This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

“The Flowers” And “The Red Convertible”: Compare And Contrast Essay

1873 words - 7 pages

Death is a unique part of life, and loss is an unavoidable result of death. In Alice Walker’s 1973 short story “The Flowers”, childhood loss of innocence and death are illuminated through the experience of a child and her encounter with a dead man in post-slavery America. Louise Erdrich’s 1984 short story “The Red Convertible” is a story of loss in the face of death, set in Vietnam era America. Walker and Erdrich both use strong imagery and symbolism to effectively portray the impact of the common themes of loss and death in both short stories, albeit in different ways.
It is important to note the progression of the plots of both stories, and how imagery and symbolism play an integral role in the development of death and loss as themes. In “The Flowers”, Walker writes a short, nine paragraph account of Myop, a ten year old black girl whose day begins carefree and full of life. In the very first paragraph, Walker sets a tone of wonder and happiness, stating that each day is “a golden surprise” and “the days had never been as beautiful as these” (Walker 20). As Myop sets out on her adventure across the familiar terrain behind her home collecting the flowers alluded to within the title of the story, the imagery begins to shift in subtle ways that foreshadow a looming event. Walker writes,
She had often been as far before, but the strangeness of the land made it not as pleasant as her usual haunts. It seemed gloomy in the little cove in which she found herself. The air was damp, the silence close and deep (Walker 21).

In these three short sentences, Walker completely transforms the story. The powerful and persuasive phrasing launches the story forward into the unfortunate conclusion wherein Myop steps on the face of the decomposing corpse of a man who appears to have been lynched. This foreboding scene is especially surreal in its description. Walker shifts from the delightful imagery used earlier in the text into macabre and straightforward details. “His head lay beside him”, she writes, further stating “he'd had large white teeth, all of them cracked or broken” (Walker 21). The impact on Myop of this situation is palpable because of Walker’s effective use of imagery. Although Walker never outright answers how the man’s teeth were broken or why a rotting noose is found lying next to the body, it is clear what the circumstances of death must have been. The explanation of what has happened to this man lies within what is not explained at all. In other words, the imagery provided is explanation enough. In the end, however, Walker does not digress in her usage of symbolism or imagery. She reserves the most significant symbol of the story for the final two sentences by writing about Myop’s response to her traumatic encounter with death that “Myop laid down her flowers. And the summer was over” which further drives the plot to conclusion (Walker, 21).
Erdrich aligns the plot in “The Red Convertible” into a chronological progression of events...

Find Another Essay On “The Flowers” and “The Red Convertible”: Compare and Contrast Essay

The Red Convertible Essay

1175 words - 5 pages The Red Convertible Vanished Brotherhood In the short story “The Red Convertible” you will find some important elements that are integral to the support and development of the theme brotherhood. First, you will see how the road trip gives a lesson in the story. Second, you will discover how the war affected the relationship of Lyman and Henry. Finally, you will understand the symbolism of the red convertible and the link it has between

Compare and Contrast Essay: “The Last Unicorn” and “The Hobbit”

954 words - 4 pages life on the line throughout the novel. He also goes to talk to Smaug, even with the fact in mind that Smaug is a dragon. As for the Unicorn, her journey is not as physical as Bilbo’s, but still very dangerous in its own right. The Unicorn has to escape Mommy Fortuna’s Carnival and lives under the constant threat of being captured by a human. When she faces the Red Bull, and King Haggard, she is afraid she will end up like the other unicorns and

Louise Erdrich's The Red Convertible

1283 words - 6 pages The book of the red convertible begins in the native America where two brothers staying with each other. There is the family consisting of Lyman Martine and the other brothers such as Henry. There is a very strong relationship in the family such that the family is bind together before the occurrence of the Vietnam War experience in the war. The story began on a very humble start when the insurance company pays Lyman for the claim against the

Literary Analysis: "The Red Convertible"

1906 words - 8 pages portrayal of events. However it can also be an expression of perceptive truth, events are experienced much they would be in real life – confusing and disjointed. To look into these narrative elements of text, I will use examples from “The Red Convertible” by Lois Erdrich to demonstrate how Lyman’s narration style is representative of psychoanalytic concepts, showing how he deals with the situations presented in his life. Oftentimes the lens

Compare and Contrast Essay

977 words - 4 pages To truly compare or justify anything to be superior to something else, you must have more than one thing to compare. When I start to review narrative and descriptive essays, I have to try to understand what separates the two. I chose to compare “Caged Bird”, by Maya Angelou as my Descriptive essay and “How to say nothing in 500 words”, by Paul McHenry Roberts as my narrative essay. To me these two essays set themselves apart from each other

