This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

“The Horse Dealer's Daughter” And “The Lady With The Dog”

1063 words - 5 pages

The way in which both authors portray their main characters path to finding love is quite astounding. In the short story, “The Horse Dealer’s Daughter” written by D.H Lawrence its completely unintentional, the good doctor was merely making his rounds to the people of his city when the euphoria of Mable at her father’s grave swept him to follow her that night. In the short story, “The Lady with The Dog” written by Anton Chekhov, Anna the female main character was only intended as another sexual conquest it was only after Gustov had her that he could not let go. Within both short stories there are many similarities as well as differences in the plots and what they present as well as between the main characters, in the following paragraphs.
Chekhov’s main character Gurov, a man from moscow with three children and a wife who he has a history of being unfaithful to finds himself at the crossroads of infidelity once more, however, his infidelity blossoms into star crossed lovers struggle to be together. Anna Sergeyevna, also married was simply another conquest on Gurov’s list, nothing special as his comments on , “Theres something pathetic about her, anyway” (Literature383). D.H Lawrences’s main characters, Mable and Jack Fergusson were both married unlike Chekhovs characters Fergusson did not charm Mable without having any intentions to marry, their love began when Fergusson rescued Mable from attempted suicide, she felt that him saving her was a translation of him loving her as well. This climactic scene directly differs with because Chekhov’s plot because Gurov charmed Anna, he spent time with her and took the time to form the connection needed to have Anna the way he wanted her.
The resulting feelings however, were completely unintentional because the emotions had not come when she was with Gurov crying in her room because of how sad she felt at the sin against her husband or even the sin against herself. His love for her strengthened in his return to his home in Moscow and his time away from her (Creasman1). Anna and Mable both share a key characteristic of unhappiness, for Anna it is her husband and the life of misery that being married to him entitles her too as for Mable to death of her father as well as losing the family business, the family home, and about to experience her first run in with homelessness she has every reason to be unhappy (Literature1).
The male main characters Gurov and Joe Fergusson both saved their female counterparts and drastically changed their lives whether it be literally or figuratively. In Mable’s pride she found her downfall, Fergusson had merely been finishing his rounds as a doctors assistant when he saw Mable making her way down to the pond. Mable attempted suicide and Fergusson dashed into the murkey pond to save her but in a sense this was not the only way in which she was rescued (Fulford1). In addition to them falling in love as result of his heroic actions she was too saved from a life of poverty in...

Find Another Essay On “The Horse Dealer's Daughter” and “The lady with the dog”

Pitiful Human Condition Exposed in Endgame, Dumbwaiter, and The Horse Dealer's Daughter

1544 words - 6 pages The Pitiful Human Condition Exposed in Endgame, Dumbwaiter, and The Horse Dealer's Daughter      The three stories, The Endgame (Beckett), The Dumbwaiter (Pinter), and The Horse Dealer's Daughter (Lawrence) all deal with the themes of repression, repetition, and breakdowns in communication. The stories show us the subjectivity of language and exemplify the complexities of the human condition.   Samuel Beckett arrived on earth

The Internal Conflict of Relationships in D.H. Lawrence's The Horse Dealer's Daughter

1675 words - 7 pages The Internal Conflict of Relationships in D.H. Lawrence's The Horse Dealer's Daughter Love is one of the most complex and boundless emotions that human kind experiences. There is no set definition as to what it is or how it is felt by all, to each person it is a very intimate and personal evolution of a bit of the soul. It is for that reason that it is not strange to find both Mable Pervin's and Jack Fergusson's identification of love so

The Lady with the Dog

1849 words - 8 pages Chekhov by reworking his short story “The Lady with the Dog,” almost a century after the original was published. The “infidelities” consist of transgressions in the form, characterisation and setting, and the shift of the emphasis from male to female characters. Nevertheless, comparing both stories shows that each version does not simply stand aloof from the other—they both complement each other and produce a thorough and complete picture of the plot

the lady with the dog

645 words - 3 pages Anna and Dmitri are two people with a strong desire to be together, but this is conflicted by reality. Their reality is that they are married to other people. The love that they share for one another represents the struggle that one may face wanting to break away from reality. Dmitri was a man who had been unfaithful to his wife quite often. Her imperfections seemed to be his only reasoning for this. Dmitri was most likely only in Yalta to look

The Lady With The Pet Dog

768 words - 3 pages The time period during which Anton Chekhov's The Lady with the Pet Dog (Meyer, Michael. The Compact Bedford Introduction to Literature, 165-176.) was written sets the tone for the story. Once we are aware that Chekhov was writing near the end of the Victorian era, we are propelled into the past, to a time when societal rules concerning marriage and commitment were drastically different than they are in our modern society.Immediately, we learn

