This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Fall Of Tsarism In Russia

4077 words - 16 pages

The Fall of Tsarism in Russia
Some sources suggest that autocracy is outdated and the reason for the
collapse of Tsarist Russia. However, other sources suggest that
without the complications of war, Russia may have prospered. Tolstoy
and Kokovstov both have conflicting views. Tolstoy the pessimist,
believed that autocracy was an outdated form of government not suited
to 20th Century Russia. However Kokovstov the optimist thought that
Russia would have prospered if it wasn't for the Great War.

Source C uses an extract taken from Tolstoy's letter to Tsar Nicholas
II, three years before the revolution of 1905.

There was a significant growth in the army of secret police, which
indicates that the Tsar is not strong enough and needs a personal army
to enforce his authority. This is proved in events such as Bloody
Sunday whereby police open fire on innocent workers in a peaceful
protest for requesting descent pay and conditions. Russia had now
become a police state. As people are attacked for open thought and
speech, this furthermore proves Tolstoy's argument, "autocracy is
outdated".

"The policy of censorship continued to produce meaningless bans"
indicates that the government was out of touch with the Russian
citizens. This situation could be compared with Nazi Germany because
Russia appears to be a police state. Religious persecution was at its
worst, which shows that the Tsar was very dependant on Orthodox
Christians because they believed he was ordained by God. The situation
was getting worse because the government's policy of increasing taxes
had failed and now peasants were starving. This highlights the
government's incompetence. 'As a result, all classes are openly
hostile to the Tsarist government'. This indicates that the Tsar could
not control all the classes, he had only got the secret army and
police state on his side.

In this extract, Tolstoy states that the prisons are overcrowded
meaning that people are willing to go to prison for their beliefs. A
majority of the Russian people are not afraid of what the Tsar could
do to them if they commit crimes. This shows how outdated Tsarist
Russia is and how out of touch the Tsar Nicholas II is because so many
Russian citizens are willing to go to prison for their beliefs.

At this time it is no secret that the lower classes such as the
working class oppose autocracy and the Tsarist government. Tolstoy
(the writer of this source) used the fact that he was a part of the
upper class to his advantage. He was able to speak openly because he
himself was an aristocrat.

Source C is biased because it was written by Tolstoy, the man who
states the first argument. "Autocracy is an outdated form of…"

Tsar Nicholas II's October Manifesto opens with 'Our unchangeable...

Find Another Essay On The Fall of Tsarism in Russia

Russia: The Fall of Human Rights

966 words - 4 pages Union, working secretively never informing the outside world what they did. This comparison that Mr. S made questioned the ability to write anything that the press wished to, or the freedom of press. Paul Klebnikov the editor of a Russian version of the Forbes magazine was killed by being shot in Russia. He wws looking into a set up of money laundering which had to do with the Chechen reconstruction fund that gave a trail that went in the direction

Political and Economic Changes in Russia Since the Fall of the Soviet Union

1530 words - 6 pages Since the collapse of the Soviet Union, Russia has undergone many changes. These changes were very profound and included the drastic restructuring of both the political structure and the economy. When the Russian people became dissatisfied with the communist system, they pushed for a regime change, which resulted in the dissolution of the Soviet Union and the introduction of a democratic system. Along with these political changes came the

Why did Tsarism Survive the Revolutionary Crisis of 1905?

1506 words - 6 pages Tsarism was under threat from a combination of crises that occurred throughout 1905. The autocracy managed to survive against a weak and disorganized opposition by conceding political agreements and through tough repression with the use of force. Russia suffered from economic tensions and a disastrous war with Japan in the early 20th century. The reluctance of the government to act in problematic situations and its isolation of the problems of

THe Legacy of Communism in Russia

982 words - 4 pages THE LEGACY OF COMMUNISM IN RUSSIAEver since the fall of communism in Russia in 1989, the past has constantly come back to haunt or influence the present. Matthew Brzezinsk, the author of, Casino Moscow, writes about his experiences about going back to the Soviet Union and observing all that goes on today in the 'free' country of the former Soviet Union. There is still widespread corruption, just as there was back in the cold war days. Mayors

The rise of communism in Russia

2190 words - 9 pages The Rise of Communism in RussiaÒUnless we accept the claim that LeninÕs coup dÕ tat gave birthto an entirely new state, and indeed to a new era in the history ofmankind, we must recognize in todayÕs Soviet Union the old empire of theRussians -- the only empire that survived into the mid 1980ÕsÓ (Luttwak,1).In their Communist Manifesto of 1848, Karl Marx and FriedrichEngels applied the term communism to a

