This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Ford Pinto Case Essay

749 words - 3 pages

Business Case (The Ford Pinto)
There was strong competition for Ford in the American small-car market from Volkswagen and several Japanese companies in the 1960’s. To fight the competition, Ford rushed its newest car the Pinto into production in much less time than is usually required to develop a car. The regular time to produce an automobile is 43 months but Ford took 25 months only (Satchi, L., 2005). Although Ford had access to a new design which would decrease the possibility of the Ford Pinto from exploding, the company chose not to implement the design, which would have cost $11 per car, even though it had done an analysis showing that the new design would result in 180 less deaths. The company defended itself on the grounds that it used the accepted risk-benefit analysis to determine if the monetary costs of making the change were greater than the societal benefit. Based on the numbers Ford used, the cost would have been $137 million versus the $49.5 million price tag put on the deaths, injuries, and car damages, and thus Ford felt justified not implementing the design change (Legget, C., 1999). This was a ground breaking decision because it failed to use the common standard of whether a harm was a result of an action on trespass or harm as a result of an action on the case (Ferguson, A., 2005).

From reading this case, we realize the company did not apply the managing ethics competency in building its goals and structure. Managing ethics competency involves the overall ability to incorporate values and principles that distinguish right from wrong in making decisions and choosing behaviors (Hellriegel, J., 2004). Ford did not approach the question of redesigning the gas tank to make the car safer versus waiting another year allowing the foreign market to dominate subcompact vehicles. Their goal was only to maximize profits. They did not into account the interests of their share holders and when they did come into consideration, they were analyzed against profits. One has nothing to do with the other. Their goal should not have been a race to make the most affordable subcompact car. Their focus should have been to make a subcompact car that was not only most affordable but also the safest subcompact. They were aware of the dangers associated with the rush production. It would have made a difference if the $11 savings had been passed on to the customers...

Find Another Essay On The Ford Pinto Case

The Ford Pinto: An Inexpensive and Compact Vehicle

1397 words - 6 pages began recalling the defective vehicles in order to reinforce the fuel tanks. In 1980, production of the Pinto ceased. Ethical Issues The Ford Pinto case brings about numerous ethical issues regarding product liability, corporate social responsibility, and respect for other human beings. Firstly, when senior executives at Ford Motor Company made the decision not to repair the hazardous fuel tank, they failed to consider all of the stakeholders

Legal and Ethical Anlaysis of the Ford Pinto

1234 words - 5 pages required cars to be made in such a safe manner that in case of a crash from the rear the leakage should be minimum. Although Ford had conducted enough of research but the design flaw in Pinto was that the fuel tank was near rear axle and the bladder pipe could cause leakages way beyond what was sanctioned. Plus they were also affected by external hot or cold temperatures. Calling the cars rolling on the road for adjustment would have drained the

Ford Pinto Case

1158 words - 5 pages FORD PINTO PAGE 1 FORD PINTO PAGE 5 El CasoFord PintoEn la actualidad ha habido numerosos casos que han puesto en riesgo la reputación de compañías reconocidas debido a la falta de buen juicio en cuanto a la seguridad de sus productos. En el caso del Ford Pinto del 1971, en el cual se fabricó un vehículo que presentaba un peligro para la seguridad de los consumidores, analizaremos las posibles soluciones y

Irrational Pollution & Ethics: A Case Study of the Ford Excursion

1206 words - 5 pages Overview:During the 1990s the sale of sports-utility vehicles (SUVs) increased six times. Ford produced an 8,500 pound, 6.5 foot wide, 7-foot high, 19-foot long gargantuan SUV dubbed the Excursion to meet the insatiable consumer demand. The motor company anticipates 50,000 to 60,000 sales a year, and at a retail cost between $40,000-$50,000 and a profit margin of around $20,000 the company stands to reap enormous profits. However the 44-gallon

Case Study: Ford Ka - Breaking new ground in the Small Car Market (Insead 599-038)

6029 words - 24 pages This Case Study focusses on the Marketing of the Ford Ka.In this essay three questions are answered:1. What is the traditional segmentation in the Car Market.2. What is the new segmentation in the Car Market3. What is the best segmentation and positioning for the Ford Ka.GROEPSOPDRACHT 2MARKETING MANAGEMENTCASE FORD KARotterdam, 9 april 2003Studenten: Cindy Brouwerstudentnr. 119661e-mail adres cindy.brouwer@meespierson.comNico Geelhoedstudentnr

