This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Fierce Controversy Essay

766 words - 3 pages


Taylor Whitbeck

Intro to Cultural Anthropology

Professor Michael Cepek

March 6, 2010

Yanomami Position Paper

To properly understand the controversy surrounding the Yanomami and Napoleon Chagnon, one must look back to the start of this situation. In 2000, investigative journalist Patrick Tierney published the book Darkness in El Dorado which accused Chagnon and his colleague James Neel of spreading a measles epidemic among other things. Tierney also makes seven other basic accusations against Chagnon. (1) He claims that the Yanomami are not a "fierce people" as Chagnon had previously reported. (2) Chagnon noticed this warfare because of his own interaction with the Yanomami. By trading machetes and shotguns for information Chagnon sparked their increased levels of violence. (3) Tierney accuses Chagnon of staging his films for dramatic purposes, which is why the films won so many awards. (4) Tierney suspects Chagnon of altering or even making up data that he included in his article, which was published in Science in 1988. (5) He claims that Chagnon used unethical techniques to gain genealogical information from the Yanomami about their ancestors. (6) Tierney states that Chagnon is wrong when he claims that he is the first outsider to have made contact with the Yanomami people. Tierney argues that there was a woman named Helena Valero who was kidnapped by the Yanomami and lived among them for over fifty years. (7) Tierney also accuses Chagnon of violating Venezuelan law by being involved in a plan to establish a private Yanomami reserve. This was called the FUNDAFACI project which would allow Chagnon and others to interact with the Yanomami free from government control.

These seven accusations against Chagnon are quite serious and have been the basis of the Yanomami controversy for years. Whether or not any of those accusations are true has been the subject of much debate in recent years. However, these implications have helped analysts of the controversy formulate four basic questions about Chagnon and his research: (1) Did Chagnon violate the ethical principle of "do no harm"? (2) Did Chagnon...

Find Another Essay On The Fierce Controversy

Dam Building on the Yom River

1178 words - 5 pages Dam Building on the Yom River The proposed for Kaeng Sua Ten dam project has provoked controversy for more than ten years. Due to fierce objection from the locals, the government's aspiring aims to construct the dams in Phrae province's Tambon Sa-Iab may never leave the drawing board. The government declared that the dam was essential. It would reduce flooding, ease seasonal drought areas, and lead to agricultural development. Dams

The Civil War and Its Effects on the Nation

985 words - 4 pages The Civil War is known for its brutality and fierce fighting on both sides that led to one of the greatest wars in the history of the world. The war was vigorously contested and fought with courage and pride for one’s beliefs. The war would tear apart a country and reunite it stronger than ever, the country regrouped and began building a stronger infrastructure and a brighter future. The Civil War will never be forgotten and will always help

Should Embryonic Stem Cell Research Be Federally Funded?

1693 words - 7 pages . However, because ES cell research uses genetic material that is used to create life it has been overflowing with debate. This controversy has been around for years. And for years each side has been immovable in their conviction. Those who oppose ES cell research believe it is wrong because it involves the destruction of embryos. This blatant disregard for human life makes many people who oppose ES cell research uncomfortable and outraged. Many

Issue Brief

948 words - 4 pages % identified as DKs. The take away is that after such a fierce political battle, the public remained as it was—confused. The NLL itself is too intricate an issue for the public to understand and the addition of the controversy over the confidentiality of the summit documents complicates it even more. Furthermore, the target of accusation is the late president Roh Moo-Hyun, and accusing him has proved a complicating factor in the whole affair. What


1253 words - 5 pages reproductive potential of plants and animals vastly exceed their given means, yet population levels remain fairly constant. Based on this observation Darwin concluded that the plants and animals surviving the fierce competition among all life are inherently better equipped to live and subsequently passed their superiority to their offspring. In October of 1838 Darwin experience a great revelation: Being well prepared to appreciate the struggle for