The rise of commnism in russia

2116 words - 8 pages The Rise of Communism In Russia"Unless we accept the claim that Lenin's coup d'etat gave birthto an entirely new state, and indeed to a new era in the history ofmankind, we must recognize in today's Soviet Union the old empire ofthe Russians -- the only empire that survived into the mid 1980's"(Luttwak, 1).In their Communist Manifesto of 1848, Karl Marx and FriedrichEngels applied the term communism to a final stage of socialism inwhich all

The Stability of Russia in 1914

761 words - 3 pages The Stability of Russia in 1914 In 1914 Russia's stability was questionable; the Tsar's regime had been under considerable strain due to the unsuccessful uprising in 1905. The Tsar still had the support of the army, which helped to put down many attempts at revolution. However, there was still brewing resentments about the harsh conditions of the Tsar's government that threatened to explode at any time. The

The Rise of Communism in Russia

1962 words - 8 pages The Rise of Communism in Russia"Unless we accept the claim that Lenin's coup d'etat gave birthto an entirely new state, and indeed to a new era in the history ofmankind, we must recognize in today's Soviet Union the old empire ofthe Russians -- the only empire that survived into the mid 1980's"(Luttwak, 1).In their Communist Manifesto of 1848, Karl Marx and FriedrichEngels applied the term communism to a final stage of socialism inwhich all

The Case of Brewing Sector in Russia

7710 words - 31 pages 1. INTRODUCTIONThe aim of this report is to evaluate the viability of investment by Hong Leong Group in Russia and in particular in the brewing industry.The first step of this project is to analyse the decision of choosing Russia as an offshore location. This decision has been based on the attractiveness of the country in terms of its financial structure, people skills and availability and business environment.The study will be followed by an

The failure of Marxism in Russia

2095 words - 8 pages Iain Pearson, 1st year, Modern History (BA Hons)'Far from being the creature of ideology, in its essential features the Soviet state defied Marxist theory,' Discuss.When the Tsarist regime in Russia was overthrown and the Bolshevik party under Lenin ruledas a single party government, it was claimed by many that a Marxist regime had beenestablished. Many within the Bolshevik party were firm believers in the Marxist theory andthought that the

The War of 1812 in Russia

1456 words - 6 pages The War of 1812 in Russia When Russians talk about the war of 1812 they do not mean the war in which Washington was burned by the British, but the war in which, apparently, the Russians burned Moscow. This war between the French republican empire and the Russian Tsarist Empire was as remarkable a high - spot in the history of the latter as it was a low - spot in the history of Napoleon. For Russia, it was one of those rare moments in

Similar Essays

The Fall Of Communism In Russia

2445 words - 10 pages to the contrary of its good intentions when applied in Russia. During 1989 the world looked on with amusement as the communist government in the U.S.S.R collapsed and was replaced with a government committed to democracy and the free market. The ethics of brother hood, equality, the plight of the poor and the working class (all characteristics of communism) slowly diminished over the years of corrupt rule, violence and

The Fall Of Communism In Russia

2811 words - 11 pages The Fall of Communism in RussiaThe Reasons for the fall of Socialism/Communism and the Troublesof Starting the New Democratic System in the Russian Federation "Let'snot talk about Communism. Communism was just an idea, just pie in thesky." Boris Yeltsin (b. 1931), Russian politician, president. Remarkduring a visit to the U.S. Quoted in: Independent (London, 13 Sept.1989).The fall of the Communist regime in the Soviet Union was morethan a

The Fall Of Communism In Russia

2805 words - 11 pages The Reasons for the fall of Socialism/Communism and the Troublesof Starting the New Democratic System in the Russian Federation "Let'snot talk about Communism. Communism was just an idea, just pie in thesky." Boris Yeltsin (b. 1931), Russian politician, president. Remarkduring a visit to the U.S. Quoted in: Independent (London, 13 Sept.1989).The fall of the Communist regime in the Soviet Union was morethan a political event. The powerful bond

The Fall Of Russia Essay

1301 words - 5 pages privatized, although workers and managers owned most of these enterprises, many of which have not still been restructured to compete in market conditions. “Under the program, every citizen of Russia would be issued a voucher with a face value of 10,000 rubles (the equivalent of about $30) (Remington 199).” By that time, most vouchers issued in 1992 had been used by their owners to buy shares in firms directly, invest in investment funds, or sell on