The True Tragic Hero: The Crucible’s John Proctor

1375 words - 6 pages

The true tragic hero: The Crucible’s John Proctor

A tragic hero is a noble man who commits a fatal flaw. The hero’s downfall is a result of their choices which leads to a punishment that exceeds the crime. “The difference between Proctor and Willy Loman is enormous; the former is the rather typical tragic hero who is defiant to the end, the latter is trapped in submission and is living a lie” (McGill 4). John Proctor is one of the main characters in The Crucible. he is married to Elizabeth Proctor and they live in Salem. In Arthur Miller’s famous play, The Crucible, John Proctor represents a classic tragic hero because he is a well respected man of noble stature, he is conflicted because of his fatal flaw, and his downfall is a result of his own choices.

First, in The Crucible, John Proctor is very well known in the town of Salem. “John Proctor was not simply a farmer but a man of significant wealth derived from diverse sources: inheritance, farming, rents, tavern keeping, and commercial ventures” (McGill 5). The Proctors get their wealth from many sources which has caused them to be very high in the social class. “Miller does refer to Proctor as a farmer, notes that he has followed the family tradition of tinkering with inventions, and consistently implies that he and his friends represent a social element inferior to the Putnams” (McGill 5). During The Crucible John Proctor is constantly faced with the problem of preserving his good name. “Previously preferred over truth, his good name is now preferred to life itself” (Popkin 7). John Proctor’s reputation is very important to him and he consistently tries to maintain his status in Salem. When it comes to his trial he chooses to give up his own life rather than tarnish his reputation.

Second of all, in The Crucible John Proctor commits a fatal flaw. “The tragic hero, whether Antony, Phedre, Hippolytus, or even hero, is like all other men in that he is guilty of wrongdoing” (McCollom 6). Proctor personally feels he violates his own moral code because in the play he is unfaithful to his wife (Popkin 142). John Proctor committs adultery with his former servant, Abigail. John’s wife, Elizabeth, later fires Abigail because she was suspicious of her and John and wanted her to leave him alone. In The Crucible Reverend Hale is talking to the Proctor’s and asks them to prove their knowledge of their religion by reciting the ten commandments. Proctor starts to name them and accidentally misses the seventh sin, “Thou shalt not commit adultery” (Popkin 6). This was more than a coincidence it was John Proctor unknowingly confessing to his sin. When Proctor is wrongly accused of witchcraft, Proctor suffers more from his guilt for his adultery not because of the accusations (McGill 3). “The hero’s action is guilty from one point of view and innocent from another” (McCollom 4). Towards the end of The Crucible Elizabeth Proctor relieves John from his guilt. From her point of view, John’s mistake was also...

Find Another Essay On The True Tragic Hero: The Crucible’s John Proctor

Who Is The True Tragic Hero?

1049 words - 4 pages In Sophocles' Antigone, surprisingly, the title character is not the tragic hero. Creon, King of Thebes, is granted the title of the true tragic hero. In order to prove whether or not Creon is in fact the true tragic hero, first one must answer the question, "What is a tragic hero?" According to Aristotle, the hero must be of noble stature, but also represent himself in such a way that he earns respect. This person is not perfect, and he must

The True Tragic Hero of Antigone

1244 words - 5 pages Has your pride ever stopped you from doing something? In Sophicles play Antigone. The king Creon indirectly kills his whole family by being stubborn and not listening to others opinions. Throughout his journey he displays the characteristics of Aristotle; tragic hero. These include being extraordinary, having good and bad sides, a tragic flaw, becoming aware of his mistakes and failing miserably in the end

The Tragic Death of John Proctor in Miller's The Crucible

1278 words - 5 pages light of this goodness his death is tragic. John Proctor transformed from a deceitful man and husband, to one who was true to himself as well as his beliefs. At the beginning of the play Proctor willingly cheats on his wife with a young girl of 18. He also is very passive and does whatever he can to avoid becoming involved with the witch trials. When Hale is searching for a motive for why the girls might be lying about witchcraft, and Proctor

John Proctor, Ultimately Becomes a Hero, in Miller's The Crucible

729 words - 3 pages John Proctor lived in Salem, Massachusetts. Salem had been struck with witchcraft rumors that were started by a manipulative teenage girl named Abigail. He knows that the girls were sporting, and blaming innocent people of supernatural crimes that cannot occur. John Proctor’s wife Elizabeth had been accused of witchery, as a form of revenge from Abigail. Abigail had strong feelings for John Proctor, and wanted to get rid of Elizabeth. In the end

