This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Helms Burton Act: Necessary Law Or Dysfunctional Policy?

5702 words - 23 pages

The Helms-Burton Act: Necessary Law or Dysfunctional Policy? U.S. policy toward Cuba, centered as it is on the embargo, is both obsolete and counterproductive. There is a near-total disjuncture between our stated objectives and the means chosen to achieve them. Not only do the means not serve the ends, it seems the US designed to work against them. With the Cold War over, Cuba is of little importance to the United States. Yet, under the Helms-Burton Act, the United States appears willing to jeopardize its vital relationships with Canada, Europe, and Mexico all in an effort to force their compliance with its Cuba policy. To place at risk that which is of major importance on behalf of that which is of little importance would certainly seem irrational. This goes far to explain why no other government supports the embargo.History of the Original Embargo Initially, the U.S. trade embargo against Cuba made sense. Imposed after Castro had nationalized all American properties without compensation, vowed to spread his revolution to the rest of Latin America, and edged toward alliance with the Soviet Union . The embargo was designed to punish Cuba for the expropriations and to raise the cost to the Soviet Union of maintaining its new relationship with Cuba. It was also meant to raise the cost of Cuban promiscuity in the rest of the hemisphere, and thus expressed a containment strategy. At first there was even some expectation that it might prove so damaging as to bring about the collapse of the Castro regime. By the end of the 1962 missile crisis, that hope was gone. Nevertheless, given the potential threat to U.S. security arising from Cuba's military alliance with the Soviet Union, the imperatives for maintaining the embargo were strong.In these early years, moreover, the embargo was not simply a unilateral measure on the part of the United States. Feeling themselves threatened by Castro's vow to project Cuba's power throughout Latin and South America, other governments joined the efforts to contain Cuba until, by 1964; all members of the Organization of American States (OAS) except Mexico had broken diplomatic and trade relations with Cuba .For its part, until well into the 1970s, the United States put forward but two conditions for rapprochement with Cuba: 1) that the latter end its efforts to spread revolution in this hemisphere, and 2) that it sever its military ties with the Soviet Union . There was no demand that Cuba become a democracy or adopt a market economy. On the contrary, in his speech before the 1962 OAS Meeting for Foreign Ministers in Punta del Este, at which Cuban membership in the OAS was suspended, Secretary of State Dean Rusk emphasized that the United States objected to Cuba's activities and policies in the international arena, not to its internal system or arrangements .The support of the OAS countries for the U.S. embargo lasted for more than a decade--or so long as they felt threatened by Cuba. By the early 1970s, however,...

Find Another Essay On The Helms-Burton Act: Necessary Law Or Dysfunctional Policy?

The PATRIOT Act is Necessary, Lawful and Effective

1788 words - 7 pages delayed notice searches will never be informed of the search, but in reality, the notices are only delayed, so, law enforcement agencies are required to notify the subject of the search within a reasonable amount of time. Another misconception is that book records can be obtained just because of what a person reads or the websites he visits. Instead, the PATRIOT act allows investigators to obtain “tangible things” in order to acquire information

The Affordable Care Act Is Necessary Social Reform

747 words - 3 pages Affordable Care Act delivers it could become a landmark social reform policy comparable to Medicare, Medicaid, Federal Housing, and Social Security. This legislation has both good and bad implications for society. The benefits of the law are targeted to those citizens who fall closest to the Federal Poverty Line. Historically, social reform is a knock down drag out political debate with clear winners and losers. In this case, the people of Texas are

the significance of the lemon law act

1337 words - 5 pages exactly this law is and how it is applied to the state of Nebraska. What exactly is the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act? Cartalk explained that the act can be defined as the following. For any product that has a written warranty, if the product or any part thereof contains a defect after reasonable number of attempts, by the warrantor to repair the defect, the warrantor must either provide a refund for or replacement of the product. Autopedia

Employment Law: The Unfair Dismissals Act

1609 words - 6 pages Employment Law The Unfair Dismissals Act 1977-2007 was set up to give clear guidelines on how an employer’s decision to dismiss an employee may be contested by an independent body. The main purpose of this Act is to shield employees from unfair dismissals. It also provides for an adjudication system and a redress system to those employees whose dismissals have been found to be unfair. This legislation does not prevent dismissals from

Capitalism in the U.S, Necessary Evil or Blatant Oppression?

648 words - 3 pages worth thelives, poverty and oppression? The answer in many minds was no.Mr. Forrest McDonald attempted to answer this question in his essay.McDonald ended his essay with a statement on the Sherman Antitrust Act. Ofthis act, McDonald stated the following: '...it would lead Americans very near tokilling the goose that had laid the golden eggs.' Trusts were what keptcorporations in power during the time of the Sherman Antitrust Act. Theobjective of

The Best Immigration Policy or the Worst?

