This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Immigration And Job Loss Debate

1155 words - 5 pages

The Immigration and Job Loss Debate

A debate that always seems to raise its ugly head when the issue of "foreign labor" is discussed concerns the types of jobs that immigrants take and whether they are actually taking these jobs away from American workers. I look at it as jobs they are "left with", not ones they are taking. The debate always shows an American family that has been displaced or lost their livelihood because they can no longer compete with cheaper labor. In reality the jobs that the immigrants get are the most undesirable, strenuous and dangerous ones. The only American workers that they compete with are the unskilled ones. I intend to explore if immigrants "taking" American jobs, if they are only taking the jobs that Americans don’t want or are they being forced to take certain jobs in specific industries.

As seen in Cooper’s article; The Heartland’s Raw Deal: How Meatpacking is Creating a New Immigrant Underclass, we see how companies have taken advantage and exploited the workers willing to work for less. These companies have tapped into the supply of labor that is willing to work for less than union wages. As a result of the de-unionization of the meat-packing industry, companies that were paying union wages as high as $30,000 a year were able to turn right around and hire all new workers for as little as $6. per hour. This is a big difference in pay for the same exact work. Sure, many American workers were willing to do the work, just not for the minimal wages. The meatpacking industry was able to increase profits at the expense of the American workers. The debate about whether the immigrants "took" those jobs from the American workers needs to be re-addressed to the companies that took advantage of the "cheap labor". Are the immigrants just willing to work for the lower wages or are these the only jobs they qualify for?

We see immigrants in the restaurant industry, not as chefs but as dishwashers and busboys. We see them in the agriculture sector as migrant workers doing literally backbreaking work of weeding and picking our fruits and vegetables so we can purchase them at low prices. We use immigrants as gardeners and groundskeepers and expect them to work outside, in Phoenix, in 100 plus degrees. I don’t think any of "us" could tolerate the conditions that they work under. They clean our schools, our offices and our stores. They get security jobs on the shifts that American workers don’t want, night watchmen. They take the construction jobs from companies that avoid paying union wages. These opportunities are presented by American companies that are only interested in their bottom line. The desire to hire immigrant workers, documented or undocumented, is out of the greed of profit-driven corporate America. The fact that Immigrant laborers are desperate for work is exploited by the very companies that promote lower prices for consumers, American consumers. An irony of sorts. We pay lower wages so we can have lower...

Find Another Essay On The Immigration and Job Loss Debate

Debate between Job Order Costing and Process Costing

4776 words - 19 pages Debate between Job Order Costing and Process Costing Table of Content PART 1 INTRODUCTION 1 PART 2 COSTING SYSTEM 2 1. Job Order Costing (JOC) 2 2. Process Costing (PC) 3 PART 3 ACCOUNTING METHODOLOGIES 4 1. Last-In-First-Out (LIFO) 4 2. First-In-First-Out (FIFO) 5 3. Comparison between LIFO and FIFO 6 PART 4 CASES STUDY 7 Case 1 – Law Firm 7 Case 2 – Furniture Manufacturing Industry 7 Case

Immigration And The Economy Essay

1665 words - 7 pages negative facts about immigration. So, is immigration a positive or negative aspect on the Canadian economy? Since there is no evidence that immigration contributes to the unemployment level in Canada, there is evidence that proves immigration opens up job opportunities. Therefore reduces unemployment. If Canada did not allow immigration, there would be a large amount of unemployment."Immigrants expand the demand for goods and services through their

Immigration and the Media

1704 words - 7 pages Immigration has always been a contentious issue in the United States. Benjamin Franklin thought that an influx in German migration into the United States would flush out the predominately British culture at that time. Furthermore, a continual wave of foreign cultures began pouring into the American metropolitan areas at the turn of the 20th century. The migration of these people began a mass assimilation of cultural ideology and customs into

The Ear And Hearing Loss

1025 words - 4 pages The Ear and Hearing Loss The ear is the organ of hearing and balance in vertebrates. The ear converts sound waves in the air, to nerve impulses which are sent to the brain, where the brain interprets them as sounds instead of vibrations. The innermost part of the ear maintains equilibrium or balance. The vestibular apparatus contains semicircular canals which in turn balance you. Any movement by the head, and this apparatus sends a signal to

