This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Failures Of Prohibition Essay

619 words - 3 pages

In the 1920s, prohibition was put into effect. No one was allowed to consume, sell, or transport alcoholic beverages. Prohibition was meant to help Americans better themselves physically and emotionally. It was also meant to decrease crime rate and reduce taxes on jails and poorhouses. Prohibition was the government’s way of attempting to purge moral failings. Prohibition was indeed a failure.
In David E. Kyvig’s article, he argues that prohibition was in fact a failure. Kyvig states that, “While in reality national prohibition sharply reduced the consumption of alcohol in the United States, the law fell considerably short of expectations. It neither eliminated drinking nor produced a sense that such a goal was within reach” (200). Kyvig explains how the government had a noble way of thinking but did not see what was coming with the evolution of prohibition. The government was overwhelmed with all of the ...view middle of the document...

For example, during the 1920s, fewer people were arrested for public drunkenness, and there were substantially fewer Americans treated for alcohol-related diseases” (190).
Although both of the articles make valid points, I have to agree with Kyvik. I do not think that prohibition was a success. The government had very noble reasons and high expectations that it would actually better the American population. “When the Eighteenth Amendment took effect on January 17, 1920, most observers assumed the liquor would quickly disappear from the American scene” (191). People are going to do what they want to do regardless of what the government says. Even though the government told people not to drink, bootleggers found ways to supply and people found ways to drink. People always find a way to get what they want. If you tell someone not to do something, it is only going to make them want to do it more. “Absence makes the heart grow fonder.”
Enforcing prohibition was a failure because not only did it do the complete opposite of what the government thought it would do, but it completely backfired. “They did not realize that the law would be resented and resisted by sizeable elements in an increasingly urban and heterogeneous society where restraints on the individual were becoming far less compelling” (191). The crime became organized and there was more crime than ever before. Jails filled up because so many people were getting caught with alcohol. “During 1929, 75,298 prohibition cases alone were concluded. In 1920, federal prisons contained just over 5,000 inmates; ten years later they contained over 12,000, more than 4,000 of whom were serving time for liquor violations” (197). Prohibition also led people to depend on other things, such as drugs, to substitute for alcohol.
Prohibition was a failure because nothing worked out the way it was supposed to and people are going to drink no matter what, but too many people let alcohol consume their lives. Because of alcohol, people lose sense of who they are, go to jail, die, or even kill someone else. Although prohibition was a complete failure, the lessons of Prohibition are still very important today.

Find Another Essay On The Failures of Prohibition

The Introduction of Prohibition Essay

1002 words - 4 pages The Introduction of Prohibition Prohibition was introduced in 1920 as part of an amendment to the Constitution of the USA. It was introduced for a variety of different reasons including a wartime concern for preserving grain for food rather than for brewing and distilling. There were also feelings against the German-Americans, who were responsible for brewing and distilling, at a time when America was at war against

The Effects of Market Failures Essay

2048 words - 8 pages The Effects of Market Failures Innovation has a crucial impact on the standards of living in particular economy. It is generally agreed that research and innovation are the main sources of growth and job creation in market economies. i.e. output is increased through greater acquisition of knowledge. Subsequently, 2 things matter for economic growth: savings and the state of the productive knowledge (i.e. shows how

The History of Drug Prohibition

1225 words - 5 pages Drug prohibition was not always accepted as it is today. Indeed, until the early twentieth century, there were few drug laws at all in the United States. Before the Harrison Narcotics Act of 1914, one could buy heroin at the corner drugstore; even Coca-Cola contained small amounts of cocaine until 1903 (Vallance 4). Some of the most proscribed drugs today were sold like candy and (quite literally) soda pop. What caused the sudden shift to

The Causes of the End of Prohibition

1788 words - 7 pages The Causes of the End of Prohibition In 1919 the Eighteenth Amendment to the American Constitution, banned the 'manufacture, sale or transportation of intoxicating liquors' This happened in a hope to keep America prosperous through the 'boom' of the 1920's, to keep a sober workforce amongst the country, and to set up an example to the rest of the world, that they had high moral standards and were superior. Then

The Mafia of the Prohibition Era

2203 words - 9 pages Although the Mafia is most associated with the Prohibition era of the 1920’s when it dominated crime in all major US cities, the true beginnings of the most infamous criminal organization started quite earlier. Beginning in the late 1800s, many Italians immigrated to New York City due to continued rumors of success in the area. This trend continued out of the 19th century and into the 20th as over 500,000 Italians immigrated to the United States

