This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Flaw Of Utilitarianism Essay

837 words - 3 pages

Philosophers Bentham and James Mill developed an ethical theory, utilitarianism, proposing that all action should be directed toward achieving the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people. Utilitarians further argue that achieving the greatest happiness overall is not only the right thing to do for society but also moral. Although this theory is applicable in many situations, when one takes a closer look it is clear to see that utilitarianism is immoral.To argue that utilitarianism is immoral it is first necessary to define morality. The dictionary's definition of morality is "The quality of being in accord with standards of right or good conduct" (American Heritage). Utilitarianism would indicate that "in being in accord with the standards of right or good conduct" is choosing that action which achieves overall happiness. Utilitarians further rationalize the following:To be moral is, by definition, to be concerned with promoting the well-being of others, not just oneself. Well-being is determined by happiness (however happiness is construed in detail). So to be moral is to be concerned with promoting the happiness of others, not just oneself. But morality requires also that one not favor any particular person. To do so would be unfair. We may put this by saying that morality requires impartiality. So to be moral requires that one be impartial in being concerned with promoting each person's happiness equally. This is, then, to be concerned with maximizing overall happiness. (Ethical Theory, 3 and 4)This rationalization corresponds well with the belief of utilitarianism, however if this rationalization is truly moral, then every utilitarian decision should be moral.When analyzing certain situations it is clear to see that achieving overall happiness can actually be immoral. One hypothetical case that contradicts morality in utilitarianism is a situation involving a professor who gets tortured to bring happiness to his students. Assume that a professor is extremely disliked by his class of thirty students because he is a harsh grader. After all the students receive poor midterm grades, they finally get fed up with the professor and decide to torture him. From a utilitarian's point of view, the students will analyze this situation through certain steps before making a decision. First they determine what actions are open to them, in this case, whether or not to torture the professor. Second they determine who will be affected by these actions; the professor and the students will be affected. Then they calculate the consequences of each action for the happiness of each person affected, once again, in this instance the students will be happy and the...

Find Another Essay On The Flaw of Utilitarianism

The Flaws of Act-Utilitarianism Essay

1775 words - 7 pages In this paper I will argue that John Stuart Mill, the presenter of the most compelling theory of act-utilitarianism (AU), ultimately falls short in addressing the moral complexities which factor into man’s virtues and its effect on his motives for certain actions. John Stuart Mill’s core arguments follow and contrast many theories established by Jeremy Bentham. Combining the idea of consequentialism, that consequences of actions are the

explain the main forms of utilitarianism

989 words - 4 pages Carys Jones 26th March 2014EXPLAIN THE MAIN PRINCIPLES OF CLASSICAL FORMS OF UTILITARIANISMUtilitarianism is the idea that the greatest good for the greatest number, so the action that causes the most number of people, pleasure or happiness. It is a teleological theory of ethics, as it is more concerned with the outcome rather than the act. It is also relative and subjective. Utilitarianism is a consequentialist theory as it decides whether an

Tragic Flaw of the Riddle Solver: Oedipus Rex(by Sophocles)

897 words - 4 pages Aristotle defined Oedipus Rex, written by Sophocles as the perfect tragedy. One of the elements in his definition of tragedy included tragic flaw (hamartia), and he said a tragic hero's downfall should be due to his/her tragic flaw. King Oedipus falls from a high status from being a powerful noble king in to a low status by blinding himself and committing a moral sin of killing his father, marrying his mother, and producing an offspring with

Othello's Flaw in Shakespeare's The Tragedy of Othello

808 words - 3 pages Othello's Flaw in Shakespeare's The Tragedy of Othello In Shakespeare?s play Othello, Othello himself is the tragic hero. He is an individual of high stature who is destroyed by his surroundings, his own actions, and his fate. His destruction is essentially precipitated by his own actions, as well as by the actions of the characters surrounding him. The tragedy of Othello is not a fault of a single person, but is rather the consequence of a

Describe The Main Strengths And Weaknesses Of Utilitarianism

1040 words - 5 pages Utilitarianism was Originally formulated by Jeremy Bentham in the 18th century, and fully developed by John Stewart Mill in the 19th. It Asserts that we should always act so as to produce the greatest ratio of good to evil for everyone concerned with our decision and As with all moral theories, has many strengths and weaknesses.The prominant criticism of Utilitarianism is that it is extremely hard to predict the results of an action. The

Can Utilitarianism meet the objections of its critics?

