The Flag Burning Debate Continues Essay

1212 words - 5 pages

The Flag-burning Debate Continues

 
   Nazis captured Jim Rogers. He was routinely beaten and given barely enough food to survive. During the time he spent in a World War II prisoner of war camp, he managed to keep his sanity by scraping together bits and pieces of colored cloth in order to make an American flag. As his fellow prisoners began to die, it was his American flag which provided him with a sense of identity and gave him the inspiration to keep living.

 

It is no wonder, then, that Jim becomes disturbed when he turns on the news and sees our flag being burned in the streets of foreign nations. What disturbs him even more is when he sees the American flag being burned by Americans in America. In 1989, the Supreme Court overturned, in a 5-4 decision, a guilty verdict against a Texas flag-burner, claiming that burning the American flag is a form of free speech which is constitutionally protected. Yet the fact that flag-burning is legal does not ease Jim's angst, and apparently his feelings are shared by many of his fellow Americans. The majority of Americans are in favor of adopting a constitutional amendment that would make flag-burning illegal (Johnson 16).

 

After multiple attempts, a flag-burning amendment was finally approved by the House of Representatives in 1995, but it fell 3 votes short of approval in the Senate (Buckly 75). Still, lobbyists continue to push for anti-flag-burning legislation. One may wonder why, if the majority of Americans want the flag protected, does Congress and the Supreme Court continue to resist the idea of a flag amendment.

 

The easiest argument to make against protecting the flag is that burning it is a form of free speech which is protected by the First Amendment of the Constitution. But a question arises as to whether or not burning a flag is really "speech." The First Amendment states that "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a

redress of grievances" (Phillips 162).

 

After reading the First Amendment, it is difficult to see how the act of speaking can be equated with using a cigarette lighter to set a flag on fire. When demonstrators are burning the flag, they are said to be expressing their disapproval toward the government.

 

But as the observant reader may have noticed, no where in the First Amendment do we find any mention of "expression." Whatever a demonstrator says while burning the flag is speech, but the actual act of burning the flag is expression and, as we have seen, is not necessarily constitutionally protected.

 

A less common First Amendment defense of the burning the flag is that flag-burning falls under the right of citizens "peaceably to assemble." Although seeing an American flag set on fire would be a source of...

Find Another Essay On The Flag-burning Debate Continues

The Flood Stories: The Validity Debate Continues

2325 words - 9 pages Paul AberionEnglish 303 West Lit BackgroundsProfessor Beth Haddrell10/ 20/ 03'Revision PaperThe Flood Stories: The Validity Debate ContinuesIn the Epic of Gilgamesh, it articulates how, "For six days and six nights the winds blew, torrent and tempest and flood overwhelmed the world, tempest and flood raged together like warring hosts" (Sandars 111). Alternatively, in the Old Testament, it simply states, "All the fountains of the great deep [were

How issues such as immigration, abortion, specifically the Supreme Court decision of Roe v. Wade, and flag burning have divided American society and how decisions or comprimises have been reached

682 words - 3 pages burning of our flag has caused many controversies. Some citizens believe thatburning the US flag should be banned no matter what the reason is. Others believe wehave the right to burn the flag if we want to. Gregory Lee Johnson set fire to the US flag and was arrested. He was convicted under a Texas law that classified the flag as a "venerated object that permits criminal prosecution of those who desecrate it." He was sentenced a year in jail and

Respect our Flag and Respect our Freedom

1325 words - 6 pages , and Canada allow flag burning. In Denmark, burning of the national flag is permitted; however, burning of any other nation’s flag is forbidden (“Debate”). In France; however, as of 2010, it has become illegal to burn the national flag; some citizens have already been fined. Germany and Hong Kong enforce more severe punishments that can include imprisonment up to several years for the burning or desecration of their national flags (“Debate”). It

What Is Flag Burning?

