The Great Grammar Debate A Study Of Grammar's Place In The Classroom

2069 words - 8 pages

IntroductionGrammar is often defined simply as "how words and their component parts combine to form sentences" (Oxford 2001). Unfortunately, the definition of grammar and the reality of its existence in our language are neither simple nor easily definable. Linguists have for years fought over whether the "rules" of language are fixed or dynamic, and educational theorists have toiled in a parallel mêlée over how it should be taught (if it is even to be "taught" at all). This paper will attempt to pick through some of that noise and see if any sense can be made of the sense of language, as well as pose a recommendation as to where it should reside in the pedagogy of our school systems.A Little HistoryLinguists can generally be divided into two groups: "prescriptivists", or those who hold that language is set in stone by fixed rules, and "descriptivists", or those who believe that language is a dynamic entity that evolves from the cracks and patterns of actual usage (Cameron 1995). There was a time, not so long ago, in a galaxy not so far away, when the prescriptivists were the ostensible monarchy of the grammar kingdom in the United States; a time when everyone seemed fairly clear about what should be taught and in what order (Nunberg 1983). Verbs in all their complexity dominated the scene, and conjugations and inflections were learned by repeating everything until you threw up. The result was that while many grammarians-to-be understood a good deal about how English was constructed, many also found writing to be a tiresome and confusing process that did little more than tease the boundaries of sanity (Finegan 1980).All kidding aside, such a process, which requires a mastery of "the rules" before advancing to content, takes a great deal of time to master. Picturing yourself in a foreign country should be enough to realize that this simply is not very practical for many learners. In the eyes of this process, for example, a student cannot be expected to write a term paper (or even a simple paragraph) until he has passed through the "rules" stage. Neither can an English language learner feel comfortable to communicate in English if he's focused solely on whether the words he uses are "right" or "wrong."The obvious fallacies of this system did not enter into the American consciousness until World War II, when the army realized that servicemen immersed in an intense language program simply did not have the time to learn the rules of the target language (usually German, as was the case with the author's grandfather). Grammatical supremacy, consequently, gave way to a "stimulus-response system" in which learners memorized a catalog of responses to certain prompts that mirrored situations outside the classroom (Milroy 1991). Grammar from this direction is not analyzed in the classroom but, in theory, enters the consciousness by some mysterious osmosis. Unfortunately it also fails to equip students to produce original utterances of their own....

Find Another Essay On The Great Grammar Debate A study of grammar's place in the classroom

Marijuana: The Great Debate Essay

2697 words - 11 pages attention about this drug may have played a large role in this recent increase in widespread recreational use. Kuehn (2011) concludes in her article that, “fewer teens report much danger in use—and fewer teens report disapproval of use” (p. 242). These recent changes and shifts in attitudes bring about much debate on the topic of whether these increases are good or bad for individuals and society as a whole. Even though most agree that marijuana use is

The Great Debate Essay

1940 words - 8 pages , humanistic, reductionistic, etc. The practices are simply techniques and methods. The treatments of choice at any level are therefore those which most effectively promote the individual's capacity for self-awareness and self-care (Gordon, 1985). Both modalities have demonstrated effectiveness in therapy (Weiten, 1995), and although each theory undoubtedly has its' flaws there remains a place for both in the modern evolutionary

The Great GMOs Debate

3174 words - 13 pages urbanization that is currently taking place and it is transforming society into mostly urban areas because the need for rural land to farm is decreasing (Brush, 2001). GMO technology is allowing less land to be used than traditional farmers use, and the yields are being utilized for a larger population size than a traditional farmer’s crop can feed. As urban wages increase and rural wages decrease, smaller farms are going out of business, which in

The Great Beef Debate

1936 words - 8 pages not override the terms of the SPS agreement. The EU did not alter its regulations, prompting the United States to instigate tariffs against $116.8 million of European goods, mostly luxury items from France, Germany and Italy, countries that the US saw as the strongest supporters of the ban . These tariffs remained in place for years as attempts to resolve the dispute through bilateral negotiation repeatedly failed to reach a solution. In 2003