Edmund Burke: His influence on the Enlightenment

1278 words - 5 pages Ireland, and asked Burke to become his personal secretary. He then switched positions to become personal secretary to Charles Watson-Wentworth, who was known as a liberal Whig and also the Marquess of Rockingham. In his position under Watson-Wentworth, Burke became very monumental in the constitutional controversy in Britain under King George III. George argued strongly for royal power over the constitution and political parties. Burke knew that

The Difference between Lobbying and Bribery as it pertains to the 2002 Winter Olympics

904 words - 4 pages Being chosen to host the Winter Olympic Games is an honor and a privilege. Like with any large and popular sporting event, there is a lot of money involved. With the influence of money and natural greed, competition to host the games becomes fierce and the potential for digressions multiply. This is the case of the 2002 Winter Olympics in Salt Lake Utah. After winning the bid to host the games, it became known that the Salt Lake Organizing

Ryanair Marketing Strategy

929 words - 4 pages accomplished and continues to evolve. However, a new competitor has entered the market and threatens their “lowest fare anywhere” motto. EasyJet, founded in 1995 (Spotlight falls on, 2013) has emerged as another low cost carrier (Wensveen, 2011) and is keeping competition fierce as they try to exceed Ryanair customer service by providing “speedy boarding”, more flexible fares, guaranteed seats and better food service (Low cost airlines, 2013). In

Charles I innocence

820 words - 4 pages After the end of the civil war, officers of the New Model Army, formed by Cromwell, decided to put Charles on trial. Parliament voted to negotiate with the King in order to come to a peace agreement, but that was met with a fierce rebuke from Cromwell and his army. In order to kill any hope for the King and to prevent any kind of compromise between the King and Parliament, one hundred and eighty members of Parliament were excluded, and forty

Definition of Psychology

1039 words - 4 pages seen as distinct from the body. Definition of Psychology: Psychology is one of the youngest sciences. It is still going through the process of its development. There has been much fierce controversy about its definition. It has been variously defined as the science of soul, the science of mind, the science of consciousness, the science of behavior. The science of soul: Psychology was first defined as the

Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X: Icons for the Civil Rights Movement

990 words - 4 pages and his mom was put into a mental institution. He was a self-taught individual who did not receive much in the way of a formal education. He grew as a leader with his motivation, intelligence and determination. However, both men were fierce advocates for civil rights and consider their blackness to be a critical component of their identity and their strength. Martin Luther King Jr. was born into a family whose name was well known. His family

Similar Essays

Stem Cell Research Controversy Essay

891 words - 4 pages The controversy over stem cell research’s use in the medical field is almost two decades old. So why the sudden intense return of fierce political debates over an old issue? It’s because President Obama recently revoked the ban on stem cell research, as he believes it holds the potential to revolutionize the medical industry in the years to come. As USA Today quoted him saying in March, after he stopped restricting federal funding for stem cell

Ultimate Fighting Championship Essay

573 words - 2 pages Ultimate Fighting Championship The sport of Ultimate Fighting Championship has gained popularity throughout the past five years. UFC consists of two fighters using two styles of combat, fighting each other until someone submits or gets knocked out. Since the start of the UFC there has been great controversy if it should be legal in the US. States such as Kansas, Ohio, and South Carolina have outlawed UFC. This has some fans upset

The Controversy Facing Patient Safety In The U.S

800 words - 4 pages Fierce healthcare reported sometime in June of 2012 that hospitals across the country had received safety report cards from one Leapfrog group. They reported that most facilities got a C or below in the rankings. The report also showed that the biggest hospitals such as the Henry Ford Hospital in Michigan barely got a passing grade. The report cards were meant to inform patients and also to motivate improvements in patient safety, they were

Homophobic, I Think Not Essay

940 words - 4 pages We all know who Eminem is whether it be because we listen to his music or because of the huge controversy that seems to fallow his next billboard hit. Ever sense the release of his first album The Slim Shady LP in 1999 or the more predominate album under fire The Marshall Mathers LP released in 2000, and Encore in 2005 Eminem has been fighting off critics and gay and lesbian right activists because of his "lyrical content." People say that he