The Great Unknown Essay

1798 words - 8 pages

We are presented with a scenario in which a friend offers me a grade-A essay to turn in as my own, but because of my moral compass, I reject his offer though I was quite tempted to accept. The question remains of whether or not I declined his offer freely, and if we are to assume that determinism is true, we must ask whether or not my decision was the result of free will. What appears to be a simple case of decision making, we will find, is loaded with arguments both for and against the existence of free will. To answer whether or not my decision to reject my friend’s offer was the result of free will, we will hypothesize the opinions of three men who would maintain starkly different ...view middle of the document...

And because, he argues, free will implies actions without cause, free will does not exist. As such, in the given scenario, D’Holbach would obviously state that A did not act freely in declining B’s offer because it is impossible for A to ever act on free will.
Libet and Liberty, or How to Ignore Scientific Data
If presented with our given scenario, neuroscientist Libet would disagree wholeheartedly with D’Holbach’s pessimistic view of free will. Libet is a libertarian who asserts that people sometimes act freely and are not completely determined. He describes the manifestation of free will as the power to veto psychological impulses and consciously decide what action to take; to some, this may appear to be a new definition of free will. However, the scientific experiment on which he bases his opinion actually suggests that, if determinism is true, free will in usual, non-causal sense may not exist.
To validate the existence of free will, Libet measured electrical impulses in the brain by attaching nodes to subjects’ scalps and asking them to flick their wrist, while they monitored a fast-moving clock and indicated when they made the conscious decision to act. Results showed that the subjects’ brains emitted unconscious electrical impulses prior to conscious awareness of desire, suggesting that voluntary action is preceded and caused by something other than conscious decision making. However, Libet does not accept the experiment as evidence against free will. He suggests that free will can be defined as a form of impulse control, the power to veto. Similarly, in our scenario, A’s decision not to accept B’s offer requires A to veto the underlying impulse to accept. This vetoing power is what Libet believes constitutes free will. Therefore, Libet would argue, the original impulse had no effective action and A exhibited free will through impulse veto.
Frankfurt’s Three (Really Complicated) Degrees of Free Will
Like Libet, Frankfurt believes free will is exercised when one chooses voluntarily what impulses to act and not act upon. As a Compatibilist, he insists that people sometimes act freely although their actions are causally determined; however, he attempts to redefine free will so it does not conflict with determinism. According to his theory, free will can only exist when one satisfies Three Degrees of Freedom, which are specific combinations of interlaced desires that he describes as follows: First Order desires are desires to perform certain actions; Second Order Desires are desires to have certain desires; the Will is a First Order desire that one acts upon; and a Second Order Volition is a desire that a certain desire be acted upon, thereby becoming Will. These desires formulate the following Three Degrees of Freedom.
Freedom of Action (1) is fulfilled by one acting upon a Will; Freedom of the Will (2) is satisfied when Second Order Volitions allow desires to become the Will. Lastly, having a Will that is Free (3) requires Freedom of the...

Find Another Essay On The Great Unknown

Medical Marijuana Essay

460 words - 2 pages sclerosis and other serious medical conditions that do not discriminate between liberals and conservatives. For another, marijuana is not some exotic mystery drug whose effects are unknown; it's been around so long that it is embedded in our culture -- music, movies, television and literature(HIAASEN). Opponents of the marijuana amendment say the wording is too loose because it allows marijuana to be prescribed for other medical conditions besides the

Food Miles Essay

944 words - 4 pages warming, as this happens the sea level rises and the planets temperature increases. The earth now has 7 billion people and is going to rise dramatically in the next 2 years, this means there will be more people burning Carbon Dioxide which will make global warming occur much faster. Global Warming makes a great impact to the environment and future generations because the world will become hotter causing us to not be able to grow some plants

Poetic Perceptions of Death

4162 words - 17 pages sees only agony and a forlorn reality in death rather than it being a new beginning as in “Crossing the Bar.” In conclusion, Tennyson showed great contradiction and ambivalence towards death in his poems. As, immediately following his dear friend’s death, Tennyson “portrays death as an entity that follows the author.” Haunting him through each and everyday as seen in the way Mariana begs for death and salvation throughout “Mariana”. However

The Tone of Irony in The Unknown Citizen

1997 words - 8 pages “The Unknown Citizen,” a poem written by W.H. Auden, alludes to a time of great change in American history, where the poem is meant to mock the government’s viewpoint of the perfect role model for an unrealistic, impractical citizen. The author, W.H. Auden, writes and intends for the historical context of his poem to be in the late 1930’s, when America was going through the Great Depression. Citizens were losing a sense of nationalism for

