The Flaws And Shortcomings Of African Historiography

5019 words - 20 pages

The Flaws and Shortcomings of African Historiography

History is formed through a combination of personal experiences, psychological state, personal objectives, relation with the interviewer, position in society and many other factors that cannot be scientifically monitored and accounted for. Thus, no historian has been able to filter through the many layers they need to in order to arrive at an accurate account of history. What “personal narratives” and “life histories” provide are numerous examples of the complexities and ambiguities that accompany any reconstruction of African history. Each account of history does not offer a different perspective from which one may view a particular event or time, simply because no two accounts have the same concept of location or time. Western and African romanticism has lead many historians to create and adapt scientific methodologies in order to penetrate the combination of personal objectives, interview limitations, and psychological intricacies that were present in each life history.

Whether it is a matter of age, race, psychological state, or personal (or group) objective, the subjects oftentimes function in differing paradigms, which leads to significant inconsistencies between the transmittance and recording of any particular history. Texts such as Belinda Bozzoli’s, Women of Phokeng, Marjorie Mbilinyi’s article entitled “I’d Have Been a Man,” and several articles in White, Cohen and Miescher’s, African Words, African Voices, to put forth the claim that the information historians collect from “life histories” cannot be generalized in any way to correctly represent a society or group of people.

Each author claims to recognize his/her biases and shortcomings, then goes on to say, despite these, I have something with more truth to share with you. It’s as if they put disclaimers, then say, if you ignore that they are poor and are only giving interviews believing they will gain something from them; if you ignore that they are human and have biases and prejudices stemming from experiences and events we (historians) have no knowledge of; if you ignore that if we let each person speak about what they thought of history and did not direct them in any way, we (historians) would rarely get people concentrating on similar events, and when they did, there would be significant inconstancies in the accounts; if we ignore all this, what is being is significant only as far as no one is more important than another man (which is purely idealistic) and getting different perspectives is interesting. But that is all it is, interesting! With enough disclaimers and ‘considering’ any claim, theory, or historical account becomes valid history.

Relationships Between Interviewer and Subject:

As recognition and acceptance of the subjects’ ability to hold back and alter information increased, so did historians’ emphasis on the quality of the relationship between interviewer and interviewee. For example, Bozzoli...

Find Another Essay On The Flaws and Shortcomings of African Historiography

A Historiography of the Reconstruction Era

4644 words - 19 pages Elliott FarringtonHistory 633.01Apr. 21, 2013Reconstruction: The Historiography of a Pivotal Era in American SocietyIt has often been stated that it is the duty of all historians to place facts about the past into an objective, cohesive chronological narrative that will help guide others to solve the problems of the present and future. It is important for the historian to have the ability to sort out the distorted facts from ones that are

A Historiography of the Reconstruction Era

4644 words - 19 pages Elliott FarringtonHistory 633.01Apr. 21, 2013Reconstruction: The Historiography of a Pivotal Era in American SocietyIt has often been stated that it is the duty of all historians to place facts about the past into an objective, cohesive chronological narrative that will help guide others to solve the problems of the present and future. It is important for the historian to have the ability to sort out the distorted facts from ones that are

The Shortcomings of the Articles of Confederation

1112 words - 4 pages executive power, the Articles of Confederation proved ineffective in the successful governing of the United States. By the lack of assistance in solving post-war financial issues, the inability to maintain law and order in events of opposition, along with the disorganization of diplomatic relations exposed the shortcomings and the inadequate nature of the Articles of Confederation. America’s vulnerability can be attributed to the post-wartime

The Great Gatsby & The Shortcomings Of Society

887 words - 4 pages Fitzgerald used Jay Gatsby in The Great Gatsby in the same way that Lorraine Hansberry used Walter Lee in ?A Raisin In The Sun? to reflect the shortcomings of society as a result of the American dream.Both Walter?s and Gatsby?s optimism of life influences their visions of the American dream. A perfect example of this is given by Gatsby's constant efforts to regain Daisy's affection. His infatuation with Daisy distracted him from the more

Shortcomings of the Articles of Confederation

820 words - 3 pages American Government and its territorial sovereignty, but without the ability to oppose the trespassers America's northwest was at their mercy. Additionally now stripped of the protection of the British Navy, American shippers were subject to the threat of piracy, notably the buccaneer nations of the Barbary Coast (Pageant). These North African nations were subdued only by tribute or force and with America not able to offer either their merchants

