The Ideal Governing Society Essay

1804 words - 7 pages

The views of Hobbes and Rousseau on the state of nature are drastically different and unique. Though, both philosophers have written works on how to achieve an ideal governing society, their ideas on the state of nature contrast greatly. A wide spread of ideas are expressed by both on the state of nature and the effects that forming a state had on the population. Hobbes views it as a much more radical, while Rousseau believes the state of nature is innocent. Their clashing viewpoints allow us to challenge our own thoughts on the matter. Reading and analyzing both of their stances on the state of nature can help one greater comprehend and perceive their own views on the topic.
While Hobbes thinks that a state of nature is also a state of continual war, Rousseau holds that we are innocent and society is what corrupts us. Hobbes states that man is in a mindset of fear and selfishness whilst in the state of nature. Rousseau on the other hand argues that man was perfect in the state of nature, and changes to the state of nature brought upon discontentment and violence. He asserts that man lost his freedoms and equality in the forming of civilization. He continues by saying that the rich took excessive land and tricked the majority of the people near them into thinking they were the authorities. I think that I agree more with Rousseau and his argument that society is what corrupted man in the state of nature. For example, a young child playing in the park can be considered innocent, but if an older person comes along with drugs, eliciting them as medicine, then the child can easily become corrupted.
Hobbes argues that the state of nature is a continual state of war, every man should fend for himself. We see an example of this when he says, “The condition of man... is a condition of war of everyone against everyone” (2). He insists that man wants to bring peacefulness, but is more focused on his survival. Hobbes says man has the right to do anything necessary to protect his life. Since there is no personal ownership in Hobbes’ view of the state of nature, one can imagine that without perfect peace between men, there could be many issues arising with such freedoms. Besides the natural laws, common sense laws recognized by everyone, Hobbes does not recognize any laws whatsoever.

In much contrast to Hobbes, Rousseau believed that Hobbes was incorrect in his idea of basically dropping modern man into a state of nature. Rousseau thought that Hobbes’ line of thinking was inaccurate, that is, to put cultured people directly into state of nature, and he insisted that the true state of nature would consist of a more savage people.(1) Those who would not come into much contact with each other, but rather, would be like-minded and peaceful. Because Rousseau claimed these people were innocent, neither good nor bad, there must not have been in a continual state of war such that Hobbes suggests; at least according to Rousseau.
Hobbes'...

Find Another Essay On The Ideal Governing Society

"Society as it should have been" A description of the ideal society according to simplistic ideals and ethics.

1979 words - 8 pages reflects how I would like my ideal society to be, with the exception of Religious Belief and the anti-technology stance.Ideally, the society to kick into play would be commune based, but not entirely self-sufficient. The idea of interdependence should not be stricken from a community. Services and products would be developed by large groups of the community to ensure production and completion.All communities would be linked via a network of

Utopia. The Ideal Society. My definition of an Utopian society and what it would consist of. (written after reading Thomas More's "Utopia")

674 words - 3 pages A utopian society is a society which has perfect political and social order. When talking about a utopian society, the word perfect is synonymous. A perfect society seems close, but is really very far away. The ideal society consists of knowledge, reverence, and equality. Knowledge is the information that people acquire and use to have a better awareness and understanding of things. Reverence is having a respectful attitude towards something or

Thesis: With the variety of family situations arising in todays society, the typical well-rounded nuclear family should no longer be considered the ideal family concept.

1151 words - 5 pages diminished from the thoughts of modern families as more opportunities have opened up to allow a variety of alternative life-styles. With the variety of family situations arising in today's society, the typical well-rounded nuclear family should no longer be considered the ideal family concept. Families may now consist of only one parent or two mothers and two fathers. These images, in and of themselves, no longer make up the conservative views of

Karl Marx and Frederick Engels

1757 words - 7 pages Independence[viii] Marxism puts the responsibility of governing into the hands of every person, a hope of absolute equality. It aims to create a society that does not just allow the people to choose those that govern but in actually running the communities, the workplaces, and the society.[ix] This government insures that the people are represented because the citizens are those in charge of governing. Although this ideal equal society seems great

