The Failure Of The Qing Dynasty

1255 words - 5 pages

The Failure of the Qing Dynasty

Although some short term successes were achieved for China when
dealing with western demands of diplomatic relations and free trade,
in the sense that it retained their pride in their tributary systems,
such responses were in flawed in the long term. Focusing on the time
period 1793-1839, this essay will investigate what were the western
attempts and demands in diplomatic relations and free trade. It will
also investigate what was the reason to the failure of the Qing
dynasty to respond effectively to western demands of diplomatic
relations and free trade. The two aspects will be explored
respectively. It will be argued that the Qing government’s failures in
responding effectively had led to long term grievances towards China’s
existing system by the West, as well as exacerbated silver outflow of
Chinese economy. The main factor leading to failures in effective
response to western demands was China’s construct that it was superior
to any other alien powers.

Western demands for diplomatic relations can be seen in the three
missions from 1793-1834 (Macartney, Amherst and Napier), but Qing’s
rejection of Western demands resulted in Western grievances towards
the existing system. The failure for Qing to respond effectively to
Western demands was due to its world view that it was superior.

The Macartney mission was a relative success, for communication
between the West and China had been established, but the latter two
missions were failures in term of establishing a friendly relationship
between powers. The main objectives of the missions were to open the
whole East to British trade, place relations with China on a regular
basis, and the dissemination of Christianity, for which Qian-long
however found it “utterly unreasonable”. More friction could be seen
between the West and China with Amherst’s reluctance in conforming the
kowtow ritual. Emperor Jaiqing viewed such act as an insult to the
Middle Kingdom due to British pride and arrogance, and added that no
more attempts need be made to send mission to Beijing. The Chinese
emperor was further humiliated by Napier’s breaking of five important
regulations: did not apply for permission to go to Guangzhou, had no
customs permit to reside in the Guangzhou factory, sent his
communication to the viceroy not as humble “petition” from an inferior
to a superior but as a “letter” to an equal, the letter was in Chinese
not in English, and he tried to get the letter delivered directly and
not through the Cohong merchants.

It was a failure for the Qing in the long term for it aroused Western
grievances in the Chinese system. Such view was supported by the
historian Vohra, for he argued that incidents like the Emily incident
although showed Westerners were willing to cope with such inferior
treatment,...

Find Another Essay On The Failure of the Qing Dynasty

Economy of the Ming Dynasty Essay

817 words - 3 pages imperial China. Trade with foreign nation flourished so much that the Ming government had to restrict the amount of goods coming in and out of China. Many different jobs were taken by the people and the society greatly prospered along with the government. Though the economy was so great, the Ming Dynasty followed in the dynastic cycle and also eventually came to a downfall and was succeeded by the Manchu ruling Qing Dynasty.Works CitedChina - MSN

The Shang Dynasty of China Essay

1354 words - 5 pages The Shang Dynasty has the earliest recorded written history. The Shang Dynasty was from 1600-1046 BC. It lasted over 500 years and belonged to seventeen generations. It arose during the Bronze Age in China. Thousands of archaeological findings have been found in and by the Yellow River valley. The cradle of Chinese civilization.The Shang Dynasty of China was the second hereditary dynasty in China. It lasted almost six hundred years with thirty

Fall of the Romanov Dynasty

1097 words - 5 pages While Gregori Rasputin was not the main cause for the Russian revolution and the collapse of the Romanov Dynasty, Rasputin was a determinant that spurred on the eventual downfall of Russia. Rasputin was a factor of the end of Tsarism through; his association with and acceptance into the Romanov family, his outward appearance to be a personal advisor to the Tsar as well as actually having a great deal of influence over the Tsar and the political

Poets of the Tang Dynasty

1855 words - 7 pages in their poetry, there are connections between the Tang Dynasty poets’ works and their respective religions. Wang Wei (699-761CE), was a Buddhist poet that was born in to the upper class in Shanxi. He passed the Chin-Shi system – a system that was designed to challenge government and bureaucratic officials in all realms of knowledge from poetry and art to academia. However, Wei was exiled due to a loss of popularity during his career. This is

The Age of Foundation: The Han Dynasty

967 words - 4 pages The Age of Foundation: The Han Dynasty The Chinese Empire is a land of innovation, mystery, culture, and art. From mysterious trade partners to military expansionists, the Chinese people have faced a constant evolution of change over their vast history. China’s innovative and advanced mindset has made the West wonder in awe for centuries, and it is difficult to realize that, unlike the West, the East has been the center of technological and

