The "Great Man" Theory Of History

1503 words - 6 pages

Two famous writers have presented us with opposite theories about the influence of leaders. Thomas Carlyle wrote most passionately: "Universal History, the history of what man has accomplished in this world, is at bottom the History of the Great Men who have worked here." Heroes teach us right and wrong, he said; heroes give us great inventions and discoveries. It is the great few who transform society; the multitude follows them. Modern democracy, he believed, has produced millions of fools who vote, other men who go to Parliament and palaver, and, inevitably, the few who act.TOLSTOI'S INFINITESIMAL ELEMENTSBy contrast, Count Leo Tolstoi asserted that there is no greater fool than he who thinks he makes history and believes others when they assure him he does. Not even a leader like Napoleon Bonaparte, according to Tolstoi, has any part in determining the course of history. Napoleon was the tool of vast social forces beyond his control. "Studying the laws of history," Tolstoi declared, "we must absolutely change the objects of our observation, leaving kings, ministers, and generals out of the account, and select for study the homogenous, infinitesimal elements that regulate the masses."Both Carlyle and Tolstoi are representative of long rosters of illustrious writers. Those who share Carlyle's view of the role played by men of genius tend also to be aristocratic in political viewpoint. Among the most enthusiastic have been men who believed that they themselves were to be among the great of history and that their indomitable wills could overcome all obstacles-Hitler and Mussolini, for example.By contrast, those who have agreed with Tolstoi have often been socialists. For socialism, as Marx taught it, was a triumph of the masses over the few, and of irresistible historical tendencies over individual effort-socialism being the irresistible tendency of the modern age. Tolstoi's less specific determinism has also received support from most social and natural scientists, who have hoped that by applying the theory of determinism to all events they may explain history far better than can the biographers of greatness.LEADERS ARE BOTH UNIQUE AND TYPICALLike many other puzzling problems in political science, the conflict between these rival theories dwindles in importance if we ask an appropriate methodological question: Why are we interested in the argument? What do we want to know? First, we want to discover the consequences of the acts of particular men; second, we want to explain the interaction of social forces-economic wants, nationalism, religious beliefs, and so on. If we are to understand the first problem, the peculiar combination of qualities that particular men undeniably possess become objects of serious attention. Men are the actors of politics; some men are more active than others; and the shape and direction of their activities earn them leadership, great or minor. If we are interested in the second problem, the interaction of social...

Find Another Essay On The "Great Man" Theory of History

The Guilt of a Great man

710 words - 3 pages , even the rejected ones. Hans used his guilt in this situation to help others in their time of need. Lastly, Hans took in Max Vandenburg, a Jewish run-away, fully aware of the consequences. The ultimate push of compassion and acceptance, Hans took in the fully rejected Jew that needed a place to hide. Max was Erik’s son; Hans had promised that he would do anything for Erik or his family. Hans channels his guilt into keeping his promise to the man

The History of Darwin’s Theory of Evolution

1045 words - 4 pages fossils. He was then convinced that time played an important role in the history of the Earth. In his book “Histoire Naturelle, Générale et Particulière” (1766), he noticed that some species present common characteristics and can be grouped in families. Some species titled “major” such as lion, giraffe and human present unique characteristics, and with time, by losing them, this species engendered new species referred to as “inferior”. “The Great

The History and Theory of Magical Realism

1219 words - 5 pages The History and Theory of Magical Realism       Fantasy, Magical, Supernatural, Sublime, and Realism are all several genres of literature that may be familiar to many people. However, there may be one that is not as well-known as these: Magical Realism. Although Magical Realism is mostly common in the Latin American countries, one may wonder where and how Magical Realism got its start. On the other hand, one may simply wonder what some of

The Shakespeare Theory of Seven Ages of Man

1519 words - 6 pages when needed. The article entitled “Seven Ages of Information Retrieval”, the author who is Michael Lesk explained about the history or the beginning of information retrieval based on the theory of Vannevar Bush’s 1945, Warren Weaver in 1949 and also related to theory of Shakespeare 1955 which is seven ages of man, starting from infancy and leading to senility. Vannevar Bush (1980-1974) was a leader of American science and engineering during

The History of the Great Plague

1506 words - 7 pages The Great Plague was one of the most destructive diseases ever in the history of mankind. This Plague spread through China and eventually made its way to Europe and killed around 50 million people. During this time the Great Plague dominated and brought the worst out of people. This pestilence started in Europe during the 14th century. Around this time period the population was growing rapidly and the food supply was scarce due the severe

