The Fallacy Of Nonsense Essay

2355 words - 9 pages

The Fallacy of Nonsense

Lewis Carroll was a professor of logic, writing among his well known works of fiction, treatises on the subject of logic and even a textbook, Symbolic Logic. “It is the function of logic to classify and formulate fallacious forms of argument as well as valid ones.” (Burks 367) So is it some of the functions of Carroll’s tales of Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass. Presenting different puzzles, riddles, or what appears to be on the surface nonsense, Carroll in these books present many questions of logic and indirectly their solutions, challenging the ability of the reader to believe what has been presented. All his nonsensical puzzles can be either proved or disproved using some form of logic. “Not only is it not nonsense… it also contains, by implication, a great deal of excellent sense.” (Heath 51)

At one point in Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, a pigeon claims Alice to be a serpent, because serpents eat eggs, and Alice eats eggs. (Carroll A/T 47) The propositions would be then what is quantified in symbolic logic as universal, with the functional word “all”. Using the notation AE to represent the proposition “Alice eats eggs”, SE to represent “Serpents eat eggs”, concluding AS, “Alice is a serpent”, and “” to mean “therefore”, the argument is represented in simple terms as:

}  AS

In Symbolic Logic, Carroll represents this same argument as:

}(m being assumed to exist)  x’y’1

(Carroll SL 261) where x would represent Alice, y would represent serpents, and m would represent eggs. He states this argument form to be a fallacy, or invalid by definition. Carroll may have chosen to use this particular example to demonstrate a fallacy due to the fact that the reader already knows that Alice is not a serpent, leaving it to logic to prove why.

Another fallacy is presented in Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland at the mad tea party. On the two propositions “I say what I mean” and “I mean what I say,” (Carroll A/T 61) Alice concludes equivalence, applying the symbolic logic rule of conversion. Translated into a form which can be applied, the first proposition becomes “All I say is what I mean”, notated “All S is M”, by definition a universal proposition. The second, assumedly a conversion of the first, is translated “All I mean is what I say” and is notated “All M is S”, also a universal proposition. However, the conversion is invalid, because a universal proposition converts to a particular proposition. The valid conversion would be “All S is M” to “Some M is S”, or “Some of what I mean is what I say”, according to the symbolic rules of conversion. (Copi 194) Now it is clear that the two propositions are not necessarily equivalent, and the following propositions...

Find Another Essay On The Fallacy of Nonsense

Analysis of a quote from Shelley's A Defense of Poetry using Wimsatt and Beardley's article "The Intentional Fallacy".

2869 words - 11 pages ESSAY TOPIC:Analyse the following statement from Shelley's A Defense of Poetry using Wimsatt and Beardley's article "The Intentional Fallacy". Your essay must contextualise the quote, demonstrate the quote's relationship to the broader theory of Romantic authorship, and provide a definition of intention and why it is central to the Romantic conception of authorship."A man cannot say, 'I will compose poetry.' The greatest poet even cannot say it

The Fallacy of Love Songs Essay

1116 words - 5 pages understand the differences between ‘falling in love’ and ‘real love’ and how the transition from the former to the latter occurs have resulted in many broken and unhappy marriages” (Petersen 16). This idea of unconditional love seems ideal, but brings a darker side with it. In our current pop culture, Rihanna has demonstrated what could be called a form of unconditional love. After her partner, Chris Brown, physically abused her, a few years

The Fallacy of Bellori's Views on Caravaggio

874 words - 4 pages It does not seem to be true that Caravaggio, as stated by Giovanni Bellori, “advanced the art of painting”. At first, based off of Caravaggio’s primary contribution to art, tenebrism, one may conclude that he was an innovative painter of his time. This happens to be very similar to the views of Bellori, who argues that Caravaggio was innovative in that he introduced realism and abandoned the conventions of preceding painters. In this case it

The Fallacy of ‘Emancipation’: African Americans in Florida from 1865 - 1870

2372 words - 10 pages The African-American during the Reconstruction Era probably felt victorious as well as discomfited. Prior to the Civil war, slaves hoped freedom would give them the right of equal status in American society, but their dream of an egalitarian America was impeded after Lincoln’s assassination. To add to former slave woes, the southern economy lay destitute. Many southerners felt the added wage earners (former slaves) would destroy the cotton

Decision Making: Fallacy Summary and Application

850 words - 3 pages making. The fallacies that will be discussed are:First, Appeal to Pity fallacy, Second, "Ad Hominem" or personal attack fallacy, and third the false alternatives or false dilemma fallacy. The first is an appeal to emotion fallacy. The personal attack fallacy is of relevance. And the third is a fallacy of insufficient evidence.Appeal to Pity FallacyThe first discussed fallacy is the Appeal to Pity fallacy. The Nizcor Project website (2005) defines

