This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Grant Of Immunities To Officials Of Foreign Nations And International Organizations

1961 words - 8 pages

WHAT IS THE RATIONALE FOR THE GRANT OF IMMUNITIES TO UN CIVILIAN PERSONAL AND HOW, IF AT ALL, DOES IT PREVENT ACCOUNTABILITY FOR MISCONDUCT BY CIVILIAN PEACEKEEPERS?

INTRODUCTION
The grant of immunities to officials of foreign nations and international organizations is a widespread and accepted practice in international relations and not without good reason. These immunities and privileges play a crucial role in enabling such persons to carry out their duties effectively without the interference of political or coercive influences.
However as the well known saying goes, power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Granting absolute immunities is also hence, problematic as ...view middle of the document...

This is premised on the notion that such individuals must be empowered to carry out their duties without undue interference from the host state. This traditional idea of diplomatic immunity forms the basis for immunities granted to UN officials as well.
This rationale can be found reflected in the UN Charter itself which states as per article 105 that:
(i) the Organization shall enjoy in the territory of each of its Members such privileges and immunities as are necessary for the fulfilment of its purposes;
(ii) representatives of the Members of the United Nations and officials of the Organization shall similarly enjoy such privileges and immunities as are necessary for the independent exercise of their functions in connection with the Organization.
Therefore the first basis for immunities for UN personnel flows from the charter itself.. However it is pertinent to note that such officials are solely granted a limited, ‘functional’ immunity as per the words of the Charter. The logical rationale that would therefore flow is that all acts falling outside the scope of such individual’s ‘functional’ or official are not within the purview of the Chartered immunity and may be prosecuted.
The convention on immunities and privileges makes the position clearer, conferring direct immunity on UN officials, civilian staff, military observers, and ‘experts on mission’ which include members of Civilian Police from all forms of legal process unless such immunity is waived by the Secretary-General. It also empowers the Secretary-General to grant immunities.
In the case of peacekeeping missions specifically, in practice, immunity is granted under Status of Forces Agreements (SOFAs) concluded between states, providing for the jurisdiction governing military forces and in certain instances civilian personnel, in a foreign state. SOFAs typically permit sending states to exercise exclusive criminal and civilian jurisdiction over its citizens that form part of a peacekeeping mission abroad.
In the case of peacekeeping missions immunity is particularly important as the states involved are generally post conflict nations with unstable political environments and wherein normal machinery of law and order does not exist or has been severely compromised. In such delicate situations the threat of liability would deter such officials from executing their duties with decisiveness. Moreover, it is also highly questionable whether the courts of such states mired by armed conflict and with crippled legal machinery would even be able to adhere to international standards of due process in such trials. Therefore allowing foreign personnel to be tried by such courts may be considered risky and inappropriate.
Furthermore, in the case of civilians especially, who are not empowered to carry arms for their own protection, the threat of impunity by the state they are functioning in would greatly compromise their ability to work effectively unless they are granted...

Find Another Essay On The grant of immunities to officials of foreign nations and international organizations

Did the United Nations and the International Community Fail to Prevent the Rwandan Genocide?

1795 words - 7 pages Did the United Nations and the International Community Fail to Prevent the Rwandan Genocide?In 1994 in a period of 100 days approximately 800, 000 Rwandan Tutsis and moderate Hutus were killed by Hutu extremists in what was undoubtedly the largest genocidal attack since the Jewish holocaust in the Second World War. The tragedy lay not only in the events which unfolded but the incredibly disappointing response from the rest of the world in terms

League of Nations and United Nations

945 words - 4 pages bypassed the UN and went on to invade Iraq with the reason that 'Iraq possesses weapons of mass destruction which threatens the security of the world' without any solid evidence. The United Nations Organization was created with the objective of ending all armed international conflicts by negotiations and peaceful conflict resolution. However it did nothing, even though there were oppositions from France, Germany and Russia. If the United Nations

The League of Nations

1569 words - 6 pages questions include the main aims of the league, countries not being in the league and how it weakened it and explaining how successful the league was in 1920's and 30's.In January 1918 Woodrow Wilson set up 14 points which included a very important one, number 14 was 'An international organisation to be set up to protect the independence of countries and settle disputes' which was to be called 'The League of Nations' and the 14 points, Woodrow

The League Of Nations

752 words - 4 pages The League of Nations, a former international organization, was formed after World War I to promote international peace and security. The basis of the League, also called the Covenant, was written into the Treaty of Versailles and other peace treaties and provided for an assembly, a council, and a secretariat. Because the peace treaties had created the League of Nations, the League was bound to uphold their principles. but however, it became

