This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Great Debate Essay

1940 words - 8 pages

The Great Debate

Introduction:
I'd like to know why, the other day, I had this random thought:
"I'm a bit hungry. I'd like to eat a carrot. "
Two theories would explain this seemingly unimportant thought as follows:
Behavioural
- As a child, you received positive verbal reinforcement for eating a carrot, and still expect such positive factors to happen if you continue such behaviour.

Psychoanalysis
- You are trying to suppress your hidden cravings for violence and sex by sublimating your energy into random thoughts, although some unconscious "id" needs are being shown - after all, a carrot is a phallic symbol.

In the first part of this paper I shall summarise the concepts of Psychoanalysis and Behaviour theories, as in my view theory in itself is an argument for a concept. Theory is a collection of propositions to illustrate principles of a subject (Oxford Dictionary, 1976). Secondly this paper explores similarities concerning the theories, eventually leading to a conclusion concerning their significance in today's therapeutic arena.

Freud's Psychoanalytic Model:-
The data and observations are gathered from case studies of clinical practice in psychoanalysis, as well as from Freud's self-analysis. The key motivational forces are sex and aggression; the need to reduce tension resulting from internal conflicts. Personality is structured around three interacting components (id, ego, superego) operating at three levels of consciousness (conscious, preconscious, unconscious). Developmental emphasis is on fixation or progress through psychosexual stages; experiences in early childhood (such as toilet training) can leave a lasting mark on adult personality. Origins of disorders are unconscious fixations and unresolved conflicts from childhood, usually centring on sex and aggression.

In arguing that behaviour is governed by unconscious forces, Freud suggested that people are not masters of their own minds and that behaviour is greatly influenced by how people cope with their sexual urges (Weiten, 1995, pg11). Most psychologists viewed psychoanalytic theory as unscientific speculation that would eventually fade away, but by the 1940's psychoanalysis was so popular that it threatened to eclipse psychology entirely. (Hornstein, 1992). Because of the popularity of psychoanalysis, psychologists were forced to apply scientific methods to the topics of personality, motivation, and abnormal behaviour. In studying these topics, many of them saw merit in some of Freud's concepts (Rosenzweig, 1985). Freud re-awakened popular interest in the importance of the dreaming mind and stressed the healing power of interpretation by an expert psychoanalyst. (Siegel, 1985).
"To be concerned with dreams is a form of self-realisation"
C. G. Jung

Therapy:-
What happens in psychoanalysis is that people tell stories with meanings, metaphors and symbols. They tell them again and again, in search of insight,...

Find Another Essay On The Great Debate

The Great GMOs Debate Essay

3174 words - 13 pages . In Asia, redistribution is not the answer because the country has an enormous population of which many live at the hunger level on a daily basis (Brush, 2001). In Africa, food production has decreased, not increased (Brush, 2001), and both Asia and Africa are great examples of why the pro-GMO camp believes that GMOs are the answer world hunger. Biotechnology of GM foods makes agriculture more advantageous than traditional farming because the

The Great Beef Debate Essay

1936 words - 8 pages Given the sizes of the European and American economies and the amount of trade between them, it is inevitable that disputes will arise. I will focus on the continuing clash over the European ban on hormone-treated beef and the recent dispute over American steel safeguard measures. These two trade disputes represent different types and different issues within the trade relationship, although both expose weaknesses in the WTO system. The beef

The Great Uniform Debate

797 words - 4 pages Have you even considered how a student feels about wearing uniforms? In fact, almost 65% of students dislike them. This number illustrates that more than half of the students object the uniforms. Although students may be required to wear uniforms because of the inappropriate clothing some wear, a school’s dress code is much more beneficial. Wearing uniforms will constrain the student from expressing their creativity through clothing: as a result

The Great Debate

850 words - 4 pages pros and cons when implemented in society. The battle between these two ideological works its way throughout society alternating between the protests and debates in the U.S. today to the great terror of the Cold War. Laissez fair economics remained popular for many years after their creation during the Enlightenment era. Many governments had seen the benefits of allowing their people to govern their own economic policies business grew

the great debate

630 words - 3 pages Geographical issuesToo often, we become so consumed by what presents to be the problem that we overlook what might be an obvious solution. The problem of urban sprawl is abundantly clear to everyone who daily needs to commute in capital cities whether by car or public transport - and the forecasts offer little relief. Melbourne's population is predicted to grow to almost 7 million in the next 40 years, while the Port of Melbourne projects that B

