The Extent To Which The Human Rights Act Of 1998 Strengthened The Rule Of Law In The U.K. Constitution

3695 words - 15 pages

The Extent to Which the Human Rights Act of 1998 Strengthened the Rule of Law in the U.K. Constitution

The Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA), an Act introduced to give effect to
rights from the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) in domestic
legislation. Its introduction has affected many legal areas;
especially the conceptions of the rule of law and their place in the
UK constitution. To understand the effect of the HRA, it is first
necessary to establish the initial status of these two concepts.
Having established this, the extent of the impact of the HRA can be

Rule of law and HRA

The concept of the rule of law has traditionally attracted two
different interpretations.[1] In terms of the impact of the HRA, each
interpretation, namely formal and substantive, invoke different
outcomes concerning their consequent effect upon the UK constitution.

The formal approach adopted most prominently by Dicey, holds the
fundamental tenet, ‘those who make and enforce the law are themselves
bound to adhere to it’.[2] It is less concerned with the actual
content or ‘justness’ of the laws themselves, but more in ensuring
that there is equal subjection of all citizens under the given system.
This positivist ideology separates the question of what law is, and
what it ought to be.[3] Raz went onto add that laws created under the
standard of the formal interpretation should be capable of acting as a
guide to an individual’s conduct. They should be prospective, guided
by clear rules, with open access to the courts (containing an
independent judiciary) and relatively stable.[4] This is not an
exhaustive list of what the formal interpretation entails, but the
latter two characteristics are of most interest to the HRA, especially
Section 6. It introduces obligations for public bodies that were not
previously evident in common law or statute. As such this raises issue
with the continuity or stability of law.

Also of relevance are Dicey’s views on the status of common law within
the rule of law. He felt there was no need a Bill of Rights, because
the general principle of the constitution is the result of judicial
decisions determining the rights of the private person.[5] Effectively
what is being stated here is that the common law is the guardian of
the rights of the individual, as shown in the case of Derbyshire
County Council v Times Newspapers Ltd.[6] Dealing with the right to
express criticism of publicly elected bodies, the Court of Appeal held
that the questioning by a newspaper of the official dealings of the
council was legitimate criticism. Common law was the tool used to
reach the conclusion, with it being decided that it was contrary to
the public interest for public bodies to have a common law right to
sue for libel. Although, the Court of Appeal did take guidance from

Find Another Essay On The Extent to Which the Human Rights Act of 1998 Strengthened the Rule of Law in the U.K. Constitution

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Rights of Man and the Citizen compared to The U.S. Constitution and the Declaration of Independence.

794 words - 3 pages escape religious persecution, but it had existed long before that. This "freedom of religion" allows our country to generally be a safe haven against religious persecution. Another striking similarity is in Article 11 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, "Everyone charged with a penal offence has the right to be presumed innocent until proved guilty..." This same idea is implied in Amendments 4-8 of the Constitution: Article XI especially

Human Rights and John Rawls The Law of Peoples

3834 words - 15 pages Human Rights and John Rawls The Law of Peoples Abstract: Which political and juridical foundation can justify the transit from the Western, particular, to the universal? John Rawls tries to answer this question in his article, "The Law of Peoples," proposing a kind of contract or agreement. A first agreement should be attained among liberal-democratic societies on a few political and social issues such as human rights. Then this agreement

To What extent did the spread of Christianity violate Human Rights and Freedom in Africa? By Walubo Jude Tadeo

1919 words - 8 pages categorized with others as 'Christian'. This breaches article 18 of the Universal Declarion of Human Rights which states that, Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion. As Daneel (1971:455) points out,"The older generation of mission Church officials - European and African - tended to view the Separatists as their opponents, 'sheep-stealers' who rob members of their flock, and as 'twisters of the truth'. The Separatist

Do human rights treaties call for special treatment under the law relating to reservations laid down in the Vienna Convention of the Law of Treaties 1969?

2909 words - 12 pages to a treaty, so if these reservations are deemed impermissible, "the only course open is to declare that this consent is not valid and decide that these states cannot be considered parties to the instrument in question".In the Human Rights Law Journal, the US government also stated that reservations which are contained in instruments of ratification are integral parts of a state's consent to be bound by the treaty in question, and so are not

Assess the degree to which African Americans were denied Civil and Human Rights in the southern states of the USA in the decades leading up to the 1950s.

1000 words - 4 pages eat spiritual dirt? Did I act as equals among equals? I do not know."Miscegenation was made illegal in Texas in 1925 and in Mississippi in 1920. This penal code disallowed black-white marriages in the two states. This was also factor in which African Americans were denied civil rights. It was seen disgraceful for a white woman to marry a black man by society. African Americans were seen as the second-class citizens. However in the state of

"To a great extent the Constitution is a document with as many checks upon the power of the people and majority rule as upon the power of the government." Assess the validity of this statement.