The Lady with a Dog Literary Analysis

787 words - 3 pages Throughout the short story of “Lady with a Dog” many characters drastically change. Personally, I believe that the person that shows the heavier amount of change is Gurov. Of course, both Gurov and Anna change, but Gurov takes things to a different level considering his past. Gurov is at the age of forty, he has a daughter at the age of twelve and also two other sons. By this time in most adults’ life they grow up. A man of this age most of

Chekhov's "Lady With The Pet Dog"

319 words - 2 pages On the "Lady with the Pet Dog" Chekhov tells us the story of Gurov and Anna. They first meet on the Russian province of Yalta, being both of them married they ultimately decided to be involve in an extramarital relation. In one hand Guruv is the head of a family, on the other hand Anna is a woman married to a high ranked politician. After they get involved in this forbidden relationship, they fell in love with each other, but have to hide their

Contrast essay of "The Lady with the Pet Dog" by Anton Chekov and "the Lady with the Pet Dog" by Joyce Carol Oates'

752 words - 3 pages While both the original and the reworked versions of "The Lady with the Pet Dog" are interesting stories, Anton Chekov's is more compelling than Joyce Carol Oates's due to a point of view from a different character, a stronger main character overall, and a more intriguing setting.In these two stories the account of what takes place is told from opposing sides of the relationship. In Chekov's version of "The Lady with the Pet Dog," the story is

Love in Anton Chekhov’s The Lady with the Dog

1708 words - 7 pages , because it doesn’t exactly answer the question “when”. On the other hand, it is a perfect answer to describe the mysterious nature of love. Similar to the nature of love, some stories also don’t have a beginning or end. Anton Chekov has been acknowledged to be the master of this kind of stories. People sometimes describe those stories as “a slice of life”. The Lady with the Lap Dog, for that matter, is an example to both unexplained love and

"The Lady with the Dog" A forbidden love

1656 words - 7 pages "The Lady with the Dog", written by Anton Chekhov is the story of Dmitriy Dmitrich Gurov and Anna Sergeyevna. The story begins when Gurov is taking some time off at the province of Yalta, Russia. Which is located south of Russia by the black sea. Yalta is Russia's most fashionable resort. Gurov is a prominent man close to his forties with a family waiting for him back in Moscow. Disputing his marital status, Guruv is a person who dislikes being

Radical Revision Project of The Lady with the Dog

704 words - 3 pages The radical revision project that my partner and I decided to do is a scripted scene of a new ending of the short story The Lady with the Dog. My partner and I will be performing a scene in which we will meet up at the Moscow and discuss our love for one another. That is when Dmitri notices a scar on Anna’s face. He begins to panic and pace around her in devastation. Anna can’t seem to stop crying and feels completely stuck in-between a love

Similar Essays

The Horse Dealer's Daughter Essay

762 words - 3 pages single personal thought of her." (61). This shows that Jack does not know how he feels about Mabel until he hears himself utter, "I love you! I love you!" (63).In this story, "The Horse Dealer's Daughter," symbols are used as love progresses. The pond symbolizes the start of Mabel and Jack's love. The description of the pond suggests Jack's feelings for Mabel before they fell in love. Water symbolizes many things, such as, rebirth. It is a natural element that is used to describe feelings of love and happiness. Lawrence's use of symbols provide the reader with painted connections to the story and the events that shape the story.

Paradoxical Power In The Horse Dealer's Daughter

1180 words - 5 pages Paradoxical Power in The Horse Dealer's Daughter   In D.H Lawrence's "The Horse Dealer's Daughter," Mabel Pervin and her three brothers are left with debts to pay after the death of their father. To pay these debts, the Pervins are forced to sell every horse that they own. Then, they must separately create new lives elsewhere. Although Mabel's brothers have decided where they will be going and what they will be doing, as the story opens

Depression And Love In The Horse Dealer's Daughter

822 words - 4 pages The way in which events are organized in a story is important in conveying a message to the reader. In D.H. Lawrence's short story, The Horse Dealer's Daughter, the plotting of key events in Mabel's life contributes to the overall depressive effect and meaning. First, Mabel's mother dies, causing her to have extreme depression. Then, this depression leads her to seek suicide. Her seeking suicide unites her with Dr. Fergusson, who in turn

D. H. Lawrence "The Horse Dealer's Daughter" An Analysis

530 words - 2 pages "The Horse - Dealer's Daughter"D. H. LawrenceThe role of women in society is constantly an issue. D.H. Lawrences's story shows through passive natures, obedient attitudes, and shattered egos a woman struggling to live her life according to her three verbally abusive brothers."The Horse - Dealer's Daughter" is about Mabel, who tries to commit suicide by drowning herself in a pond. A young doctor, Joe Ferguson, saves her. She then believes that he