The Great Health Debate

578 words - 2 pages Braden SmedaMs. TaylorENG 4UOctober 2, 2013The Hottest Issue in North AmericaMichael Moore's brutally honest film Sicko debates the pros and cons of both the American and Canadian healthcare systems. Canada and the United States are the two most powerful countries in the world, however they both have two very different health care systems. Healthcare has become one of the hottest issues in North America, as neither Canada, nor the United States

The Great Debate

621 words - 3 pages -Federalist were afraid that there was great potential for the government to become corrupt and ultimately dominate the people. All three branches of the new central government went against the Anti-Federalists belief of restraining government power. They feared the government would eventually utilize its unlimited power to deprive the people of their freedoms The Anti-Federalists had every right to reject the Constitution as it was written

Leaving Home – The Great Debate

1115 words - 5 pages Traversing lands unknown to one before has always been a subject of mystery, as these foreign sights and wonders give way to many unexpected discoveries to the naïve mind. In any society, the idea of travelling abroad is still taboo in most circles – the ethnocentric ideals of most traditional cultures, while not outright forbidding, but still do look down on the practice of leaving home with goals of success. Whether it be religious thoughts

The Great Stem Cell Research Debate

1498 words - 6 pages difficult, but sometimes you don't deal with the same things you would if you were a doctor.One of the biggest controversies still in debate in the medical field is that of stem-cell research. Debates about the ethical and social limits of medical science are becoming an everyday thing. Of course, the fear that medical science is moving too fast and into areas where it doesn't belong is not new. The current pace of scientific discovery seems to

The Great Stem Cell Research Debate

1497 words - 6 pages difficult, but sometimes you don't deal with the same things you would if you were a doctor.One of the biggest controversies still in debate in the medical field is that of stem-cell research. Debates about the ethical and social limits of medical science are becoming an everyday thing. Of course, the fear that medical science is moving too fast and into areas where it doesn't belong is not new. The current pace of scientific discovery seems to

City vs Country: The Great Debate

775 words - 4 pages The majority of people can remember the time they first heard the tale of “The Town Mouse and the City Mouse,” but nowadays, the paradigms once expressed by the revered Aesop may not reflect the advancements made by society, which have changed lifestyles in both the cities, and the rural country areas. While there are many advocates on both ends of the spectrum, a clear consensus has never truly been reached. While the city is clearly favorable

Similar Essays

The Great Gaming Debate Essay

1163 words - 5 pages games. The X-Box one is set to receive games such as “SWERY's D4, Remedy's Quantum Break, Project Spark, Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare and of course, a new Halo game” while the PlayStation 4 will receive games like Infamous Second Son, Driveclub, The Witness and Uncharted 4 (Hamilton). With such impressive games, gamers can expect a bright future for both consoles but the X factor in this great gaming debate remain to be Sony’s PlayStation Now

The Great Debate Regarding Creation Essay

889 words - 4 pages The Great Debate Creation by God? The Big Bang? Books, manuscripts, scientific papers, scriptural works, documentaries, ancient artifacts, and countless web sites all deliver differing theories, most with finales of doom. One could logically suppose that a big boom did occur when this mysterious form of existence sprang into being. Attempting to argue the theories surrounding the birth of the universe, one by the hand of a Supreme Being and

The Great Debaters: The Wiley College Debate Team

1487 words - 6 pages when that day is going to come? Is it going to come tomorrow, next week, a hundred years, never? No the time for justice, the time for freedom, the time for equality is always always right now” (The Great Debaters). Emotional and Psychological factors The emotions felt by the Wiley College debate team can be seen during their debate with Oklahoma City University. After experiencing racism their entire lives, they now had the opportunity

Marijuana: The Great Debate Essay

2697 words - 11 pages attention about this drug may have played a large role in this recent increase in widespread recreational use. Kuehn (2011) concludes in her article that, “fewer teens report much danger in use—and fewer teens report disapproval of use” (p. 242). These recent changes and shifts in attitudes bring about much debate on the topic of whether these increases are good or bad for individuals and society as a whole. Even though most agree that marijuana use is