745 words - 3 pages . However, congress can impeach these judges if they feel that they are not fulfilling their jobs. Through this system of checks and balances, no branch of government can become too powerful.Another way in which the power of government is checked is by the bill of rights. This list of amendments to the constitution states the rights of the citizens of America. The Bill of Rights protects Americans' "inalienable rights". Rights such as trial by jury

Have the courts struck a balance between the protection of individual rights under The Human Rights Act and Parliamentary sovereignty?

2052 words - 8 pages reinforced the rights of the individual against the state. However, the courts have not always been so zealous in defending rights and liberties, as cases such as Malone indicate. Nevertheless, when the Human Rights Act 1998 was passed, the courts were again given a special role with regard to protecting human rights.According to section 2 (1) (a) of the Human Rights Act, when determining a question relating to a Convention right, a national court must

The Impact of the European Convention on Human Rights on UK Law

1987 words - 8 pages . Supporters of a Bill of Rights claim it would curb executive powers, since courts could simply refuse to apply laws, which conflicted with it. This in turn would be a powerful incentive for a government to avoid introducing such legislation in the first place. The provision in s.19 of the Human Rights Act 1998, requiring ministers to state whether a Bill conforms with the 1998 Act, this will discourage the executive

Investigate the increasing importance of human rights after World War II in both international and Australian law.

1153 words - 5 pages , the Constitution which expresses some rights including right to vote, common law with implicit rights such as right to fair trial and NGOs like Red Cross.Domestically, escalating fundamentality of human rights is illustrated by international scrutiny of asylum seekers and Aborigines. International human rights' violations cause an upsurge in refugees, which increase importance of human rights in achieving security and liberty for persecuted

Culminating assignment for civics which details how I would creat awareness to change the outdated law of the sex offenders act.

584 words - 2 pages How Can I Make A Difference?Why I choose this issue:In light of the recent murder of Holly Jones, it seems timely for this country to address its sex offender laws. Specific focus should be placed on the pattern and behaviors of repeat sex offenders. Although currently a sex offender registry exists throughout Canada, it seems that this is not enough to protect the vulnerable, especially our children. After Christopher Stephenson's death in

How Does English Law Give Effect to the Right to Marry and Found a Family as Guaranteed by Article 12 of the European Convention on Human Rights?

1816 words - 7 pages Article 12 would extend only to cases where there was a breach of English law. But the primary purpose of the convention is 'to guarantee certain human rights irrespective of the provisions of national law'. In the past the UK has had quite poor record before the European Court of Human Rights, largely because the Convention was not part of UK law until the passing of the Human Rights Act 1998.By applying article 12 the European court has to

Similar Essays

Uk's Constitution: The Rule Of Law And Parliamentary Sovereignty

2184 words - 9 pages sovereignty, they are unable to override parliamentary sovereignty unilaterally . Both Lords Hope and Steyn disapproved of unlimited Parliamentary sovereignty by making references to current constitutional developments such as the Human Rights Act 1998, the Scotland Act 1998 and Factortame . Lord Steyn concluded that Dicey's explanation 'can now be seen to be out of place in the modern constitution' . The approaches of both these Lords

Human Rights And The Savings Law Clauses Of The Jamaican Constitution

905 words - 4 pages Constitution which proscribes that: “[N]othing contained in any law in force immediately before [August 6, 1962] shall be made to be inconsistent with any provisions of this chapter [3]…” Moreover, though Section 17(1) of the Jamaican Constitution provides that “[N]o one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment,” entrenching here the basis whereby civilised standards of treatment in Jamaica are safeguarded

The Incorporation Of The Human Right Act Into British Law

2404 words - 10 pages rights clash with the sovereignty of parliament because sovereignty means that there is nothing that can blind our parliament. But the Human Rights Act tries to do this. When the Human Rights Act really gets going, judges will be involved in political cases. For example, they may consider laws which extend police power, or which limit freedom of the press. Although they cannot set them aside, they will be able to criticise

The Extent To Which The Rise To Dominance Of Company Law In The Nineteenth And Early Twentieth Centuries Was The Inevitable Consequence Of Technologi

3414 words - 14 pages The Extent to which the Rise to Dominance of Company Law in the Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries was the Inevitable Consequence of Technological Advance During this period of history, Britain experienced what came to be known as the ‘second industrial revolution’ – a period of major industrialization with changes to British industry as a whole, and further to this, a change in the idea of the ‘company’ or firm. Hand