This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Greco Persian Wars Essay

1470 words - 6 pages

If history has taught us anything about the past it is that the views of the past are for the most part negligible to change which is why it is possible to find a variety of interpretations and explanations for one single event. No truer claim can be made about the Greco-Persian War of 5th century BC as an examination of Paul Cartledge and Peter Green’s work as influential writers in comparisons to other historians of this field can yield several points of interests where there has been coherence but also conflict due to their treatment of ancient sources. More importantly is that by comparing Cartledge and Green’s work it is possible to see how representative their work is of the academic ...view middle of the document...

Green adds on to this calling Herodotus’ The Histories at most a ‘semi-rationalised fantasy’. Cartledge and Green are highly representative of other historians in their use of the same sources to explore the Persian Wars but they are strongly speculative of the degree that the sources truly depict the past.
Cartledge poses great criticism of Herodotus as he claims him to be bias in his work and flawed in history making by personalising his views on Sparta which led to a one-sided approach. This attitude has be attributed to many others primary sources relating to the wars including the ‘Oath of Plataea’, a marble stele inscription found in Athens which supposedly marked as a dedication to an oath sworn prior to the Battle of Plataea. Cartledge denounces its authenticity and rather sees the stele as a product of Athenian propaganda that was used as a religious offering due to its discovery near a religious shrine. Green is more accepting of the oath but casts doubt into where the oath was actually administered. The ancient Greek historian, Ephorus believes it was at the Isthmus but Green argues that this was unlikely considering Pausanias and Aristeides haven’t met at this point to make the oath. Lycurgus of Sparta suggested that the oath was made at Plataea but Green argues that this point would be too dangerously late considering their proximity to the Persian army. Green’s personal opinion is that the first meeting between Pausanias and Aristeides at Eleusis seems to be the most logical location of where the oath was made. On the topic of the Oath of Plataea Cartledge and Green are divided as representatives of scholarly opinions as Cartledge rejects its existence and Green while agreeing that it could exist provides his own proposal of where the oath occurred.
Many of Cartledge’s criticism of Herodotus are valid as they are evident weaknesses in his work but other historians have been exploit these weaknesses by addressing how the context of these biases may in fact be informative by letting the reading understand the psyche of the people involved in the war. While Cartledge see the symbolic meaning of Thermopylae as constructs of Herodotus’ exaggeration and embellishment in order to ‘preserve the fame of important and remarkable achievements produced by both Greeks and non-Greeks’ other historian Green included argue that perhaps if the battle itself did not contain the significants that it did than it would have not led up to the climax at the battle of Salamis and Plataea. The divide between Cartledge and Green’s work stands out boldly when the authors interpret symbolic imagery behind the sources they use which stipulates that they their works are not necessarily representative of each other completely.
The immortals that were mentioned by Herodotus employed in the Battle of Thermopylae were often depicted as elite heavy infantry that served as counterparts to the Spartans but modern interpretations have been divided on...

Find Another Essay On The Greco-Persian Wars

Assess the contribution of Athens to the Greek victory in the Persian wars

2029 words - 8 pages Greece's conflicts with Persia in the Persian Wars lasted from around 499 BC until 448 BC and through Greece's multiple victories at Marathon, Salamis, Plataea and Mycale, eventually ended with Persia being repulsed. As one of the two super powers of ancient Greece, Athens played a considerable role in the Persian Wars. This can only be said as far as that it was in fact the genius of the Athenian leaders more then Athens as a state which

The Heroism, Divine Support, and Greek Unity Displayed in the Persian Wars

2296 words - 9 pages In early fifth century BC Greece, the Greeks consistently suffered from the threat of being conquered by the Persian Empire. Between the years 500-479 BC, the Greeks and the Persians fought two wars. Although the Persian power vastly surpassed the Greeks, the Greeks unexpectedly triumphed. In this Goliath versus David scenario, the Greeks as the underdog, defeated the Persians due to their heroic action, divine support, and Greek unity. The

The Conquest Of Greece

1132 words - 5 pages The Conquest of Greece Swords clashing together, Athenians and Spartans standing side by side trying to fight the murderous Persians who are on a conquest to conquer all of Greece .The Persian empire was located on the continent of Asia, and it existed between 530 B.C.E to 330 B.C.E .The Greco -Persian war started in 479 B.C.E when the Persian empire (modern day

Greece-Persia wars

798 words - 3 pages , known in Western history as the Persian Wars, or Greco-Persian Wars, lasted 20 years--from 499 to 479 BC.Persia already numbered among its conquests the Greek cities of Ionia in Asia Minor, where Greek civilization first flourished. The Persian Wars began when some of these cities revolted against Darius I, Persia's king, in 499 BC.Athens sent 20 ships to aid the Ionians. Before the Persians crushed the revolt, the Greeks burned Sardis, capital

