The Glaring Problems Hidden In The Similarities Of The Stand Your Ground And Castle Doctrine Laws

1080 words - 5 pages

In the forever changing worlds of law enforcement and criminal law, there are two
embedded laws in the criminal justice system that contain not only striking similarities, but also contain hidden applications that have been used in an inconsistent and yet, an unpredictable manner. These two laws, the Stand-your ground law and the Castle Doctrine are the two laws which have, within the last three years, have garnered both national and local attention when reviewing exactly how these laws are applied, justified, prosecuted, used, and defended.
The Stand- your- ground law essentially allows an individual to use force, whether deadly or not, in self-defense when there is reasonable or ...view middle of the document...

The Castle Doctrine is a common law doctrine that designates a person's abode, residence, living location or dwelling, (or, in some states, any place legally occupied, such as a car or place of work) as a place in which the person has certain and assured protections, defenses, and immunities. These provisions afforded within the Castle Doctrines allow such a person, in certain circumstances, to attack an intruder instead of retreating.
Typically, deadly force is considered justified and a defensible homicide only in cases when the individual reasonably feared imminent danger, a peril of death, or receiving serious bodily harm to either oneself or another person. The doctrine is not a defined law that can be invoked, but is a set of principles which is incorporated in some form in the law of most states. Currently a total of forty-six states have incorporated the Castle Doctrine into law.
“The difference between the Castle Doctrine and Stand Your Ground laws is where they apply: The Castle Doctrine applies in a person’s home, and Stand Your Ground extends the right to any place the defender has a right to have a gun” (Lott).
“The statutes vary widely from state to state and may have minor, but crucial differences in their language and application. On the other end of the legal spectrum, some states have laws imposing a duty to retreat. A duty to retreat generally means that you can't resort to deadly force in self-defense if you can safely avoid the risk of harm or death (by running away, for example). If that is not an option, say if you were cornered or pinned down and facing serious harm or death, then you would be authorized to use deadly force in self-defense.” (Findlaw).
However, some states have adopted the Castle Doctrine and do not have the Stand-you ground law on the books. Some states are just the opposite, and some have both of the principles in their criminal defense and prosecution arsenals. The reasoning behind this can be consistent
THE STAND YOUR GROUND AND CASTLE DOCTRINE LAWS 4 with how many states interpret, construe, and understand each of these laws, or doctrines and base these perceptions and...

Find Another Essay On The Glaring Problems Hidden in the Similarities of the Stand Your Ground and Castle Doctrine Laws

Stand Your Ground Essay

1567 words - 7 pages they feel their life is in danger, however unlike the Castle Doctrine, a person can even protect themselves outside of their homes. The Stand Your Ground Law allows individuals to protect themselves if they feel their lives are in danger as long as they are following two certain guidelines. These guidelines are as follows: an individual must have permission to be at the location and they also can not be participating in any illegal activities

Stand Your Ground? Essay

1047 words - 4 pages the "Castle doctrine" was in place. The "Castle doctrine" meant you could use deadly force if someone attacked you in your home. "Stand your ground" not only absolved the homeowner of any obligation to retreat, it extended that concept outside the home (Schultz). Since the law was enacted in 2005, the number of justifiable homicides in Florida has increased dramatically. In 2005, there were 43 such cases; in 2009, the last complete year

stand your ground

1649 words - 7 pages Florida’s stand-your-ground law. The third possible solution to improving Florida’s stand-your-ground law would be to place the twenty-two states with the stand-your-ground law that extends outside the home on the ‘castle’ doctrine. Evidence to support my claim can be found in the article, “Trayvon Martin and the Meaning of Self Defense” by Expert Steve Klingaman. In Klingaman’s article, he discusses the differences between the twenty-two states

stand your ground law

2222 words - 9 pages and accountability. Before the Stand Your Ground laws, right to use deadly force was strictly not allowed. An individual had to show that it was reasonable to believe that the use of such force was necessary to prevent sudden death or great harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the imminent commission of a forcible 'felony'. Only when a person was attacked in his home by a person not having an equal right to be there, she/he had a

The Glass Castle is a better Place To Stand

1500 words - 6 pages .) This never happened in “The Glass Castle”. In Jeanette’s book she never put what seems like very important information and just drops it. The problem is resolved by the end of the chapter so the reader doesn’t have to worry about remembering a fact or not. This makes it seem like your reading a new story in every chapter. “A Place to Stand” just seems to me like a long drawn out story. The style of writing is not the only thing was better. The

