This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The First Crusade And The Ideas Of Crusading

2006 words - 8 pages

Contrary to many commonly held notions about the first crusade, in his book, The First Crusade and the Idea of Crusading, Jonathan Riley-Smith sets out to explain how the idea of crusading thought evolved in the first crusade. In his book, Riley-Smith sets out five main arguments to show how these ideas of crusading evolved. Firstly, he argues that Pope Urban’s original message was conventional, secondly that a more positive reaction was drawn from the laity (due to the ideas surrounding Jerusalem), thirdly, that the original message of crusading had changed because of the horrible experiences of the first crusaders, fourth, that due to these experiences the crusaders developed their own concept of what a crusade was, and lastly, that these ideas were refined by (religious) writers and turned into an acceptable form of theology. Riley-Smith makes excellent points about the crusade; however, before one can delve directly into his argument, one must first understand the background surrounding the rise of the first crusade.
Throughout the ten-century, particularly in France, the world had become an extremely violent place. Feudal Knights were often quarreling over land possession, looting, and looking to lay people to provide them with sustenance . Likewise, the power of these knights and the extent of violence flourished due to the increasingly lacking power and authority of the kings . The Church, in an attempt to halt the violence and anarchy attempted to take control and issued such concepts as “the Peace of God” . Similarly, at this time other movements for peace by the Church were underway, and one of the commonly held ideas was the need to transform the world to more “monkish ideals”. From these ideals also sprouted the concept of the laity having “God-given functions to perform, functions that could include fighting to protect the Church”. Pope Leo IX (1049-1054) is an example of this idea; he often used militia to fight against his opponents. In the early eleventh century, there came a pivotal figure in the ideas of Church sanctioned war, Pope Gregory VII (1073-1085). Pope Gregory was involved in the Investiture Contest, and soon turned to scholars to seek out “justification for his conviction that violence could be used in defense of the Church and could be authorized by it”. The movements generated by Pope Gregory, as well as the results of the Investiture Contest only furthered the violence, chaos, and lack of power of the kings in Western Europe.
Throughout this chaos in Western Europe, there were stabilizing factors. One of the most important factors was religion. In the superstitious society of Western Europe in the late tenth and early eleventh centuries, people often looked to nature to interpret divine signs. Relics were becoming increasingly popular. Sin was a constant concern to these people. A popular way of ridding oneself of all sin was the pilgrimage. In this type of society, it is not very hard to see how the idea of...

Find Another Essay On The First Crusade and the Ideas of Crusading

Context and Causes For The First Crusade

1334 words - 5 pages . Asbridge’s conclusion seems to take a negative stance toward the Crusading ideology. He describes the harsh actions the Crusaders made during the war based on their so called “faith.” The whole focus of The Crusade was placed on capturing the city of Jerusalem. Asbridge suggests that because The Crusades succeeded that a miracle had indeed taken place and that it was “God’s will” that led them to victory. According to Asbridge, if the first

The First Crusade: a success? Essay

2516 words - 10 pages chronicles Gesta Dei per Francos, God's work done by the hand of the Franks". But did the people of the First Crusade really fulfil all that Pope Urban II had been hoping for? If he had lived to hear of the capture of Jerusalem would he have agreed that the Crusade had been a "remarkable success"? This essay will examine the question of what Urban II was hoping for when he made call to Crusade at Clermont, and whether the people who responded to

Was the First crusade fought under the pretense of religion

2027 words - 8 pages Was the first crusade a war fought exclusively in the name of God?The 'First Crusade' was a holly war that was fought in 1095. Not known as a crusade until much later they were known and seen to people as pilgrimages. The war was fought from most of the European countries, against the growing power of the Byzantine empire and Islamic religion which was spreading like wild fire across the middle east. Muslim armies had conquered Syria, Persia

What Caused the First Crusade, and was it a Success?

1346 words - 5 pages The First Crusade was cause by conflicts between the Christians and the Muslims for the Holy Land, Jerusalem. Jerusalem was the holy city for all three groups of different faiths; the Christians, the Jews, and the Muslims. For the Christians, Jerusalem was where Jesus was crucified and resurrected. For the Muslim, Jerusalem was the place where Muhammad had ascended to heaven. For the Jews, it was their God's city and it was the sit of Solomon's

The Wars Of The Crusade

848 words - 4 pages celebrate mass and pray for Christian victories or to carry relies of saints” (Lords and Ladies). The crusades were also a set of holy wars between 1096-1270 A.C. The first Crusade was over the Christian knights and the Muslims in order to regain their holy land. After the Christian knights captured Jerusalem. The Crusades eventually caused other holy wars to spread causing conflicts between other Christians fighting against Christians. “The second

