The Gateway To Future Disaster Or To Temporary Prosperity

1451 words - 6 pages

The Keystone XL pipeline crosses “more than 1000 water bodies” such as rivers, streams, aquifers, as well passing by “approximately 2500 water wells” (Swift). This could be a disaster waiting to happen; potential water contamination could raise major ethical concerns for surrounding townsfolk and farmers. The XL extension would extend south east from Alberta, Canada reaching Steele City Nebraska and finally connecting with the pre -existing Keystone pipeline enabling access to the Gulf Coast region. The pipeline itself would be 1,664 miles long and would be expected to transport around 830,000 barrels each day. Despite controversy arising on each side of the debate, both economists and environments skew the available information to support their own goals. Both sides have flaws, but is there one side which is more justified economically, environmentally, and ethically than the other? If the sand oils are not shipped via the Pipeline XL to the Gulf Coast, it will come by train, in greater bulk than it is currently. And if it isn’t refined here in the United States, it may be burned in China where the refining process is not as safe or clean for the environment thus resulting in more greenhouse gas emissions. As previously mentioned, there are also concerns about oil spills, and about potentially contaminated water supplies. Both sides rely on assumptions and predictions, and while oil spills are certain to happen, there may be greater environmental risk and economic loss if the Keystone XL pipeline is not constructed. All of this leads to the question: should the Keystone pipeline XL extension be built?
While the views of the Keystone XL pipeline are varied, it is accepted by both views that fossil fuels and the byproduct greenhouse gases is a real issue. However, the difference is in the belief of how great an environmental influence this pipeline will have. This also originates from fundamental value differences, from that of money and economic prosperity versus potential future environmental concerns (Guggenheim). Both sides must be weighed before hasty judgements are made. James Hansen, a NASA climate scientist made the claim that the Keystone XL pipeline “would be ‘game over’ when it came to the effort to stabilize the environment” (Eilperin). However, another NASA climate scientist, Gavin Schmidt, disagrees this fatalistic view, arguing “There is an urgency to acting but it's not because there's a point of no return” (Herath). Those in opposition to the pipeline claim that this pipeline would encourage further the process of extracting the crude or bitumen which “emits roughly 15 percent more greenhouse gas emissions than the production of the average barrel of crude oil used in the United States” (Eilperin). This is a good point, however it must also be considered whether the refineries in China or other foreign interests would produce more greenhouse gas with dirtier refining methods.
The State Department coincides with this, stating in...

Find Another Essay On The Gateway to Future Disaster or to Temporary Prosperity

Procrastination: Gateway To Failure Essay

1581 words - 6 pages education, conditions are ideal for procrastination to exist. In addition to intangible mental work, higher education levels can be described as having flexible deadlines and often self-defined goals. When excuses are accepted or accommodated, the procrastinators behavior is reinforced, advancing the problem. Procrastination can come into effect as a temporary and infrequent fallacy, or it can play the roll as a continuous infirmity which

Gateway to heaven" Essay

4439 words - 18 pages side.No saviour from on high deliversNo faith have we in prince or peerOur own right hand the chains must shiverChains of hatred, greed and fearE'er the thieves will out with their bootyAnd give to all a happier lot.Each at the forge must do their dutyAnd we'll strike while the iron is hot.I cried, this is what they were fighting for; they were fighting so that we could have a future, so that we would be able to read beautiful literature such as

Jane’s Path to Prosperity

2434 words - 10 pages Jane’s Path to Prosperity In The beginning of Jane Eyre, Charlotte Bronte introduces Jane as an orphan girl who is residing at Gateshead with Mrs. Reed and her children. Bronte walks us through the episodes of Jane’s life as she moves to Lowood, Thronfield, Moor House, and finally to Ferndean. Throughout these stages, Bronte will show how charity was depicted through the interactions that Jane had. Through these perspectives we will see that

OnLive: The Future of Gaming or Technological Disaster?