1848 words - 7 pages "Man does not strive after happiness;only the Englishman does."F. Nietzsche, "The Twilight of the Idols".Since its foundation by J. Bentham in the late 18th century and its further development by J.S. Mill, H. Sidgwick and several other philosophers, utilitarianism has been one of the most controversial moral theories.The theory's underlying idea is, that only such acts are right which produce and maximise happiness as their outcome, in other

The Idea of Utilitarianism According to Jeremy Bentham

965 words - 4 pages Utilitarianism is a moral calculus – dependent upon a cost-benefit analysis – whose function is to maximize utility, which determines right from wrong. Jeremy Bentham, who argued, that the highest principle of morality is to maximize happiness, founded the doctrine; hence, according to him, the right thing to do is anything that maximizes utility. Moreover, Bentham contended against the opponents of the principle of utility that every moral

THE TRAGIC FLAW OF OEDIPUS The tragic flaw of Oedipus that caused him suffering all his life. This is about the book Oedipus Rex by Sophocles

916 words - 4 pages , Oedipus, as a good- natured person who has bad judgment and is frail. Oedipus makes fatal decisions and is condemned to profound suffering because of them. Agreeing with Aristotle that Oedipus' misfortune happens because of his tragic flaw. If he hadn't been so judgmental or narcissistic, as Miller would characterize a personality like Oedipus, he would never have killed King Laius and called Teiresias a liar. In the beginning, Teiresias is

The Tragic Flaw Of Shakespeare's "King Lear" Includes excerpts from the dialogue

3789 words - 15 pages depicts the troubled parts in his life and eventually his death that is caused by the suffering and calamity. There is the feeling of fear in the play as well, that makes men see how blind they are not knowing when fortune or something else would be on them. The hero must be of a high status on the chain and the hero also possesses a tragic flaw that initiates the tragedy. The fall of the hero is not felt by him alone but creates a chain reaction

The Flaw of Civilization

768 words - 4 pages Until the twentieth-century, the world was unfamiliar with the newly-named phenomenon known as genocide. The first instance of the mass killing of an ethnic group that proliferated throughout world news was the Holocaust. Under the Nazi Regime, the German government indiscriminately massacred millions of Jewish men, women and children. However, the Holocaust was by no means the first occurrence of a genocide. Historical evidence reveals a

The Differences in John Stuart Mills and Jeremy Bentham's Versions of Utilitarianism

2653 words - 11 pages The Differences in John Stuart Mills and Jeremy Bentham's Versions of Utilitarianism In what ways did John Stuart Mill's version of utilitarianism differ from that of Jeremy Bentham? Which do you consider preferable? The Cambridge International Dictionary of English defines utilitarianism as "the system of thought which states that the best action or decision in a particular situation is the one which most benefits the most people

Similar Essays

The Flaw Of Hamlet Essay

759 words - 3 pages The Flaw of Hamlet      Many Shakespearean scholars, including A.C. Bradley, believe that the character Hamlet is an over analytical person, always "unmaking his world and rebuilding it in thought" (A.C. Bradley). It is argued by many that Hamlet's tragic flaw is his inability to accept things the way they are presented, thus criticizing everything in the world around him. Hamlet delves deep into what he believes is the reality of

The Effect Of Utilitarianism Essay

1412 words - 6 pages who experienced near-death, or people who attained freedom after long periods of hardship and torture. These people would definitely view their lives, and those who went through the same experiences, in a different light. If we were to analyze Utilitarianism closely, we would realize that they do not put any values on human life. In the Utilitarian point of view, every human life is worth the same. No matter what the status of the entity. Even if

The Tragic Flaw Of Hamlet Essay

1069 words - 4 pages The Tragic Flaw of Hamlet One of the greatest works in literature, Shakespeare's Hamlet has been the topic of controversial discussion ever since it was written. The controversies range from "Is Hamlet truly mad, to Is Hamlet really in love with Ophelia." The most intriguing topic of discussion though, is Hamlet's fatal flaw. As in all Shakespearean works, there is always a tragic hero. This hero is always the person that the audience

Explain The Forms Of Utilitarianism Essay

726 words - 3 pages decision procedure.Some Weaknesses of Utilitarianism.It allows us to do evil so that good might come. For example, in a time of crisis, innocent people may be imprisoned or executed if it calms down the population (if say they are believed to be responsible for terrorist acts). The British police were guilty of this during the Northern Irish troubles.The no-rest objection: act utilitarianism, if followed to the letter, could prevent us from doing