Chaos in the Castle

1275 words - 6 pages . James was so surprised that he couldn’t even believe that this had happened. Why would Cratchit want to stop Elsa from being queen? The guards check his pockets and found the missing crown. All along, Cratchit was the thief and kidnapper. He was given a key to the castle, and never returned it. This is how he got in, using the old key. The guards forced Cratchit to tell the reason of why he did this. Cratchit said that all his life he wanted to stop

Homoerotic and Homophobic Possibilities in The Castle of Otranto

1393 words - 6 pages Homoerotic and Homophobic Possibilities in The Castle of Otranto Eve Sedgwick describes the gothic novel as a “dialectic between the homosexual and homophobic” (92). Homosexuality was first recognized in the eighteenth century and resulted in far reaching social responses. With the establishment of the term “homosexuality”, social tensions appeared. These tensions found their way into novels as fears of sexuality and the struggle for sexual

The Doctrine of Recollection

1256 words - 5 pages Socrates’ Doctrine of Recollection is invalid because of the flawed procedure that was employed to prove it, its inability to apply to all types of knowledge, and the weakness of the premises that it is based on. In Plato’s Meno, Socrates suggested that knowledge comes from recollection, or, in Greek, anamnesis. He believes that the knowledge is already implanted in the human mind, and by recollection, men can retrieve back knowledge. There

The Development of Ground and Air Transport

2784 words - 11 pages A. The development of ground transport In old days, before the wheel invention (pre-3000 B.C) people normally were carried the sick and wounded on the shoulder between two men or backs of friends or animals(MacDonald & Miller, 1989). Forced transports were used for those with mental disorders in ancient time, however, one of the earliest uses of the wheel for patient transportation was constructed (circa 900 A.D.) by Anglo-Saxon, so they

The Doctrine of Predestination

1606 words - 7 pages Kyle Dallapè Professor Oesch Core Theology 101-1 March 4, 2014 The Doctrine of Predestination “In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth.”1 Arguably, this verse from Genesis is one of the most well known verses in the Bible aside from John 3:16. It is a universal Christian belief that God created the world and all of its inhabitants, making Him all-powerful. As Christians recognize God’s omnipotence, they also acknowledge that God

The Doctrine of Salvation

2277 words - 9 pages INTRODUCTION Is it possible to understand the gospel message, serve as an officer in a church, be sure of your salvation, and yet still not get into heaven when you die? Matthew, one of the original twelve disciples, answered this question clearly. Yes, on “that day”, many will stand before God and hear Him say, “I know you not; depart from me.” (Matthew 7:23 KJV) The assumption is all professing Christians want salvation. Salvation

Similar Essays

The Laws Regarding Stand Your Ground Not Being Equally Applied

1871 words - 8 pages Trayvon Martin was shot and killed on February 26, 2012 in Sanford, Florida by George Zimmerman. Zimmerman was the neighborhood watch coordinator. The laws regarding Stand your ground was only applying to Mr. Zimmerman and he was acquitted on July 13, 2013. Why did this law only apply to George Zimmerman and not Trayvon Martin? Debate Final The night of February 26, 2012 Trayvon Martin was visiting with his father, he had been suspended from

The Fight Part 3 Stand Your Ground

1915 words - 8 pages , you mean the one you murdered in cold blood. Yeah, Alex told me what you did. I don't need to explain myself to you, you're a subordinate. Yes you do you arrogant bastard, you don't just get to kill a child and then do a run through on your own daughter's mind to stop her because she is the only one who even tried to stand up to you. The only one even aware what you were up to with the backbone to stand up to you unlike Alex even now my brother still admires you too much to confront you not just about this but about what an arse-hole you've been since your friends died.

Weak Claims In Article ‘Stand Your Ground’ Laws Encourage Vigilantes

1353 words - 6 pages necessity, while others take the opinion that it is unethical and needs to be repealed across all states. With many high profile cases such as the Treyvon Martin case, these laws have come under a lot of fire and scrutiny. Cynthia Tucker who is an African American visiting professor at the University of Georgia, experienced journalist and 2007 Pulitzer prize winner, has established her side of the issue in her article ‘Stand your Ground’ Laws

The "Stand Your Ground Law" Should Not Be A Law

755 words - 4 pages accidents such as death or severe body injury. That is no different than the law in almost every other state. “The U.S. Commission on Civil Rights is investigating the enforcement of Stand Your Ground laws because there is not enough data on how effective they have been.” Michael Yaki, a commissioner, said: “There is an absolute lack of real data or information about how these Stand Your Ground laws have been or are applied.” He argued that they do