The Human Genetic Engineering Debate Essay

2276 words - 9 pages

Science is moving forward at an increasing rate every day. Just in the past decade, there have been numerous new discoveries in astronomy, chemistry, geology, paleontology, and many more scientific fields. However, some of the fastest growing subjects are in the field of biological sciences, more specifically genetics. Over the past twenty years a new genetic science known as genetic engineering has come to prominence. Genetic engineering is the direct manipulation of an organism’s genome using biotechnology, including a human’s genome. As a result, scientists have begun to experiment with altering human traits, known as “designer babies.” In response, many issues have arisen culturally, as perspectives argue whether or not the application of this science is ethical and under what circumstances it should be used, if at all. There are three primary perspectives: One side has the view that this science is a solution to the prevention of genetic diseases and should only be used under such circumstances, the second sees it as an opportunity to pick out desirable traits in children, as well as the prevention of genetic diseases, and the last position is against all acts of genetic engineering, including both the picking of traits and the prevention of genetic diseases. The largest factor when reviewing the different perspectives is whether or not one feels fixing what is naturally occurring, is natural at all. As a result of all three positions, new questions have begun to arise, including how genetic engineering will affect the human race, how the science will be tested and implemented, how the economics of genetic engineering will affect the population, and whether or not it is something that can be controlled.
The overall concern in the debate over human genetic engineering is whether the practice is ethical and safe. However, before dealing with the issues regarding the actual practice of the procedure, almost all people ignore how the actual technology and science would be tested and implemented before using it on society. Dr. Philip M Rosoff, the director of clinical ethics at Duke University Hospital, has considered this issue. He created a “thought experiment” regarding the testing and indicates that the potential dangers of implementing genetic enhancements in humans, especially highly valued traits such as intelligence, would mandate thorough testing on animals, specifically chimpanzees. The tests on them would either show good or bad results, and depending upon those outcomes, the determination of the future of the science will be decided. Hypothetically speaking, if the experiments on increasing the intelligence of the chimpanzees are effective, then we as humans are left with some huge dilemmas. One, we will have to decide whether to continue testing on more apes or not, two, is the continuation of the science ethical, and three, what do we do with these new highly intelligent chimpanzees? Rosoff suggests multiple theories on what to do...

Find Another Essay On The Human Genetic Engineering Debate

The Need for Policy Makers to Regulate Human Genetic Engineering

1449 words - 6 pages Human genetic engineering (HGE), a prevalent topic for scientists in research, is the process of manipulating genes in the human genome. Potentially, scientists can use the process of HGE to alter many biological and psychological human traits by gene modification. Currently, however, there is a large deficiency in information regarding HGE and its effects to the human body; creating a need for scientists to conduct more research and tests

Human Genetic Engineering in Beneficial to Society

1836 words - 7 pages implantation, which is used occasionally today to avoid hereditary diseases or to choose gender, genetic discoveries can become a sort of artificial evolution. By changing the genes in embryos before implantation, humanity has the potential to control many aspects of its offspring. The human race should welcome human genetic engineering, because the technology will inevitably be used, is ethically sound, and provides opportunity for advancement

Human Genetic Engineering: Dreams and Nightmares

1418 words - 6 pages at great length before further steps are taken. Works Cited Anderson, Clifton E. "Genetic Engineering: Dangers And Opportunities." Futurist 34.2 (2000): 20. Academic Search Premier. Web. 06 Feb. 2014. Black, Eric, dir. Frozen Angels. Dir. Frauke Sandig. 2005. Film. 10 Feb 2014. Evans, J. H. Playing god: Human genetic engineering and the rationalization of public bioethical debate. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2002. Print

How genetic engineering can stop human suffering.

1185 words - 5 pages approached. They are directly studying genes and DNA, the very building blocks of humans and the source of potentials, physical make up, and tendencies; the information that defines who we are and what we become. DNA also holds the information that we need to discover the cures for, and nature of, many complex genetic diseases that plague the human race and cause so much suffering. The answer to cancer and diabetes lie in our genes. Genetic engineering

Technologies and the Family Genetic engineering Discuss how four types of genetic engineering can assist with human reproduction. State and describe how each process is performed.