Greco-Roman Traditions

1659 words - 7 pages dedicated himself to reading works such as Almagest and Isagoge. Already a master of the Koran at a young age, Avicenna built his mind from the teachings of Aristotle and became a prominent poet, doctor, scientist and most importantly a philosopher. Avicenna was encouraged to combine Greco-Roman traditions and philosophies into his faith and devotion to the Koran. Islamic culture integrated heavily Arabic, Byzantine, Persian, and Indian traditions

Misconceptions Concerning the Battle of Thermopylae

3489 words - 14 pages ." Battles of the Ancient World. London: Amber, 2011. 11,46,,51+. Print. Facho, Michael C. "Greco-Persian Wars: Battle of Thermopylae." History Net Where History Comes Alive World US History Online GrecoPersian Wars Battle of Thermopylae Comments. Military History Magazine, 14 Apr. 2007. Web. 23 Jan. 2014. Grant, Michael. "Thermopylae." The Classical Greeks. New York: Scribner's, 1989. 11,16+. Print. Grundy, Gregory B. "The Battle of

Untitled

1557 words - 6 pages The Role of Women in Greco-Roman Society: As Reflected in Classical Mythology The Greco-Roman society was a very patriarchal society. This is reflected throughout the myths in classical mythology. By looking at the classic mythology we will see that the roles women portrayed are very different than women's roles in today's society. Although there are a few similarities to women's roles in today's society, their roles are more like those

Power and Politics: Athens' Fall from Grace

773 words - 4 pages Greco-Persian wars came to an official end. The League however, did not disband, and instead continued until the end of the Peloponnesian war. Even though the Delian League began as a pact between city-states, it slowly progressed towards a union of countries under the power and influence of Athens. Athens controlled not only the resources, but also the navy of the Delian League, giving them the opportunity to usurp their authority over the

AJDNJDF

1598 words - 7 pages Xerxes invasion of Greece in 480BC and the Sicilian expedition by Athens in 415BC were both spectacular failures that showcased the unnecessary and unambiguous Imperial Aggression to acquire any strategic advantage rampant during the Greco-Persian and Peloponnesian Wars by not only the Persians but also the Athenians. They significantly share the fact it was ineffectual military command, inadequate knowledge of the topography and hubris that led

Athens in the 5th century B.C.E: Athenians’ Golden Age

764 words - 4 pages Throughout the centuries, civilizations have prospered and fallen with only their effects left on the world as their evidence of their existence. Ancient Greece is widely accepted as the most influential civilization ever, with the Golden Age of ancient Athens being its pinnacle. The Golden Age of Athens began when Athens became the most powerful Greek city-state, centralizing their power following their victory of the Greco-Persian wars

The World without the Seven Years’ War

1271 words - 6 pages Before and during the Ottoman revolution, Persia saw her economy, now benefiting from strong trade from India and the East coming through the Suez Canal, rocket ahead of the struggling Afro-Greco-Ottoman Empire, but with trade freed up in the empire, they had once again become the dominant state, meaning their recent gains in the east did not go unnoticed. A war with Arabia over Islam becoming "too secular" saw the Ottoman Constituent gain

Similar Essays

Why The Greeks Won The Greco Persian War

1576 words - 6 pages Why the Greeks Won the Greco-Persian War There are times in history that something will happen and it will defy all logic. It was one of those times when a few Greek city/states joined together and defeated the invasion force of the massive Persian Empire. The Greeks were able to win the Greco-Persian War because of their naval victories over the Persians, a few key strategic victories on land, as well as the cause for which they were

Crucial Battles Of The Persian Wars

2004 words - 8 pages ANCIENT HISTORY ASSESSMENT TASK - Ben PilgrimSalamis or PlataeaThe Ionian revolt provoked the Greeks and the Persians to start what is known as the Persian Wars. With the large pockets of Ionians living in Persia getting more and more discontent, a revolt was imminent. The first thing the revolting Ionians set out to do was to rid the Ionian cities of tyrants and set up democracies in their place. The Ionians were not alone, the Athenians sent

The Persian Wars And Their Effect On Western History

1053 words - 4 pages The two Persian Wars, the first lead by the Persian Emperor King Darius in 490 B.C. and then the second by his son Xerxes from 480 -479 B.C. are often considered to be a crucial turning point in western history. The empire once known as Persia is now made up of the modern day countries of Iran, Iraq, Turkey, and Afghanistan all eventually following the Islamic religion. Most of their neighbors in the region are also Islamic states, compared to

Effects Of The Persian Wars On Sparta And Athens

337 words - 2 pages , causing the beginning of the Persian Wars.The Athenians praised the gods, mainly Zeus and Athena, for the winnings in the war. Winning gave Athens confidence even though the war caused Athens to be left in ruins. The Athenians went on to produce their amazing civilization. One of the most important results of the wars was that Athens was established as the dominant Greek naval power. This gave Athens the opportunity to create a widespread empire