2623 words - 10 pages The Best Immigration Policy or the Worst The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA) is viewed as one of the most important policy implementations in U.S. immigration history. As drafted, IRCA proposed to be a policy to control and deter all illegal immigration into the U.S., but the policy was truly directed at stopping the flow of Mexican immigrants that continues to be the largest immigration flow in the world. Daniel Tichenor

Are the ACT and SAT really necessary? - English 103 - Argumentative Essay

1294 words - 6 pages Casey Lane English 103 Argumentative Essay 23 October 2017 Are the ACT and SAT Really Necessary? “For the vast majority of the [Chicago State] university's graduates who scored in the middle range of the test as high school students, the ACT explained only 3.6% of the differences in cumulative college GPA” (The ACT). In the late 1800s, schools began using forms of testing to see if students were capable of attending higher education after high

Policy Analysis of The Runaway and Homeless Youth Act

2476 words - 10 pages (sexual abuse/assault), in need of increasing access to health care(Administration for Children and Families 2004). In 2004, $105,000 was used in grants under the RHYA. According to Expectmore.gov these kinds of numbers could increase within the next 5 years and policy advocates feel it is necessary. This will hand over more money to the agencies that need it most. Under the Runaway and Homeless Youth Act of 1974, these numbers and funds

Policy Problem and Solution: The No Child Left Behind Act

1652 words - 7 pages tried to Nullify (p.68), an attempt by states to declare national laws or null or void, parts of the No child left behind act. While “Connecticut opted to sue the federal government for failure to adequately fund the law” (Shelly, 2011). Why don’t all the states simply reject the NCLB and ESEA? Reliance on federal funding by the states is so strong that they have to accept the conditions in order to receive the funding they need (Shelly, 2011

Policy Analysis of the Older Americans Act of 1965

2120 words - 9 pages the age range of forty to sixty nine years, the protection of Americans exceeding seventy years of age stopped. Younger generations still have people discriminating against the elderly in the workplace. In the fiscal year 2010, (O’Shaughnessy, 2012) only about 5.1%, or 3 million people, out of the 57.8 million people age sixty and over, received services funded by the Act. These services included home delivered meals, home care, personal care

Policy Analysis: The Compassionate Use of Medical Cannabis Act

2387 words - 10 pages and Wiley on January 15, 2014 (Senate bill 1182, 2014). The bill has been referred to the Senate Law and Justice Committee and was scheduled for a public hearing on Tuesday, January 28, 2014 (Senate bill 1182, 2014). There has been no further hearing or committee action. In order to qualify for medical marijuana, a physician would complete an evaluation of the patient’s medical background and current medical condition (Senate bill 1182, 2014

Similar Essays

An Example Of The Policy Cycle In New Zealand Using Homosexual Law Reform Act 1986 As A Case Study

2653 words - 11 pages This essay will explore the Homosexual Law Reform Act as a case study of the "policy cycle". Through out this essay I will investigate the interactions which took place between actors such as politicians, interest groups, individuals which led to the emergence, formation and the implementation of the Homosexual Law Reform Act. This paper discusses the background and the leading events which set the agenda. This essay also will go on to

The Hill Burton Act Essay

1523 words - 7 pages and war, the Hospital Survey and Construction Act, also known as the Hill-Burton Act was passed in 1946. The Hill-Burton Act was to provide grants and loan to facilities for the construction of nursing homes, rehabilitation centers, hospitals and health centers (Health & Human Services, 2000). Facilities receiving these funds had three rules to follow: they weren’t allowed to discriminate based on race, color, national origin, or creed, though

The War Measures Act: Was It Necessary?

1295 words - 5 pages emergency power during a war, invasion or rebellion. It allowed the cabinet to do anything necessary for the “security, defence, peace, order and welfare of Canada” (Morton and Granatstein, 1989, p.7).The act severely limits the freedom of Canadians. It was used during World War One (1914), World War Two (1939) and the October Crisis (1970). It also has a negative effect on the esteem of Canada as it can be viewed as a hypocritical democratic

Homeland Security: The Patriot Act, Is It A Necessary Evil?

1298 words - 6 pages ? When is the line drawn on how much power the government can have? Is the Patriot Act effective enough that it is necessary? Should we as Americans willing to trade freedom for safety? Can the Patriot Act effectively stop or hinder terrorist attacks; has its stopped enough attacks to be validated? Another question is does America want a government that has that much power, how much are we as Americans willing to sacrifice, and how much more liberty’s