This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Geothermal Energy Act 2010 Essay

2150 words - 9 pages

Theories of Law LWB333- Topic 2: Coal Seam Gas and Lock the Gate- 3000 Words- 17 April

Queensland Minister for Natural Resources and Mines


Attention: Submission to inquiry regarding the Land Access Code (Qld)

Executive Summary: (500 words)

Coal Seam Gas and Lock the Gate
Land Access Code (‘LAC’) aims to increase protection for landowners with regards to Coal Seam Gas (CSG)Mining Activities being carried out on their property. These amendments apply to all resources acts; meaning the Geothermal Energy Act 2010 (GE Act), Geothermal Exploration Act 2009, Greenhouse Gas Storage Act 2009 (GHG ...view middle of the document...

This policy submission will critically evaluate the LAC provisions through a Utilitarian and a Law and Economic viewpoint.

The Utilitarian viewpoint
From a Utilitarian perspective, the LAC must be critiqued in its ability to create the greatest level of pleasure or happiness and the least amount of unhappiness or pain for all stakeholders. In the context of this policy critique, Jeremy Bentham is the leading utilitarian theorist. His scientific approach to the idea of utility allows for an objective framework to be used to resolve the current conflict between the rights of landowners and mining companies.

Despite being a fellow utilitarian and a follower of Bentham’s works, John Stuart Mill disagreed with the nature of ‘happiness.’ While Bentham conceded that there were no qualitative differences between pleasures, only quantitative discrepancies, this explanation of Hedonism was criticized for being too egalitarian. Mill’s “The Greatest Happiness Principle” extends upon Bentham’s principle, in saying that it is not the quantity of pleasure, but the quality of happiness. Despite the differences between either principle, Bentham’s theory will be used objectively to quantify happiness.

Due to the derivative nature of utilitarian rights, they are not as decisive as deontological theories. It would seem nonsensical to deem a right as ‘absolute’, thus adding strength to utilitarianism. The system of ranking rights among other interests under Bentham’s principle is advantageous, in that, the victor is the right which has the ability to maximize happiness.

In order to provide a definitive answer with regards to competing interests, the Law is required to put aside intellectual niceties and other deontological considerations. The consequences are used as the only relevant determinant. It is often difficult to weigh up the competing interests in terms of utility, thus certain rights and interests are assigned to stakeholders that have shown to maximize happiness. Therefore we utilize the following four criteria as a guide, not in a strict sense, in order to measure the overall effect of the Land Access Code on the relevant stakeholders:
1. Its intensity
2. Its duration

3. Its certainty or uncertainty
4. Its propinquity or remoteness

Landowners represent the primary opposition to Queensland’s LAC provisions. As resources are owned by the crown and not the property owner, the crown allows mining companies to access these resources and to negotiate access agreements and compensation with the landowner without their consent. Depending on the intensity and duration of the mining activities, a landowner may experience varying levels of ‘pain’. For example under the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (‘MRA’), the activities undertaken within an Exploration for Coal Permit (‘EPC’) range from ‘Preliminary Activities’ (such as soil sampling) to ‘Advanced Activities’ (such as drilling). Due to the type of permit or...

Find Another Essay On The Geothermal Energy Act 2010

Geothermal energy in America Essay

2293 words - 10 pages American energy community. The U.S. Department of Energy Geothermal Technologies Program’s report, A History of Geothermal Energy Research and Development in the United States published in 2010 is a four volume series that covers the thirty year period between 1976 and 2006 of growth and development of geothermal energy in America. This report is as the primary source detailing what started the exploration, how it will be accessed, the engineering

Geothermal Energy Essay

1033 words - 5 pages Geothermal energy is the heat from the Earth’s. The geothermal energy is very sustainable and the resources of the energy can range from the shallow ground (Geothermal Energy, 2010). The hot water and hot rocks are found underneath the Earth’s surface deep down with very high temperatures and it is called magma. The ground water is 10 feet of the Earth’s surface (Geothermal Energy, 2010). The temperature is very constant between 55 and 60

Geothermal energy

927 words - 4 pages Geothermal Energy as a Renewable Energy Source “Geothermal energy is a remnant heat derived from the foundation of the planet 4.5 billion years ago, as well as heat from the radioactive decay of naturally occurring unstable isotopes” (Glassley, 2010, p.43). This type of energy is considered renewable because it produces extremely small amounts of greenhouse gases, which is threatening to the Earth. Geothermal energy can be used for various

Improving Geothermal Energy

1319 words - 6 pages It is common knowledge that the quest for a better, infinite energy resource is consistently being searched for. The simple answer in solving the energy crisis is to utilize the heat from the Earth we live on. Geothermal energy harnessed from magma will produce enough energy to power the world. Geothermal energy is already one of the most effective and environmental friendly sources of power that is used today (Introduction to Geothermal Energy

