The Good Man Based On Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics

1504 words - 6 pages

The Good Man Based on Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics

Plato believed that a man could only become good by knowing the truth, and he could not know the truth without being good. This shows to be somewhat of a paradoxical argument. On the other hand, Aristotle had a different theory regarding the goodness of man. Aristotle claimed that the good man was the norm and the measure of ethical truth. Pertaining to Aristotle's definitions, in this essay I will explain the meaning of the previous statement. I will then critique it from an internal view and contrast that by critiquing it from an external view. As ethics has developed and changed over the years, Aristotle's concept of the good man can be altered to fit our modern society.

An Understanding
In an attempt to understand Aristotle's statement, the contents of that statement must be analyzed. There are four key contents to discuss. They are the good, the function of man, the notion of ethics, and ethical truth.
Book One in Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics discusses the most worthwhile human life. The life in question is the good life. Aristotle states that all of our activities aim to produce the good life. Every activity aims at some good; therefore, there is some good at which every activity is aimed. However, he states this is a fallacious argument. His point is to open up a hierarchy of goods. Every activity aims at some good and is subordinate to some other activity. The good of the ruling activity is more choiceworthy. The highest good will be that for the sake of which we engage in any activity, and that is the topic of ethics. Aristotle then comments on Plato's theory of the good. Plato claimed there was a "universally present" characteristic in all good things. However, Aristotle states that if there were a "universal" good, then there could be a single science of it. Yet there is no single science of good food, good people, good friendship, etc. Aristotle concludes that there is no universal good. Aristotle must now fashion his own interpretation of what he calls the "highest" good. The highest good is ultimately the aim of all actions. "What is best appears to be something complete" (1097a29) and this must be self-sufficient in that, nothing can make it better. "Of this sort happiness seems most to be." (1097b)
The next content to be discussed is the function of man. Aristotle tells us that our function is to live, and to do what we do humanly. We are to live in understanding and insight. We have reason, we act and we don't react. All fashions of human nature have to be lived thoughtfully from within. One is accountable and must act for one's own reasons and not another's. In essence, the function of man is to live ethically.
The third content of Aristotle's statement is ethics. However to be more specific, I'll discuss what is ethically good. Living ethically good is contributing to the concept of happiness noted above. Ethics is not...

Find Another Essay On The Good Man Based on Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics

Happiness in Nicomachean Ethics and Living the Rule of St. Benedict Today

569 words - 2 pages Essay written by Elizabeth Sippel From pursuing pleasure to avoiding pain, life seems to ultimately be about achieving happiness. However, how to define and obtain happiness has and continues to be a widely debated issue. In Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle gives his view on happiness. According to Aristotle, different types of people pursue different ends. “The many,” or ordinary people, pursue pleasure, whereas politicians seek glory

"The Idea of Good in Teachings of Different Philosophical Schools" (based on the Internet sources)

2182 words - 9 pages . Therefore, each person has different highest good because of different potentials. The individual happiness of a person depends on the ability of this person to apply his or her knowledge to a real world. A concept fundamental to Aristotle's ethical philosophy states that everything in this universe has been created to achieve a purpose and has been designed to perform the given function. In the case of man the goal of actions is happiness.Platonic

Qualities of a Good Ruler- Based on Niccolo Machiavelli's - "The Prince."

1038 words - 4 pages In history, the main reason why a nation prospers is because of its leader. The best written piece I have come across on this topic is Niccolo Machiavelli's book, "The Prince". A leader should be intelligent, strong, caring and devoted to his subjects. Although people have different opinions in the qualities of a good ruler, all believe that a leader should help his nation grow and thrive.In his book, "The Prince", Niccolo Machiavelli states his

Trust the honest good man

914 words - 4 pages . There is no reason for the readers not to trust Meursault for his honesty.In conclusion, Meursault should be trust-worthy for being objective and honest. There is a good man hiding inside his indifferent mask, just like the intelligent soul behind Piggy's fat body in Lord of the Flies. Unfortunately very few people in both stories can see the solid personalities inside either of them. Before being discovered any positive personality traits, Piggy and

Critically Examine Aristotle's Understanding of the Good and its Relationship to Human Function

1050 words - 4 pages this should be the chief end of human life and whether it is actually moral or not. The answers against Moore's argument seem acceptable, but by no means certain, meaning Aristotle's argument for the relation of "good" to human function could be mistaken.Bibliography:Gerard J. Hughes, Aristotle on Ethics (London: Routledge, 2001)Wikipedia, Nichomachean Ethicsaccessed March 2006