Disasters of Ford Pinto

2173 words - 9 pages The topic of this paper will be on Ford Motor Company. It will be surrounding the Pinto car fires, which occurred within 1970 to 1976. It will consist of all the relevant facts of the incidents, ethical issues. We will be using the systematic approach of the eight step model to complete this paper. The focus of the paper is the writers are taking the place of the recall coordinators.The pertinent facts in this case are Ford Motors was in a hurry

Ford Pinto Trial

1371 words - 5 pages again. In a landmark case a jury awarded Richard Grimshaw, a Pinto burn victim, $125 million in punitive damages and another $2.8 million in compensatory damages, "The largest award ever made by a jury in a personal injury case".2 About the same time $666,280 was awarded to the family of Lily Grey, who had died in an accident. These amounts were much more than the $200,000 for a human life and the $67,000 for personal injury that Ford had originally

Legal and Ethical Analysis of Ford Pinto

3714 words - 15 pages concerning Pinto fuel system integrity was necessary (27).In February 1978, a California jury handed down a verdict that assessed $125 million in punitive damages against Ford in a case involving the rupture and explosion of the fuel tank on a 1972 Pinto. A judge later reduced punitive damages to $3.5 million (28).In February 1978, NHTSA conducted experimental crash test of 11 Pintos manufactured from 1971 to 1976. The Pintos were staged at

Ford Ka: Breaking New Ground in the Small Car Market : Insead case on market segmentation

1751 words - 7 pages Central IssueWith the small car market in France undergoing rapid change, the strategies of yore are making way for newer methodologies. No longer can a car manufacturer simply make a big car for the wealthy and a small car for the less fortunate. For Ford, it is critical that they determine their target market for a new addition to their lineup, the Ka. But first, Ford needs to determine who that target market is by segmenting it in such a way

Legal Case Study

2047 words - 8 pages Legal Case Study The American Automobile industry has historically been tied to the nations economic cycle in which three or four years were good followed by one or two poor years. In 1977 there were four major U.S. automakers including General Motors, Ford, Chrysler and American Motors. Imports were starting to make their presence in the market because they offered subcompact cars at reasonable prices. Ford

Examination of Four Different Ethics Cases

1053 words - 4 pages banned pesticides have already been found in our flood waters) or from being found in our imported foods. Case 2.2: The Ford Pinto 1968 – Ford produced the Pinto to compete with foreign (mostly Japanese) auto markets. Condensed processes for quicker production, to have it on the market sooner (any changes needed to be made would have to be made during production instead of during drafting). During crash tests, all models Ford tested had failed

Similar Essays

The Ford Pinto Case: Legal And Unethical

641 words - 3 pages . Taking an ethical approach to the Ford Pinto case makes it hard to accept the risk/benefit analysis used by the Ford Motor Company. In making what seems to be the correct decision based on numbers, Ford adopted a policy for allowing a certain number of people to die or be injured even though it could have been prevented. From a human rights perspective, this is a blatant disregard for human life. Ford legally chose not to make the design changes that

Managing Product Safety: The Ford Pinto

2547 words - 10 pages of conscience exhibited by the manufacturer when confronted with defective obstacles which could have delayed the production and cost millions of dollars, which in their mind was not an option. The purpose of introducing the Ford Pinto was to gain market share in a highly competitive compact arena and remain profitable for the company to manufacture. As in this case, some ethics of design do not withstand the test of profit and safety. The best

Managing Product Safety: The Ford Pinto

2520 words - 10 pages exhibited by the manufacturer when confronted with defective obstacles which could have delayed the production and cost millions of dollars, which in their mind was not an option.The purpose of introducing the Ford Pinto was to gain market share in a highly competitive compact arena and remain profitable for the company to manufacture. As in this case, some ethics of design do not withstand the test of profit and safety. The best interest of the company

Ford Pinto Case Paper Assisgnment University Of Phoenix Leadership Paper

1770 words - 8 pages difficult, but using an ethical decision-making process and examining different ethical perspectives can make it easier. It has also provided a more in depth understanding of how to avoid unethical behavior in an organization, and the importance of organizational citizenship. References Hoffman, M. W. (1982) “Case study: Ford pinto: Corporate obligations and responsibilities: Everything is new again” [PDF File] (pp. 222-229). Cengage Learning, G