This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Flawed Electoral College Voting Process

1201 words - 5 pages

The Flawed Electoral College Voting Process

When Americans vote their choice for President, one would assume that these votes would be tabulated and the majority vote would win. But this is not the case at all. The Presidency is ultimately decided by the Electoral College, what William McClenaghan calls “one of the least understood parts of the American political process”(340). McClenaghan also defines the Electoral College as “the body that makes the formal selection of the nation’s President, from what the Framers intended into a `rubber stamp’ for the popular vote in presidential elections”(67). The original Electoral College did not succeed for very long, however; it only worked for as long as George Washington was President (328). In the election of 1796 a Federalist and a Democratic-Republican were paired as President and Vice-President. This happened because these two men received more electoral votes than their expected running mates. This is where the trouble started, but it has not nearly ended. There have been some cases where the popular vote of America was contradicted by the electoral vote winner. Every person in America is equal and should have the same authority in their voting. The Electoral College should be abolished not only due to its obvious flaws, but because all Americans should have the equal right to vote. No one governmental entity should have the right to decide the American people’s choice.

One serious flaw in the Electoral College system is that the popular vote winner does not always win Presidency. This is a result of two factors. “In each State the winning candidate customarily receives all that State’s electoral votes”(343). For example, in 1992 Bill Clinton received barely 50% to win New York’s popular vote and therefore won all of it’s electoral votes (343). What about the opposing 50% of the population? The other factor is how electoral votes are distributed. “...each State has two electors because of its Senate seats, regardless of its population. Because of them, the distribution of electoral votes does not match the facts of population and voter distribution”(343). “The current system unfairly favors states with smaller populations allocating electoral votes according to a state’s representation in Congress”(Early History of the Electoral College, l). “The disproportionate electoral strength of the less-populous states enables a candidate, to win the presidency without winning the popular vote”(Critics Claim Democracy Tarnished, 1). The smaller states have more electoral votes per person than larger states; therefore more votes in larger states don’t count. Neil Pierce, author of The Electoral College Primer 2000 says, “Every other office in the United States is elected on the basis of the person who gets the most votes, ...But the electoral college, for reasons no one can ever explain to you logically, values some votes over other votes”. The popular vote winner has lost in election races in...

Find Another Essay On The Flawed Electoral College Voting Process

The Electoral College Essay

946 words - 4 pages The Electoral CollegeThe Electoral College process is part of the original design of the U.S. constitution. The Electoral College was devised by theFounding Fathers to elect the president and vice president. In this essay I will asses whether the system is democratic. I shall dothis by discussing its strengths, weaknesses and attempts to reform it.The Electoral College system has been criticised many times since its establishment. It is seen to

The Electoral College Essay

834 words - 3 pages Over the years, many conflicts have arisen about the process in which our president is elected. The election of 2000 opened up the public's eyes to the election process and how the Electoral College works. This also brought out the flaws that the Electoral College possesses. This has led to many debates about improving or totally changing the presidential election process.The Electoral College distributes votes according to the number of

Abolishing the Electoral College

748 words - 3 pages The Electoral College today is a very complex system of voting and campaigning. When it was first created, the Framers thought the average citizen of their day was not intelligent enough to know who should be leading their country. So they created the Electoral College which was run by people who knew what they were doing. The Electoral College is a body of people who represent each state and they determine the president. The real question is

The Electoral College

2395 words - 10 pages States are indirect popular elections. Even though voters cast their ballots for the presidential candidate, they are really voting for a group of electors who pledge to vote for a particular candidate. (Project Vote Smart) This group known as the Electoral College is made up of 538 citizens who are responsible for voting on behalf of their states and it is this group that actually chooses the president. The number of electoral votes is based on

