The 1st Temptation Of Jesus As Used To Defend The Inquisitor's Argument In Dostoevsky.Freedom Vs Bread Supported By Marxism The Institutional Church The Grand Inquisitor And The Church

1792 words - 7 pages

Throughout the ages man has given up freedom for the earthly and essential bread of life. Man is given freedom through grace but this does not fulfill their hunger and thus they will gladly give it up for bread. This is clearly evident in people's following of Marxism, Dostoevsky's Grand Inquisitor, and even the institutional church itself.Marxism began as a philosophy called dialectal materialism .This philosophy is based among other things on philosophical materialism which states that nature is all there is and all that is needed. There is no supernatural or higher being because nature provides us with all the answers. Through science we can understand how we came to be (Darwinism), and what we are made of (atom discovery). So people turned to this philosophy that denies God's very existence. Marxism says that religion is the "opiate of the masses" because it appeases them and makes them live with hunger and injustice, and thus keeps them from revolting. Trotsky also states this in Brailsford and Marxism, "Religious, as indeed any other, ideas being born out of the soil of the material conditions of life and above all the soil of class contradictions, only gradually clear themselves away and then live on by the force of conservatism longer than the needs that gave birth to them and disappear completely only after the effects of serious social shocks and crises." It offers excuses for their suffering such as it is the will of God, God is punishing you, make sacrifices for God, and the poor shall see the kingdom. Marx and Engels state in On Religion "Does not every minute of your practical life give the lie to your theory? Do you consider it wrong to appeal to the courts when you are cheated? But the apostle writes that that is wrong. Do you offer your right cheek when you are struck on the left, or do you not institute proceedings for assault? Yet the Gospel forbids that ...Are not most of your court proceedings and the majority of civil law concerned with property? But you have been told that your treasure is not of this world." The promise of eternal life is what most appeases people. It has no earthly explanation and no one but God and the devil can offer it to you. People can live with suffering and strife if they have the consolation of living gloriously in the kingdom with their deceased family and friends. When people cry out to god they cry out for justice against hunger and all that afflicts them. They create their Gods in their own image and make them powerful and strong. When this God has not answered the prayers of the poor they shall pledge alliance to an idea, government, or dictator who can offer them what God has denied them. When religion is destroyed people will revolt and all men will unite and be equal.In Dostoevsky's The Grand Inquisitor the argument that men will give up their freedom and reject God for earthly bread is presented. He states, "Make us your slaves but feed us." Jesus rejects the things that would have helped...

Find Another Essay On The 1st temptation of Jesus as used to defend the inquisitor's argument in Dostoevsky.Freedom vs bread supported by marxism the institutional church the grand inquisitor and the church

Security in The Grand Inquisitor Essay

1415 words - 6 pages being to worship and Christ averted from becoming one. It is very easy to lose faith in something that never reveals itself. As time has passed, we can see our faith in Christ has diminished. The rejection of the security that power brings, represented by the kingdoms. Christ should have grabbed that power to persuade men to give up their freedom in a trade for security. The Grand Inquisitor concludes that because of Christ’s rejection of the three

Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints

1404 words - 6 pages Jeffs died in 2002. Warren Jeffs was convicted for sex-crimes in 2011 and sentenced to life imprisonment and $10,000 fine (Jacobson, 2011). One defining characteristic of the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints is the practice of polygamy. The cult teaches that polygamy is ordained by God and it is necessary for any man to attain the highest level of salvation. The general belief in the cult is that a man must have a minimum

Paradise Lost’s Satan and The Grand Inquisitor's Evil

912 words - 4 pages Evil’s origin begins with Adam and Eve using their special gift, free will, to commit the first sin. They sinned because they were tempted from the free will to choose between following or disobeying God’s orders. Paradise Lost is an epic written by John Milton that describes the fallen angel Satan and the fall of man. The Grand Inquisitor by Fyodor Dostoevsky is about an archbishop who talks with Jesus and wants to burn him as a heretic

The Church as the People of God

1605 words - 7 pages “a movement of the Spirit in its structures.” Green himself claims that “In truth, the church is both a movement and a strutcture, and the charistmatic and the institutional are not inherently at odds.” This claim I am not as much in agreement with Green on. I do think that in our world we have tried to make the church an institution, and possbily succeeded in some sense, but I do not believe that an institution can also be a community. I do

The Church

1793 words - 7 pages other gods before me (KJV).” The Bible is very clear that there is only one God. However, As stated by Clowney, we must not become exclusive in the church but that we should be available and be prepared to meet the challenges of secularism (16). This does not by any mean state that we should accept and become a religious group who is willing to lay aside our doctrinal and theological principles for the betterment of society. As Clowney stated, we

