This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Experience And The Manifestation Of “Romantic Love” In The Caribbean And The High Himalayas

1541 words - 7 pages

This paper aims to address the question: ‘Is Romantic love the same world over?’ by studying the experience, expression and manifestation of Romantic love in Guadeloupe’s (2006) and Du’s (2008) ethnographic accounts.

We meet, we fall in love, we get hurt, we part, and then we meet again. Sounds familiar? Yet, a simple question like, ‘How do you know you are in love?’ baffles many.

The study of human emotions began in the late 1970s and has flourished since; centring on the role it plays in the personal and social life of the individual, and how culture influences emotion (Lutz & White 1986: 405, 410). Love is considered to be one of the six, fundamental emotions surrounding human ...view middle of the document...

He further suggested that Romantic love does not subsist in non-individualistic societies, with the exception for the few that encourage premarital sexual freedom (Lindholm 2006: 11).

This paper is neither concerned with proving the universalness of Romantic love, nor disproving Lindholm’s (2006) insistence that some cultures lack the existence of Romantic love. Instead, this paper accepts that as an emotion, Romantic love may be both socially shaped and socially shaping (Lutz & White 1986: 418), and thus, questions the cultural relativity of Romantic love. Cultural relativity refers to whether or not a phenomenon occurs in similar forms across different cultural settings (Stevenson 2008: 8). Is falling in love in Paris the same as it is in Japan? Simply put, should Romantic love exist in a culture, it is probable that it varies in the way it manifests, how it is experienced and expressed when compared to another culture. Consistent with this, Jankowiak and Paladino (2008: 8) states that basic emotions are similar between cultures, but may vary in the degree to which the culture values or emphasizes the emotion.

By recognizing that there may be differences in the expression, experience and manifestation of Romantic love, it is then important to explore it emically and etically (Jankowiak & Fischer 1992: 154). In a study of East meets West, this paper will determine and define when Romantic love occurs, and identify the approaches these cultures takes to Romantic love (Lindholm 2006: 11). Du’s research focuses on the Lahu people, a collectivist society, who mainly reside in Southwest China, while Guadeloupe’s’ research focuses on the Caribbean, an Individualist society. Elza was born in the Dominican Republic, and moved to Aruba at a young age. Guadeloupe’s research is particularly interesting, as while the Caribbean subsists within the Euro-American realm, it appears to implement dissimilar cultural practices from the average Euro-American.

Manifestation and Experience

One major example of how Romantic love may differ in its experience and manifestation is in the varying views as to when Romantic love is expected to flourish. As Sarsby (1983: 2) states that Romantic love is not restricted to an individual and can exist in both the private and public spheres. Similarly, Lindholm (2006: 15) states that while individuals may experience the emotion that we identify as akin to the Western sense of Romantic love, those feelings may pose different implications in varying cultures. Moreover, Lindholm (2006: 11) states that some cultures perceive marriage as a family concern, and thus, any feelings felt, experienced or expressed prior, during and after marriage subsists in the public spheres. Thus, young men and women alike regard matrimony as an obligation and requirement instead of a love-match.

The popular Western notion about Romantic love and marriage is well encompassed by Frank Sinatra in his hit song, Love and Marriage (1955)...

Find Another Essay On The Experience and the Manifestation of “Romantic Love” in the Caribbean and the High Himalayas

The manifestation of violence in Antigone

2073 words - 9 pages Introduction The notion of violence by means of theme, language, staging, chorus and characterization is manifested in Sophocles’ Antigone. As suggested by Hannah Arendt (1969: 243) in her essay On Violence, “violence cannot be derived from power, in order to understand it, we must examine its roots and nature.” Violence can only be discussed when accompanied by a discussion of power. Walter Benjamin states “violence can first be sought only

The perception of love in romantic films

1226 words - 5 pages We've all seen them, those cheesy romantic comedies where two (beautiful) strangers meet and fall in love. They run into some sort of conflict and eventually find a way back to each other in the end. Although that seems like a harmless concept, that kind of "love" results in unrealistic expectations of what a life partner should be, unrealistic expectations of what the ideal woman or man should look like and unrealistic expectations of what

The Manifestation of Conflict throughout Romeo and Juliet

2001 words - 9 pages oppose each other in meaning. Shakespeare commonly used this stylistic feature throughout the whole story of Romeo and Juliet, and one might even describe the relation between Romeo and Juliet as an oxymoron; two people from two different opposing families. The two subjects do not fit together what so ever, still, they find a way to embrace and love each other, similarly to how two opposing words in an oxymoron does. An example of an oxymoron in

The Identity and History of the Caribbean

2174 words - 9 pages consisted of a large, captive lower class and a powerful, wealthy upper class. As the plantation systems became successful labor was needed in order to progress. Slavery became the answer to the problem. Slavery played an important role in the how the economy changed the islands because there was a shift on the main economic ingredient, Sugar. Section 2 of Caribbean Slave Society and Economy shows how the economy shifted during this expansion

What are the differences between romantic love and true love?