The Loss of Power and the Loss of Purpose

1243 words - 5 pages he had once explained himself to be before the war. With such a great loss that he suffered, he constantly thinks, and speaks about the war. When thinking about Anja, and those that he lost, he explains how “it still makes me cry..even from my dead eye tears are coming out” (Spiegelman, Vol I, 84). Despite his best efforts to find meaning as a survivor by helping his son write a comic book about his experiences, he continues to suffer from his

Immigration, Policy and The State

2372 words - 9 pages IntroductionImmigration is one of the most prevalent topics in Canadian politics today. It is brought up during policy revisions and is always an issue during election campaigns. That may be because Canada has one of the largest markets for immigration in the world. Annually, about 200,000 new immigrants enter into Canada to become permanent residents. {{44 Smick, Elisabeth 2006;}} The majority of these immigrants come from Asia, particularly

Illegal Immigration and the Environment

1643 words - 7 pages of Land Management ask for $23.5 million the first year to help with the illegal immigration problems. The Bureau of Land Management wants to completely put into practice a five-year plan, the cost for this is estimated at $62.9 million. This is not an unreasonable sum to pay out to protect our fragile border parks, national monuments, and wildlife refuge areas against damage done by the illegal immigrants, and to prevent additional loss of our

The American Dream and Immigration

782 words - 4 pages way of citizen jobs. What many people fail to see is that immigration brought more opportunities into America than people think. They create new jobs by creating new businesses and paying taxes. They also provide cheap labor for many industries which keeps the American economy functioning. Immigrants are also often bringing the best talents and skills to America which helps our country remain competitive. Their arrival to the United States is

B.Y.O.B and the con job

948 words - 4 pages B.Y.O.B is the title of a song by System of a Down, a very political and inspiring metal group. The Con Job is poem by Charles Bukowski who is famous for a number of his poems. It’s easy to assume that B.Y.O.B and The Con Job are very similar in topic, yet different in the same sense. I will first discuss the song B.Y.O.B and then the poem The Con Job. Both the Song and the poem use examples and illustrations to show why they protest these wars

The Ploughman Job and The Job Characteristics Model

2979 words - 12 pages upon that “Hunger was a fact of life”, p.22. A ploughman job meant so much that if it was not done in sufficient amount, it has caused the so called famine-struck. Back in the seventh-century Sussex, the Saxon historian and the monk Bede denoted that famine-struck is that of a number of about 40 to 50 emaciated and starving people pack up in a pact to commit suicide together. They would join hands and leap over to the edge of the seas to die by

War and the Loss of Innocence

1671 words - 7 pages In his memoir, A Long Way Gone, Ishmael Beah deals with his loss of innocence as he is forced to join the children army of Sierra Leone in the country's civil war after being conscripted to the army that once destroyed his town in order for Ishmael to survive. His memoir acts as a voice to show the many difficulties that the members of Sierra Leone's child army had to suffer through and their day to day struggle to survive in the worst of

Similar Essays

The Real Issue Behind The Immigration Debate

504 words - 2 pages The controversy over immigration has typically overlooked the political purpose of immigration: to supply citizens who will cherish and uphold the American Founding principles of equality and liberty, of government by consent and the rule of law. Founding a new nation and then perpetuating it are the two greatest challenges of statesmen. Part of that task of perpetuation—and Abraham Lincoln reminded us that it can be a more difficult

Rhetoric In The American Immigration Debate

1649 words - 7 pages boy trying to reunite with his mother who had left him for a job in the States—to herself better understand the human aspect of the debate. The story of Enrique is fundamentally a story that stirs the emotions. While we may find reasonable the logical arguments laid out by the Nazario’s sources, and while Nazario’s ethos is backed by extensive notes, the tale is fundamentally an anecdotal account in the larger debate over immigration. Its appeal

Job Loss In The Solar Market Industry And Rice Market Floor Prices

2204 words - 9 pages quantity proportional to each other, even though the total quantity of radiological services traded in the marketplace has increased. This occurs as new businesses are entering the market, therefore the units of the service produced and provided by each business would not increase as greatly. Part B Why ending solar panels rebate will cause job loss in that industry? (Case Study) In this case study, what is being analysed, with solar power being

The Debate In The United States Over Immigration

1300 words - 5 pages The Debate in the United States over Immigration      Immigration plays a huge role in the population of the United States. The U.S. is looked at as a place for a new start and a place to begin a new life. This country gives people the opportunity to make their own choices and have their own freedom, who are we to decide who can have these rights or not. Should Americans really have to right to deny another human being the right to live in