The Fatal Pride Of Odysseus Essay

1091 words - 5 pages

Yasmine Karam

The Fatal Pride of Odysseus
Odysseus is known as a great war hero and leader who encounters and conquers unimaginable obstacles in his quest to return to Ithaca. This is understandable, given that Homer often uses Odysseus’ point of view in recounting his tortuous ten-year journey. However, beneath the surface is another perspective that is often overlooked, namely, that of Odysseus’ men who accompany him on this journey. Odysseus often glosses over his shortcomings as a leader and accentuates or even exaggerates his successes. If his men had been given more of a voice, it is likely that a different account of Odysseus’ leadership qualities would have been presented. For instance, Odysseus takes great pains to portray himself as an innocent victim and Homer’s readers generally accept this perspective. Odysseus’ hubris makes him careless when it comes to the safety of his men and therefore, an unreliable leader. Careful analysis of the scenes featuring Cicones, Aeolus and the Winds, and Scylla and Charybdis reveals that Odysseus often fails to transcend his own self-interest and ultimately he is the one responsible for the deaths of his men.
The events that take place on the island of Cicones reveal Odysseus’ flaws in two ways. First, in his vanity, he wishes to make an impression that will last long in the minds of men, and he therefore leads his men in a rampage against innocent people in order to plunder their wealth. The treasure could have been taken without wholesale murder and enslavement but Odysseus is accustomed to thinking of himself as a great hero and indiscriminately applies his wartime practices of kill or be killed. To be so unnecessarily violent says a lot about Odysseus and his wrong assumption that because of who he is, it is perfectly acceptable to kill innocent people as he pleases. Second, Odysseus’ own unscrupulous practices sends signals to his men that such behavior is acceptable. Accordingly, they indulge in premature celebrating on “stores of wine,” which impairs their good judgment (Homer 146, 52). Allowed to over-drink as they please, the men lose their sense of moderation and feast on the sheep and cattle, giving “fugitives” an opportunity to call in the island’s army (146, 54). However, rather than take responsibility for his lax leadership, Odysseus blames his men, calling them “mutinous, fools” for butchering “sheep after sheep” and cattle (146, 51-52). In truth, the men only acted on his command but got carried away, resulting in the deaths of many of them. Odysseus weaves a different image for readers about this incident in order to hide his own error and protect his reputation. If he were to admit that he had a major role in the many tragic deaths of his men, he would be admitting that he is not necessarily the reliable and admirable leader he and many others believe him to be.
After leaving Aeolus, Odysseus fails to inform his men that he has the east, south and north winds in the ox skin...

Find Another Essay On The Fatal Pride of Odysseus

The Bow of Odysseus Essay

2454 words - 10 pages The Bow of OdysseusTo quote Crissy, "Book 21 of the Odyssey might be termed 'The Book on the Bow.'" It contains the history of the bow and an account of the contest which marks the beginning of Odysseus' final attack on the suitors. It is by means of the bow that Odysseus disposes with the suitors, retakes control of his household, and fully reclaims his lost identity. But this bow is not only a deadly weapon; it is also a symbolic link both

The World of Odysseus Essay

3005 words - 12 pages The World of Odysseus was written by Sir Moses I. Finley, and it is an in depth analysis of the Iliad and the Odyssey. The period in history that helped to produce these two phenomenal works is veiled with uncertainty due to the fact that an actual written history doesn't exist. Homer put his history of the period together from the traditional custom of oral poetic story telling that originated from the late Dark Age and early Archaic Period

A Freudian Analysis of The Fatal Sisters

676 words - 3 pages A Freudian Analysis of The Fatal Sisters   When the psychoanalytical approach is applied to Thomas Gray's "The Fatal Sisters,", each of Freud's three main theories are glaringly apparent. A major factor in the poem's psychoanalytical grisly texture is that the poem is sung by the giants at the loom as they weave. The language they use not only reflects upon the characters, but it offers new insight for Freudian analysis. The

The Complex Odyssey of Odysseus

1126 words - 5 pages Skylla, and even asks him, “ must you have battle in your heart forever? / The bloody toil of combat?” (Homer 212-13). He defies her knowledge and superiority and fights the six-headed monster. In both situations, Odysseus, shows that his pride comes before his reason, and he needs humility in order to survive these harsh situations. However, Odysseus does have some humility. When Odysseus is speaking to the gods especially to Athena he is a humble

