The Handsomest Drowned Man In The World And The Drowned Giant

2338 words - 9 pages

Write a comparison of The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World and
The Drowned Giant, commenting in detail on the ways in which the
authors' use language to convey their respective themes.

"The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World" by Gabriel Garcia Marquez
and "The Drowned Giant" by J.G. Ballard are both short stories written
with similar plots but explore extremely different themes. In this
essay I am going to compare the theme, plot, setting, language choices
and stylistic effects between the two short stories and how all these
relate back to theme itself.

The themes of the stories are totally different. They are both about
how societies react to the external world and exotic things, but the
meanings are exactly opposite. In Marquez's story, an exotic drowned
giant was found on the beach next to a poor, small village, but soon
accepted into their homes and loved by the people with respect and
pride. Since the village men had no knowledge to anything beyond their
small area of nearby villages, their horizons were extremely narrow
and had never seen such a beautiful man before, so he was treated as
God and even gave him identity and buried him in the nicest way they
could offer. Because of the large drowned man, the village men had
realized the ugliness of their own society and how simple and plain
lives they lived. The drowned man here brought inspiration and change
to the village with no ambition, no dreams and no knowledge about the
outside world-and motivated them, bringing 'colour' to their lives and
making them realize how simple, plain and uncivilized they lived and
gave them faith and hope and inspiration to a brighter future and a
way to civilize themselves and their society. In contrast, in
Ballard's story, the theme is completely different. A gigantic,
enormous giant the size of a ship had appeared next to the city but
also on the beach. The giant was much huger in size compared to
Marquez's story, but he was never accepted into the society. The
crowds of people, except for the narrator never believed in what they
saw and took him as some joke and amusement. The crowds took no
respect to the giant and climbed all over him and destroyed him. After
the excitement wore down, no one cared about him anymore and was left
there to rot. The giant was never accepted and was always treated as
an outsider and the people rejected any humanity of him. In this
story, the theme Ballard explored is that people in civilized places
see amazing things happening everyday, but it is always ignored and
prefers the old, lazy and boring life, no one prefers any change to
doubt their knowledge and society. Society needs something to have
faith in, to inspire us and give us hope, but in Ballard's story, the
change was rejected.

At the beginning of the story, the settings of the two stories are
very similar, but tell different details on the setting. Marquez
described the first children who found out about the...

Find Another Essay On The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World and The Drowned Giant

Andre The Giant Essay

1029 words - 4 pages with fellow wrestlers and fans and eat and drink massive amounts. Andre was actually pronounced at one time, “the Greatest drunk alive” It was said that Andre would Drink over 7000 worth of calories in booze a night. Andre the Giant holds the world record for the largest number of beers consumed in a single sitting. These were standard 12-ounce bottles of beer, nothing fancy, but during a six-hour period Andre drank 119 of them.Sadly

Intuitions Role in the Giant Spectrum

1543 words - 7 pages there is no need for conscious reasoning as intuition takes over ones judgment capabilities. It is then that the question of intuitions role in our everyday judgment, comes about. In a multitude of case studies involving the latter question, researchers inquire about the effect of intuition upon everyday judgment calls in life and the work field. “Think before acting!” From the time a child is born they are unknowingly told to think with their

Mexico- The Latinamerican Giant

1878 words - 8 pages In the world there are clearly economic gaps amongst nations– with most of the wealth concentrated in few countries. Mexico, considered a Latin American giant, is currently labeled as a developing nation due to its less developed economic and social state when compared to other more affluent nations. The reasons as to why Mexico has not yet reached a developed state is due to a number of factors, but the most prevalent are its colonial legacy

The Interesting Man in The World

775 words - 3 pages black beard, and wearing a captain’s hat and a light jacket with a white turtle neck shirt underneath and sporting a deep tan as if he’s been on the water for a while, the man poses with a beautiful woman beside a sword fish they have caught. The man and the women are laughing uproariously as if they are having the time of their lives; both of their teeth are sparkling white. The narrator says “he is the most interesting man in the world

Man Versus Self, Man, and World: The Corrupting Power of Ambition in Macbeth

1275 words - 5 pages what is morally just, confirming how ambition is corrupting. Consequently, the battle between his desires and moral judgement comes to an end when Macbeth develops into a sinful character of immoral judgement. Macbeth’s character develops from one of a moral compass to a wicked man, which is shown when Macbeth states, " I am in blood/ Stepped in so far that, should I wade no more,/ Returning were as tedious as go o'er" (3.4.167-170). Macbeth

