The Houses Of History, By Anna Green And Kathleen Troup

1098 words - 4 pages

In The Houses of History, many different schools of historical thought are presented and light in shed on what exactly it means to be those different types of historians. Not all historians think the same way or approach history from the same perspective, but some similar groups of thought have converged together and have formed the various types of historians that will be presented, such as empiricists, psychohistorians, oral historians, and gender historians. All of these groups can approach the same event or concept and look at them in an entirely different way simply due to the way the historical approach they are accustomed to views things.
A beginning group of historians to take a closer look at is the empiricists. The empiricists have a very strictly factual and logical view on history and how to examine it. They believe that past is both “observable and verifiable” and that through adherence to three strict principles, the past can be represented objectively and accurately. (Green, Troup 3) The three aforementioned principles can be summed up as: meticulously examining historical evidence and verifying the evidence with references, making sure the research is completely impartial and free of biases and prejudices, and using an inductive, or observational, method of reasoning. (Green, Troup 3) The empiricists seek to find universal historical truths through objective research and sticking to the facts.
The next group of historical thinkers is the psychohistorians. Sigmund Freud was the pioneer of psychoanalytic theory and psychohistory interprets history through psychoanalysis. Psychoanalytic theory helps explain the players in history through their behavior and how they operate psychologically. Psychoanalytic theory was summarized as having 3 different components: that infancy and childhood are the times that greatest shape people in adults, all people pass through the same stages of maturation, that behavior as an adult is mostly unconscious, and that everyone experiences psychological conflicts throughout their lives. (Green, Troup 60) This type of historical approach helps historians understand the people being studied in a deeper and more personal way, by delving into what shaped the person psychologically and how that affected their behavior. One example was given where a psychohistorian examined the memoirs of a man named Abbot Guiber, and in the memoirs he wrote extensively about his childhood and upbringing which gave the historian a greater insight into society of the time and place of which he lived, society of France in the 12th century. Another prominent example has been the constant psychological analysis of Adolf Hitler, a view into his upbringing and psychological development over his lifetime which helped shed some light onto what prompted and reinforced his infamous behavior and decisions.
Another important group of historians are the oral historians. Oral history is considered to be a methodology and not a theory by...

Find Another Essay On The Houses of History, by Anna Green and Kathleen Troup

History of Modern Psychology: Anna Freud

1514 words - 6 pages Male visionaries dominated in the philosophical contributions to the psychology as a formal discipline; however, many prominent women pioneered major roles in psychology history between 1850 and 1950 (Goodwin, 2005). Freud Sigmund was not only among the Freudian to build credibility in psychology field, this is because Anna Freud-her youngest daughter took career in psychology and made important contributions in the history of psychology. The

Flipping Houses and the Foreclosure Crisis

1148 words - 5 pages have made the foreclosure problems worse and have lost millions in tax dollars by helping people buy homes they could not afford. The city provided down payment loans of up to $20,000 to mostly low-income buyers. This was through the federal Afford-A-Home program. This program did little to determine whether the people actually had the financial means to afford staying in their homes. Things remained unstable because banks where mandated to make

Black and Blue by Anna Quindlen

768 words - 4 pages men and women, the varieties of people and love, the bonds between mother and child, the solace of family and friendship, the inexplicable feelings between people who are passionately connected in ways they don't understand. It is a remarkable work of fiction by the writer whom Alice Hoffman has called "a national treasure." With this stunning novel about a woman and a marriage that begins in passion and becomes violent, Anna Quindlen moves to a

Blakc and blue- by anna quindel

1091 words - 4 pages with what you have just read. The book is not clear about who is talking and who there during a particular scene. Anna Quindlen is also not clear about what is going on. In a lot of places I was not sure if Fran was having a flashback or if her husband really found her.Even though most of the setting changes are either flashbacks or the family moving to a different place, the story is difficult to follow. Other than that the only problem I had

The Characters of Leo Tolstoy's Anna Karenina

1816 words - 7 pages The Characters of Leo Tolstoy's Anna Karenina       By examining the character list, one immediately notices the value Tolstoy places on character.  With one hundred and forty named characters and several other unnamed characters,  Tolstoy places his central focus in Anna Karenina on the characters. He uses their actions and behavior to develop the plot and exemplify the major themes of the novel.  Tolstoy wishes

Ballet- A brief history of ballet incl. famous ballets, ballet dancers incl. Anna Pavlova, pointe shoes, and techniques.