The League of Nations

680 words - 3 pages isolationism, which meant that the USA is not to pay attention or take part in any international conflicts.A major problem which the League faced was that at no time were all the major nations of the world members (The Modern World, page 30). The USA never joined; Germany was only admitted until 1926 but left in 1933 after the disarmament issue. Japan left in 1933 after attacking Manchuria and was followed by Italy in 1937 after they invaded

The Wealth of Nations

1072 words - 4 pages : Locke, Steuart, Mandeville, Petty, Cantillion, Turgot, not to mention Quesnay and Hume again. Smith took from all of them: there are over a hundred authors mentioned by name in his treatise...The Wealth of Nations is not a wholly original book” (1999). Rima disagrees to some extent saying that it “contains remarkably few references to the writings of other authers and that Smith was perhaps less scholarly in this regard than he might have been

The League of Nations

1292 words - 5 pages The League of Nations was created during the conference in Versailles, France, 1919, when Woodrow Wilson, the president of United States came up with fourteen points. The League of Nations was a point of Woodrow Wilson's fourteen points. It was created to stop wars by working out the problems with each other, to improve the world, to get rid of weapons, and to enforce the Treaty of Versailles. The League of Nations wasn't welcomed in the United

The Wealth of Nations

993 words - 4 pages The Wealth of Nations Adam Smith’s famous attempt to explain the nature and causes of the wealth of nations rests on several crucial assumptions about human nature which in turn rely on false universalism and questionable dichotomies. To begin with, Smith makes roughly three claims about human nature. Primarily, Smith assumes that self-interest is inherent in all human beings. As opposed to animals which rely on benevolence, in opposition

"To What Extent Is Ralph Bunche's Vision For The International System The Best Benchmark By Which We Should Measure The Effectiveness Of The United Nations Today"

1105 words - 4 pages present has perused these set of goals with flying colors, there are hundreds of aid organizations which operate with the U.N and these agencies really make life easier for these people.Bunche also urges the U.N to spread democracy on virgin lands. Democracy is built on the foundation that everyone can reason, and only when everyone thinks and contributes to their respective government that everyone's voice will be heard and answered. At present

International Relations to 1970: Examine the reasons for the United Nations intervention in the Gulf War of 1991. Was this intervention justified?

1698 words - 7 pages The United Nations intervention in the Gulf War of 1991 represented a controversial turning point in the development of the organization, despite having a firm legal basis and adhering to its purposes and principles. The Iraqi invasion of Kuwait on 2 August 1990 was met with unanimous UN condemnation, imposing sanctions and calling for the withdrawal of Iraqi troops. UN motivation for intervention was based primarily on institutional aims and

Rights and Wellbeing of Children: United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund

634 words - 3 pages opinion, United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund (UNICEF) is the most effective user. UNICEF promotes the rights and wellbeing of every child in 190 countries and territories, focusing on reaching those in greatest need. It has a huge following. It regularly tweets about the problems related to the children worldwide, their status in emergency situations, what are they going through and what is being done to help and support them. UNICEF

Similar Essays

False Promises And Failures Of International Organizations

1176 words - 5 pages to enforce its purposes, is either corrupted or disunited. With reference to these criteria, I would like to analyse three best-known IOs in the world – League of Nations, United Nations and International Monetary Fund – explain their failures with provided case studies and bring probable solutions to the problems for these IOs. The League of Nations The first International Organization, which I would like to analsye is the very first

Supporting Organizations Of International Trade Essay

1978 words - 8 pages International Trade and policies Different countries have diverse governments, policies, currencies, monetary systems and many diverse products. This is certainly one motive why international trade is extremely complex. In today’s fast growing market and the development of international trade amongst nations has initiated many policies to be enacted and a need for international organizations. International trade policies entails the joint

The Ways In Which Social, Cultural, Economic, Legal And Political Differences Among Nations Affect The International Business Of South Korea

1098 words - 4 pages to nations that would try to use these weapons against other countries. "Recently, the regime has placed emphasis on earning hard currency, developing information technology, addressing power shortages, and attracting foreign aid, but in no way at the expense of relinquishing central control over key national assets or undergoing widespread market-oriented reforms." (http://www.countryreports.org/content/koreanorth.htm)North Korea's legal system

Biography Of Ulysses S. Grant And The Civil War

675 words - 3 pages General Ulysses S Grant is, militarily, the reason why the Union was preserved, and why the Civil War did not extend past April 1865. Ulysses S Grant born Hiram Ulysses Grant was born on 27 April 1822 in Pleasant, Ohio. Grant and his family moved to Georgetown, Ohio, just one year after his birth. Grant was a graduate of West Point in 1843 and was commissioned as a second lieutenant in the 4th U.S. Infantry stationed in Missouri. Grant was