Significance of Organizational Change in Robbins' Awaken the Giant Within and Gladwell's What the Dog Saw

914 words - 4 pages I’ve been reading two books during the past couple of weeks, “Awaken the Giant Within” by Tony Robbins and “What the Dog Saw” by Malcolm Gladwell. Whenever I read a book, I read it with an eye towards lessons or insight I can use in organizational change. Robbins’ book is full of insight; Gladwell’s has its moments. These disparities of insight stem from the difference in construction and intent of the two books. Robbins wrote his book as a

Globalization: The Big Friendly Giant

1713 words - 7 pages to create a world without borders (West). Reaching such goal will put both the rich countries and the LEDC’s (less Economically Developed Countries) in a common ground, which allows for various positive interactions to take place. This controversial issue has two sides to it. Some people argue that globalization can damage traditions, cultures, and even countries; while others think that the benefits that it has brought and will continue to bring

The Sleeping Giant: China Agriculture

1096 words - 4 pages world. China produces an astonishing 125.9 million tons however; their nation consumes 138.29 million tons nevertheless, the United States in comparison grows 7.04 million tons of rice. I show these statistics to show the natural resources that China occupies. China's agriculture only represents 15 percent of the G.D.P because the majority of the countries income is based around technology and industry. China's government now realizes that its

One Small Step for a Man, One Giant Leap for Mankind: The Moon Landing Hoax

1428 words - 6 pages hovering in its orbit for twenty-four hours. Armstrong and Aldrin allegedly ambled over the lunar surface upon the Lunar Module’s arrival on the Tranquility Base, Armstrong reporting: “The Eagle has landed”. Upon his descent from the Eagle’s ladder, Armstrong delivered his famous words: “That's one small step for a man, one giant leap for mankind” (“The First Lunar Landing”). After arriving back to Earth at a high speed of 25,000 miles per hour

One Small Step for a Man, One Giant Leap for Mankind: The Moon Landing Hoax

2377 words - 10 pages Union for the title of the first man on the Moon (“The First Lunar Landing”). The Space race was “in the immediate aftermath of Gagarin’s orbital flight”, in which Yuri Gagarin was a Soviet who became the first man to enter space (Logsdon). Advised by NASA and his vice president, Lyndon B. Johnson, President Kennedy discovered that the use of Sergei Korolev’s existing R-7 launcher could result in success in the transference of a multiple person

Hydrogen Energy is the Next Giant in Alternative Energy

855 words - 3 pages Hydrogen Energy is the Next Giant in Alternative Energy Hydrogen economy is an alternative source of fuel and energy that does not damage the environment. Fossil fuels which is the fuel used by many countries is damaging the earth and has to be switched to a better alternative, such as the hydrogen economy. Although it is not used in many places it can substitute fossil fuels and give recyclable substances back to the society that uses them

Similar Essays

Magical Realism In "The Handsomest Drowned Man In The World" By Gabriel Garcia Marquez Essay

574 words - 2 pages An incredibly large object washes toward the shore. Not until the floating mass washes ashore, do the children realize that this is a man, a drowned man. At first, the children amused themselves by playing with the body, burying the corpse, digging it up and re-burying it over and over. Men from the village noticed their play and alerted the others in the village.The body was taken into the village, laid out on the floor, and upon examination

Misogyny In The Poem "Ode On The Death Of A Favourite Cat, Drowned In A Tub Of Gold Fishes" By Thomas Gray

1718 words - 7 pages the growth of the unsuspected reign of female poets and their ideologies may prove that he illustrates diction that relates to the treatment of women during the time his poem was published in 1748. The poet proposes the notion that women could not survive in a world full of feminine ideologies. Thomas Gray negatively critiques women by portraying them as a commodity of trade, by stereotyping their needs and desires and by depicting them as

The Giant Panda Paradigm Essay

1358 words - 5 pages The Giant Panda Paradigm The Giant Panda is a creature of mystery. Adults and children alike appreciate it for its cute, fuzzy, lovable qualities, but it is an animal that is in desperate need of immediate attention. Scientists know the basics: how and what they eat, where and how they live, and how they reproduce. The fact remains, however, that this universally loved national symbol of China is facing the threat of extinction. What

Flipkart A Giant In The Making

867 words - 4 pages Flipkart - A giant in the making Flipkart went live in 2007 with the objective of making books easily available to anyone who had internet access. Today, they’re present across various categories including movies, music, games, mobiles, cameras, computers, healthcare and personal products, home appliances and electronics, stationery, perfumes, toys, apparels, shoes – and still counting!. Wow sounds an impressive list but reaching this far