A Discussion of The Grand Inquisitor from 'The Brothers Karamazov' by Fyodor Dostoevsky

686 words - 3 pages The Grand Inquisitor is an adaptation from The Brothers Karamazov, a novel written by Fyodor Dostoevsky. It is a Russian novel, set in 19th century Russia. The Inquisitor, the part of the story that we are dealing with, is a discussion between two of four brothers, Ivan and Alyosha.Alyosha is the youngest brother, of about twenty years of age. He is preparing to become a monk in the Eastern Orthodox Church. Ivan is older, about thirty years of

Medieval vs Renaissance: Corruption in the Church.

645 words - 3 pages Renaissance ideas of individualism in that the clergy thought that it was ok to use explore the attributes of the human mind. Individual power and accomplishment was enjoyed and seen as good. Members of the Catholic clergy were financially, politically and socially corrupt. The abuses of clerical power and privileges by the clergy spanned all parts of their daily lives. The daily lives of the Catholic clergy were filled with intemperance and overindulgence

Women in the Church

1839 words - 7 pages . This quiet almost light-like expression harkens to the dark and light imagery in Confessions. It also harkens back to role of the Virgin Mary, who stood quietly behind in the background and supported her son Jesus through all of his triumphs and tribulations. The role of women has changed several times since beginning of the Christian church. As the church grew is size and structure, women in the church grew is size, and then fell drastically

Leadership in the church

2002 words - 8 pages would get out that the gifts came from his church and those people might begin to come. Lastly, is family orientation. The Aspostle brings almost a community as a family idea. He is the Father and the church is his children. E. F. helps them through interrelational problems and is there for them in their times of need. He gives them a place where they can bring their lives openly and not have to fear rejection or judgement. The Way Church is a

The Church and Facebook

1758 words - 7 pages Facebook replacing the imperative physical relationships we need to fellowship with each other. It is a sad truth that we are so busy we cannot find time to carve out an hour in the week to go to church. Out of convenience, more people turn to Facebook as a place to spill their frustrations and praises to the status update question: “What’s on your mind?” If people are confessing and fellowshipping on Facebook, what is the job of the Church in the

The Church and Euthanasia

542 words - 2 pages case, a terminally ill person is asking the physician to assist them in ending their life. Oregon is the only state in the United States who allows this kind of euthanasia. This idea is contradictory to the principles of health care because physicians vow to heal, along with helping the patient feel comfortable and caring for the patient to their best ability.The Church considers these types of euthanasia to be wrong because they involve the

Similar Essays

More Merciful: The Grand Inquisitor Or Jesus?

1297 words - 5 pages holds their conscience and their bread in his hands?” (133). Lastly, he provides his subjects with universal unity and with a universal state, which he maintains and controls. By alleviating all three of man’s basic anguishes, the Grand Inquisitor is able to ensure that “everybody will be happy and will neither rebel nor destroy each other any more as they did under [Jesus’] freedom”(133).The Grand Inquisitor comprehends

Jesus And The Role Of Sin In The Catholic Church

753 words - 3 pages the Church." 1213:5) However, without Christ's sacrifice of his life and suffering on behalf of humanity the sacrament of baptism would not be possible.Baptism addresses the Original Sin of Adam and Eve in a way made possible only by the sacrifice of Jesus. As St. John baptized Jesus, so are all adherents of the Church. By Jesus' teaching, suffering, and dying the Church and its sacraments gain its power and original sin is obviated. "If water

The Church Of Jesus Christ Of Latter Day Saints.

1268 words - 5 pages : (1) The Book of Mormon, (2) Doctrine and Covenants, (3) Pearl of Great Price, and (4) the Bible as long as it is correctly translated, they consider the King James Version as there official bible. Book of Mormons is a collection of 15 books, supposedly covering the history of an ancient people in America from 2200 BC to 421 AD. Joseph Smith (Founder of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints) claims its location was revealed to him on

Explain How The Story Of Jesus' Baptism In Saint Mark's Gospel, Helps Christians To Understand Why Baptism Is Important In The Church Today. Use Infant And Believer's Baptism

1248 words - 5 pages As a sacrament, Baptism is practised throughout all Catholic Churches today. Jesus' Baptism, remains the blueprint for all of today's Baptisms. The features and patterns of events used by John the Baptist and Jesus over 2000 years ago are still central to our modern Church's Service. Many features of Believer's and Infant's Baptism, that are used today are similar to how Jesus, would have experienced his own baptism. Throughout the course of