856 words - 3 pages will burn out, but not too sure how long it will take. Still, in the end, when its all said and done one will experience one more thing that comes with Romantic love; Pain. Whether the pain is due to how and or why the love ended; the fact that it is over; or the feeling of despair because they were supposed to be "the one true love" the fact is, that it is there. Romantic Love is a cycle that will bring happiness along with despair, pleasure

A Comparison of Romantic Love in A Midsummer Night's Dream, The Tempest, and Twelfth Night

1626 words - 7 pages Romantic Love in A Midsummer Night's Dream, The Tempest, and Twelfth Night In all of Shakespeare's plays, there is a definitive style present, a style he perfected. From his very first play (The Comedy of Errors) to his very last (The Tempest), he uses unique symbolism and descriptive poetry to express and explain the actions and events he writes about. Twelfth Night, The Tempest and A Midsummer Night's Dream are all tragicomedies

Plantation and Race in the Caribbean

1740 words - 7 pages and society of the Caribbean. Three people have taken it upon themselves to portray the Caribbean in their own ways. The opinions of Sidney Mintz, Michelle Cliff and Antonio Benitez-Rojo are made clear in their works and are discussed below in relation to two main issues; race and the plantations. The Issue of Race Perhaps out of personal experience and perhaps out of direct experience with people of the Caribbean, Michelle Cliff makes

Slavery in West Africa and the Caribbean

652 words - 3 pages Many people around the world believe that slavery was only held in North America with Africans being the only type to face punishment. This widely spread stereotype is actually false. The Caribbean and West Africa were large affected by the transatlantic slave trade in 1450 to1750. While wrong and immoral, the slavery in both places have similarities and differences. 
 The Caribbean was one of the worst slave trading operations in the world

The Region of the Tibet-Himalayas

851 words - 3 pages of the mountain.” (Krakauer, Into Thin Air, page 27). However, despite not being well known the Tibet-Himalayas are an area with many common characteristics, both of a physical, human, and cultural kind. Physical Characteristics The Tibet region has common physical characteristics. The elevation of this is area is the highest elevation in the world that humans as a whole inhabit, with “an average altitude of 4875m (16,000ft)” (The World

Poverty in Latin America and the Caribbean

1696 words - 7 pages . It seen as the old story being rewritten, the dynamics surrounding this issue by might be different. It can be said that poverty is not caused by one sole issue, when looking at the as a whole. But in everyday life economic problems of Latin America and the Caribbean can be seen as issues that can be solved separately. Although these issues can be examined separately and do affect individuals differently, these issues can be traced back to one

Lost In Translation - Literature and Language of the Caribbean

638 words - 3 pages The Caribbean features literature from English, French, Dutch, Spanish, and also fusions of fragments of those languages forming a dialect or sometimes a new creole language emerges. The experiences of the islands are similar, but not identical. Therefore the women and men had difference experiences and so authors will have different themes in their literature. Some may be more focused on the social aspects of the country, some political, and

Similar Essays

Impact Of Outside Invasion In The Central Andes And Himalayas

1055 words - 4 pages Impact of Outside Invasion in the Central Andes and Himalayas In Toward a Cultural Ecology of Mountains: The Central Andes and Himalayas Compared, David Guillet writes to address the nature of cultural adaptations between two mountain populations. His research is spurred by increased recognition that human intervention can cause detrimental resource degeneration in these fragile mountain environments. Guillet attempts to answer two

The Manifestation Of Imagery Essay

875 words - 4 pages of this and Rio’s character is highly charged in it. From the beginning the play opens up the characters being in a movie theater. Rio lives in a world where she wants to do her own thing but then wants to emulate what the manifestation of it. Through this particular narration, Rio, represents the younger generation in the Philippines. She is female, young, attractive, and is ambitious to the point where she wants to make movies and not

Variations In High Altitude Populations. The Purpose Of This Paper Is To Describe The High Altitude Stresses And The General Adaptations Made By The Tibetan Population In The Himalayas And The Quechua

2341 words - 10 pages enough. Many physical adaptations that reflect "the genetic plasticity common to all of mankind(Molinar,219)" have to be made to survive and even more than that thrive in this type of environment. In this paper I will describe the high altitude stresses. Along with adaptations made by the populations living in them. The two high altitude populations which I will examine in this paper are the Tibetan people of the Asian Himalayas and the

Agriculture In The Himalayas Of Nepal

1187 words - 5 pages Agriculture in the Himalayas of Nepal According to some estimates, as much as 90% of Nepal's population relies on agriculture for its sustenance.[1] The significant climactic variations between Nepal's sub-tropical Terai region, hills region, and Himalayan mountain region lead to a variety of different agricultural models. Within the northern Himalayan region, additional variations in agricultural style exist because of changes in the