This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The General Motors And Fisher Body Case Study By Benjamin Klein, Robert Crawford, And Arman Alchian

1426 words - 6 pages

The General Motors & Fisher body Case Study

The first paper referring to the case study was written by Benjamin Klein, Robert Crawford, and Arman Alchian, "Vertical integration, appropriable rents and the competitive contracting process." (Klein et al, 1978). It discusses "possibility of post contractual opportunistic behaviour" (Klein et al., 1978 p297) and is a great example of vertical integration used to relieve a hold up in the face of assets specificity, as occurred between GM & Fisher body. The paper has gone on to be considered the “Prevailing view” of the case study, and is supported by other papers.
In 1998, Klein refers again to the Fisher body (FB) - General Motors (GM) Case, ...view middle of the document...

However, favourable conditions arose for FB to take advantage of General Motor, specifically to ask for a monopoly price on the bodies. Consequently the contract aimed to set a price at cost plus 17.6% (Klein et al, 1978). The contract also specified that GM could not be charged higher than the average market price or not more than other car-companies for similar products.
The case then develops interestingly between FB & GM, due to the serious increase in demand for cars (Klein et al, 1978). This led to GM being dissatisfied with the price they were now paying Fisher. The increased price was due to a "substantial increase in body output per unit of capital employed" (Klein et al., 1978 p309). With the lack of capital cost pass-through in the original contract, this was a precarious development. Furthermore, GM required FB to relocate their plants next to GM plants, this they declared was crucial to efficiency in production. This supposedly never happened because of the great investment FB would have to make and In 1924, GM described the contract as unacceptable and started acquiring the remaining 40% of Fishers stock. (Klein et al, 1978). Klein (1988) proposes that explicit human capital with technical proficiency was considerable grounds for GM to vertically integrate with FB.
After revising the original documents, Coase (2000), does not agree that the contract performed well and states that it was changed through complete ownership so as to get the Fisher Brothers more involved in GM. He also highlights the fact that the contract included arrangements for GM to obtain 60% of FB's assets and 3 of the 5 Fisher Brothers' would be chosen by GM for their board. Also in 1921, a member of Fisher finance group of advisors became the director of GM, followed by 2 more in 1924. One became president of Cadillac division of GM (Klein, 2005). A forth Fisher was included in GM's board of directors when FB was fully bought. Coase (2000) considers the 2 firms interests as fairly aligned when the original contract was written and executed, and unlikely that Fisher would behave opportunistically to take away rents from GM. He claims that GM "allowed FB to act opportunistically by locating its plans away from the GM assembly plants, which raised its costs and therefore its profits under the cost plus 17.6% pricing formula." (Coase 2006, p.257).
However, despite common belief, FB did build 8 body plants that were located next to GM plants between 1922 - 1925 and they were inclined to use the most common technology available (Klein 2005). Specifically, GM did not obtain the remaining 40% of FB due to unfavourable contractual relationship and transactions: but instead, "The exclusive dealing contract designed to protect FB's original GM specific capacity investments against a potential hold up by GM created an FB holdup of General Motors" (Klein 2007, p.1). - The case study demonstrates the importance of distinguishing between insufficient hold up...

Find Another Essay On The General Motors and Fisher Body Case Study by Benjamin Klein, Robert Crawford, and Arman Alchian

Case study of Automobile Industry. Research on General Motors

5656 words - 23 pages will dedicate ourselves to products and services that create enthusiastic customers. No one will be second-guessed for doing the right things for the customer.Teamwork: We will win by thinking and acting together as one General Motors team, focused on global leadership. Our strengths are our highly skilled people and our diversity.Innovation: We will challenge conventional thinking, explore new technology and implement new ideas, regardless of

General Motors: Company overview and comparative analysis

1906 words - 8 pages competing companies had EBITDA margins that were between 10.7% and 14.1%, all higher than that achieved by General Motors. In 2005, earnings before extraordinary items at General Motors were -$10.46 billion, or -5.4% of sales. This profit margin is lower than the level the company achieved in 2004, when the profit margin was 1.4% of sales. The company's return on equity in 2005 was -37.7%. This was a lot worse than the 11.1% return the company achieved

Lone Bather by A.M. Klein and The Swimmer by Irving Layton

1554 words - 6 pages similes and word choice are both mastered by these two poets. In some cases, it seems as if the two are trying to make their points distinct from each other’s. In the case of word choice, A.M. Klein chooses to dwell on a more positive side, with Layton taking the negative. Proof of this is found in “Lone Bather'; : “swims fancy and gay ....under the satins of his great big bed.'; This quote shows the richness and

The primary internal and external influence on the General Motors Corporation

3834 words - 15 pages organization is discussed one by one.Internal influence: StrengthsThis section analyzes the internal strengths of the corporation. The General Motors are rich in brands and product lines. The General Motors Corporation acquired and mergers many brands and auto companies in the early stage of its history. The General Motors Corporation acquired Buick and Oldsmobile after it is founded. Then it brought Cadillac, Elmore and Oakland and so on. As a