The Ideal of a Man, the Ideal of a Woman of the Heian Court Based on the Tale of Genji

1400 words - 6 pages social preference of relationships in the period. Looking from another perspective, I think how Genji reacts to her attitudes toward him provides the reader with a peep of Murasaki Shikibu’ feminism; that is, perhaps she looked down on men being childish, selfish, indifferent, and ignorant, in contrast to Utsusemi’s deeds that are meant to be considerate of a man she cares for. These apparent flaws of Genji, however, may not have been factors that

Essay on the Short Story "A Good Man Is Hard To Find" by Flannery O'Connor

806 words - 3 pages In a "Good Man Is Hard to Find" by Flannery O'Connor, the contrast of good and evil is not as evident as it appears on the surface. The road that the family in the story travels symbolizes good up until the point the grandmother all but forces the family to make a detour onto a dirt road that leads to their demise. She is the unlikely antagonist in the story. A serial killer named, The Misfit, is the protagonist despite his homicidal actions

The Ideal of a Man & The Ideal of a Woman of the Heian Court Based on Genji Monogatari

1339 words - 5 pages there, it was just a matter of shaping her to be dependable, steady, and however else Genji wanted her to be. The ideal of a man or woman in our modern society—for me at least—would be something truly unachievable, because it would require having the greatest qualities regarding “everything” (our idea of “everything” is much more extensive than the Heian court's idea, as we know more about the world), but it would still be based solely on

The Ideal of a Man and Woman of the Heian court Based on the Tale of Genji

1571 words - 6 pages In this paper I will be discussing the ideals of a man based on the Tale of Genji by Murasaki Shikibu with translations by Royall Tyler, beginning with some background information on what the Tale of Genji is, then moving on to discuss the ideals that were presented in the story and how the ideals are contradicted. The Tale of Genji, otherwise known as Genji Monogatari, is a classic Japanese literary work that was written by Murasaki Shikibu

The Ideal of a Man and Woman of the Heian court Based on the Tale of Genji

1498 words - 6 pages write what is arguably the most accurate literary depiction of itself and its inhabitants available to the public. The novel was written for the yokibito, or women of the aristocracy. According to The Tale of Genji,the ideal Heian court gentleman was a man of many talents, one of political power and prestige, and as it seems in the novel, one of considerably good looks and emotion. If one takes a quick look at the protagonist, Prince Genji, one can

The Motionless Arrow, Aristotle's thoughts on Zeno's Arrow Paradox

917 words - 4 pages Aristotle's thoughts on Zeno's Arrow Argument as represented in Chapter 9 of Aristotle's Physics: A Guided Study can be understood in such a way that it might not be 'next door to madness'. In this chapter, Aristotle interprets Zeno's argument of the Flying Arrow as 'missing the mark'. There are four premises for this argument, and in Aristotle's opinion, premise three can be rejected. He does not believe that time is composed of indivisible

Similar Essays

Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics Essay

1132 words - 5 pages In consideration to Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle’s view of the great-souled man is that of an individual that represents happiness and obtains the five virtues: wisdom, justice, bravery, self-control, and the overall goodness within an individual (happiness). The magnanimous person is very complex and displays the proper virtues at the proper time, and in the proper way. In addition, the great-souled man accommodates to his surroundings where

The Contradictions In Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics

824 words - 3 pages am. Without them I don't know what I would do. In Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics there is emphasis on the importance of action. From action of life, friendship, and happiness (which are voluntary actions), to action of reason (which is a rational faculty of the mind), we could not exist without action. To begin with, voluntary actions are those "of which the moving principle is in the agent himself, he being aware of the particular

Friendship And Self Love In Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics

1663 words - 7 pages IntroductionAristotle, a pupil of Plato is one of the greatest, ancient Athenian philosophers. Nicomachean Ethics is Aristotle's most advanced work on ethics. In fact, Nicomachean Ethics was written around 340 BC. It is most likely to have been named after either his father or son, who were both named Nicomachus. Undoubtedly, friendship is one of the most important elements in the books of Aristotle's ethical principles. Out of the ten books of

Old Vs New South, Paper Based On Flannery O'conner's Book A Good Man Is Hard To Find.

1233 words - 5 pages Paper based on Flannery O'Conner's book A Good Man is Hard to Find -Old vs New SouthIn Flannery O'Connor's stories, 'A Good Man is Hard to Find' and 'Good Country People,' a change from the old south to the new south is quite evident. O'Connor uses these stories to show the differences between the old and new south and to voice her disapproval as to what the south was becoming. What upset O'Connor about the new south can be shown by carefully