Energy Resources

1509 words - 6 pages Petroleum and geothermal energy are both things we use every day. We have based our lives on them and other resources like them. Petroleum is one of the world’s primary sources of fuel for transportation. In its natural form, petroleum is a flammable yellow to black mixture. It is not man made it occurs naturally in the earth’s surface. It is also known as crude oil. ("What is petroleum," 2008) Petroleum can be both mined and drilled

Lucy Taylor

830 words - 4 pages principles of geothermal energy mirror other renewable energies, but provide a whole spectrum of benefits due to the physics behind the systems. Geothermal energy stipulates a range of pros and cons, but with such availability, extracting the Earth’s heat energy with minimal proposed risks act as the greatest benefit when discussing alternative energy sources. Unlike fossil fuel burning, geothermal is widely accepted as a clean energy. Energy sources such as nuclear power demonstrate many health risks and those exhibited by geothermal are minimal in comparison. Therefore, geothermal energy illustrates the potential to become a leading source of energy within society.

Geothermal in Indonesia

634 words - 3 pages Indonesia is located in Southeast Asia, it’s made up of more than 18,000 islands and is the fourth most populous country in the world. 88% of the power generated in Indonesia is from non renewable resources. In order to change this, we decided to use geothermal energy to reduce the carbon emissions that are produced from the coal and oil. Indonesia has 40% of the world potential for geothermal energy Indonesia is the fourth most populous

An Overview of Geothermal Energy

1041 words - 4 pages An Overview of Geothermal Energy To understand the history of geothermal energy, we must first understand what it is. At the center of the earth, the temperatures can reach extreme heats of up to 9,000 degrees Fahrenheit. The earth has many layers and as these layers come in contact with each other the heat from the deeper level conducts to the next level. For example, the layer closet to the earth’s core becomes hot from the

Geothermal Energy

729 words - 3 pages The power of electricity is available to anyone with a simple click of a button. The methods of obtaining the energy used to develop that electricity are commonly debated topics. One of those methods is using geothermal energy, or the Earth’s naturally produced heat. There are plenty of intriguing facts centered upon geothermal energy. For thousands of years, geothermal energy has been used in some countries for heating and cooking

Geothermal Energy

1255 words - 6 pages the earth's environment. To solve this quagmire, we will need to look to the list of renewable energy resources, specifically we will need to look at Geothermal Energy. Geothermal Energy is a renewable energy source that is drilled from wells in the Earth's crust or harnessed through fissures-like "leaks" in tectonic geography, such as a hot spring or volcano. It does not produce any form of greenhouse gas or Carbon. If we took advantage of

Is Geothermal Worth the Price?

955 words - 4 pages Is Geothermal Worth the Price? The rising cost of energy has given homeowners the opportunity to explore alternatives. Geothermal heat pumps are one available option. Even though geothermal heat pumps are expensive, their efficiency and reliability will provide a value capable of overcoming the high installation cost. The tremendous benefits this system provides will allow the recovery of the lofty cost. Geothermal heat pumps differ from

Similar Essays

Geothermal Energy: The Alternative Of The Future

2132 words - 9 pages Geothermal Energy: The Alternative of the Future When the energy crisis hit Americans in the 1970's, people were scrambling to find ways to conserve energy. The crisis brought to attention the very real shortage of fossil fuels. Gas and oil prices skyrocketed, and Americans looked for ways to save energy. They started producing smaller cars, driving less, and turning down their thermostats. Also, they started to examine alternate energy

Geothermal Energy Is The Solution To The Energy Crisis

1957 words - 8 pages Geothermal Energy: A Solution to the Energy Crisis Abstract So far, scientists have not found a successful substitute for fossil fuels that can handle both the large demand for energy and solve the global warming problem. I propose that geothermal energy is a clean, widely available, and renewable alternative to the usage of fossil fuels. In this paper, I will explain how use of geothermal resources can be energy-efficient, environmentally

Evaluation Of The “Patient Protection & Affordable Care Act Of 2010”

1152 words - 5 pages Human Services is a profession that has been deeply affected by certain legislation passed by Congress. One of the most influential acts that has been passed, was the “Patient Protection & Affordable Care Act”, put in effect by President Barack Obama in 2010.This legislation has affected the department of Human Services profoundly more than any other legislation in the past decade. Many positive changes have been made but, many could argue the

Events In The World Of Finance Under A Descriptive And Critical Work Around Three Events In The World Of Finance – Glass Steagall Act (1933), Sarbanes Oxley Act (2002) And Dodd Frank Act (2010)

1988 words - 8 pages EVENTS IN THE WORLD OF FINANCE GLASS-STEAGALL ACT (1933) - SARBANES-OXLEY ACT (2002) - DODD-FRANK ACT (2010) Under a descriptive and critical work around three events in the world of finance - Glass-Steagall Act (1933), Sarbanes-Oxley Act (2002) and Dodd-Frank Act (2010) - is intended to explore the American national contexts in which they occurred. In common, all these events rose from situations which resulted on strong economic and