The Great Debate

850 words - 4 pages pros and cons when implemented in society. The battle between these two ideological works its way throughout society alternating between the protests and debates in the U.S. today to the great terror of the Cold War. Laissez fair economics remained popular for many years after their creation during the Enlightenment era. Many governments had seen the benefits of allowing their people to govern their own economic policies business grew

the great debate

630 words - 3 pages are key requirements to promoting rural living. Unfortunately, Government policies only threaten access to affordable health in the regions and plans to introduce changes to Youth Allowance will result in even more country kids failing to realise their potential. The rail network is of Third World standard which, in the case of Victoria, still languishes with a gauge network that our founding fathers sought to remedy through federation. But beyond

The Great Health Debate

578 words - 2 pages can come up with a resolution on the subject healthcare.Firstly, the American healthcare system is privatized, stating that all Americans must buy health insurance from health insurance companies in order to receive medical coverage. In the United Sates, fifty million Americans do not have health insurance; eighteen thousand of the previous number passes away because they cannot receive the treatment that they need, and over one million citizens

The Great Uniform Debate

797 words - 4 pages Have you even considered how a student feels about wearing uniforms? In fact, almost 65% of students dislike them. This number illustrates that more than half of the students object the uniforms. Although students may be required to wear uniforms because of the inappropriate clothing some wear, a school’s dress code is much more beneficial. Wearing uniforms will constrain the student from expressing their creativity through clothing: as a result

Linguistic Choices in The Great Gatsby A study of the linguistic choices in Scott F. Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby.

676 words - 3 pages Linguistic Choices in The Great GatsbyThe Great Gatsby emerged in the 1920's with triumphant fanfare, cementing its place as a classic American novel as well as proclaiming its classification as a modern onr. The Great Gatsby pushed the boundaries of literature by abolishing preconceived notions of viewpoint, emotional language, and examining real world issues. The presentation of death in The Great Gatsby is unusual and is dealt with in a

Determiners: A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language

2571 words - 10 pages In this essay I intend to investigate how differently one of the closed word classes, determiners, are approached in a series of pre and post corpus-based English grammar reference books, course books and practice books. And the theme of my investigation is how corpus affects the development of English teaching materials. The grammar reference books I intend to analyze and compare are “A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language” (ACGEL) and

A Critical Analysis of Fostering Diversity in the Classroom

673 words - 3 pages Fostering diversity in the class roomDiversity comes in many forms and provides a great deal of benefit to the classroom. It is beneficial to all students, public school through post secondary. These benefits are then transferred to the workplace when the student leaves the academic world and enters the labor market. San Diego Community College District Chancellor Augustine Gallego concludes "Education in a diverse environment enhances the

Similar Essays

Grammar And Writing In The Classroom

767 words - 3 pages In the article entitled “How to Teach Grammar, Analytical Thinking, and Writing”, Lynn Sams (2003) voiced and suggested methods on how grammar and writing should be taught in the classroom. This article was published in the English Journal by the National Council of Teachers of English. Sams based her research on her 16 years of experience as a high school teacher and the instructional approaches she used with her sixth, seventh, eighth and

A Classroom In The Park: An Analysis Of Place Based Education

2017 words - 9 pages that create a clandestine learning environment to teach students that even though they may be small, they can still make a big difference in the world. Ms. Deirdre Bingaman, of Donnelly, Idaho, believes that every student can make a difference in the world and has been faithfully following Dewey’s place-based education and learning methods for 20 years. She has settled down into her 5th grade classroom for 14 years now and truly loves her job

A Case Study On Traffic Congestion In Vancouver Downtown *Note That Grammar Is Not A Factor In The Grading System Of Any Ib Geography Assignment

943 words - 4 pages IB Geography 11 HLTraffic Congestion in Vancouver DowntownCommuting to, from, or within the Vancouver downtown has become a more timely business than it was in the past decades. This problem will become worse, with the increasing volume of cars traveling into downtown each day and the continual rise of residential population in the area. The number of cars commuting into Vancouver downtown daily has grown from 225,000 in 1981 to 255,000 in 2001

The Importance Of Grammar In English Instruction

3545 words - 14 pages grammar analysis (Longacre). The notional structure of Tradition begins with exposition. Exposition allows the writer to “lay out” crucial information such as time, place, local color, and participants that are involved in the narrative (Longacre 34). Tradition’s exposition includes time – July Fourth 1984, the place is a two-acre backyard owned by George Smith’s cousins. Local color would include a family picnic and a family versus family softball