The Loyalty Crew of Odysseus

703 words - 3 pages In The Odyssey, Homer conveys a mixed message about Odysseus’s crew. At times, they seem loyal, whereas other scenes reveal them as disloyal. Homer does this to help center the attention on how Odysseus can fall victim to temptation and stand up to take control of his crew. The critical moments where Odysseus and his crew are in disagreement are significant because they demonstrate how Odysseus is epic, yet still human and flawed. After

Character Analysis of Odysseus in the Odysseus by Homer

662 words - 3 pages Who was Odysseus? Odysseus was the main character in a story titled The Odyssey; which was written by Homer. In the story, Odysseus is trying to sail back to his home on Ithaca, but on the way home, he encounters a little trouble! Throughout the story he portrays bravery, intelligence, and stays loyal to his crew. Odysseus was brave. He came upon an island of Cyclopes, one-eyed monsters and entered their cave. Despite his crew, who wanted to

The Pride of Othello

1034 words - 4 pages The Pride of Othello     In Shakespeare's Othello, Othello's pride prevents him from finding the truth, eventually leading to his demise. Initially, Othello and Desdemona are deeply in love, despite her father's disapproval of their marriage. However, when Othello promotes Cassio instead of Iago to Lieutenant, Iago has his revenge by convincing Othello that Desdemona cheats on him with Cassio, destroying the marriage

The Trials of Odysseus of Homer's Odyssey

1654 words - 7 pages prove his valor, intellect, and determination. Incorporated into The Odyssey are many current-day characteristics of man including a constant dependence on others, the presence of a greater vision, or lack there of, and the essence of a sensitive side behind courage and pride. At times throughout The Odyssey Odysseus didn't think about the consequences of his actions and depended on guidance from the gods to help lead him in the right direction

The Odysseus: The Theme of Love

519 words - 2 pages The Odysseus: The Theme of LoveThere are many essential emotions that form the building blocks of ourlives. These emotions help to shape the people that we are. These feelingsare emotional necessities to ultimately keep us happy. Nothing makes thesefeelings more evident than the Odyssey by Homer. Through out the course ofthis book there is one major emotional theme which is love.Often times in life we search for a companion, someone to share our

Divine interactions on the journey of Odysseus

1751 words - 7 pages Odyssey EssayIt took Odysseus a total of ten years to get home after the end of the Trojan War. Different gods had different feelings about Odysseus when aiding and thwarting him on his journey back to Ithika. Odysseus traveled all over the Mediterranean Sea searching for a way back to his precious homeland and beautiful wife, Penelope. Odysseus had been forced to fight for a total of ten years in the Trojan War, carried away from his son

The match of Odysseus and Penelope

1015 words - 5 pages How many women can spend years waiting for a man? How many men can spend years can spend years facing horrors at sea to return to a woman? In The Odyssey by Homer Penelope waits twenty years for Odysseus while he is trapped at sea. Despite their decades of separation, their shared strengths of loyalty and cunning make them ideal for each other. One important characteristic Penelope and Odysseus. When Odysseus and his soldiers fail to return

Similar Essays

The Shadow Of Odysseus Essay

846 words - 4 pages companions downfall. Odysseus’ excessive pride, confidence and love for himself can be seen numerous times throughout the Odyssey. This personality can be presumed to have developed since childhood. From the beginning when Odysseus first got his scar, he had already proven to be far more superior to others. Although only a child, Odysseus had slain a great boar, which may have been the start of the development of his arrogant nature. Showered with

The Heroism Of Odysseus Essay

2412 words - 10 pages poem The Odyssey, by Homer, Odysseus gains the title of hero during his journey back to Ithaka, from Troy, by proving to be one. It is through his characteristics and experiences that he becomes the well developed man at the end of the book. In truth, because of his confidence, loyalty, and difficult struggles, Odysseus becomes a genuine hero to the people he defended. Odysseus’s confidence fuels him to perform the actions he does, and he shows

The Traits Of Odysseus Essay

1103 words - 4 pages In Homer’s The Odyssey, there are a lot of traits displayed that are considered important in ancient Greek culture. These are shown by many different characters, but mostly by Odysseus (he is, after all, the main character in the epic poem). Odysseus is the epitome of a Greek ruler: he has a lot of admirable traits. His only fault is his hubris, but that is overcome and taken care of. Throughout Homer’s The Odyssey, Odysseus displays wisdom

The Character Of Odysseus Essay

1502 words - 7 pages The main character in this novel, Odysseus has many great traits and without them, he would never have been able to see his family after a long journey that took almost 20 years. Some of the traits that Odysseus shows that he has throughout the book many times are loyalty, craftiness and intelligence. Being loyal is what keeps him going, and his craftiness and intelligence are what keeps him alive in some points and in others, just lets him