Qing China History: Challenges from the West

2776 words - 11 pages backwardness and decided to make changes. Yet, the fact was that conservatism in society still influence the mind of many Chinese. Some more stimulants were necessary to arouse their support. In the third period, the force of change played the most important role in Late Qing history. There were several reasons behind. First, there was the total awakening from all level. The most conservative figure Cixi, after the failure of the Boxer Uprising and

The End of the Romanov Dynasty

1537 words - 6 pages Why was there a revolution in February?The February Revolution of 1917 was the beginning of the Russian Revolution that lasted through to October. Although the causes were numerous, ranging from political to economic, it was the consequence of a combination of situations and events. This revolution resulted in the abdication of Tsar Nicholas II and was the first stage in the Russian Revolution, leading to the October Revolution where Lenin takes

Buddhist Art of The Wei Dynasty

2429 words - 10 pages traditions, with other popular Buddhist art forms from places, such as India. The arrival of Buddhism in China greatly influenced the art of China for many dynasties. According to Art in China by Craig Clunas, the Wei Dynasty, which started in 386 and ended in 535, was an era in which Buddhism was central to the culture of both the noble and common people. For much of the Wei dynasty the artists and sculptors were slaves to the state. Different

Funerary Pillars of the Han Dynasty

951 words - 4 pages As I viewed these funerary pillars from the Han dynasty, I noticed that the tops of their heads were flat. This indicated to me that they may have been used as a support system to hold up something. This led me to believe they may have been part of an entrance to a Han dynasty tomb. The pillar to the left shows an image that appears to be a human-like being holding a stone tablet while sitting on top of a pillar. I could not read what

Achievements of the Tang and Song Dynasty

665 words - 3 pages During the Tang and Song dynasty, many excellent achievements have been accomplished which are still being preserved and used widely over centuries. Their citizens were excelled in many fields with several of new and practical inventions which all directly affected the citizens’ lives. Especially, the big rise in science and technology as well as attaining such great progresses in agriculture and economy were some of the most remarkable ones

The Failure of Chartism

848 words - 3 pages The Failure of Chartism For the chartist to have had a focus, they would all have to have had the same issues, and all held equal support for all 6 parts of the people’s charter, the paper behind the chartist movement. This was not the case; in many instances the people would only support something when it suited them, a knife and fork issue, this was the cause for the collapse in the movement. In source one it does say how people wanted

Similar Essays

The Decline Of Qing Dynasty Essay

1295 words - 5 pages corruption and failure of the imperial court to deal with crisis.Historically, its own people, the native Chinese of the Han race, mostly governed China. The two exceptions are the Mongolian Yuen Dynasty and the Manchurian Qing Dynasty. The transition between Qing's predecessor Ming and Qing was a particularly difficult one, mainly due to Han people's strong resentment of a "barbarian" government. Surrendering to the Qing was not only an abandoning of

To What Extent Did Anti Foreign Sentiment Contribute To The Collapse Of The Qing Dynasty?

2355 words - 10 pages China was plagued by famine, natural disasters and economic problems which the government failed to recover from in the nineteenth century. Empress Dowager Cixi was a reluctant reformist and made sure China remained a monarchy till her last breath in 1908 which created anti-Qing feeling. Although the fall of the Qing Dynasty can argued as a result of its failure to reform and modernize China to keep its people content, perhaps the most

This Essay Describes Women In China During The Qing Dynasty

2176 words - 9 pages foundational female virtue. Indeed, the Qing rulers promoted chastity to the point where it became virtually a cult. The Han dynasty was a time when several important morality books for and about women were published. These books became classics and were reprinted, revised, expanded on, and read in upper class households in all later dynasties especially during Qing dynasty. One of these classical morality texts was Biographies of Exemplary Women

Explain The Causes For The Failure Of White Revolution? ( In Pahlavi Dynasty)

5848 words - 23 pages Explain the causes for the failure of White Revolution?M.AbdollahiMay 1999IntroductionThe circumstances of the events between the years 1960 and 1963 are considered as the background and basis for the proclamation of the White Revolution. The general atmosphere of political uncertainty and poor economic prospects reduced domestic saving and investment. Thus the inflationary pressure continued and the cost of living rose day by day. In addition