John Proctor Tragic, or Pathet

1359 words - 5 pages John Proctor: Tragic, or Pathetic? "I have given you my soul; leave me my name!" (138). This is the disturbing vision we are left with at the end of Arthur Miller's play The Crucible. This scream is let out by the main character John Proctor; who has been accused of witchcraft, and is to be hung on that merit unless he confesses. John Proctor is innocent of such deeds, yet he will lose his life if he does not admit he committed such a

In depth analysis of why john proctor is a hero in THE CRUCIBLE

1895 words - 8 pages . Standing up for what he believed in and dying to keep a good name for his kids, John Proctor, in my eyes, is the perfect example of a tragic hero. He followed what his heart told him, and that was to tell the truth, even if it meant dying for it. He may not be an example of the "Perfect Puritan" but he ultimately did what some of those "Perfect Puritans" could not. Expressing your feelings toward something you think is unfair and morally

Brutus: A True Tragic Hero

1082 words - 4 pages of these conspirators there is one man that stands out to be a tragic hero, and that is a man by the name of Brutus. He was a great friend of Caesar who ultimately became one of Caesars worst adversaries. He betrayed Caesars trust and friendship when he agreed to be part of the assassination plot. A tragic hero is someone who is in a place of high standings or a place of power. This leads to a huge fall from greatness to death. A tragic hero must

"The Crucible": John Proctor

672 words - 3 pages The Crucible: John ProctorIn the book The Crucible there is a struggle within to have one have a sense of belonging to society. They want to be loved by that society no matter how much they may seem that they don't belong. But they do want to show that to everyone, everyone that may not think that. John Proctor is a good example of a struggle to find a place in society. He's the type of person that wants to plow his fields on the good days even

Defending John Proctor (The Crucible)

717 words - 3 pages Ladies and Gentlemen, can you imagine where in this world, many innocent people had died for just a nonsense accusation caused by a small girl? And what had become the outcome? An innocent man had gone to jail of being accused in contact with the devil. Here, I clearly stated that John Proctor is not guilty. Knowing that he had a contact with the devil was clearly not true. Maybe most of you thought that a guy which had caused a lot of trouble

John Proctor in The Crucible

958 words - 4 pages How can just one person or thing have such a great effect on so many more, such as one little rock falling could cause twenty more to tumble as well? As I was reading Arthur Miller's novel, The Crucible, I noticed this was a very significant theme. John Proctor is a dominate character in the story, who is greatly respected by the Salem community. Although he is a powerful leader, he has some unworthy traits also. Throughout the book, he seems

The Tragic Hero Macbeth

1163 words - 5 pages It has always been a controversial debate that Macbeth has been a dead butcher not a tragic hero, since some literature experts have not recognized him as a hero but just a murderer. Based on thorough research, many critics have suggested that Macbeth, from the tragedy of Macbeth, has evidently been a tragic hero. The protagonist, Macbeth, possessed the flawed qualities of a tragic hero, by the fact that he was ambitious, immoral, and

Similar Essays

John Proctor: Tragic Hero Essay

1679 words - 7 pages In the play The Crucible by Arthur Miller, John Proctor is seen as a tragic hero because he is able to overcome his tragic flaw of hubris, but still the circumstances led to his death.A tragic hero is a person who has sacrificed their lives for a principle. It is shown in the play that ordinary people can be tragic heroes. They believed so passionately in an idea that they were willing to make the ultimate sacrifice, their lives, for it. There

The Crucible: John Proctor As A Tragic Hero

667 words - 3 pages KnoopSarena Knoop Mrs. Cox English 10 4 September 2014 John Proctor - Tragic Hero A tragic hero is a very favored person that suffers from a downfall which leads to their death. John Proctor like many others is a tragic hero. Proctor is a very respected man in Salem but he also has a few flaws that have proved him to be a tragic hero which are prideful, lustful, and well respected. Later in the play The Crucible, Proctor realizes his flaws and

John Proctor: A Tragic Hero Essay

732 words - 3 pages A Tragedy as a literary Work is described in which there is a hero that is basically moral individual destroyed by some character flaw and by force beyond his or her control. That hero is a tragic hero who experiences an inner struggle because of this flaw. Because of his charter flaw and his struggle to do what is right, John Proctor is a tragic hero. John Proctor is a very friendly man. Everyone likes being his friend. He is open, kind

John Proctor Is A Tragic Hero In The Crucible By Arthur Miller

638 words - 3 pages lead to his downfall. Arthur Miller purposely incorporates these characteristics into John Proctor, one of the main figures in The Crucible. He masterfully portrays Proctor as a tragic hero even though he is a common man.      A tragic hero is usually a member of the upper class or royalty. However, Miller believes that a common man is just as capable of being a tragic hero. Fear is the underlying element of tragedies