Uncertainty

1759 words - 8 pages her life will continue to get worse. However, Ozeki once again does not allow her to fall victim to that feeling and gives her a reason to continue living. Nao is able to meet her great-grandmother, Jiko, and learn the beauty of Zen and meditation. Through that and the death of Jiko, she conquers her fear of the unknown and learns to accept the uncertainty instead of letting it consume her. By talking about Nao’s and her father’s suicidal

not so perfect

669 words - 3 pages In W. H. Auden’s poem the “The Unknown Citizen”, the words portray a perfect man in society. As someone reads the poem a person can easily visualize a depiction of exactly what the poem is titled, a citizen that is not known at a personal level. That is why someone needs to read between the lines to unearth significance, animosity, and purpose to the poem. The poem, “The Unknown Citizen”, has no true struggle as someone reads through the

Trench Warfare: Hell on Earth

1185 words - 5 pages The Great War, fueled by the excessive pride of each country, devastated the world. Each side felt superior to the other and would not stop until it emerged as the victor. These countries altered the style of fighting from a primitive face-to-face combat to systematic style of battle through trenches. To adapt to this style, countries developed new weapons and tactics to prevail over their enemies. But, the war simply remained a draw. Trench

A Journey into the Soul in Heart of Darkness

1618 words - 6 pages ; Marlow with his descriptions of the jungle, probably thought the jungle was a living thing.  "An empty stream, a great silence, an impenetrable forest."  The fear of entering such a terrible place, but how could he know it was terrible unless he entered it?  The answer is simple, the only way Marlow can be scared is if he can already identify fear.  Fear is unknown just like the soul until it is found, and can

Japan and how militarism effected it - 20th Century History - Research Paper

855 words - 4 pages population, under the militaristic ideology japans economy flourished because the emperor made considerable efforts to employ and utilize the population by increasing building railways and investing large amounts of money in heavy industry. However when the great depression struck in 1929 the price of silk dropped 50% and agricultural workers were severely underpaid because of this. One can only assume if they did not have such a high western

Jabiluka Uranium Mine and How It is Monitored and Data Collected

1409 words - 6 pages catchment areas, one area is located near the mines and one is not (Australian Government, unknown). Air quality assessment includes the monitoring of radon gas and dust, which takes place all year round (Australian Government, unknown). Radon monitoring takes place at stations near the Mudginberri community (near Jabiluka) and in Jabiru (near Ranger Mine). Though these methods are great and keeps an eye on things accidents still occur. On the 7th

Some Unexplainable Necessities

2047 words - 8 pages “There are things known and there are things unknown, and in between are the doors of perception,” stated Aldous Huxley. Cannery Row has a simple premise: Mack and his friends are trying to do something nice for their friend Doc. Mack hits on the idea that they should throw a party, and the entire community rapidly becomes involved. Unfortunately, the party rages out of control, ruining Doc's lab and home. In an effort to return to Doc's good

Similar Essays

The Great Unknown: Steven Spielberg’s Close Encounters Of The Third Kind

2107 words - 8 pages Why do we fear the unknown? In the process of answering this question, science-fiction genre films successfully capture the history of American society at distinct points in time. The genre is so closely linked to social and historical contexts that its development relies solely on this connection. Sci-fi myths and conventions have remained static for decades, and the only measurable change in the genre lies in the films’ themes (Gehring 229-230

Dover Beach By Matthew Arnold Essay

1561 words - 6 pages what he saw as his country's destructive self-confidence, Arnold despaired that the advancement of knowledge should be attended by the loss of human feeling (Rosenblatt). England was the first country to enter into the Industrial Revolution (Unknown). At this time, England was at its prime, one of the leaders of the world, and great exhibition. This great time was known as the Times of Trouble (Unknown). The movement and machinery were

Shakespeare's Misrepresentation Of Julius Caesar Essay

869 words - 4 pages entirely accurate, it is of great importance to literary scholars and those who can enjoy such art. Shakespeare’s purposeful neglect of the flaky rumor surrounding Caesar’s life and to accurately portray his true biological and marital relations gave Shakespeare the opportunity to portray the story with morals and the consequences of one’s actions as the root. That way, we could not judge any of the characters for who they really were. His

The Impact Of Societal Standards Essay

985 words - 4 pages of “The Unknown Citizen” the author uses the first person pronoun, “we,” “had anything been wrong, we should certainly have heard.” (Line 29). This statement shows how the man was really nothing more than what people thought of him. In “Barbie Doll” the woman tried to “exercise, diet, smile and wheedle” (Line 14) to rid herself of her “great big nose and fat legs” (Line 6), which were seen as undesirable by her peers; at one point she realizes she