Club luncheon meeting Billy attends back in Ilium, a Marine Corp Major who had served in Vietnam addressed the attendees. The Marine spoke of his experience serving in Vietnam, and his view that “the Americans had no choice but to keep fighting… until the Communists realized that they could not force their way of life on weak countries” (59). The Marine spoke of his belief that North Vietnam should be bombed “back into the Stone Age, if it refused to see reason” (60). This juxtaposition of clearly contradictory views illustrates the justification by those in the military in regards to their own actions. To the Marine, it is implausible that the United States would be “forc[ing] their way of life on weak countries” such as Vietnam by “bombing [them] back into the Stone Age” (59-60). This inability of those in the military to see their actions as anything less than divinely just is illustrated throughout Slaughterhouse-Five.
In one particularly poignant passage, Billy views a World War II film on television late at night in reverse. The film, in its backwards view, shows fires going out, buildings being restored, and wounded men being made...

Find Another Essay On The Execution of Private Slovik

The Unjust Execution of Anne Boleyn

1554 words - 6 pages , and not attractive she used her body and her sense of style in attempts to win the English people over. Henry used these small everyday household struggles into something bigger, and they ultimately led to her unjust execution. Works Cited "Anne Boleyn: Biography, Portraits, Primary Sources." Anne Boleyn: Biography, Portraits, Primary Sources. N.p., 2 Nov. 2008. Web. 8 Feb. 2014. Bevan, Richard. "Anne Boleyn and the Downfall of Her

The Execution of the Man who made the Guillotine Famous/Maximilien Robespierre's execution

514 words - 2 pages the war an offensive, rather than defensive affair, which no longer warranted a wartime dictatorship as the Committees had been. The heat is another very important factor to consider. It was 104 degrees on 9 Thermidor; most of the men involved hadn't slept for over 48 hours and were living on caffeine, paranoia and adrenaline.On the day of his execution, Robespierre was taken first to the Committee, where his jaw was bandaged (Robespierre had his

The Definition of Private

534 words - 2 pages The Definition of Private Anyone who has ever received one of those pesky telemarketer phone calls during dinner most likely understands the idea of a private phone number. No one likes to have their phone line invaded by paid phone operators who just want your money. Working long and hard on a group presentation regarding technology threatening/improving privacy, one can realize that the word private has several different connotations and

The Stanford Method of the Execution of Mayor Yin

1139 words - 5 pages The story “The Execution of Mayor Yin” takes a perilous look at the dark side of the events that happened during the Cultural Revolution. Chairman Mao’s Red Guards were tasked with a cultural cleansing that left many people more confused at the roles they played in society than it reinforced the social class structure. The story tells of a young member of the Red Guard and the personal conflict he suffered during the cleansing of Hsingan

Elizabeth's Reaction to the Execution of Mary Queen of Scots

1369 words - 5 pages Elizabeth's Reaction to the Execution of Mary Queen of Scots Important Dates: 1st February 1587: Death Warrant Signed 8th February 1587: Mary Queen of Scots executed. In October of 1586, Mary was put on trial at Fotheringhay for plotting to kill Elizabeth and claim the English throne. Elizabeth's last letter to Mary was delivered at the start of the trial: You have in various ways and

The Methods of Execution and the Medical Experiments at Auschwitz

752 words - 3 pages The Methods of Execution and the Medical Experiments at Auschwitz My report will deal with the ways the prisoners of the Auschwitz concentration camp were executed, and also the medical experiments that took place. Accurate statistics were not kept, but the estimation of deaths that took place at Auschwitz ranged from 1.5 million to 4 million. Jews were the largest number of people who were killed. Poles and Soviet prisoners were also

The Death Penalty: Methods of Execution in America

1929 words - 8 pages criminals in an attempt to prevent others from committing similar crimes. Over the centuries, the methods used to conduct these executions have evolved and changed due to effectiveness and public opinion. In America, there have been five different execution methods used. These five methods consist of hanging, firing squad, gas chamber, electrocution, and lethal injection. The next five sections of this paper will cover each of these methods in greater

The Right of Private Defence

2811 words - 11 pages most outrageous manner by bands of ruffians, in one of the most remarkable and, at the same time, one of the most discouraging symptoms which the state of India presents to us. Under the circumstances we are desirous to arouse and encourage the manly spirit among the people than to multiply restrictions on the right of private defence. We are of the opinion that all the evil which would arise by the execution of one person over-stepping what

The Benefits of Private Enterprise

1452 words - 6 pages Private enterprise is the ironclad foundation of the United States of America. Whenever this right is jeopardized, the stability of the country follows in a symmetric trend. However, the value of this system has not always been clear. Throughout time no country has embraced this system quite like the United States. Private enterprise entails the right to market and sell a product or service, as well as the right of purchase. Indeed the

Rousseau: On the Importance of Private Property and Private Interests

1488 words - 6 pages In a society based on private property, a conflict arises between private economic interests and the general interest of the society. For this to be minimized in favor of the general will, Rousseau advocated a return to simple society based on a primitive economy. In his critiques on civil society, Rousseau identifies the division of labor, private property and exchange as the central causes of moral and political corruption in that society

The Methods of Execution used in the United States of America

1661 words - 7 pages The Methods of Execution used in the United States of AmericaWhy read?*Firstly you will learn about the different types of executions that take place, when someone is sentenced to the death penalty.*You yourselves will be able to judge whether these types of execution are a so called Humane and Painless way to die.*Although very doubtful, you may well find yourself in the position where this is happening to you!Things to be covered.*The

Similar Essays

The Execution Of Mother Earth Essay

764 words - 3 pages and the right downwards.The activation of the device shall turn off the electormagnetic forces that the vehicles all over the world use to fuel the cars and send the whole world into poverty and dismay along with us.As Ali followed his brother's instructuons game on getting back at the Americans,Sealed the containerTurned the opposing lids in different directionsSuddenly the tin glowed red hot then white and detonated within his hands sucking in the rest of Afghanistan along with him.The white flame sucked in the Earth and dissapeared into a white ball then exploded out on itself scattering Mother Earth in bits of meteorite.The Execution of Mother Earth.

Publicizing Execution Of The Death Penalty

1340 words - 5 pages lawyer Millard Farmer considered Pat's private execution as a "[shameful] secret," they believe "if most people in Louisiana would see what the state did... they would throw up." (Dead Man Walking, Prejean, p.94) But what kind of bloodlust are they promoting on a long term basis? The evil image of our numbed laughing joyfully for seeing death and torture is not exactly the way to raise awareness for respecting human life. If they were to punish, have

The Death Penalty: Multiple Methods Of Execution

2021 words - 8 pages The death penalty is one of the nation’s most hotly debated topic. Most Americans are either heavily in favor of execution or heavily opposed to it. In America, there are multiple methods of execution, lethal injection, firing squad, hanging, electrocution, and the gas chamber. Imagine, being strapped to a chair in various areas; usually the chest, groin, arms, and legs. A metal skullcap attached to your head, and then you’re blind folded. What

The Main Reasons Of Anne Boleyn’s Execution

1354 words - 5 pages and Catherine Parr ( Two of them were beheaded: Anne Boleyn and her cousin, Catherine Howard. However, the execution of Anne was the most notorious one during the reign of Henry VIII. His reasons of beheading his wife were: he had difficulties with getting divorced from his previous wife and he did not want a long process, Anne could not give birth to a son who could have been his crown prince, he was not attracted by Anne