The Great Migration: A history of Movement

1161 words - 5 pages African-American history in the Twentieth Century is best summarized by both the Civil Rights Movement, and the lesser known Great Migration, in which a large number of them made a move north, west, or overseas, between the years of 1910 and 1940. The broadest reason for this movement is the Jim Crow laws of the south, in which many of the regulations that were harmful towards those parties, whom were already affected by the institution of

The Great Gatsby The Life Of A Good Man

734 words - 3 pages The Life of a Good ManNick Caraway, the narrator of The Great Gatsby, introduces himself as a thoughtful and moral human being. He recites the advice his father gave him earlier in his life: "Whenever you feel like criticizing anyone just remember that all the people in this world haven't had the advantages you've had" (Fitgerald 1). This taught him not to be selfish even though he had material advantages over other people. I think that Tom

The History Of The Atomic Theory and Michael Farrady

569 words - 2 pages Michael Faraday was a firm believer that solid experimentation was needed in order for a theory to be supported. Whilst experimenting with electrical currents in 1819, he discovered that when a current passed through wire, it deflected the directional needle of a compass. This was the first time magnetism had been linked to electricity. From these observations, Faraday came to conclusion that electricity created some sort of magnetic field

The Great Plains and the history of the Froniter

1437 words - 6 pages The Great PlainsDo you need a paper about Great Plains History? This paper by two well known authors should do the trick.Walter Prescott Webb and Fredrick Jackson Turner were two of the most influential men to explain in detail the history of Frontier of the Great Plains. Webb and Turner differ in their interpretation of the how the Frontier movement began. Webb believed geography determines, where people chose to live whereas Turner believed

The Theory, History, and Development of Magical Realism

3678 words - 15 pages publication of Magical Realism: Theory, History, Community, edited by Lois Parkinson Zamora and Wendy B. Faris. In this book Zamora says, “Magic realism’s most basic concern [ is] – the nature and limits of the knowable. Magic realist texts ask us to look beyond the limits of the knowable” (498). Faris presents some new observations in magical realism as a literary mode in her book Ordinary Enchantments: Magical Realism and the Remystification of

The History, Theory, and Application of Avogadro's Principle

691 words - 3 pages combined forming a compound, only one atom from each element combined. However, based on experimental evidence gathered working with gasses at the time, Gay-Lussac proposed a theory of combining gas volumes: when two gasses form a unique product, they combine in ratios of whole numbers. For example, combining two volumes of hydrogen gas and one volume of oxygen gas produces two volumes of water. If this reaction had been in accordance with

Similar Essays

Leadership Theories: Great Man Theory Essay

849 words - 4 pages Chapter 1: Leadership theories Leadership theories are attempts to answer some of the question people have about leadership. These theories range from simple “armchair philosophies” about the personal characteristics and effect relationship between leaders and followers and situations. Great man theory Thomas Carleyle, an influential Scottish historian, is given credit for the dictum: “the history of the world is but the biography of great men

The Forgotten Man: A New History Of The Great Depression

1510 words - 6 pages The Great Depression tested America’s political organizations like no other event in United States’ history except the Civil War. The most famous explanations of the period are friendly to Roosevelt and the New Deal and very critical of the Republican presidents of the 1920’s, bankers, and businessmen, whom they blame for the collapse. However, Amity Shlaes in her book, The Forgotten Man: A New History of the Great Depression, contests the

The Great Chain Of Man Essay

1054 words - 5 pages himself and attempts to put him in his place by enlightening man of his presumptuousness and the wickedness of his pride. By defining man’s place in the Great Chain of Being, Pope demonstrates the complexity and intricateness of the universes’ order. Pope began writing at an early age, composing epic poetry at twelve years old and published several famous works one of which is “An Essay on Man” (Alexander Pope 87). “His writing did not strive

The History Of Massage Theory Essay

839 words - 4 pages The history of massage therapy can be traced back over 4,000 years varying in several different applications and styles. The word ‘massage’ originates from the Arabic root “mass’h” which means to touch, knead or squeeze. Massage is traced back to the Ancient Chinese, Greek and Roman history and some of the greatest medical historians and physicians of antiquity have recorded their use of massage for therapeutic purposes including the enhancement