Fallacy Summary and Application Paper

2148 words - 9 pages conclusion would not be more likely to be true.ReferencesCurtis, G. "The Fallacy Files". Retrieved from, J. "Logical Fallacies". Retrieved from, T. "Explanation of Basic Fallacies". Retrieved from, R. Nonsense: A Handbook of Logical Fallacies. Axios Pr. September

Fallacy Summary and Application MGT 350 - Critical Thinking: Strategies in Decision-Making July 16, 2005

1358 words - 5 pages , explain their significance to critical thinking, discuss the general application to decision-making, and provide examples that illustrate each fallacy. Further analysis of fallacies indicates several characteristics common in all fallacies. Most typical are logical fallacies. Logical fallacies are errors in interpretation. They can be categorized into relevant fallacies, where the premises are not relevant to the conclusion, and insufficient

Fallacy Summary and Application

870 words - 3 pages logically irrelevant to a conclusion. A fallacy of insufficient evidence fails to provide sufficient evidence to support the conclusion though its premise can be logically relevant. The ability to identify logical fallacies in the arguments of others, and to avoid them in one's own arguments, is both valuable and increasingly rare (Holt, 2005). Three fallacies that fall into either one of the above categories, there definitions and significance with

Summary and Application

1237 words - 5 pages , identification of fallacies is essential for high-producing organizations.The red herring fallacy is a logical fallacy where an individual introduces an irrelevant issue into a discussion to draw attention away from a core issue. As a result, the conclusion is not relevant to the original issue. For example, a reporter asks the President of the United States if he supports Roe v. Wade. President Bush may answer by describing the types of judges

Fallacy Paper

1072 words - 4 pages , fallacies can be very persuasive to the casual reader or listener. One in particular, the false cause fallacy, is used quite often in today’s society. Hurley states that, “The fallacy of false cause occurs whenever the link between premises and conclusion depends on some imagined causal connection that probably does not exist.” For example: Every time my son wears his dirty socks at a soccer game his team wins. Therefore, to prevent the team

Fallacy Summary and Application Paper - UOP CSS/330 Required Paper

1124 words - 4 pages Fallacy Summary and Application PaperFallacies by definition are a false or mistaken idea's, or an often-plausible argument using false or invalid inference. There are two types of fallacies discussed in this paper. Logical fallacies of relevance are fallacies that occur because the premises are logically irrelevant to the conclusion. Logical fallacies of insufficient evidence are fallacies that occur because the premises, though logically

Similar Essays

Metalanguage In A World Of Nonsense Based On The Book Alice In The Wonderland

1071 words - 4 pages Alice gradually explores Carroll's Wonderland in Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, serving as a guide for the reader through this world. Carroll's world of nonsense reflects a different type of speech where statements of characters are taken literally. This method of storytelling stands as a foundation in Carroll's world. He accentuates his mastery of the subtleties of semantics, which appears to be an underlying principle of nonsense in the

The Fallacy Of The American Dream In Fitzgerald’s "The Great Gatsby"

801 words - 3 pages dreams. With your mind set so tight on one idea, you are unconsciously setting yourself up for failure because you have no back up plan. The 1920s seemed to be full of wealth and fame but this was not valid. According to statistics, “It is a fact that millions of people lived below the poverty line in the 1920s”. It is clear now that you always need another dream to fall back on. Because of the fallacy of the American dream, many people were

The Fallacy Of Schizophrenia Essay

657 words - 3 pages “A psychotic disorder characterized by loss of contact with the environment, by noticeable deterioration in the level of functioning in everyday life, and by disintegration of personality expressed as disorder of feeling, thought (as delusions), perception (as hallucinations), and behavior” is Webster’s definition of the word schizophrenia. At the mention of the word schizophrenia some of the first things that come to mind are John Nash in A

Milton's Elegy Vs. Gray's Elegy. Through The Use Of Imagery, And Pathetic Fallacy, Argues The Superiority Of Milton's Elegy

887 words - 4 pages Often, John Milton's Elegy and Thomas Gray's "Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard" have been compared. Many believe that Milton's Elegy influenced Gray's Elegy. While the two Elegies' have a lot in common, they are still very different. Using literary elements, such as imagery, tone, and the use of pathetic fallacy, this essay will show that Milton's Elegy is superior to Gray's.Imagery is very important in a poem, novel, or elegy. It allows