1131 words - 5 pages American flag. Now about some flag burning laws all around the world. In Australia it is perfectly legal to burn a flag. Theres even a group in australia that sells flag burning kits (Flag burning debate)! Now lets mosey on to the complete other side of the spectrum. In Germany flag burning is highly illegal. It is punishable up to one years in prison. Hong Kong shares laws related to Germany’s because they believe that theres no need to burn a flag

Free Speech or Flag Protection? There Can’t Be Both

1695 words - 7 pages The first and only time I had ever heard of someone burning the flag when I came across an article on Regory Lee Johnson. In 1984, he showed up at the Republican National Convention in Dallas, Texas and burned an American flag in order to show his knowledge of the policies of Reagan administration. At the time, he was convicted of flag desecration, but the Supreme Court overturned that decision by ruling that burning a flag was “expressive

Ethnography of the American Flag

1003 words - 5 pages the flag, representing the removal of their colony. The helper then places their stripe into an incinerator. This continues until all the pieces are in the incinerator and the fire is lit. While the participants of the ceremony watch the flag burn the ceremony leader says “Nothing is really ended until it is forgotten. Our Flag, the symbol of freedom for over 216, 000,000 citizens of our great land, and the banner under which countless millions

Flag and Anthem Etiquitte

1734 words - 7 pages to hold on tightly as he hoists the flag. With each upward motion, the flag begins to tug from my hands. When I am sure the flag will not touch the ground, I snap to attention and render a salute. The sweat continues to pour into my eyes, making each blink a challenge. My partner joins me in saluting. Mission accomplished. We drop our salute and about-face. As we march back in perfect unison, I am proud. When I hold the Stars and the Stripes, I

Texas v. Johnson argumentative

816 words - 4 pages Texas v. Johnson Argumentative To this day, Americans have many rights and privileges. Rights stated in the United States constitution may be simple and to the point, but the rights Americans have may cause debate to whether or not something that happens in society, is completely reasonable. The Texas v. Johnson case created much debate due to a burning of the American Flag. One may say the burning of the flag was tolerable because of the

Flag desecration

773 words - 3 pages icon of our country? The issue of flag burning asks America just that question: Should America tolerate or condemn it? Flag burning does seem to be the ultimate act of symbolic protest used to express dissension against the American Government. There is simply no questioning the fact that flag burning offends people, but the controversy of flag burning tests the dominion of the First Amendment to the Constitution. The First Amendment states

Flag Desecration

6511 words - 26 pages Flag Desecration The issue of flag desecration has been and continues to be a highly controversial issue; on the one side there are those who believe that the flag is a unique symbol for our nation which should be preserved at all costs, while on the other are those who believe that flag burning is a form of free speech and that any legislation designed to prevent this form of expression is contrary to the ideals of the First Amendment to our

Confederate Flag, should it stay or go? - American Government - Essay

613 words - 3 pages Few symbols are more hated and loved than the Confederate flag. Its meaning has shifted over the past 150 years and continues to change. Walk around campus and you can see the occasional Confederate flag on the pocket of a shirt or hanging in a dorm room. The question is what do all these flags represent: Southern heritage, outright racism, or just rebellion against authority? The original flag of the Confederacy was not what we know as the

Similar Essays

Burning The American Flag Essay

696 words - 3 pages Burning the American Flag The American flag consists of thirteen horizontal stripes, with seven red stripes alternating among six white. In the upper left corner there is a rectangular blue space that contains fifty white stars. The thirteen stripes symbolize the thirteen original colonies of the United states of America and the stars represent the fifty states of the Union. White is said to symbolize purity and innocence. Red symbolizes

The Canadian Flag Debate Essay

1318 words - 5 pages Canada had been an outstanding country for many years but has always lacked one important thing. Until the year 1965, Canada did not have their own official flag. The Canadian flag debate was a major controversy to Canada because many thought it was about time for Canada to have their own flag years after gaining their independence from Britain. The Canadian flag debate had a very interesting background and the Canadians involvement towards the

The Act Of Burning The American Flag

1097 words - 4 pages I am an American soldier going on ten years of services in the United States Army.I'm currently a Drill instructor for basic combat training at Ft. Knox Kentucky. I HaveServed in Bosnia, Kosovo and Iraq and have seen what makes this nation the greatest inthe World. From the horrors of War, to your battle buddies showing strength andkindness during difficult times. Flag burning can be and usually is a very controversialissue with people. Many

Flag Burning And The First Amendment

2165 words - 9 pages interests. A particular group of students from the Model United Nations/Junior Statesmen Club (MUN/JS) decided to celebrate American freedoms with a mural depicting a burning flag along with textual references to civi liberties. However, principal Paula Duncan refused to authorize the mural, stating that it could "easily be perceived as an endorsement of flag burning." In February of 1993, the school board supported Duncan's decision by voting 6