The Electoral College - 1010 words

1010 words - 4 pages Every four years, on the Tuesday following the first Monday of November, millions of U.S. citizens go to local voting booths to elect, among other officials, the next president and vice president of the United States of America (The National Archives and Records Administration 1996). Their votes will be recorded and counted, and winners will be declared. However, the results of the popular vote are not guaranteed to stand because the Electoral

The Electoral College - 2474 words

2474 words - 10 pages disagreements the delegates finally reached a decision. Consequently, they created a complex "filtering" process known as the Electoral College. This way both the people and congress could elect the president, or at least that was what was intended. The structure of the Electoral College was similar to that of the Centurial Assembly system of the Roman Republic. "Under that

The Electoral College System

1413 words - 6 pages based on percentage and multi-member district. Electoral College consists of 538 electors. To become a president 270 or more votes are required. However, if none of the candidate gets 270 votes, then the House of Representatives would select the president. I argue against Electoral College system. First of all, people are not voting directly for the President or the Vice President. A pure form of democracy is in which people exercise direct power

The Electoral College - 1191 words

1191 words - 5 pages Mackenzie Marquess Professor Beange Govt 2305 23 October 2013 Electoral College Outline The Electoral College is a system that elects the president, it is possible for a presidential candidate to win the popular votes of the citizens and still lose the election because of the electoral college, a prime example of this rare happening is the election of 2000 where George Bush lost the popular vote to Al Gore but still won the votes of the

Elimintating the Electoral College

1661 words - 7 pages ; establish a new voting system under which each party nominates a single Presidential candidate; and in the event of no candidate winning a majority of the popular vote, a runoff would take place in a separate election, between the two candidates who received the most votes in the first, general, election. The reason that these changes should be made is because of all of the tribulations with the present formation. The Electoral College is

The Electoral College - 513 words

513 words - 2 pages whichever president wins the most popular votes, wins all the Electors of that state. There are however two exceptions to this rule. In Maine and Nebraska the two Electors are chosen by statewide popular vote and the remainder by the popular vote within each Congressional district.The Electoral College is a way in which the states get a voice in the election for president. States are represented by the total number of representatives in the

The Electoral College - 2080 words

2080 words - 8 pages believe that the only way to change the voting system is to pass an amendment to the constitution. There are 39 generally smaller states in the US. These states hold a majority in the senate, and also hold a majority in the ratifying of the constitution. The electoral college gives the proportional advantage to the smaller states. Thus it would be near impossible to pass an amendment to take away power from the smaller states and give that power

Similar Essays

The Flawed Electoral College System Essay

1041 words - 4 pages implement change. Voting by popularity would eliminate the current bias that is in favor of the Republicans. Another criticism of the Electoral College is it’s winner take all character. Florida gets 25 electoral votes and had they split 13 to George Bush and 12 to Al Gore, then Al Gore would have become president instead of George Bush. The constitution has nothing in it that mandates winner take all. State law regulates the choosing of

The Electoral College: An Outdated And Flawed System

1376 words - 6 pages of functioning with this outdated and flawed system; however, it would function more efficiently if the system was replaced with a system that allowed the president to be elected by a direct popular vote. The only way to accomplish this completely would be to pass an Amendment. The Electoral College is the current system for electing the next president and the process is as follows: a direct popular vote is conducted in each state – each of

The Electoral College: Rationale And Process

2331 words - 9 pages president and no one receives a majority of electoral votes then the decision would be in the hands of the faceless party favorites customarily nominated to the electoral college." Another charge is that the present system produces inequalities in popular voting power. It is believed the minority voters in each state are denied their political right to expand meaningful alliances across state lines. Their contention is that the minority votes are

Electoral College What Is It, Different Types, Process, Examples (2000 Election)

1672 words - 7 pages the basic idea of Electoral College, the whole process of electing delegates involves many different methods. Well first Presidential candidates will start campaigning, to get their name out to the people. Next comes the presidential primaries and caucuses. The primary elections are run by state and local governments, while caucuses are private events run by the political parties. A state primary election usually is an indirect election: instead of