3277 words - 13 pages Russia. Sir Frederick Ashton, the brilliant choreographer and director of England's Royal Ballet, became a dancer because he was smitten by the performances he saw Pavlova give when he was a boy in Lima, Peru."Leave acrobatics to others, Anna...It is positively more than I can bear to see the pressure such steps put upon your delicate muscles and the arch of your foot...I beg you never to try again to imitate those who are physically stronger

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Green Energy

871 words - 4 pages hybrids and biofuel vehicles have been introduced as alternatives to vehicles that use fossil fuels to run. There are certainly disadvantages to using alternative energy sources-- colloquially, “green” energy sources-- but the benefits of using these alternative energy sources far outweighs the disadvantages. The obvious advantage to using renewable energy sources is that these energy sources, by definition, do not “run out.” For example, if

How Dysfunctional Marriages Impacted The Lives of the Heroines of "Madame Bovary" and "Anna Karenina".

1434 words - 6 pages What are the major components of a successful marriage? Trust? Communication? Love? What happens when these vital components are missing? Could a marriage survive the absence of these extremely important elements? In the novels Anna Karenina, Leo Tolstoy and Madame Bovary, by Gustave Flaubert, there is a lack of these major factors in the heroines' marriages. The heroines of these novels are very similar; therefore it can be said that they

Legalization of Equine Slaughter Houses in the United States

1989 words - 8 pages closed in 2007, after congress banned slaughter houses by cutting funds for inspection in 2005. “But in 2011, the ban was lifted because the funding prohibition expired” (Gustin). Now, it is in debate whether slaughter houses will soon be legalized or not. United States Senator Max Baucus states, “Congress is moving closer to allowing United States’ horses to be slaughtered, with a move that allows inspections of the facility” (Baucus Praises

'Ride Frank and Anna: An analysis of Pride and Prejudice, Frankenstein and Anna Karenina

1360 words - 5 pages Frankenstein and Leo Tolstoy's Anna Karenina are each an example of iconoclastic individuals struggling in their society's expectations.The BBC production of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice, directed by Simon Langton is a carefully replicated period love story for a contemporary audience.The dialogue and repartee, is thoroughly crafted, to evoke tension, wit and flirtation in the two main characters while still remaining accessible to a modern

"Sir Gawain and The Green Knight." By Sir Gawain

1170 words - 5 pages that follow is Gawain's ironic challenge of honesty and bravery, and the consequential effect brought upon by keeping the green girdle. Sir Gawain, terrified from hearing the sound of a blade being sharpened on a grindstone, resolves his courage and proceeds to call out for the Green Knight. Gawain is answered, and in time, the Green Knight appears with a huge "Danish Ax devised for that day's deed." The Green Knight welcomes the knight, and

Similar Essays

The Decoration Of Houses Essay

2071 words - 8 pages In Edith Wharton’s first major work, The Decoration of Houses, she states that “the impression produced by a landscape, a street or a house should always, to the novelist, be an event in the history of the soul” (qtd. in Falk 23). Later in her Pulitzer-winning novel The Age of Innocence, Wharton uses her knowledge and love of architecture to develop her characters, as she had previously deemed important. Thus, she takes style of houses, their

Film Analysis Of Anna And The King

2289 words - 9 pages Film Analysis of Anna And The King When we want to analyze a film, we must know what films represent. Film is the term we use to describe a particular material and medium of communication that has certain specific properties governed by certain physical laws…use to produce particular communicative texts that formulate particular fields of symbolic meaning and effects, and meet particular sets of criteria that give

To His Coy Mistress, By Andrew Marvell And The Rights Of Woman, By Anna Letitia Barbauld

1421 words - 6 pages Throughout the poems “To His Coy Mistress” by Andrew Marvell and “The Rights of Woman” by Anna Letitia Barbauld, violence is used in contrasting ways. Marvell uses violence to manipulate his mistress into a powerless position, while Barbauld uses it to incite rebellion against just such a power structure.Though violence is not the primary thematic concern within the majority of both works, it plays an essential role in developing the storyline

“Anna And The French Kiss” By Stephanie Perkins ~ Book Report

759 words - 4 pages feels she can’t let down or leave, by falling for someone in France. Anna has a difficult relationship with her father, and so does St. Clair, which brings the two of them together. She can scarcely speak French let alone Spanish and has fervor for the cinema, where she goes to often in France when she finds out that there are several cinemas. She isn’t very feisty or weird, but just finicky and good-hearted. Étienne St. Clair is the main male