1590 words - 6 pages Technologies and The Family-Genetic Engineering-Human reproduction has been known to be a relatively inefficient process. As stated on the website,, the average fertile couple holds an 80% probability of fertilization for any particular exposure of egg to sperm. However, by the time of the first menstrual period after ovulation approximately half of the early embryos have failed to develop. Therefore, the probability of a

Human Genetic Engineering is a Recipe for Social Discrimination

1600 words - 6 pages "stuck" with breeding kids naturally and hope for the best like in the Savage Reservation (Huxley 32). In other words, instead of helping the human species, there is a substantial amount of harm being done to the human species. People are undermining the quality of life with something that is destroying the society little by little. Russell Powell a professor at Oxford claims that genetic engineering will have no significant impact on diversity

The Ethics of Genetic Engineering

2994 words - 12 pages the human by changing this code. Genetic engineering today has already helped many infertile patients to have children by a technique called in-vitro fertilization (Toward E01.) In October 1993, the Doctor Jerry L. Hall, a geneticist, at George Washington to University Medical Center cloned a human embryo. This set off an ethical debate. Ethicists asked why the cloning was done, and who will set the guidelines for this practice in the future

Genetic Engineering and the Public

1035 words - 4 pages found in several species, varieties and morphs. In California, Commissioner of California’s Fish and Game, Sam Schuchat, felt that there was a difference in genetic modification depending on the use of the product made.[2] The use of genetic engineering for pets can be viewed as frivolous and/or an abuse of power. On the other hand, medications such as human insulin, which have long been made through genetic modification of bacteria and yeast

The Benefits of Genetic Engineering

1018 words - 4 pages this field. Today's research in genetic engineering is bringing about new methods for curing and treating major medical illnesses. The Human Genome Project has allowed geneticists to map the genes of human beings. This project is far from complete, as the DNA sequence of humans is extremely long, yet it will eventually show geneticists which genes are responsible for certain inherited diseases. Identified genes could be repaired

Genetic Engineering is the Future

2002 words - 8 pages Genetic Engineering is the Future The debate over genetic engineering has emerged as one of the hot topics of today's political mainstream. With new discoveries happening everyday, science is coming closer to achieving perfection in the art of genetic manipulation. But is it all worth it? Some people argue that genetic engineering is a corporate scandal, and simply allows large companies to make more money. I will show through my

Genetic Engineering the Church View

1505 words - 6 pages be done using genetic engineering. Although we have a potential to harvest and already do see many advantages as a result of this, a deeper issue looms like a cloud on the horizon: are we prepared for the ramifications involved in this concept that has such high potential? At the center of the issue is the perspective of the Church. And it is through human dignity that religion and cloning are linked. Genetic engineering, and, specifically

Similar Essays

The Genetic Engineering Debate Essay

1694 words - 7 pages Harris’s ““Goodbye Dolly?” The Ethics of Human Cloning” examines “the possible uses and abuses of human cloning and draw out the principal ethical dimensions, both of what might be done and its meaning, and of public and official response” (353). While in C. Cameron and R. Williamson’s article, “In the World of Dolly, When Does a Human Embryo Acquire Respect?” discusses about the debate of genetic engineering, the authors also look at several

Human Genetic Engineering Essay

1640 words - 7 pages Human genetic engineering can provide humanity with the capability to construct “designer babies” as well as cure multiple hereditary diseases. This can be accomplished by changing a human’s genotype to produce a desired phenotype. The outcome could cure both birth defects and hereditary diseases such as cancer and AIDS. Human genetic engineering can also allow mankind to permanently remove a mutated gene through embryo screening as well as

Genetic Engineering: Is The Human Race Ready?

1491 words - 6 pages It is incredible to see how far genetic engineering has come. Humans, plants, and any living organism can now be manipulated. Scientists have found ways to change humans before they are even born. They can remove, add, or alter genes in the human genome. Making things possible that humans (even thirty years ago) would have never imagined. Richard Hayes claims in SuperSize Your Child? that genetic engineering needs to have limitations. That

Genetic Engineering: The Negative Impacts Of Human Manipulation

1712 words - 7 pages . Upon genetic engineering humans, custody battles over human embryos will emerge, becoming no different than the custody battles of children in today's world. Once a genetically engineered embryo is placed in the womb and categorized as a successful pregnancy, fights will erupt about what to do with the frozen, leftover, human embryos (Lemonick). However, parents wishing to have a genetic relationship with their child are likely to avoid a process