Answers: Study the sieges of Antioch and Jerusalem during the first crusade and Acre during the Third Crusade. Describe the logistical hardships of mounting a siege in foreign territory

1576 words - 6 pages Study the sieges of Antioch and Jerusalem during the first crusade and Acre during the Third Crusade. Describe the logistical hardships of mounting a siege in foreign territory. Compare the means and ends of each campaign. How did the Crusaders act toward Jews and Muslims.Just as the developing warfare of the West, sieges were more common during the Crusades than were actual battles, and in the broader scope, the outcomes of these sieges were of

The Children's Crusade: Innocence, Masculinity, and Humanity

1870 words - 7 pages finished. They were leaving the comforts of home to fight in a war they did not know much about. After Mary’s rant, Vonnegut named his book The Children's Crusade after being called children fighting in war(Kunze 45). The name was also brought up again when referring to Billy and the other American soldiers while at a German detainment camp. After being cleaned and shaven, did the Englishmen finally noticed how young and innocent the soldiers

McCarthy and The Anti-communist Crusade

1293 words - 5 pages country. They lost their friends, jobs, families, and all respect by everyone they knew. Ellen W. Schrecker states, “The anti-communist crusade affected thousands of individuals, institutions, and communities […].” meaning that this Red Scare affected every aspect of American life, not just the people accused (199). Businesses, families, organizations, and every part of American society were negatively impacted by this incident. Safety of mind is

Indiana Jones And The Last Crusade

631 words - 3 pages Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade The theme of this Indiana Jones movie is the constant contrast between Indy and his father Dr. Henry Jones. The difference is in their outlook on live and the many mysteries that surround them. Indiana only trust pure fact and will not listen to any ?truth? he hears from other individuals. He only believes in what he can see and touch. On the other hand, Dr. Henry Jones believes in the in the supernatural and

The Crusade: A Form Of Terror

882 words - 4 pages The crusade was a campaign of many battles in the name of Christendom that was waged against heretics, pagans and Muslims in general. These crusades were sanctioned by Pope urban II with the aim to resist the entrance of Muslims into the Byzantine Empire initially but later on extended to capturing of Jerusalem and the holy land from Muslims who occupied it at that time. Subsequently, a gruesome series of unholy alliances, sieges, manslaughter

The Failure of the Second Crusade and the Fall of the Christians

794 words - 4 pages Amongst the wars that have been fought in the history of mankind, The Second Crusade can be counted as one of the most disastrous. Completely contrary to the First Crusade, the Second Crusade was lead by two leaders with two un-cohesive agendas. This division of power and lack of military organization ultimately led to the massacre of thousands of Christian Crusaders and crushing losses along the way in the Crusaders' attempts to recapture the

Similar Essays

The Cause And Effect Of The First Crusade

2388 words - 10 pages . 970-c. 1130 / Oxford : Clarendon Press ; Oxford ; New York : Oxford University Press, 1993.Asbridge, Thomas S., The first crusade : a new history. 1st Oxford University Press paperback, 2005Krey, August. C, The First Crusade: The Accounts of Eyewitnesses and Participants, (Princeton: 1921), 257-62, Jonathan. The first crusade and the idea of crusading. London [England

The First Crusade Essay

1263 words - 5 pages theJews. Eventually, they reached Constantinople and were sent by the Emperor Alexius I to AsiaMinor where they were slaughtered by the Seljuk Turks.A papal supported Crusade was soon to follow. The soldiers for the first true Crusadewere recruited from the warrior class of knights. By 1096, ' an international military force, with alarge nucleus of knights from central and southern France, Normandy, and Norman Sicily, madeits way across the Balkans

The First Crusade Essay

1963 words - 8 pages Mos Eisley spaceport on the planet Tattooine where “you will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy.” Were these to be the ranks of Pope Urban II’s holy army? Clearly, this seems to be the case. The First Crusade, 1095 – 9 started with the Peoples Crusade after the preaching tour of Pope Urban II. The Crusaders were not an organization of knights and foot soldiers as I would have imagined, but an agglomeration of men, women

The First Crusade Essay

731 words - 3 pages in these battles, the Crusaders , those charged with the holy task of carrying out the churches directive, at first reading sound quite familiar to the inhabitants of the Mos Eisley spaceport on the planet Tattooine where “you will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy.” Were these to be the ranks of Pope Urban II’s holy army? Clearly, this seems to be the case. The First Crusade, 1095 – 9 started with the Peoples Crusade