The Life and Work of Mary Crawford: A Feminist Psychologist

1489 words - 6 pages traditional family role (Crawford 2001). In her adolescence, Crawford began idolizing many role-models of non-traditional females in powerful and interesting roles outside the home (Crawford 2001). Crawford listened to radio shows, read books like Nancy Drew, and was influenced by female leaders like Golda Meir, the Prime Minister of the newly created Israel (Crawford 2001). Academia was always a strong point of Crawford’s. She scored the highest SAT

Case Study: General Electric Company and 3M Worldwide

1622 words - 6 pages the foundation research for further development and analysis of the two companies' financial health.Company Selection Paper - General Electric Company and 3M WorldwideA publicly traded company is one which has issued securities through an offering, and which is now traded on the open market ( When a company is publicly traded, it is under constant scrutiny by shareholders, analysts, and the general public.As a result of the

Euthanasia and the robert Latimer case

1013 words - 4 pages to 'put them out of their misery'. One of the strong questions raised in my mind is: Does the killer really want to put the victim out of their misery? Or is it the killer who is under the extreme pressures of living with the victim, and is it their own lifestyle that they are truly fed up with?In the Robert Latimer case, as in many other cases of euthanasia, it can never be proven whether or not Latimer killed his young daughter Tracy to 'save

The Nutcracker by Jennifer Fisher

1392 words - 6 pages The Nutcracker by Jennifer Fisher Copyright © 2012 Dance Heritage Coalition Page 1 Created in 1892, during a golden age of classical ballet in Russia, The Nutcracker might have remained one of Tchaikovsky's lesser-known ballets if not for its virtual immigration to the United States. The first Russian critics found plenty to dislike, though they did praise parts of the choreography by Lev Ivanov, when the ballet was presented at the

The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde by Robert Louis Stevenson

1217 words - 5 pages Robert Louis Stevenson’s novella, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, takes place in 1870’s England and centers on a man by the name of Dr. Henry Jekyll, who is a respectable doctor among his own community. In the beginning of the story, Mr. Utterson (who is the lawyer responsible for drafting Dr. Jekyll’s final will and testament) is walking with his friend, Mr. Enfield. As they are walking past this street, Enfield reminisces about a

The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde by Robert Louis Stevenson

1655 words - 7 pages oscillating novel, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, written by Robert Louis Stevenson, goodness was trapped by evil just as Jekyll was trapped as Hyde. Jekyll’s pure spirituality desired the holy richness of evil and all its wrongdoings. His laboratory experiments discovered his desire to feel the sensation of evil without truly being evil. His laboratory experiments discovered a way for him to escape. Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde fought the battle

Literary Analysis of The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde” by Robert Louis Stevenson

1846 words - 8 pages The city of London proved to be the sole dominant location in the 1800’s during the Victorian era in this novel. As the story unfolds in the classic literature novel, “The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde” written by Robert Louis Stevenson, the magnificent city of London becomes a darker and mysterious location. The powerful city of London embodied the freedom and solitude required for the antagonist of the story, Mr. Hyde to hide his

Similar Essays

Sony And General Motors Essay

4209 words - 17 pages that presumably accounted for Sloan and Morita's remarkable success. The often-unstated implications of such analyses suggest, therefore, that we would do well to broaden our views of management and of risk.Introduction This paper is about the management styles and philosophies of two executives, Alfred P. Sloan, Jr. of General Motors and Akio Morita of Sony, who managed by exception in rather unusual circumstances.We begin with the presumption

General Motors And Chrysler Merger Essay

2633 words - 11 pages · The concerns of all stakeholders need to be addressed and satisfied · The new entity must learn General Motors and ChryslerMergerHuman Resource ManagementSubject: 750 Human Resource ManagementImage source: HYPERLINK "", International Labour Organization Charman; A.T. Kearney study conducted in 1998 and reported in Haebeck, M.H., Kroger, F. and Trum, M.R. (2000) After the Mergers

The Rise And Fall Of General Motors Company

1592 words - 7 pages , both declined due to a lack of large capital from Durant. Durant declined and General Motors was founded on 16th Sep 1908.By 1910 the company owned 20% of the American auto industry by buying up numerous smaller competitors but at the expense of significant debt. Durant was removed from his position as the leader of GM and replaced him with a board of trustees. Durant went on to start another company and Incorporated Chevrolet Motor Company in

Eileen Fisher Case Study

605 words - 2 pages Eileen Fisher, Inc. is a woman's fashion company that was founded in 1984 in New York City. Their mission is to strive to create both clothing and an environment that inspires women to celebrate who they are by incorporating beauty, versatility, comfort and simplicity throughout the company. Along with the 22 Eileen Fisher stores in major cities, major retailers such as Bloomingdale's, Saks Fifth Avenue, Marshall Fields, and Macy's, carry the