The International Monetary Fund's Advantages and Shortcomings

2226 words - 9 pages The International Monetary Fund (IMF) is an organization of international that was started in 1944 at the Bretton Woods Conference and it officially was created by 29 members of countries on December 27, 1945. A fixed exchange rate system set up in Bretton Woods Agreement in which each country the IMF par value for the currency based on gold and the U.S. dollar. By reason of the dollar was fixed at $ 35 per ounce of gold, is also the same par

Employment, Relief and the Breadwinner Ideal: A Historiography of the Great Depression in Canada

1797 words - 7 pages Hollingsworth and Tyyska discuss the employment of women in their article, both wage work and work performed outside of the “paid labour force.” (14). They also look at work discrimination of women based on gender and marital status. They argue that disapproval of married women working for wages during the Depression was expressed not only by those in position of power, such as politicians, but also by the general public and labour unions

Bentham’s Principle of Utility and its Shortcomings as the Sole Basis for Morality

2018 words - 8 pages Jeremy Bentham in his book, An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, is trying to create an ethical system that he believes ought to be the basis for all decision making. He states that “As to ethics in general, a man’s happiness will depend, in the first place, upon such parts of his behavior as none but himself are interested in ; in the next place, upon such parts of it as may affect the happiness of those about him

Flaws of the Death Penalty

973 words - 4 pages Flaws of the Death Penalty Capital Punishment has been part of the criminal justice system since as far back as 1700 B.C. However, in recent times opponents have shown the death penalty to be racist, barbaric, and in violation with the United States Constitution as "...cruel and unusual punishment." In this country, although laws governing the application of the death penalty have undergone many changes since biblical times, the punishment

The Flaws of Act-Utilitarianism

1775 words - 7 pages others. Bentham’s quantitative approach would put too much pressure upon the decision making of an individual and deprive him of the liberty to pursue personal interests of happiness allowed by Mill. However, in both having AU philosophies, both theories show many flaws. Although Mill’s theory would hypothetically hold stronger than Bentham’s, the glaring holes in Mill’s argument leads to my conclusion that his theories on morality hold false

The Flaws of Prison Labor

953 words - 4 pages The Flaws of Prison Labor The debate over prison labor has existed as long as the concept it’s self. Opponents claim that it exploits prisoners, takes away jobs from the general population, and puts people in danger by allowing convicts access to their personal information. While supporters of prison labor argue that it helps the economy as well as benefits prisoners. On this issue I stand on the side of the supporters. By having

Similar Essays

The Historiography Of Race And Discrimination In Baseball And Sports

3903 words - 16 pages The Historiography of Race and Discrimination in Baseball and Sports Historical and sociological research has shown, through much evidence collection and analysis of primary documents that the American sporting industry can give an accurate reflection, to a certain extent, of racial struggles and discrimination into the larger context of American society. To understand this stance, a deep look into aspects of sport beyond simply playing the

Man Bites Man: On The Goodness And Shortcomings Of Anthropos.

1300 words - 5 pages Man Bites Man: On the Goodness and Shortcomings of AnthroposThe question of whether humanity itself is evil or not is one of the most fundamentalaspects to any cultural world view, and at best a very divisive one. The two majorrepresentatives of this conflict within Christianity and in recent Western culture as a wholewere Pelagius and Augustine. The former of these two thinkers advocated a world-viewfeaturing man as capable of manufacturing for

The Shortcomings Of Standardized Testing Essay

1916 words - 8 pages Since the U.S. Congress passed the No Child Left Behind program, standardized testing has become the norm for American schools. Under this system, each child attending a school is required to take a standardized test at specific grade points to assess their level of comprehension. Parents, scholars and all stakeholders involved take part in constant discussions over its effectiveness in evaluating students’ comprehension, teachers’ competency

The Flaws Of Hamlet Essay

705 words - 3 pages The Flaws of Hamlet     Many human beings experience intense emotions that dramatically affect the outcome of their lives. Although sometimes melancholic and rash when necessary, Hamlet's hubris is his indecisiveness. Throughout this play, Hamlet's melancholy fuels his indecision, from his first interview with Gertrude and his new father. Hamlet's rash attitude is portrayed when he talks with the Ghost on the parapet, and