2532 words - 10 pages OnLive: The Future of Gaming or Technological Disaster? The OnLive Company first proposed their plan to provide cloud-based gaming service to the public at the E3 conference, June 2009. To many of the enthusiasts at the conference, it seemed that an On-Demand service for video games was only natural, given that movies and music have already adopted cloud distribution. As Microsoft and Nintendo premiered their new resource-hungry consoles

Homeschooling: The Road to Disaster

3165 words - 13 pages , its regulation varies greatly. Idaho, for example, does not even ask parents who wish to homeschool to inform any state or local officials of their intentions. Oregon, meanwhile, mandates that homeschooling families periodically have a "qualified neutral person" test their children (Archer).To begin, homeschooling does offer some advantages. Today, the most popular reason for homeschooling is that parents are unhappy with public schools. In 1996

The Gateway to The Soul. Metaphors that Justify War

2494 words - 10 pages want the truth; we thirst for it like those traveling through the desert without water and we are tired of being manipulated and deceived by those we elect to serve our interests. However, more often than not, we settle for what is given to us. Our truth is wrapped by the media and promoted as gospel without hesitation or moral reservation. Our acceptance of and reliance upon the media for sensitive, truthful, information brings a sense of security

The Great Lakes Global Freight Gateway Project: Detroit to Halifax

1516 words - 6 pages Great Lakes Global Freight Gateway Project is a program that will utilize these vacant assets to create an inland port in Detroit and to promote global trade from the Midwest (GLFG3, 3:33/8:46). This essay is going to show how the Great Lakes Global Freight Gateway Project can restore economic vitality to the region and provide growth opportunities for all stakeholders. Development The United States economy has shifted from being predominately

The Path to the Future: Science or Religion?

1242 words - 5 pages saying “because God wanted to.” This doesn’t mean that religion is bad or that science is more important, instead it means that science is the logical explanation of God’s work. Both ideas don’t have to constantly fight each other but rather make them coexists. A perfect example of such fusion between science and religion would be the theistic evolution theory, in the words of Francis Collins, author of The Language of God: A Scientist Presents


1363 words - 5 pages themselves or feel a need to impress the surrounding adults. Due to this factor, the youth's concept of self-worth is so heavily oriented towards achievement, that they often can't even be second-best. Other times, a teenager might fail to meet the family's expectations. Weak educational results or achievements can result in lack of support that a child needs at that age.Through the eyes of an adolescent, parents can be very hard to understand. For

Organizational Theory Applied to the Challenger Disaster

1009 words - 4 pages Groupthink has had a negative role in many organizations ability to make rational and ethical decisions. The Challenger disaster is no different, in fact its outcome was more serious than most. The Challenger disaster was caused by Groupthink, specifically the pressure that management was subjected to, which was then forced upon the engineers.The symptoms of Groupthink were clearly the downfall of the Challenger disaster. By analyzing these

Back to the Future

1443 words - 6 pages time machines still poses. The idea still amuses even the tech savvy people today. Back to the Future used an unchartered territory, and the interest of the people to create the empire still present today; this shows why today’s society finds the film still prevalent. Overall, people can agree that it’s exciting to think about returning to the past to create a more suitable present time, or venturing into the future to grasp what has become of this

Similar Essays

Gateway To My Future Essay

1265 words - 5 pages commentaries concerning these economic upheavals, I realized that there were subtexts common to these "crises". I could easily find the meaning of some of the words used in these articles, these included "bonds", "interest rates”, "debt defaults", and "sovereign". Contextually, I found these words intuitive and I erroneously drew a conclusion that all these upheavals called "financial crisis" were brought about by misjudgments or miscalculations by

Gateway To The Smokies Essay

1193 words - 5 pages Pigeon Forge, Tennessee, is the "Gateway to the Smoky Mountains." It is located approximately 120 miles southwest of the ETSU campus. Pigeon Forge is a highly recognized tourist town with many activities. Pigeon Forge, Tennessee contains many forms of entertainment, such as Dollywood, lodging, and restaurants for the average student tourists. The entertainment industry is the main reason why Pigeon Forge is such a well-known tourist town

The Effect Of The Chinese Economy To The Future Prosperity Of Developing Countries

1779 words - 7 pages Examine the significance of the effect of the Chinese economy to the future prosperity of developed and developing countries There is much speculation as to China's economic future, underlined of late by their entry into the World Trade Organization (WTO). There is no doubt that China has the potential to become one of the most economically powerful nations in the world as it has access to vast numbers of employees in the labour pool

The Romanian Warehouse: Gateway To Success?

1774 words - 7 pages GDP in 1989, to an international orientated market economy in the spirit of the EU in 2007. This capital slurping project for both sides (EU and Romania) has to be a beneficial investment. What could be the economic added-value of Romania to the EU and what impulse can the EU give to the Romanian economy?Romanian developmentThe figures of the Romanian macro-economic development between 1989 and 1999 are not as progressive as, maybe, expected or