Compare and Contrast Essay

964 words - 4 pages Compare and Contrast Essay The setting of a story is the time and place in which the story takes place. The author may include a specific date or time period, or leave it up to the reader to determine a time period by suggesting certain events. The author may choose to give specific examples and clues as to where the story takes place or may suggest certain things to clue the reader to where the story is taking place. The theme of a

Compare and Contrast Essay

823 words - 4 pages very different. Their appearances, personalities and how they are involved with Louis can both be compared and contrasted. Appearance can always be used to compare and contrast two characters in a movie. Penelope is a brunette with medium length hair. She also wears makeup that makes her look sophisticated and important. The makeup she wears does not make her look anything less than a rich woman. Her clothes are also of the rich fashion. She

Compare And Contrast Essay

795 words - 3 pages Compare and Contrast Essay I was only eleven years old when I first walked into the Knox Middle School. I was an upcoming student amazed at every little thing that could be seen. The place that was so old and cold, demanded new organization, after fifty-three years of passing on knowledge. It was a dream of mine to go to a school that could uphold sectional

Compare and contrast essay

1067 words - 5 pages Blerta Strikcani Compare & Contrast Malcolm X and Frederick Douglass both came from an African American back round but the time difference of these two men when they were brought to the world changed. Malcolm X had a rough life. His dad was mysteriously murdered and his mom was mentally ill and with no parent figure he got in to the street life. He got in to selling illegal substances and burglary. He was

Compare and Contrast Essay - 1546 words

1546 words - 7 pages thought so much more of her sister, Dee. “‘How do I look, Mama?’ Maggie says, showing just enough of her thin body enveloped in pink skirt and red blouse for me to know she's there, almost hidden by the door.” Maggie’s sheltered life didn’t lead her to lash out and be vengeful, like Emily in “A Rose for Emily”, Maggie’s sheltered life lead her to observe and to learn how she didn’t want to be. Maggie learned how to be kind and giving. “Sometimes

Compare And Contrast Essay

943 words - 4 pages Media is playing a major role in people’s daily life, especially during national celebrations because sometimes they direct their opinions and tell the people what to do during these celebrations. For that reason, every country the media shows celebrations in a different way than the other country depending on the culture, religion and the type of celebration. Media in Oman present Eid and the Renaissance Day celebrations as a source of joy and

Similar Essays

"Love In L.A." Vs. "The Red Convertible" Compare And Contrast

556 words - 2 pages The stories "Love in L.A." and the "Red Convertible" compares and contrasts in a couple ways. In both stories the car is used to progress through problems and to start problems. The setting, plot, characters, and other factors make both stories have common features and differ. Jake in the "Love in L.A." and Henry from "Red Convertible" both compare dramatically, though they contrast also. Settings in both short stories differ from country to

Compare And Contrast Of The Paintings: Man In A Red Turban And Louis Xiv By Van Eyck And Rigaud

1119 words - 4 pages emotions in the viewer. That being said, in this essay I will compare and contrast two portraits. The first is an oil painting titled Man in a Red Turban by Flemish painter Jan van Eyck from 1433. The second work of art is Louis XIV by Hyacinthe Rigaud, a French Baroque painter. The portrait is from 1701 and is an oil-on-canvas painting. These two works of art both demonstrate a likeness of each of their subjects but use different styles, elements and

Compare And Contrast: "The Masque Of The Red Death [By Edgar Allen Poe]" Vs. "A Rose For Emily [By William Faulkner]"

542 words - 2 pages Most notably recognized for their strange and bizarre stories, both Edgar Allen Poe and William Faulkner wrote several disturbing narratives. As such, it is not surprising to find that Poe's story, "The Masque of the Red Death," and Faulkner's tale, "A Rose for Emily," have much in common. Among their numerous similarities, the most apparent comparison is the theme of death in both plots.Foremost, in "the Masque of the Red Death," the country

To Change In Louise Erdrich's Red Convertible And The Shaw

1093 words - 4 pages Marc Stern Professor Jan Donley Leng-201-015 March 25, 2014 Exploring Change To change is to become different, to progress, and to grow. In Louise Erdrich’s stories “Red Convertible” and “The Shawl” the idea of change is used as a catalyst to advance the stories in a new and interesting direction. Both stories explain or imply some sort of change within their first sentences. The first sentence of “Red Convertible” reads, “I was the first one