The Successes and Failures of Personalized Medicine

870 words - 4 pages against all cancers. The B-RAF mutation is extremely common in 50% of patients with melanoma as well as other types of cancers, including thyroid, colorectal, ovarian, breast and lung (Harmon 2010a). The B-RAF inhibitor is being tested for in humans to determine if this molecule can block the effects of the mutated gene to stop the progress of melanoma cancer (Harmon 2010a). The clinical trial faced successes and failures. In this particular case

Past failures of the palestinian liberation organization

2064 words - 8 pages - too short, some grammatical improvements needed but otherwise a good analysisPAST FAILURES OF THE PALESTINIAN LIBERATION ORGANIZATIONIn 1948 when the country of Israel was created, Palestinian Arabs lost control of all the lands which they possessed. Although many organizations were immediately formed to regain the lost lands, it was not until 1964 when the Palestinian Liberation Organization was created, that there was a single voice to be

the rise and fall of prohibition

1677 words - 7 pages Toni CarterDiscover New York 566Professor TurnerMay 4, 2014The rise and fall of prohibition"Prohibition did not achieve its goals. Instead, it added to the problems it was intended to solve" (Thorton, 15). Prohibition was a time in the United States between 1920 and 1933 where the production, sale, transportation, and importation of intoxicating liquor were banned. Legislation, known as The Volstead Act, was enacted to help carry out the

The Reasons and Results of Prohibition

1038 words - 5 pages In December of 1917 the Eighteenth Amendment or Prohibition Act was passed, outlawing alcohol for American citizens. Thais was a major movement within U.S. history. Drinking increased substantially in the years after the Civil War, causing the desire for change within America. Overall drinking caused a major upset for men and women living within the 20’s. Research has shown that the Prohibition was caused by major social and financial issues

The Negative Impact of American Prohibition

1743 words - 7 pages Implemented in the 1920's, Prohibition made the selling and buying of alcoholic beverages illegal. Rather than improve Americans lives, Prohibition created a multitude of issues. Prohibition was a drastic failure and created more problems for the United States. Because of the lack of public support, people believed in personal choice and thought it was up to them whether or not they wanted to drink. There was a lack of enforcement of Prohibition

Modern-Day Prohibition- The Criminalization of Marijuana

614 words - 3 pages In January of 1919, the 18th amendment, the prohibition of alcohol, was ratified due to progressive movements. It was soon repealed in 1933, when crime increased and issues spread throughout the country. The concept of “gangsters” was established and unsafe alcohol became apart of America’s diet. This problem is now evident in this country today. Marijuana, an all natural plant that is known to get someone “high,” or to alter the state

Similar Essays

The Failures Of Violence Essay

1539 words - 6 pages . This event elaborates upon why Mao Zedong lost. He seemed superior, but because he attempted to use violence, he failed. And that's the crux of the matter. Nonviolence works, violence doesn't. To relieve any doubts of the failures of violence, we will examine a key event, Joseph Stalin's rise to power. After Lenin, the leader of the Soviet Union, died, Stalin seized power—again, using violence—and transformed Russia into a totalitarian

The Nightmare Of Prohibition Essay

1675 words - 7 pages Amendment on October 23, 1919. The Act was named after Andrew Volstead, a Republican representative from Minnesota. The Volstead Act, also known as the "National Prohibition Act", determined intoxicating liquor as anything having an alcoholic content of more than 0.5 percent, excluding alcohol used for medicinal and sacramental purposes. The act also set up guidelines for enforcement. Prohibition was meant to reduce the consumption of alcohol

The History Of Prohibition Essay

1525 words - 6 pages The History of Prohibition Source A is aptly named “Slaves of the saloon”. It shows a man handing over what we guess is his weekly wages to the owner of a saloon – we guess by the men drinking in the background that he is using it to buy alcohol. The source also depicts a woman and her children sitting around a table with no food. We can guess fairly easily that this is the man in the saloon’s family; there is a bill on

The Era Of Prohibition Essay

1595 words - 7 pages instinct to things that make you feel good. A lot of people feel as if alcohol helps them. It can ease stress and help you get rid of those negative thoughts. Prohibition was never going to work in the first place. The government was interfering in people's lives. It was supposed to be one of the most peaceful times in American history. Alcohol was banned so you would think not many Americans would be getting crazy. But things would get out of control