The Evolving Repercussions of Political Philosophy

1629 words - 7 pages In the United States, politics have become a growing philosophical ideal since the time of the Greeks and Romans. It has always been a weighted matter of importance to have a society which functions under laws and governing bodies. Through the progression of time, many of these political ideals have changed according to what the people of that time are socially and culturally in need of. One of these times was in the seventeenth century in

Niccolo Machiavelli and his influences on modern day leaders

907 words - 4 pages Allies, Hitler set his country back many years, causing them to rebuild their society and economy. To further show that war is not the most important factor of governing, is during George Bush Senior's term as a president of the United States. Two major events occurred that affected the American people tremendously. First, the Gulf war; Bush was able to resolve this situation in a short period of time and the American people commended him for it. The

An Individual's Perspective on Democracy.

1759 words - 7 pages in all aspects of the government agenda, allowing each individual to be susceptible to and responsible for all laws and reforms enacted. This is the ideal practice of a democracy based on its objective to ensure that each and every decision made by government is approved and assessed by all voting members of society, theoretically allowing for the greatest possible control by the people over the governing body. The concept of pure democracy is an

Comparing governments, communism, marxism, ect.

612 words - 2 pages becomes an incentive to be productive and keep the economy at its climax. In conclusion, if an ideal Marxist society can survive it would be the most superior form of government. Yet, I do not have faith in its existence, and the optimum alternative is a democracy where free trade and capitalism reigns.

An Analysis of Plato's Republic

1348 words - 6 pages but also the imperfect justice system of the community in great ways. Demonstrate how the passage relates to main ideas in the chapter The main idea of this chapter is arguing that the justice and governing of a society is imperfect no matter who does so. Socrates uses an analogy of a ship to define why this is a true statement on page 172 section 488 a-e in Plato’s “Republic” while relating to the precious metals of the soul in book 3 of the

PLato Vs Aristotle - Principles of Political Power

768 words - 3 pages ; therefore they will not covet office and will be doing it for the good of the state (Plato, 323). This is also not viable in contemporary U.S. society. Are you going to get "qualified people" to take the job if it does not pay well?Jefferson holds the opposite of Plato's ideas to be the ideal governing body. He believes that the individual comes first, and that the state is there only to be sure that the individual is first. He believes that in a

Spartan Society related

2021 words - 8 pages Explain the importance of the role or religion in Spartan Society. Religion in Sparta, like in many societies, had a purpose. Religion was important in Sparta to support the ideals of a militaristic utopian society which, after the Messenian wars, the governing forces were aiming to create. “Those who honour the gods most finely with choruses are best in war” [Socrates]. The Spartan ideal of an elite military state influenced the approach to

Similar Essays

The Ideal Puritan Society Essay

1195 words - 5 pages John SwiftThe Ideal Puritan SocietyPuritans thought of themselves as members of the Church of England. Disgusted with the tainted modern religious practices, puritans tried to change that institution. They soon became frustrated with the lack of successful reform as English kings James I and Charles I persecuted them. The Puritans migrated to the New World to create a nation according to their own beliefs. The Puritan Society was a very

Socialism The Ideal Society? Essay

2662 words - 11 pages Communism-The Ideal Society?Society is flawed. There are critical imbalances in it that are causing much of humanity to suffer. In The Communist ManifestoKarl Marx is reacting to this fact by describing his vision of a perfectly balanced society, a communist society. Simply put, a communist society is one where all property is held in common. No one person has more than the other, but rather everyone shares in the fruits of their labors. Marx is

Socialism The Ideal Society? Essay

2662 words - 11 pages Communism-The Ideal Society?Society is flawed. There are critical imbalances in it that are causing much of humanity to suffer. In The Communist ManifestoKarl Marx is reacting to this fact by describing his vision of a perfectly balanced society, a communist society. Simply put, a communist society is one where all property is held in common. No one person has more than the other, but rather everyone shares in the fruits of their labors. Marx is

El Dorado: The Ideal Society Essay

1937 words - 8 pages be found in the utopian society of El Dorado. We must also understand the etymology of the word utopia. "Eu" means good, "topos" means place, and "ou" means no. Roughly, the meaning of utopia is "the good place that is no place." This brings me to my point; though Voltaire was bringing light to social injustices through his satirical work, his notion of this ideal society could never actually occur. However, if we take the advice that Voltaire